regarding judging

hi guys,

I strongly feel that judges are not judging based on dance. They are purely judging based on entertainment. Yesterday i felt that boys bhootni ke performance was not that deserving to get 29 points. Girls are putting so much of effort and hardwork yet they are nt getting derserved points. Even this is admitted by Arshad as said in last episode but still the same happens with girls.

This is my view. Plz do comment ur views

hey... Alot has already been discussed abt the judging and there are already many threads to discuss the same. So u neednt create similar topics again and again.
Besides I dont think znd can be a perfect dance show like DID.. Most of the contestants are actors and u cannot expect them to do perfect dancing in a month. So the judges have no choice but judge based on expressions, dance and attitude altogether which gives entertainment. So sometimes it is fair and sometimes it isnt. I personally liked their bhootni ke performance :)

That's soo true and i just can't tolerate it anymore! Karan is a gud performer but not tht gud dancer=) Even though i luv him but 2 b honest he didn't deserve tht much points:( and y does we hav 2 watch Siddhesh always? I'm sick of watching him in every performance! If girlz just do 1 wrong step thn they get 8 and if boys do the same they will get 9! Boys just entertainbut girlz really dance=)

well there are some performances, those has been judged based on Entertainment and not dancing........ yes, many threads are being opened to discuss same fact.....

@rosegirl..I think Karam's performance was great y'day. Just becuz he makes us laugh through his performance and not cry, doesnt mean its not dance. If Siddesh or any established dancer had done the same thing, u wud have thought he deserved the points because he's already a good dancer so whatever he did must hv been good..but when karan does it..u think he didnt deserve the points becuz he's just an upcoming talent? Maybe Hazel cud have got more, but Karan got wat he deserved. Even the group performance was nice...and please remember...dance is a form of entertainment..we see dance for entertainment..so if a dance performance entertains u its good!!

i am sorry i dont know that there are threads discussing the same... if mods want they can close the topic

If Siddesh or any established dancer had done the same thing, u wud have thought he deserved the points because he's already a good dancer so whatever he did must hv been good..but when karan does it..u think he didnt deserve the points becuz he's just an upcoming talent?

Originally posted by: karan_kritika

hi guys,

I strongly feel that judges are not judging based on dance. They are purely judging based on entertainment. Yesterday i felt that boys bhootni ke performance was not that deserving to get 29 points. Girls are putting so much of effort and hardwork yet they are nt getting derserved points. Even this is admitted by Arshad as said in last episode but still the same happens with girls.

This is my view. Plz do comment ur views

LOL I can't agree to this on a whole but I partially agree to the fact that judges are judging on the basis of entertainment because Karan didn't deserve a 28 at all. He didn't have any hard steps and was just jumping around most of the time. But, for a group performance, the judges have to judge on the GROUP EFFORT not the effort of one or two people who outshined the group. The boys' group performance was very well coordinated and looked like a group effort rather than one person's effort.

This is why their judgement was fair on the group performance. They can't give the whole group a mark based on only two people's grace.

girls did dance iin group boys did not do dance in bhootni ke not deserving performance it was no dance only jumping and making funny faces 👎🏼

Originally posted by: -stuti-

@rosegirl..I think Karam's performance was great y'day. Just becuz he makes us laugh through his performance and not cry, doesnt mean its not dance. If Siddesh or any established dancer had done the same thing, u wud have thought he deserved the points because he's already a good dancer so whatever he did must hv been good..but when karan does it..u think he didnt deserve the points becuz he's just an upcoming talent? Maybe Hazel cud have got more, but Karan got wat he deserved. Even the group performance was nice...and please remember...dance is a form of entertainment..we see dance for entertainment..so if a dance performance entertains u its good!!

and please remember...dance is a form of entertainment..we see dance for entertainment..so if a dance performance entertains u its good!!


You've just contradicted what you're saying here! LOL..Dance is definitely a form of entertainment and therefore, it is fair for the judges to judge on entertainment. But the entertainment has to come in the form of dance not jumping or doing aerobics. LOL sorry but this is just my opinion.