Originally posted by: KK84
Sorry I disagree with you! He did deserve it cos not only has he improved amples since day 1 and keeping in mind that most people on there are already dancers or won some sort of dance show...and not to mention that most pple have just peformed stunts which actually doesn't class as dancing. Karan had some moves! Jumping up and down is part of dancing! Yeah anyone can do that but he didn't Do just that! Look carefully at his steps! Looks easy but isn't!
FYI - defn of dancing from a dictionary:
v. danced, dancing, dances
v.intr.
1. To move rhythmically usually to music, using prescribed or improvised steps and gestures.
2.
a. To leap or skip about excitedly.
b. To appear to flash or twinkle: eyes that danced with merriment.
c. Informal To appear to skip about; vacillate: danced around the issue.
3. To bob up and down.
[B][/B]
if u bub up and down in effect you would be jumping!!
Karan deserved all the 28 points and he was faaaar better than hazel who has done many performanes that he has so far but hasn't shown any improvement.she was good from the start and is good now! But isn't anything dynamic which karan's part is!
They both shared the same stage but karan completely stole the show and that says something!
Kat
going by that logic, tomorrow sunny deol will show a lot of improvement in dance, so wud u rate him better than hrithik roshan?
now this is just a hypothesis and i dont mean hazel is hrithik or karan is sunny deol..lol
wht am trying to say is...just improvement is not enough for someone to get perfect scores coz the performance def wasnt perfect...and first of all, i didnt think he overshadowed hazel, and even if he did it was because of the comedy and entertaining factor....so is that the criteria to give perfect scores? def not...
i have abs nothing against karan and i adore him....but being a dancer all my life, i am finding it apalling and unfair that judges gave him 28 for his perf..thats it