mr.kundra doesnt deserve so many points.......... - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

7.4k

Users

35

Likes

207

Frequent Posters

darshana23 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#11
well olly13244, opinion could differ.......... His charlin chaplin was act was indeed bad. As I said he was missing footwork which is base of any dance. In yesterday's performance, he has overcomed his fault and I have seen very very good footwork and steps by him........ I truely appreciate his effort for being dancer in this show from non-dancer and judges also appreciate that then nothing wrong in it. If he is putting that much effort he should get praised....

But the question is, does he really deserved that 28 marks comparing his performance to Hazel..... Forget about Hazel even, Abhishek, Sushant has performed in Khallas round previously... was his performance so great to get more or equivalent marks to what we have seen earlier...... Comedy and everything is fine but I feel his performance was definately not one to get 28.........

And judges are not blind, even god is not blind and other viewers are also not blind................

yipee thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#12
hey blossom...we def agree and admit that karan is putting great efforts and has shown a marked improvement...but shud we be giving marks only for improvement? coz it was unfair that he was given 28 and hazel 24...
and i agree karan is def sweet...i love him n kritika...and i thought it was damn sweet of him to say sorry to hazel...and then the KK hug...waiting for their duet..
but to be fair in judgement, he and hazel shud have got almost equal scores
-Olly- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#13
absolutely right blossom.love u and stuti thanks for helping me to prove my point👍🏼
Juna04 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14
I agree with Darshana and Yipee - just going by the performance itself it was not much of dancing as it was more of clowning and in comparison to Hazel I thought Karan did not deserve to get that much more than her
KK84 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#15
Sorry I disagree with you! He did deserve it cos not only has he improved amples since day 1 and keeping in mind that most people on there are already dancers or won some sort of dance show...and not to mention that most pple have just peformed stunts which actually doesn't class as dancing. Karan had some moves! Jumping up and down is part of dancing! Yeah anyone can do that but he didn't Do just that! Look carefully at his steps! Looks easy but isn't!

FYI - defn of dancing from a dictionary:


v. danced, dancing, dances
v.intr.
1. To move rhythmically usually to music, using prescribed or improvised steps and gestures.
2.
a. To leap or skip about excitedly.
b. To appear to flash or twinkle: eyes that danced with merriment.
c. Informal To appear to skip about; vacillate: danced around the issue.
3. To bob up and down.
[B][/B]

if u bub up and down in effect you would be jumping!!

Karan deserved all the 28 points and he was faaaar better than hazel who has done many performanes that he has so far but hasn't shown any improvement.she was good from the start and is good now! But isn't anything dynamic which karan's part is!

They both shared the same stage but karan completely stole the show and that says something!

Kat
KK84 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: olly13244

i disagree.with darshana23. it is not that the judges favour him just becoz of a surname. its not his fault. u must have seen in the previous episode karans charlie act was not appreciated becoz it was really not good. so they could have given him marks at that time becoz more or less he was entertaining. but they didnt.and as per the boys act it was his entry that made the act awesome .why u ppl dont accept the fact that karan has stolen the show yesterday and he really deserves the 28 . if judges are blind i suppose god isnt. he really worked tooo hard and god gave his fruit😉.so proud of u karan.



Lol!! You said the same thing as me and I hadn't een read your post!! Soooo true! Where credit is due, the judges give dil khol key! The Charlie performance none of them
liked it much.

yipee thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: KK84

Sorry I disagree with you! He did deserve it cos not only has he improved amples since day 1 and keeping in mind that most people on there are already dancers or won some sort of dance show...and not to mention that most pple have just peformed stunts which actually doesn't class as dancing. Karan had some moves! Jumping up and down is part of dancing! Yeah anyone can do that but he didn't Do just that! Look carefully at his steps! Looks easy but isn't!

FYI - defn of dancing from a dictionary:


v. danced, dancing, dances
v.intr.
1. To move rhythmically usually to music, using prescribed or improvised steps and gestures.
2.
a. To leap or skip about excitedly.
b. To appear to flash or twinkle: eyes that danced with merriment.
c. Informal To appear to skip about; vacillate: danced around the issue.
3. To bob up and down.
[B][/B]

if u bub up and down in effect you would be jumping!!

Karan deserved all the 28 points and he was faaaar better than hazel who has done many performanes that he has so far but hasn't shown any improvement.she was good from the start and is good now! But isn't anything dynamic which karan's part is!

They both shared the same stage but karan completely stole the show and that says something!

Kat

going by that logic, tomorrow sunny deol will show a lot of improvement in dance, so wud u rate him better than hrithik roshan?
now this is just a hypothesis and i dont mean hazel is hrithik or karan is sunny deol..lol
wht am trying to say is...just improvement is not enough for someone to get perfect scores coz the performance def wasnt perfect...and first of all, i didnt think he overshadowed hazel, and even if he did it was because of the comedy and entertaining factor....so is that the criteria to give perfect scores? def not...
i have abs nothing against karan and i adore him....but being a dancer all my life, i am finding it apalling and unfair that judges gave him 28 for his perf..thats it
KK84 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: darshana23

well olly13244, opinion could differ.......... His charlin chaplin was act was indeed bad. As I said he was missing footwork which is base of any dance. In yesterday's performance, he has overcomed his fault and I have seen very very good footwork and steps by him........ I truely appreciate his effort for being dancer in this show from non-dancer and judges also appreciate that then nothing wrong in it. If he is putting that much effort he should get praised....

But the question is, does he really deserved that 28 marks comparing his performance to Hazel..... Forget about Hazel even, Abhishek, Sushant has performed in Khallas round previously... was his performance so great to get more or equivalent marks to what we have seen earlier...... Comedy and everything is fine but I feel his performance was definately not one to get 28.........

And judges are not blind, even god is not blind and other viewers are also not blind................



But dancing without emotions will bore you to death! Karan not only danced but was entertaining also! Everyone has always got the marks they deserved. In comparison, hazel didn't stand out. And the judges judge on current performance and not on what so and so did last time and also remember this is not an individuals competition. It's boys against girls so they not going to compare karan's act with abishek and sushant as that would not make sense as he is not competing agaisnt them.
rahuldravidfan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Sorry but even i felt Hazel had an edge over Karan... there were many dance steps in her act and she did it beautifully.... agreed Karan had put in efforts and his performance was good.... but it did not deserve 28.... even i felt they could have given equal scores....

yipee thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#20
KK84 - compared to hazel, i think both were on par....so they shud have got equal marks....i agree that we judge a perf and not past performances...
and thats exactly why i feel karan shud also have got a 24

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".