Jugdes being 2 nice?

Ok i watched todays episode i just want to ask how many of u feel tht some times judges r giving such high points???

I agree.. I think judges r giving out sympathy votes which I think is totally unfair...I mean Mukti makes a mistake w/her hula hoops and boys give a perfect performance w/o mistake whatsoever then three judges which i feel sometimes are blind give same marks to both group. Hmm what kind of judgement is this? Can someone plzzz explain
The question Sidhesh asked today was totally right.I can see y he said that On what basis r these judges srsly judging??

All these contestants are actors... Not all of the contestants are good dancers... So their efforts and dedication towards a performance should be considered...

As per the mistakes, please dont get me wrong on this... But if we reflect back some of the boys mistakes were overlooked when their dedication and efforts were visible... I mean take the group dance of the boys in the Maa song... Siddesh slipped... Thats a mistake... But it was overlooked because of his effort and dedication... If it was not overlooked, the guys would have performed lower because that slip made the performance out of sync and reduced the potential of the performance...

I believe apart from pure dance, effort and dedication towards a performance and the courage and determination to try out new things should also be considered because most of these contestants are professional dancers...

Originally posted by: Twitz

I agree.. I think judges r giving out sympathy votes which I think is totally unfair...I mean Mukti makes a mistake w/her hula hoops and boys give a perfect performance w/o mistake whatsoever then three judges which i feel sometimes are blind give same marks to both group. Hmm what kind of judgement is this? Can someone plzzz explain
The question Sidhesh asked today was totally right.I can see y he said that On what basis r these judges srsly judging??

Originally posted by: Angad_Kripa_200

All these contestants are actors... Not all of the contestants are good dancers... So their efforts and dedication towards a performance should be considered...

As per the mistakes, please dont get me wrong on this... But if we reflect back some of the boys mistakes were overlooked when their dedication and efforts were visible... I mean take the group dance of the boys in the Maa song... Siddesh slipped... Thats a mistake... But it was overlooked because of his effort and dedication... If it was not overlooked, the guys would have performed lower because that slip made the performance out of sync and reduced the potential of the performance...

I believe apart from pure dance, effort and dedication towards a performance and the courage and determination to try out new things should also be considered because most of these contestants are professional dancers...

Originally posted by: pakindmuziq

Also specially today, im wth the ppl who r better dancers, i ONLY and ONLY look at dance. This time in the final round guys were better, MUCH better, EVRYTHING was just perfect and still girls got the same points. Im not saying girls were bad, actually i loved both of the acts, but then the guys act was PERFECT. They shud evn look at tht "unnis bees farak", look at the one who is better, specially whn they got the chance to look at BOTH acts and then judge and give points.

If u say this then the the first group act of guys wouldnt have scored 10.
karan kundra wouldnt have scored 21
ma act of guys wouldnt have scored 10 each ...
etc......
dance is not only about steps...entertainment, overall impact, concept , having fun, showing effort also important in dancing.

Originally posted by: nuptalie

If u say this then the the first group act of guys wouldnt have scored 10.
karan kundra wouldnt have scored 21
ma act of guys wouldnt have scored 10 each ...
etc......
dance is not only about steps...entertainment, overall impact, concept , having fun, showing effort also important in dancing.

]

So true 😊 ....only good dance doesnt make a performance good...there's everything...expressions, concept, effort, dedication and how well a person performs even if he is a non dancer

i only find vaibhavi fair

I think because these are actors and not professional dancers, their performance and courage to attempt whatever they tried to do in their acts should be considered. I know some of the actors/contestants have been on other reality dance shows, or are actually dancers, but you still have to judge each person equally. If you're going to excuse a mistake for one person, you should excuse it from the other person too. I find some inconsistencies in that regard. Some of these actors are dancing for their first time, and they get judges quite harshly (Karan for his first performance, which was actually good). While other performers get away with it (Mukti and her mistakes, and others too). Everyone needs to be judged the same, and the judges need to set a standard and judge to that standard.