Mithila_22 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
I am trying to analyse how CVs have been trying to portray Shan and Asmita. 😊
They have really written Asmita's character wellšŸ‘. Till now, the could show various shades of Asmita, a fierce police inspector, confident, understanding, mature, someone who knows what's right and what's wrong, emotional, well-behaved and many more. Today, when she was talking to Shan and Shan put so many allegations on her and called her sonagachi ke gandi gali ki paidaish and what not still she didn't utter a word..i was expecting her to slap shan at that moment,😔 but she only listened to him and vented out her anger on the chair hurting herself and it immediately hurt shan as well. I loved what she said that moment, that, which is real shan, one who insults her or the one who cares for her..this really showed how mature and sensible Asmita isšŸ‘...But at the same time she needs to make him realise that mandhandling her, abusing her is not right. I am expecting that from her in future..I mean she cannot continue to take his abuse all the time. Saving her friend, proving him innocent is completely fine, but will be really happy if CVs show Asmita making shan realising all these things as well..

Now coming to Shan..CVs are doing great when it comes to Asmita, but I can't say the same thing about Shan. Till now, we couldn't see what Shan really isšŸ¤”..His character is not explored that much yet. We have only seen his battling with his feelings and humiliating Asmita🤢..Yes we saw his care for her, we saw how guilty he was for dropping asmita on road and all but his character traits are not clear. We don't know if he can take a decision of his own. Many a times his decisions are driven by what his family thinks🄱..From what understand, he is not a sorted person like Asmita is but CVs need to show him strong somewhere..They have only been showing him loving ridhoy, craving for his mother's love, exercising šŸ˜† and ofcourse manhandling Asmita..🤢 We saw Asmita's self talks and all but shan's self talks were only about how he doesn't want Asmita to accept ridhoy's proposal and what he feels..Correct me if i am wrong, only once he was shown saying like he doesn't want Asmita to go through what he has been going through all these years. So, i feel CVs need to explore his character more the way they are going with Asmita..Ofcourse right now their focus could be Asmita and her mission and may be they will explore his character later but if they are gona show asmita falling for him then they better explore his character for us to feel why she feel for him keeping the childhood friends wala part aside..Looks Shan's character will be complex and CVs need to handle it well😃

Please drop in your views on their character growths..😳

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

2.4k

Users

5

Likes

37

Frequent Posters

kasaf thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Mithila_22

I am trying to analyse how CVs have been trying to portray Shan and Asmita. 😊

They have really written Asmita's character wellšŸ‘. Till now, the could show various shades of Asmita, a fierce police inspector, confident, understanding, mature, someone who knows what's right and what's wrong, emotional, well-behaved and many more. Today, when she was talking to Shan and Shan put so many allegations on her and called her sonagachi ke gandi gali ki paidaish and what not still she didn't utter a word..i was expecting her to slap shan at that moment,😔 but she only listened to him and vented out her anger on the chair hurting herself and it immediately hurt shan as well. I loved what she said that moment, that, which is real shan, one who insults her or the one who cares for her..this really showed how mature and sensible Asmita isšŸ‘...But at the same time she needs to make him realise that mandhandling her, abusing her is not right. I am expecting that from her in future..I mean she cannot continue to take his abuse all the time. Saving her friend, proving him innocent is completely fine, but will be really happy if CVs show Asmita making shan realising all these things as well..

Now coming to Shan..CVs are doing great when it comes to Asmita, but I can't say the same thing about Shan. Till now, we couldn't see what Shan really isšŸ¤”..His character is not explored that much yet. We have only seen his battling with his feelings and humiliating Asmita🤢..Yes we saw his care for her, we saw how guilty he was for dropping asmita on road and all but his character traits are not clear. We don't know if he can take a decision of his own. Many a times his decisions are driven by what his family thinks🄱..From what understand, he is not a sorted person like Asmita is but CVs need to show him strong somewhere..They have only been showing him loving ridhoy, craving for his mother's love, exercising šŸ˜† and ofcourse manhandling Asmita..🤢 We saw Asmita's self talks and all but shan's self talks were only about how he doesn't want Asmita to accept ridhoy's proposal and what he feels..Correct me if i am wrong, only once he was shown saying like he doesn't want Asmita to go through what he has been going through all these years. So, i feel CVs need to explore his character more the way they are going with Asmita..Ofcourse right now their focus could be Asmita and her mission and may be they will explore his character later but if they are gona show asmita falling for him then they better explore his character for us to feel why she feel for him keeping the childhood friends wala part aside..Looks Shan's character will be complex and CVs need to handle it well😃

Please drop in your views on their character growths..😳


Completely agree with you.. I hope ke maker Shan ke character ko aur jayada nikhar ke laye...Shan ke character me multi dimension hai but clear nahi hai ki real Shan kesa hai... I think emotional level pe weak hai par professional level pe strong character hai.. .Akele rahenge ke baad usse emotionally jayada strong dikhana chahiye. .. I hope maker Shan ke character ko aur jayada acche se represent kare. ..
Edited by kasaf - 6 years ago
myviewprem thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
Shantanu is a very big business man
To run business you must have maturity even emotional and knowledge of human behaviour and ability to recognize real face of people

A business man ahas to handle employees, managers, cliennts, customers, beauracrats and politicinas etc

can such a big business man be so immature to not trecognize his mother

As a kid fine i can understand hes not exposed to world, but hey wait hes born and brought up in sona gachi a very cruel place will such a kid be as innocent as Shaan

Rather kids of red light areas will grow up faster because life teaches them a lot than other children brouh up by parents lovingly

I totally think that Shaan character is badly written indeed he was more mature when in sonagachi and puchki was innocent one

Puchki saved his life when he was buried alive not his grandpa or father so he must respeect her more and trust her most

Everyone trusts childhood friends more than other friends, colleagues etc because childhood friends are closest after siblings in life and know his most deeply than others


kasaf thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Shantanu is a very big business man

To run business you must have maturity even emotional and knowledge of human behaviour and ability to recognize real face of people

A business man ahas to handle employees, managers, cliennts, customers, beauracrats and politicinas etc

can such a big business man be so immature to not trecognize his mother

As a kid fine i can understand hes not exposed to world, but hey wait hes born and brought up in sona gachi a very cruel place will such a kid be as innocent as Shaan

Rather kids of red light areas will grow up faster because life teaches them a lot than other children brouh up by parents lovingly

I totally think that Shaan character is badly written indeed he was more mature when in sonagachi and puchki was innocent one

Puchki saved his life when he was buried alive not his grandpa or father so he must respeect her more and trust her most

Everyone trusts childhood friends more than other friends, colleagues etc because childhood friends are closest after siblings in life and know his most deeply than others




I think Shan puchki ke maamle me jab uski family aati hai tab vo kuch soch nahi pata... Maker Shan ke character ko intelligent dikhaya hai jab puchki uske samne koi logical argument rakhti hai tab Shan ko consider karna chahiye aesa to dikhana hi chahiye nahi to character ko jo dikhaya hai usse bilkul opposite behave kar raha hai... Puchki ke liye uske man me confusion hai thik hai par situation ke hisab se to Shan ko logically soch raha hai vesa dikhana chahiye
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Shantanu is a very big business man

To run business you must have maturity even emotional and knowledge of human behaviour and ability to recognize real face of people

A business man ahas to handle employees, managers, cliennts, customers, beauracrats and politicinas etc

can such a big business man be so immature to not trecognize his mother

As a kid fine i can understand hes not exposed to world, but hey wait hes born and brought up in sona gachi a very cruel place will such a kid be as innocent as Shaan

Rather kids of red light areas will grow up faster because life teaches them a lot than other children brouh up by parents lovingly

I totally think that Shaan character is badly written indeed he was more mature when in sonagachi and puchki was innocent one

Puchki saved his life when he was buried alive not his grandpa or father so he must respeect her more and trust her most

Everyone trusts childhood friends more than other friends, colleagues etc because childhood friends are closest after siblings in life and know his most deeply than others



Exactly! Shan's character has completely flipped and become worse in comparison to his childhood self. Shantanu was a caring, respectful, sensitive and intelligent boy. This shan is prejudiced, close-minded, fickle-minded, dumb and abusive.
cuteariya thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#6
Agreed with all of u guys point of view
Even I feel the same that makers r not clear abt Shan character
As business men he should be strong intelligent smart but all we r getting he is nivi's Puppet
Shan know nivi hate him but still trust her more then asmita that's really unacceptable
I can just wish that makers will improve both shamita characters with passing time
Don't want to see them stupid idiotic & emotional fools
Mithila_22 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: myviewprem

Shantanu is a very big business man

To run business you must have maturity even emotional and knowledge of human behaviour and ability to recognize real face of people

A business man ahas to handle employees, managers, cliennts, customers, beauracrats and politicinas etc

can such a big business man be so immature to not trecognize his mother

As a kid fine i can understand hes not exposed to world, but hey wait hes born and brought up in sona gachi a very cruel place will such a kid be as innocent as Shaan

Rather kids of red light areas will grow up faster because life teaches them a lot than other children brouh up by parents lovingly

I totally think that Shaan character is badly written indeed he was more mature when in sonagachi and puchki was innocent one

Puchki saved his life when he was buried alive not his grandpa or father so he must respeect her more and trust her most

Everyone trusts childhood friends more than other friends, colleagues etc because childhood friends are closest after siblings in life and know his most deeply than others



Well, i agree with most of the points you stated..that kids in red light are become mature and aware of the world much early in life. Also, to run a successful business one should have knowledge about human behavior..Completely agreed.

But i think when it comes to a person's mother/family we can't really compare.. the relations in business and family are so different to each other..in business one can see vividly through a person because there is no emotional attachment..but when it comes to family, i have seen many people who are too good in understanding humans but are biased when it comes to their families..shan could be one of those...that's the reason i mentioned CVs need to explore his character a lot..we still don't know how he is in business, we are only told he is the successful businessman but we are not shown a lot about his business skills..they also need to show how he is with other people..coz till now we have seen him interacting with puchki and his family..he humiliates puchki all the time and is a bechara at home..so what are actual character traits of Shan Majumdar, how he is with friends, social life, we don't know anything..

What i expect from Shan's character is analytical thinking and observations..he denied what puchki told him at first go..understandable to me..but he needs to be shown thinking about what she said and not only his relation with puchki..in yesterday's episode also, he was shown thinking about her..i mean ok, he is so confused about his feelings for her..but shouldn't he think for once what she was trying to tell him..

I expect some mature dialogues and conversation of shan and puchki..i hope CVs work on to build shan's character and not just show him doing what he is doing right now..I am willing to give a chance to creatives..
Mithila_22 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: cuteariya

Agreed with all of u guys point of view

Even I feel the same that makers r not clear abt Shan character
As business men he should be strong intelligent smart but all we r getting he is nivi's Puppet
Shan know nivi hate him but still trust her more then asmita that's really unacceptable
I can just wish that makers will improve both shamita characters with passing time
Don't want to see them stupid idiotic & emotional fools



exactly..i don't want any of the leads to be stupid like other shows..i want them both to be portrayed independent, able to think, able to understand and analyse..Puchki's character is doing all that at the moment..Shan also needs to get out now and see what nivi is keeping his mind neutral..He did not believe puchki in one go, thike but he should atleast start analysing the situation and nivi's behavior..that's what i expect from him..and ofcourse no humiliation and manhandling of puchki..
Mithila_22 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sammy17


Exactly! Shan's character has completely flipped and become worse in comparison to his childhood self. Shantanu was a caring, respectful, sensitive and intelligent boy. This shan is prejudiced, close-minded, fickle-minded, dumb and abusive.


I hope CVs really show all the character traits which were there before ..i also don't like him when he is abusive, so narrow-minded...they show puchki understanding shan's behavior but the same is not being shown when it comes to puchki..he has always being shown mis-treating her, doubting her, misunderstanding her..the friendship/love is appearing one-sided..they need to show more of shan's involvement..
Mithila_22 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: kasaf



Completely agree with you.. I hope ke maker Shan ke character ko aur jayada nikhar ke laye...Shan ke character me multi dimension hai but clear nahi hai ki real Shan kesa hai... I think emotional level pe weak hai par professional level pe strong character hai.. .Akele rahenge ke baad usse emotionally jayada strong dikhana chahiye. .. I hope maker Shan ke character ko aur jayada acche se represent kare. ..


Shan's character could be shown multi-dimensional if CVs want..till now, they have put shan's character in a bad light..if they want to make shan appear a rutheless businees, highly-prejudiced then they need to show his good sidealso which we are not able to see right now..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".