Originally posted by: clarity
👏 👏
You hit the nail right on the head.
Bidaai- Vasundhara over Meenakshi anyday. As you said, we always knew what her motivations were and her 'flaws' were never white washed unlike on this show.
The problem is not that Me-nakshi does all this crap but rather that they try to convince us that it comes from a place of love for her family. 🙄 It's just unconvincing when you have her and other characters give sermons on how much she does for the family and then have her not even show an iota of remorse. On top of that, she goes on to hatch elaborate schemes to guilt trip everyone around her.
If they want to show us that Me-nakshi has good intentions but messes up on execution, maybe have her show some regret? After the Ketki-Ved fiasco, she did not ask for forgiveness from Ketki or anybody else. There wasn't even a scene of her which showed her fearing what would have happened to Ketki if the wedding went ahead. Instead, we get a scene of her gnashing her teeth in the dark about Mishti unmasking Ved's intentions by disobeying her. She found a way to see herself as the victim when even in this situation. Height of self-obsession.
Her behaviour or self-reflection is just not consistent with this Mahaan Meenu narrative. Characters are given reflection scenes to make the audience empathise with them and to make us understand their motives. Here, Me-nakshi is not only conning her family but also deluding herself that she is acting out of 'love' for her family, hence she is justified.
@bold- This had me go 🤷♀️ . She cries about Abir and then blames him the next moment for Nanu and Kunal going to the Maheshwaris. How come we never see her 'love' for Abir in action? If we didn't know of her so-called 'love' from her and other characters, one would think Abir is her step-child. For Me-nakshi, everyone is an afterthought. She is the protagonist of everyone's story.
Rupal Patel- Unsatisfactory performance from a veteran actor. Apart from the styling, there is no difference between her and Kokila Modi. Her dialogue delivery has that same monotonous quality as Kokila. I am unable to see Me-nakshi as a new character. I guess Kokila was better because while she was stern and dominating, she was not two-faced like Me-nakshi.