So a grieving mother’s perspective.. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2k

Users

15

Likes

216

Frequent Posters

Grey-licious thumbnail

Team Abhimanyu (Gen 3)

Posted: 9 months ago
#11

Originally posted by: Shineeeee

When FL gets hurt it's blood

When Pl gets hurt it's tomato sauce

That's what happened in Mandir today. Everyone can see Abheera's pain, but why no one came forward for Roohi? She was mourning her living baby these many weeks/months.

So Abheera would die without a baby, but Roohi is strong enough to survive.

a woman in a denim jacket is holding a cup and talking to tommy ..

Blurlaa thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 months ago
#12

Originally posted by: Jrf2021

Manjhari loved Neil Luke his real mother. She equally loved abhir ruhi as her grandkids.

Agar mahaa kaandmata ke genes activate nahi huye hote toh sab khushi khushi rehte.

LOOOOOOL no she didn't. She let him think he was some street kid who was lucky to be adopted for 20+ years of his life. She also let his father constantly bash him and treat him like he was trash. All of that could've been prevented if she had just told Harsh the truth that he was Neils father and told Neil that Harsh was his father but she didn't and wouldn't have had Akshara not revealed it.

Posted: 9 months ago
#13

Manjari herself was a victim of DV. How could she stand up for Neil. She did what she could. She adopted him and raised him like her own kid.

So lets stop blaming Manjari for everything. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

Blurlaa thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 months ago
#14

Originally posted by: JustaFan13

Manjari herself was a victim of DV. How could she stand up for Neil. She did what she could. She adopted him and raised him like her own kid.

So lets stop blaming Manjari for everything. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

Sorry but how exactly did she stand up for Neil? Neil himself called her out on it, even saying that she didn't even need to reveal the truth to Harsh, just Neil himself learning the truth would've been fine but she allowed him to be bullied and belittled for most of his life, making him feel like he was trash she picked up from the streets just for her bio son. Yes she had it tough and was unfortunately a victim of DV but that doesn't excuse her actions in giving Neil a horrible life.

Indira1211 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3

Team Abhira (Gen 4)

Posted: 9 months ago
#15

Originally posted by: Blurlaa

Sorry but how exactly did she stand up for Neil? Neil himself called her out on it, even saying that she didn't even need to reveal the truth to Harsh, just Neil himself learning the truth would've been fine but she allowed him to be bullied and belittled for most of his life, making him feel like he was trash she picked up from the streets just for her bio son. Yes she had it tough and was unfortunately a victim of DV but that doesn't excuse her actions in giving Neil a horrible life.

exactly ..why didn’t she reveal,that Neil was Harshs son and let him get his rights. She cheated Neil out of his rights just to hide her husbands cheap,extra marital affair and maybe her humiliation 🤷🏻‍♀️
Posted: 9 months ago
#16

Originally posted by: Blurlaa

Sorry but how exactly did she stand up for Neil? Neil himself called her out on it, even saying that she didn't even need to reveal the truth to Harsh, just Neil himself learning the truth would've been fine but she allowed him to be bullied and belittled for most of his life, making him feel like he was trash she picked up from the streets just for her bio son. Yes she had it tough and was unfortunately a victim of DV but that doesn't excuse her actions in giving Neil a horrible life.

Okay..

First of all..

You are insulting the surname Birla!!! Its the surname used by lakhs of people. (Real people). Insulting an actual surname just for the hatred for one fictional character 👍🏻

And please read my read my post before commenting. I said how could she stand up for Neil, when she couldn't do it for herself. Yes, she did wrong, but that's all she could do.

And How does it make sense to tell Neil the truth and ask him to hide it lifelong?? Also, Except for Harsh, nobody ill-treated him in Birla house. Everyone else loved Neil.

Sivamrith thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail 3rd Anniversary Thumbnail + 2

Team Abhimanyu (Gen 3)

Posted: 9 months ago
#17

Originally posted by: Blurlaa

Sorry but how exactly did she stand up for Neil? Neil himself called her out on it, even saying that she didn't even need to reveal the truth to Harsh, just Neil himself learning the truth would've been fine but she allowed him to be bullied and belittled for most of his life, making him feel like he was trash she picked up from the streets just for her bio son. Yes she had it tough and was unfortunately a victim of DV but that doesn't excuse her actions in giving Neil a horrible life.

Neil got a better life than he be in an orphanage... Manjiri Maa is the one who cared about him and visited him in orphanage than Abhi asked for adoption...
AnjuRish thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6

Team Ruhi (Gen 4)

Posted: 9 months ago
#18

Originally posted by: firewings_diya

I really liked manjari and abhimanyu. I don't know what manjari did as i have skipped some of the parts of gen 3. But whatever i have seen manjari only fights for happiness of her family.

I usually analyze character by putting myself in that situation.

If i was in place of manjari and if get to know my dil due to her mahanta syndrome became a catalyst in getting my son killed and my grand children's death. I will hate her to the core. As when she did not prioritize my family over her mahanta syndrome she should definitely should not marry and should take sanyas instead so that ppl don't keep expectations from her.

If i was in Abhimanyu's place who treated neil as his son more than brother and he gets to know from police 10 minute wait karthe toh neil zinda rehtha toh i would have definitely divorced my wife too as I don't want to loose anymore family members. He had withnessed enough carelessness and she was constantly being careless even when people were mourning which got manjari admitted to hospital.

If I was in AK'S place i never would have let neil go out. I would stopped by giving my kasam as i already know police 10 minute main ajayenge. Putting his life into risk and risking those kids life too just because i can not wait for 10 minutes or i can't follow them silently is not something i will do.

Even if there was no 10 minute thing and if i want to save those kids i would have gave my kasam to neil to not to come out and sacrificed my life instead of letting him sacrifice himself for my mahanta syndrome. This is the major reason i can not connect with ak.

Plus in true lub which sis humiliated sis in mantap ..could have ru. Off after roka only

Which sis does impulsive Kands and keeps running away

a cartoon of a girl pointing at a blackboard that says 100 % on it

MiVida_Messi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 months ago
#19

Originally posted by: Blurlaa

LOOOOOOL no she didn't. She let him think he was some street kid who was lucky to be adopted for 20+ years of his life. She also let his father constantly bash him and treat him like he was trash. All of that could've been prevented if she had just told Harsh the truth that he was Neils father and told Neil that Harsh was his father but she didn't and wouldn't have had Akshara not revealed it.

She let him think that he was having identical rights just like her own son Abhimanyu, she gave him a life with money, luxury, education and moral ground. Had she treated him like trash, he would have been living in servant quarters and polishing Manjiri's original son Abhimayu's shoes, Manjiri would not lose her marbles for a son who was not biologically related to her. She did her best being dependent on her loser and dominating husband, some people for example Akshara 2 does not even have the ability to give their biological son a legitimate father with luxuries while Manjari did everything in her control for Neil, a product of her husband's cheating.
MiVida_Messi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 months ago
#20

Originally posted by: firewings_diya

I really liked manjari and abhimanyu. I don't know what manjari did as i have skipped some of the parts of gen 3. But whatever i have seen manjari only fights for happiness of her family.

I usually analyze character by putting myself in that situation.

If i was in place of manjari and if get to know my dil due to her mahanta syndrome became a catalyst in getting my son killed and my grand children's death. I will hate her to the core. As when she did not prioritize my family over her mahanta syndrome she should definitely should not marry and should take sanyas instead so that ppl don't keep expectations from her.

If i was in Abhimanyu's place who treated neil as his son more than brother and he gets to know from police 10 minute wait karthe toh neil zinda rehtha toh i would have definitely divorced my wife too as I don't want to loose anymore family members. He had withnessed enough carelessness and she was constantly being careless even when people were mourning which got manjari admitted to hospital.

If I was in AK'S place i never would have let neil go out. I would stopped by giving my kasam as i already know police 10 minute main ajayenge. Putting his life into risk and risking those kids life too just because i can not wait for 10 minutes or i can't follow them silently is not something i will do.

Even if there was no 10 minute thing and if i want to save those kids i would have gave my kasam to neil to not to come out and sacrificed my life instead of letting him sacrifice himself for my mahanta syndrome. This is the major reason i can not connect with ak.

Neil was Arohi's husband, Manjiri's son, Abhimanyu's brother, Akshara could not put her grief aside and be there with her sister and husband in their worst, she chose to run away by blaming them for not sympathizing her. If she was grieving her dead unborn, Manjiri was grieving her freaking adult son, no way Akshara was right unless we want glorification of foolish female leads in ITV, and we have many, Prerna in Kasauti was dumb and somehow led to Prem's death and Anurag dumped her, same with Ishita somehow being dumb led to Ruhi's kidnapping? I forgot .. dammit, Naira and Swarna's son's death, Akshara and Neil's death, too much dumbness is there in ITV. smiley39

PTV is 2 degrees higher, Male leads directly kill female lead's siblings and then the love story starts.. LOLsmiley36

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Mehersudha

4 months ago

MOTHERS DAY 11.5 MOTHERS DAY 11.5

HAPPY MOTHERS DAY Ruhi gives pookie to abheera and says she will stay in goenkas for a month Abheera says you need extra care after delivery I...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".