ShadowImbue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 1 years ago
#1

In S1 OG Akshara had her family, her parents by her side throughout her life.


In S2 after Akshara's death, Naira had her Rajshree nani, Devyani dadi and Papa by her side. They used to be on Naira's side and showed mirror to Suwarna/Kdadi or were Naira's support system when Goenkas humiliated their daughter. Naira always had the option to stay with/without her family instead of toxic Goenkas during times when she couldn't bear it more which she did.


In S4 the difference is Abhira has no family (she doesn't know about Goenkas being her maternal family) right now it would be better to have someone by her side. Someone she would call her family. She needs a break from Poddars. I want her to leave PH (which she won't obviously) but won't it be better to have a revelation of her maternal family so she can have a family member to rely on.


edited for gen 3 storyline discussions

Edited by minakrish - 1 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

5.2k

Users

8

Likes

48

Frequent Posters

Posted: 1 years ago
#2

Mummy ki Maternal family means ladki ke nani /nana/mama/mami/mami ke bacche vagera.
Abhira ke nana/nani zinda nahi hai and mama-mami ka koi pata nahi hai.
So dekha jaye toh abhira ki mummy ki apni maternal family bhi hai nahi.

Jo maternal family ke naam par unn mai se ek abhira ke nana ki chachi surekha hai (I still don’t know mere nana ki chachi kaun hai 🙈) Kya baki sab ko yaha apne nana ki chachi ka koi idea hai???!! Nana ki chachi apne maaykewalo ki list mai count bhi hoti hai kya !! 🙈 Baki ke do jo zinda hai woh nani ke saas -sasur hai ! Meri naniiii ke saas -sasur toh badi durr ki baat ho gayi!

Abhira Ruhi dono ke paas apna maayka nahi hai kyunki maayka woh hota jaha apne parents ho. Nana ki chachi ya nani ke saas-sasur yeh toh distant family ho gayi.

ShadowImbue thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 1 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sweet_tania

Mummy ki Maternal family means ladki ke nani /nana/mama/mami/mami ke bacche vagera.
Abhira ke nana/nani zinda nahi hai and mama-mami ka koi pata nahi hai.
So dekha jaye toh abhira ki mummy ki apni maternal family bhi hai nahi.

Jo maternal family ke naam par unn mai se ek abhira ke nana ki chachi surekha hai (I still don’t know mere nana ki chachi kaun hai 🙈) Kya baki sab ko yaha apne nana ki chachi ka koi idea hai???!! Nana ki chachi apne maaykewalo ki list mai count bhi hoti hai kya !! 🙈 Baki ke do jo zinda hai woh nani ke saas -sasur hai ! Meri naniiii ke saas -sasur toh badi durr ki baat ho gayi!

Abhira Ruhi dono ke paas apna maayka nahi hai kyunki maayka woh hota jaha apne parents ho. Nana ki chachi ya nani ke saas-sasur yeh toh distant family ho gayi.

@bold Maternal family also means parents and grandparents (dadi, dadi, nana, nani) of the mother.

Naira maternal family was Maheshwari's including OG Akshara's dadi

Goenkas were Akshara's paternal family but they are Abhira's maternal family as they are related to Akshara along with Singhanias they are both Ak's maternal family. Abhinav's family would be her paternal family.

@bold By the same logic Ruhi was raised by distant relatives Goenkas as Ruhi's mother Arohi had the same relationship with Goenkas as Akshara had.

Posted: 1 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: ShadowImbue

@bold Maternal family also means parents and grandparents (dadi, dadi, nana, nani) of the mother.

Naira maternal family was Maheshwari's including OG Akshara's dadi

Goenkas were Akshara's paternal family but they are Abhira's maternal family as they are related to Akshara along with Singhanias they are both Ak's maternal family. Abhinav's family would be her paternal family.

@bold By the same logic Ruhi was raised by distant relatives Goenkas as Ruhi's mother Arohi had the same relationship with Goenkas as Akshara had.

@bold: Bilkul sahi baat hai. Ruhi has no parents and she is raised by her Nani’s saas-sasur and nana’s chachi who are her distant relatives. Ruhi ke bhi apne nana nani zinda nahi hai like abhira.

Isiliye toh Maine kaha ki ruhi abhira has no maayka kyunki maayka woh hota hai jaha apne mummy papa ho and nanihal woh hota hai jaha nana nani mama mami vagera ho. Nana ki chachi / nani ke saas-sasur yeh toh distant relatives hue dono ke. Kitno ko pata hota hai ki unke nana ki chachi(Surekha )kaun hai yah unke nani ke saas sasur (Swarna-Manish) kaun hai?!

Edited by sweet_tania - 1 years ago
Visszz thumbnail

Team Maira

Posted: 1 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: sweet_tania

Mummy ki Maternal family means ladki ke nani /nana/mama/mami/mami ke bacche vagera.
Abhira ke nana/nani zinda nahi hai and mama-mami ka koi pata nahi hai.
So dekha jaye toh abhira ki mummy ki apni maternal family bhi hai nahi.

Jo maternal family ke naam par unn mai se ek abhira ke nana ki chachi surekha hai (I still don’t know mere nana ki chachi kaun hai 🙈) Kya baki sab ko yaha apne nana ki chachi ka koi idea hai???!! Nana ki chachi apne maaykewalo ki list mai count bhi hoti hai kya !! 🙈 Baki ke do jo zinda hai woh nani ke saas -sasur hai ! Meri naniiii ke saas -sasur toh badi durr ki baat ho gayi!

Abhira Ruhi dono ke paas apna maayka nahi hai kyunki maayka woh hota jaha apne parents ho. Nana ki chachi ya nani ke saas-sasur yeh toh distant family ho gayi.

Can't fully agree to it becoz firstly it's a fictional world and jab immortal Manish and Suvarna can be alive Naitik tak zinda reh sakta hai....Atleast naksh ...sabko chodo Kairav muskan ...Ekta ke bechari heroine ko bhi atleast bechara chacha and selfish chachi hoti hai...Here no one

Posted: 1 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Vismaya03

Can't fully agree to it becoz firstly it's a fictional world and jab immortal Manish and Suvarna can be alive Naitik tak zinda reh sakta hai....Atleast naksh ...sabko chodo Kairav muskan ...Ekta ke bechari heroine ko bhi atleast bechara chacha and selfish chachi hoti hai...Here no one

Chalo nana nani nahi hai lekin uske mama mami kairav muskan bhi agar hote toh lagta ki abhira /ruhi ka nanihal hai.
Yaha toh unke nana ki chachi Surekha kaha se nanihalwali hui !!! yah unn dono ki naira/sirat nani ke saas sasur bhi kaise nanihal hua!!! Kuch bhi matlab!!
Maternal family mai maa ke sab rishtedar aa jate hai jo door ke bhi hote hai and paas ke bhi hote hai. Yaha toh unn dono ki maa ki maternal family mai nana nani mama mami jaisa paas wala ek bhi rishta bacha nahi hai jo hai sab nana ki chachi type kafi distant relatives hai.
Visszz thumbnail

Team Maira

Posted: 1 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sweet_tania

Chalo nana nani nahi hai lekin uske mama mami kairav muskan bhi agar hote toh lagta ki abhira /ruhi ka nanihal hai.
Yaha toh unke nana ki chachi Surekha kaha se nanihalwali hui !!! yah unn dono ki naira/sirat nani ke saas sasur bhi kaise nanihal hua!!! Kuch bhi matlab!!
Maternal family mai maa ke sab rishtedar aa jate hai jo door ke bhi hote hai and paas ke bhi hote hai. Yaha toh unn dono ki maa ki maternal family mai nana nani mama mami jaisa paas wala ek bhi rishta bacha nahi hai jo hai sab nana ki chachi type kafi distant relatives hai.

Surekha was already there from starting...Pehle uska Pathi, beti,twins sab de ...3rd gen Starting me uska Pathi dhe end me ye aayi...Beti ki shadhi Naira ka ghar me kisi se hui twins ka patha nahi

ghostlyghost thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago
#8

Nana's father is also part of maternal family, they are not considered dur ki rishtedar. Typically such old people doesn’t stay alive but if they do they are maternal family. Maternal family is not just someone related by blood to nani but also nana

Debospeaks thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Yuvraj

Posted: 1 years ago
#9

Why can't they bring muskan's character back? She is having two relations with abhira. Both bua and mami.

Visszz thumbnail

Team Maira

Posted: 1 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ghostlyghost

Nana's father is also part of maternal family, they are not considered dur ki rishtedar. Typically such old people doesn’t stay alive but if they do they are maternal family. Maternal family is not just someone related by blood to nani but also nana

Exactly in real world rarely grandparents parents are alive...But it happens in rare situation...But agar yaha yeh log Manish and Suvarna ko dhika sakthe toh Naksh was not an impossible task .....Goenkas are not trustworthy...The minute they know that Abhira us Akshara 's beti they will start their emotional manipulation...

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26 · 5 months ago

Seriously! What's wrong with the writers this time? Armaan and Abhira keep tossing a CHILD from here and there and by god, Armoron has to be...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Agni_Jytsona · 2 years ago

Abhira Sharma/Samridhii Shukla AT|| DT Note P. 23

“Nothing can dim the light which shines from within.” ― Maya Angelou That is the best way to describe Abhira Sharma- The Gen 4 Fl Her strength...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01 · 1 months ago

I forgot also just noticed she disappeared

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26 · 1 months ago

I do NOT believe in any crap I am writing in this post but will write the basic thought process.... For this forum cuz forumwasis are obsessed...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: A_Star39 · 2 months ago

These fools are going to a park What if Madhav sa dies.Vidya mata depressed and abhira decides to get vidya Mata remarried.What do you think how...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".