YRKKH - GEN3 - What do you think

Its confirmed they will reunite soon as STAR PARRIVAR is coming up. We all know YRKKH will get most rewards.

But honestly the writing of this show is so bad. If I was writing it. I would of started from Gen 1 Style again.

Same way how all the family was introduced but having Mimi, Swarna , Surekha, along with Gayu and then Akshu and Luv Kush and Kairav,

They could of showed her entering college. They could of made it that she did not like the idea of love marriage. Family could of arranged a marriage with Abhimanyu and their love starts there. Luv Kush Love story along with Kairav. Birla family not so family oriented. Akshu could of helped changed that. If the rating was low then yh do all the crap they showing now.

Not interested in the story of criminal goenkas luv kush , akshara goenka. The writing was degrading from season 2 itself .

Naira forgiving the killer of her mother in the interest of her husband was awful.

The then supposed lead kartik conveniently chose to overlook the gravity of the crime that luv kush did and even worked to conceal their crime untill his own son's upbringing came to the picture . He failed to show any first hand sympathy for the girl from a humanistic point of view , which is the very essence of being a human . Akshara inherited the same genes of inhumane behavior from him .

YRKKH went from a great show (S1) to an average show (S2) to a bad/worse show ( Latter S2+S3).

Akshara and Abhimanyu are great characters on paper. But the execution was poor. They never stood a chance to stand against the initial Kaira. Forget Naksh

Karthik and Naira came with their own set of baggage and their story was executed well. There was a beautiful transition from Naksh to Kaira. Of course they were ruined later. But initially, Kaira's story was on point. Both as individual characters and as a couple. In comparison, Abhira was a colossal failure right from the get-go

I mean I am sure nobody expected Abhira to match up to the bars set by Naksh. But Kaira, utna toh kar lete kam se kam. 😆

Naksh and Kiara's love story developed slowly. They were given ample amounts of time to breathe, develop, and flourish. Their personalities were enhanced by each other

While Abhira hardly met 3-4 times they were in love. I mean make it make sense

Another point is the acting. It's not like Gen 1 Or Gen 2 leads were some great actors. But they embodied their characters. They made us believe that they are the characters that they are portraying. Sadly, the Gen 3 leads even failed to do that.

This is unfortunate because personally, I think Harshad is a good actor. I loved him since his Tere liye days. I don't know what happened to him, Abhimanyu Birla has to be his weakest performance

I just hope Hc will pick better scripts in the future.

Pranali ka she was average in Uthe dil and she is average here.

Jay Soni is not a great actor either, but at least he was honest in his portrayal of Abhinav. He aces Sunshine characters like Abhinav and Ishaan.

😆

I liked the idea of what would have I done it I were the writer....

Let's see, I would have gotten another actors to play Kartik and Sirat. Would have made Sirat grey seeing Akshara getting preference over Arohi but Arohi would have been more supportive as a sister (DKP is capable of that - Bidaai).

I would have reminded people again and again that Sirat isn't Naira the legacy character. Then coming to Akshara and Abhimanyu.

I am typically not in favour of love at first sound/sight/touch/smell/taste. However, if they did wish to delve into that then realization had to be slow... People should have been confused as to what's happening why is happening. Arohi could have played role in helping Akshara realize her feelings. Sirat would be the one wanting AbhiRohi and AbhiRa should have remained confused about their feelings! Arohi could have been catalyst for both.

Kairav shouldn't be falling for Akshara's all Nadans, he definitely had more role as a child. He would have been angry young man too who would see through Sirat's intentions. He would continue ensuring things remain friendly between sisters and his love life could have been independent of Abhira, maybe like Gen 1 some best friend of AkshRohi?

Kartik and Kairav would have been best friends. Mimi would have been regarded as normal human who has left earthly possessions to Manish, Swarna, Akhilesh and Surekha and joined Naira, Akshara and Gayatri ji.

Abhira could have been mature couple realizing their attraction and finally falling in love like normal people of love at first senses. Music career could have been explored and I think makers had that intention with Parth's character too and they failed miserably by proving people with that passion cannot really make career except for being Rockstars like in other iTv. Arohi would have fallen for Neil and Sirat could have gotten upset seeing Akshara would continue getting more as badi bahu but slowly would have change of heart when Akshu saves Arohi from mishap.

And blah blah blah...

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

😆

I liked the idea of what would have I done it I were the writer....

Let's see, I would have gotten another actors to play Kartik and Sirat. Would have made Sirat grey seeing Akshara getting preference over Arohi but Arohi would have been more supportive as a sister (DKP is capable of that - Bidaai).

I would have reminded people again and again that Sirat isn't Naira the legacy character. Then coming to Akshara and Abhimanyu.

I am typically not in favour of love at first sound/sight/touch/smell/taste. However, if they did wish to delve into that then realization had to be slow... People should have been confused as to what's happening why is happening. Arohi could have played role in helping Akshara realize her feelings. Sirat would be the one wanting AbhiRohi and AbhiRa should have remained confused about their feelings! Arohi could have been catalyst for both.

Kairav shouldn't be falling for Akshara's all Nadans, he definitely had more role as a child. He would have been angry young man too who would see through Sirat's intentions. He would continue ensuring things remain friendly between sisters and his love life could have been independent of Abhira, maybe like Gen 1 some best friend of AkshRohi?

Kartik and Kairav would have been best friends. Mimi would have been regarded as normal human who has left earthly possessions to Manish, Swarna, Akhilesh and Surekha and joined Naira, Akshara and Gayatri ji.

Abhira could have been mature couple realizing their attraction and finally falling in love like normal people of love at first senses. Music career could have been explored and I think makers had that intention with Parth's character too and they failed miserably by proving people with that passion cannot really make career except for being Rockstars like in other iTv. Arohi would have fallen for Neil and Sirat could have gotten upset seeing Akshara would continue getting more as badi bahu but slowly would have change of heart when Akshu saves Arohi from mishap.

And blah blah blah...

Ye read karne me hi itna Acha lag Raha hai aur dikhate to Kitna Acha lagta.

Anyways , they tried copying a Bengali show but butchered that also ..

Originally posted by: Sakshi-deewan

Ye read karne me hi itna Acha lag Raha hai aur dikhate to Kitna Acha lagta.

Anyways , they tried copying a Bengali show but butchered that also ..

Ohh I read IN ka story... That story was worse! It was never a rishta type story anyway...

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

Ohh I read IN ka story... That story was worse! It was never a rishta type story anyway...

Aree yahi toh mein pehle din se keh rahi thi...

IN was not at all like a rishta type story...

The Vibes were so different...

Maine toh tab lamba chauda bhashan bhi likh diya tha... Us time... To express my genuine confusion...

Out of all Bengali remake... I feel in should not have been the one...

You know what... I actually feel the rista could have tried to remake the show which was remade into 'kabhi kabhi ittefaq se '.

It was family friendly theme

A rich kid (spoiled by Goenkas after her parents death)

The Birla could have been the normal family.

Although actor's should be changed... Pranali cannot act 'cute' to save her life... Personal opinion

Originally posted by: umawanderer

Aree yahi toh mein pehle din se keh rahi thi...

IN was not at all like a rishta type story...

The Vibes were so different...

Maine toh tab lamba chauda bhashan bhi likh diya tha... Us time... To express my genuine confusion...

Out of all Bengali remake... I feel in should not have been the one...

You know what... I actually feel the rista could have tried to remake the show which was remade into 'kabhi kabhi ittefaq se '.

It was family friendly theme

A rich kid (spoiled by Goenkas after her parents death)

The Birla could have been the normal family.

Although actor's should be changed... Pranali cannot act 'cute' to save her life... Personal opinion

KKIS was hilarious and that may have actually worked better here!!!

IN ka story was literally not so family friendly... They tried making Arohi bad but that's just not DKP style to make sisters fight forever... I am glad they corrected route now but damage is done!

I always thought RS wanted to highlight second chance troupe after going thru his IV with Anu Ranjan.

Story of 3rd generation has clearly been lifted from Collen Hoover's book "It ends with us".

First year was about how Abhira weren't made for each other with Abrohi in between.

Second year for 8 months we saw move on phase of Akshara with Abhinav.

No idea what's gonna take place next because it's really tiring to hear capital punishment lectures.

Gen 3 may end up with redemption tracks with out reunions and acceptance of certains facts that life must go on.

Otherwise execution, technical expertise, direction, editing, dialogues, script, acting are subpar in comparison to previous generations.

I really wanted them to fix Akshara and Arohi’s sister bond since the drama is supposed to be known for relationships. I was happy when after Arohi was pregnant for real, she realized her mistakes and was apologizing for real and wanted to live happily in Birla house. Since they were going for second separation - I wanted an Abhi death memory loss track. I wanted both Neil and Abhi to be with their wives during the whole pregnancy, and then say a month before their due date- Abhi and Neil get into an accident- Neil dies and his body is discovered, Abhi is presumed dead but his body isn’t found. Then they would have like 5 years leap- during this leap- Arohi and Akshara bond over being single mothers, Akshara becomes a singer and Arohi the best doctor, Harsh Birla becomes best grandfather for his grandkids and same with Manjiri. After leap, Abhi is found alive but memory loss, the new guy for Arohi is the one who saves him. So then they could have had Akshara trying o make Abhi recover his memory while Arohi has her love story starting with new guy.