||YRKKH 2023 Banner Contest Results|| [DT Note: pg-4, 6] - Page 3

Congrats haminasto and the other winners. Loved banner #29. Congrats once again.

Lol, I use IF on my phone and the banners appear so tiny, I had to hold up my phone almost against my specs to see what was in it. 😆Only when this contest started, I realised that there is more to the current banner than what I have been seeing all along on my mobile. 😅

I took a 2 day break and missed my chance for voting, so probably shouldn't be commenting. Still will plunge ahead. Art is subjective, so won't comment on the aesthetics of the banners. However, the winner banner is not accurately representing the show.

Not to forget people who voted are outsiders. Forum members votes have been cancelled out in the name of foul play.

And mods have clearly stated if banners doesn't fit the criteria they won't be kept here.

The least people can do is respect the effort of the person who made this.

Originally posted by: PeacefulLove

Makes all this sense only if our voice is heard. Just expect our posts to be trashed instead

It should be heard. We have every right to question why a male lead isnt getting his rightful place on the banner and why a banner which represents a past and expired version of the show would be put up again.

And I understand your concern. Well, if somehow, for some odd reason they magically get trashed,we'll just write them again. No problem. Not agreeing to a banner, what is represents and questioning the mods about it definitely doesnt fall under any rulebreaks,last i checked. There is no plausible reason for our posts to get trashed.

Congratulations to the winner and runner up.

All the banners were super good.

Originally posted by: DevilHere

Why was it not mentioned in the banner rules that Abhinav Sharma should be place in the center

It was mentioned Nav , AbhiM,Ak,Ar,MG,KM,KV,Muskan,Abhir,Roo should be present the placement was left to the banner makers discretion

I can count atleast 10-12 banners if I'm being generous that don't fit the Nav should be in the center bill, so is it wasted efforts for those guys

Also Ar is also one of the leads has been since this generation started and a legacy kid so in that manner even she should be in the center so that means 70% of the banners r null and void

The voting was put on hold once and the count of banners was reduced why was this criteria not mentioned then

Wasn't the purpose of Invite Only voting so people can't say it was biased or rigged

Banner makers followed the rules and put their efforts, just because the one we like didn't win doesn't mean we spoil the moment for the winner but....

Congrats to the winning banner.

Must say it's really in poor taste to start calling a winning banner "inaccurate" after the voting is already done.

Why weren't these concerns raised when voting was ongoing? To criticize a winning banner when the person has been declared the winner shows poor sportsmanship.

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Exactly. This is the first time I'm seeing this on IF.....many times your preferred banner may not win a banner contest but to go around raining on the winner's parade like this is😕. I'm really amazed seeing such behavior here.

Exactly

Everyone respects banner makers who are putting their efforts, voting was done and everyone here voted

If there were concerns then they should have been raised prior to the voting, after voting and participating, one can't cry foul

It is in bad taste

Originally posted by: NoraSM

Exactly

Everyone respects banner makers who are putting their efforts, voting was done and everyone here voted

If there were concerns then they should have been raised prior to the voting, after voting and participating, one can't cry foul

It is in bad taste

Well, basic respect has been lacking in this forum in general but I didn't think people would resort to bashing a winning banner after the results have already been declared. This is in very bad taste indeed and I'm feeling really bad for the banner maker who has put in the effort to make the banner.

Now people will think twice before making banners for future contests because this is the treatment they will get even after being declared winners. Instead of getting appreciation, they are being told their banner doesn't deserve to be in the forum....wow.

DT Note:

This is a congratulatory thread for the graphicers and their banners. Kindly refrain from generating fanwars on this thread. Also, kindly refrain from discussing moderation issues on the thread.

-- YRKKH Development Team