He Should Have Done This Instead! - Page 3

Deviation started from the start with the depiction of Arohi. She is nowhere as evil and devious as the sister in Icche Node.

Originally posted by: Lostin90s

Deviation started from the start with the depiction of Arohi. She is nowhere as evil and devious as the sister in Icche Node.

That is where dkp's problem lied from starting trying to make her fl or sail abhirohi sail ,when audience was more confined to abhira from start ,akshara was never treated as fl or when in which serial fl gets a grihapravesh like akshara, they never gave ,proper character growth,its like whatever has to be done abhira has to fail,they never gave proper story ,track to abhira, ekta was better in kis desh premer never waa about main pair ,but after audience love,she changed it ,but dkp whatever happens audience need to accept my choice

Originally posted by: sweta2005

They dont have the guts to do that or they would have done it much earlier,wouldn't have to drag so much ,even give full pov of Akshara, the creative doesnt have much creative left just copy pasting earlier Abhira sequences and putting it now in the serials,they can see they failed in leap ,so cant take it in ego ,they take dialogues from twitter and write it,the writer cant write his creation also better,so whatever fault fans are putting out in twitter, he is correcting it

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Yeah when he deviated from the subject matter and followed his own concept of two mins instant maggie love story then why play victim and give sob ivs that romance did not work, a niche audience only liked Abhira. I got termination letter and my genius writer saved the show.

DKP stuck to Shreemoye so why couldn't the same be implemented for 3rd generation.

Everyone saying leap was brought for sinking ship, well the ship is still sinking. No matter how much yall priase this leap for supposedly saving the show, fact is that the trps are still average. Just because the competition is low doesn't mean it's a good thing. If it falls below 2.1 then it will go to 1.8 again so where exactly is the improvement? We are back to sqaure one.

Abhira has given this show above 3.0 trp so to say that they were not accepted by the audience, is rather delusional. And if Abhira were truly not accepted then they wouldn't be the most popular TV jodi today and neither would audience have given them 3.0+ trp within 2 months and neither would the makers keep then as an option.

The reason they are still not making Navshu official is because they do know they will lose a big chunk of their audience.

Originally posted by: sweta2005

They dont have the guts to do that or they would have done it much earlier,wouldn't have to drag so much ,even give full pov of Akshara, the creative doesnt have much creative left just copy pasting earlier Abhira sequences and putting it now in the serials,they can see they failed in leap ,so cant take it in ego ,they take dialogues from twitter and write it,the writer cant write his creation also better,so whatever fault fans are putting out in twitter, he is correcting it

How will they have the guts bro? The amount of toxicity I see around where people are not just thrashing the story and characters but rather going overboard by making personal attacks on the actors and real people is overwhelming. Koi bhi darr jaye, lol. The story already made no sense since Sirat chapter. Then with Abhira, it turned cringe too, and people lost interest. At that point itself everybody should have complained about poor writing with lota lota and dola re dola dialogues. Poor execution of plotlines, like Ak supporting her sister in the worst situations possible, with Abhim being impulsive in their relationship, emotionally blackmailing Ak to confess her love, and the many more horrible storylines. Not to forget the stupidest Maya chapter. Obviously neutrals lost interest and TRP was dropping because of the cringefest. So thats why with 6 year leap since Kasauli vibe people came back as it reminded them of OG rishta vibes. But HC fans went over the top complaining that his character was getting foreshadowed. But that is because Abhim-Ak were not doing well from the start, though there was great potential in Abhim’s character initially with all the layers and everything, by the Ak-Ab marriage the character was already butchered. So all the complaining that is being done now should have happened long time back when all the cringe was still happening. With all due respect to HC whom I have loved through the years in shows like Left Right Left, Tere Liye, Bepanah; him in YRKKH has not been up to the mark. Maybe its the poor writing, bad dialogue delivery, or terrible direction, idk, but he feels so off, and yet people ask why they brought this track? Because it did better business for DKP. Its now number 2 in TRP list now, sees a consistent TRP through the weeks, so why will they not continue with this story? Its obvious that money matters.

[/QUOTE

Ya thats y post sirat track with n with HC Pr entry trp went up to 2.5 in one week abd 3+ with Abhira centric,track went down when ph tried to make arohi centr and post marriage forced arohi in all tracks which was not needed,there was no function positivity,always a negative drama ,they never gave a character growth of Akshara

Originally posted by: R.G.C

How will they have the guts bro? The amount of toxicity I see around where people are not just thrashing the story and characters but rather going overboard by making personal attacks on the actors and real people is overwhelming. Koi bhi darr jaye, lol. The story already made no sense since Sirat chapter. Then with Abhira, it turned cringe too, and people lost interest. At that point itself everybody should have complained about poor writing with lota lota and dola re dola dialogues. Poor execution of plotlines, like Ak supporting her sister in the worst situations possible, with Abhim being impulsive in their relationship, emotionally blackmailing Ak to confess her love, and the many more horrible storylines. Not to forget the stupidest Maya chapter. Obviously neutrals lost interest and TRP was dropping because of the cringefest. So thats why with 6 year leap since Kasauli vibe people came back as it reminded them of OG rishta vibes. But HC fans went over the top complaining that his character was getting foreshadowed. But that is because Abhim-Ak were not doing well from the start, though there was great potential in Abhim’s character initially with all the layers and everything, by the Ak-Ab marriage the character was already butchered. So all the complaining that is being done now should have happened long time back when all the cringe was still happening. With all due respect to HC whom I have loved through the years in shows like Left Right Left, Tere Liye, Bepanah; him in YRKKH has not been up to the mark. Maybe its the poor writing, bad dialogue delivery, or terrible direction, idk, but he feels so off, and yet people ask why they brought this track? Because it did better business for DKP. Its now number 2 in TRP list now, sees a consistent TRP through the weeks, so why will they not continue with this story? Its obvious that money matters.

Ya trp has gone down from 2.6 to 2.1 ,its great,its 2 becoz other serials are failing not for its good,lets wait for next week what happens as ipl ended others will be above

Originally posted by: Silveraliax

Everyone saying leap was brought for sinking ship, well the ship is still sinking. No matter how much yall priase this leap for supposedly saving the show, fact is that the trps are still average. Just because the competition is low doesn't mean it's a good thing. If it falls below 2.1 then it will go to 1.8 again so where exactly is the improvement? We are back to sqaure one.

Abhira has given this show above 3.0 trp so to say that they were not accepted by the audience, is rather delusional. And if Abhira were truly not accepted then they wouldn't be the most popular TV jodi today and neither would audience have given them 3.0+ trp within 2 months and neither would the makers keep then as an option.

The reason they are still not making Navshu official is because they do know they will lose a big chunk of their audience.

That s the point. Trp did not decrease at all. It's constant. All through the most crucial phase of Ipl, Ye Rishta sustained. Only show apart from Anupamaa to do that. Anupamaa s highest trp during Ipl phase is 2.9. So, Ye Rishta has done just fine. The track worked

Online popularity does not matter. Even then the most popular jodi is Katha-Viaan, not Abhira

Yrkkh use to get TRPs of 3.0+ before Abhira and it will continue to get after Abhira. In fact, Trps were far superior pre-Abhira period.

Yrkkh is a cult classic. It does not need Abhira/Harshali to work.

The show sustained even after Karan-Hina left. Naksh is still the most popular couple of Ye Rishta in the real world and will remain so. So, it will do just fine even if Harshad-Pranali leaves

The very simple fact is that all Abhira has done is put a dent in YRKKH s legacy with their cringe romance.

Originally posted by: Indira1211

they just needed to have improved on abhimanyu and akshara character arcs and there would have been no need for abhinav character. Many viewers like abhinav and are rooting for him because they introduced his character which was so good, mature and decent compared to abhimanyu..if they hadn’t brought in abhinav and just changed abhimanyu and made him,good , mature and kind..we all would have been rooting for abhira and there would not have been two fandoms. They gave us this immature abhira preleap that only young people liked and older mature viewers got bored with.. and so,trps fell. In season 2 no third angle came between kaira ..even vedika was nothing in karthiks life.. but now akshara clearly has strong feelings for abhinav..she’s even romancing him.. and she’s married to him..so the first/true love and only love essence of abhira is lost 🤷🏻‍♀️

They know how to develop characters. All of a sudden the derailment took place only when 3rd generation started? or Rajan Shahi wanted to prove that I am bigger than the show itself.

Garima only safeguarded Aarohi's interest at the cost of the leads.

When Bhavna took over she made a extreme Abhimanyu Birla into a lovefool. Akshara's maturity vanished.

Tracks were left open ended.

Entire premise was written to prove that Abhira weren't meant for each other.

Sacrifice track gave way to immaturity and impulsive behaviour. Trps dipped to 1.8 - 1.9 when out of the blue Abhimanyu handed over the divorce deed to Akshara. Reunion took the numbers back to 2.2.

White episode destroyed Abhira.

In the second generation, Vedika did not matter but here Abhinav does as the current theme seems to be about second chances.

All said and done makers were successful with Abhinav but Abirohi hit a dead end.

Mission was only partly successful.

As a result 3rd generation suffered and blame game started. It does look like a huge dent these days.

Who is the culprit?

Rajan Shahi should take onus and not act indifferent.