Is Ruhi IVF Kid? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Rancho12345

Ya that I know ITV can't be taken seriously but does it even remotely makes sense for a woman to become pregnant through IVF using someone else sperms (and her husband doesn't have any medical problem of not becoming father) While Her Husband Is Convinced that she is pregnant with his baby

In case she uses Neil's own sperms to become mother then Ruhi still Remains Neil's Daughter Anyways so nothing changes with respect to her equation with Birla Family.

Though It Would Be Even more messed up situation to think that a woman is ok to get impregnated with her husband through IVF but not biologically.

I'm getting Headache to even think on these lines 😕

Pehle yeh kitkat kha lo... Take a kitkat break (I don't work for this company... Just slogan pata hai) ...

Ab socho... Ruhi ko angel de gayi ho, conceive hui ho, ya IVF se hui ho, ya adopt ki ho....

humein farak padta?

Na padta ho toh headache kyun lena? Fiction and there will be lot of theories, some would be hilarious, some would be pure crap, some would be logical... Ultimately, accept that matches your imagination 😆 baaki sab ignore karo!

One fun theory I read.. Aru kabhi pregnant thi hi nai... She started using woh those pillows used in films ... And during delivery ek nurse aayi baby ko adoption center se utha kar aur chup chaap rakh diya...

Agar writers IF par aa akar story likhte hai, as many assume, this is just one more idea...

The whole sequence was very confusing, but here is my understanding of it. Arohi got pregnant result right when it was revealed that Ak can't get pregnant. Then in the next couple days Arohi got to know she is not really pregnant and Ak got to know that she is. After that, Arohi pretended to be pregnant for quite a while ~ a few weeks. Ak also found out that she was visiting an IVF facility, but when she spied on her, Arohi was heard saying she doesn't want to go through with it. Then Ak exposed Arohi, and within a week of that, Arohi got pregnant for real. So that's why people are saying the timing was very convenient and could have been IVF. Pretty much a week or so later, Neil died.

Also, it was very clear that Neil wasn't intimate with Arohi after she announced her pregnancy (the first time). So there were no intimate relations for about a month before she announced her pregnancy.

It's all plausible, really. So in the ITV universe, both options exist, and they can use whichever one depending on the story direction. But I strongly doubt they will go the IVF route unless they really want to remove Arohi from the story. Abhi will likely realize that Arohi is manipulating Ruhi against Abhir. And maybe also find out that she knew before him about Abhir. Maybe Arohi ends up doing some other shitty things in the meantime. And Abhi realizes that she has never changed and starts hating her again, which would remove the possibility of marriage. Also, the way people are discussing things, Abhira might be forced to get together for Abhir's sake, in which case the families might flip and decide to support Abhira instead of Arohi. We really don't know at this point.

Originally posted by: Rancho12345

Lastly Even Biological Pregnancy Also Takes Time that too doesn't Happen Overnight It's Possible 1st Test Show Negetive And After Some Time It Shows Positive This Much Leverage Has To Be Given To YRKKH After All It's Not Science Documentry Made For Educational Purposes Of Online Audience To Find Logic In It!

Well what i believe is makers have left this loose end coz they definitely don't have anything concrete. They are playing day to day or max weekly basis so you never know.

Also, these assumptions raises from several incidents

a) After fake alarm- Aruhi did visited the clinic

b) she was caught by Neil was in GV and then voila pregnant- all in a couple of days max

About the above part that's what biologically it's not possible coz she got her period and she was actually on it considering her period lasted 4-5 days and she got caught during that time only - it's just makers themselves didn't realise this

So aruhi got a fake alarm but got her period indication of her not getting pregnant.

Wanted to get physical with Neil again so that pregnancy turns true- makers clearly showed scenes indicating they're not doing it

a) time issue - neil kahin na kahin kuch na kuch doing

b) neil concern k let's not do it abi new new pregnancy h

Clearly the makers were in between ideas and confused the audience so now that until they start with it again you never know Ruhi is IVF baby or not.

Although i personally doubt that she can be coz how else are they going to pave the way for Akshara in the heart of Manju Mata.

Baki toh DKP jaane 😌

Originally posted by: lagjagale

The whole sequence was very confusing, but here is my understanding of it. Arohi got pregnant result right when it was revealed that Ak can't get pregnant. Then in the next couple days Arohi got to know she is not really pregnant and Ak got to know that she is. After that, Arohi pretended to be pregnant for quite a while ~ a few weeks. Ak also found out that she was visiting an IVF facility, but when she spied on her, Arohi was heard saying she doesn't want to go through with it. Then Ak exposed Arohi, and within a week of that, Arohi got pregnant for real. So that's why people are saying the timing was very convenient and could have been IVF. Pretty much a week or so later, Neil died.

Also, it was very clear that Neil wasn't intimate with Arohi after she announced her pregnancy (the first time). So there were no intimate relations for about a month before she announced her pregnancy.

It's all plausible, really. So in the ITV universe, both options exist, and they can use whichever one depending on the story direction. But I strongly doubt they will go the IVF route unless they really want to remove Arohi from the story. Abhi will likely realize that Arohi is manipulating Ruhi against Abhir. And maybe also find out that she knew before him about Abhir. Maybe Arohi ends up doing some other shitty things in the meantime. And Abhi realizes that she has never changed and starts hating her again, which would remove the possibility of marriage. Also, the way people are discussing things, Abhira might be forced to get together for Abhir's sake, in which case the families might flip and decide to support Abhira instead of Arohi. We really don't know at this point.

Yes that's what makes me confused too.

Hahaha yeah the story now is like expect the unexpected

Originally posted by: lagjagale

Arohi was heard saying she doesn't want to go through with it. Then Ak exposed Arohi, and within a week of that, Arohi got pregnant for real. So that's why people are saying the timing was very convenient and could have been IVF. Pretty much a week or so later, Neil died.

Also, it was very clear that Neil wasn't intimate with Arohi after she announced her pregnancy (the first time). So there were no intimate relations for about a month before she announced her pregnancy.

It's Not Shown Either By Scenes Or Arohi's Dailogues That She Actually Went Through IVF So It's Not Convincing For Me Also 1 Week Isn't Sufficient For Successful IVF Pregnancy.

Fact That Neil Believed That Arohi Is Actually Pregnant With His Child On Both Occassions Convinced Me That They Were Sexually Active Couple Or Else Neil Would Have Outrightly Rejected Her Claim Stating No Physical Relations Between Them.

I can't rule out anything In ITV world but honestly I cant imagine a scenario like Ruhi being an IVF Baby it's too ILLOGICAL And Even Unprecedented For An ITV Show.

Originally posted by: chaipaani

Although i personally doubt that she can be coz how else are they going to pave the way for Akshara in the heart of Manju Mata.

Baki toh DKP jaane 😌

Dkp not showing that Arohi Actually Went Through IVF or Arohi Even Through Self Talk Admitting Of Doing So And Neil Being Convinced That She Is Indeed Pregnant With His Baby Makes Me Believe That Ruhi Is Not IVF Kid And Neil Was Sexually Active With Arohi Rest Let's See What They Show But Until They Explicitly Clear That Ruhi Is IVF Kid I Can't Accept This Bcz It's Abnormal Even For ITV, Such Incident Has Never Taken Place In Any Show Till Date.

Biological Pregnancy Does Happen Like A Miracle In ITV Quite Often Though!

Dkp not showing that Arohi Actually Went Through IVF or Arohi Even Through Self Talk Admitting Of Doing So And Neil Being Convinced That She Is Indeed Pregnant With His Baby Makes Me Believe That Ruhi Is Not IVF Kid And Neil Was Sexually Active With Arohi Rest Let's See What They Show But Until They Explicitly Clear That Ruhi Is IVF Kid I Can't Accept This Bcz It's Abnormal Even For ITV, Such Incident Has Never Taken Place In Any Show Till Date.

Biological Pregnancy Does Happen Like A Miracle In ITV Quite Often Though!

Hey so first of all I feel you are coming out too strong. Nobody is telling you to believe anything. These are just theories and the production house will anyway do whatever they feels like doing.

About Abnormal in ITV i don't think so when a watermelon can become a baby, we have almost all types of ichadhari animals/reptiles.

And even in YRKKH many many things were left open ended and 70% of the things doesn't make sense.

Originally posted by: Rancho12345

Cost Is Not An Issue For Arohi But Ya It's Too Time Consuming (Plus No Guarantee As Well though this point can be overlooked) So It Looks Impossible To Be True I Don't Expect Logic In Tv Show But It's Too Much I Mean She Can't Get Pregnant Overnight. I can accept her being biologically pregnant without them explicitly showing Suhagraat Sequence For Neil And Arohi As It's Something Normal btwn married couples But Can't Accept Her Being Pregnant Through IVF while being sexually active with Neil (As Without that Neil Cant Believe She Is Pregnant With His Child) Without Any Explicit Scene To Prove This As It's Not Normal Btwn Married Couples.

Originally posted by: PeacefulLove

Exactly I have gone through IVF myself and know how complicated that process it but it's not easy to understand by everyone as they are in different age groups.

But don't take the comments seriously. All kinds of theories are made here to get Abhinav and Aarohi out of Abhiras life. And writers can't be trusted either. They can change tracks as per their convenience. Akshara is already changing overnight. And to unite Abhira they can take any path.

The funniest Theory Which I Read On This Forum Was That Arohi Had Black File/Folder In Her Hands While Talking To Abhir Yesterday So That Proves That Ruhi Is An IVF Baby It Was Then That I Lost It 🥴

Originally posted by: Indira1211

so far it’s assumed that Ruhi was conceived naturally as manjeri said Arohi was 3 months pregnant when Neil died. So first she lied she was pregnant..because she had had a false positive test..then it was corrected with a proper blood test..and she couldn’t back out..as she had told everyone she was pregnant..it was then that the ivf talks happened..but akshara exposed her..then Neil was angry with her..but they got back together ..and it’s assumed she got pregnant naturally because Neil knew she was pregnant when he was dying and he asked Abhimanyu to be there for his child. So Ruhi was a natural conception child..so far that’s what we can assume from what’s been shown in the show 🤷🏻‍♀️

Yes Agreed, You have provided correct series of events (along with right conclusion) just like makers have shown in the show without making assumptions as per your wish on basis of some random objects which appear in the episode just to suit your narrative!