What if one day you get accused the way i was?

Thing is -- i remember Kartik saying to Naira that he loves her waaay more than she loves him and that is why everything she does hurts him so much.

Originally posted by: Stardust91

Thing is -- i remember Kartik saying to Naira that he loves her waaay more than she loves him and that is why everything she does hurts him so much.

All he is doing is out of hurt and therefore if he feels so much then NO; he won't be able to bear the accusations that he will receive if this plan fails and when he knows the truth it will be even worse.

I still feel all this is because he is SOOO hurt that Naira wants to divorce him - he had hope when they met in Mumbai and then Mata arrived...

Maybe Mansi gets upset and gets into an accident and he is blamed -- then he will realise how wrong he was -- remains to be seen how the story plays out...

Janmashtami is in September -- so i feel the milan will be around then

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

Karthik was accused for less than a week...yess he was also being accused of causing Akshara's accident and Naira was unwilling to listen to him that day as she knew he was drinking and driving...she saw proofs against him and believed those proofs...she pushed him...threw him out of house...he kept saying he didn't killed Akshara and she was unwilling to listen...but after a day or two she closed the case despite of believing that Karthik killed Akshara but Karthik didn't accept her apology...than Karthik's father and chachu send Kashyap to make Naira believe Karthik didn't caused that accident and Naira tried her level best to prove Karthik innocent...when truth of Manish and Akilesh betraying Karthik was revealed post marriage they were forgiven after a day as if nothing ever happened...

Before what happened with Naira...let's understand a scenario...If I see my childhood best friend taking drugs...I threaten him to inform his parents being family friends...but he begs infront of me not to inform his parents...as he himself will inform them...he needs time to face his parents...I agree but on condition that if he didn't inform within few days I myself will inform them...unfortunately he overdosed after a day and died...will his parents accuse me of his death because I knew about his addiction? or will they accuse themselves for not keeping track of his unusual activities?...for not understanding him?...Who accuse somebody of murder because he/she hide about their children activities?

Naira was accused for 2 long years and even after that she is accused whenever he is angry (post leap)...so she lived in that guilt for 2 long years and is living with it even now...Naira and Karthik's case is entirely different from scenario presented...Karthik can't fathom Naira hiding anything from him...more than focusing on situation that may have led to Naira hiding about Shubham's addiction...he keeps focusing on "Things would have been alright If Naira informed him"..."Shubham would be alive if Naira informed him" that's the reason Naira should be punished and kept away from him and from his family...according to Karthik's perspective...for me he is unnecessarily punishing her...to be precise he claimed to hate her in those 2 years based on his single belief...she hides...only she hide truths?...Suwarna mata...Akhilesh...Manish...KD...Mansi...Krthik himself...never ever hide anything?...they were responsible for Shubham...Suwarna mata for giving him what he wanted without even assuring that its better for him or not and further destroying his life after making him dead infront of entire family for 19 years...Manish even after understanding what Shubham was going going through...being concerned about Shubham his endless pain...why he didn't keep track of his son's activities knowing he was suicidal and highly impulsive?...where was Manish the most logical person who believes in actions that time?

Being accused of murder by causing accident (according to proofs) of ur gf's mother and being accused of murder by hiding about BIL's drug addition (he took Naira's name Naira knew truth from before that's it)...are different sort of accusations...I've seen close relative forgiving a drunkard who was a stranger...closing the case...for causing accident of her 6 year old son who lost his life...while forgiving she repeated...my son won't return...most of relatives were against her forgiving her son's murderer...but she was adamant...her husband was with her...she use to teach me too...recently I told her about yrkkh...and she replied don't take serials too seriously at the end they need to exaggerate things to increase drama quotient...I haven't seen any lady as mature as forgiving as her...point is...hiding truth doesn't make someone responsible for someone's death and there are people in real life too who forgive someone even after losing the closest one...

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

Karthik was accused for less than a week...yess he was also being accused of causing Akshara's accident and Naira was unwilling to listen to him that day as she knew he was drinking and driving...she saw proofs against him and believed those proofs...she pushed him...threw him out of house...he kept saying he didn't killed Akshara and she was unwilling to listen...but after a day or two she closed the case despite of believing that Karthik killed Akshara but Karthik didn't accept her apology...than Karthik's father and chachu send Kashyap to make Naira believe Karthik didn't caused that accident and Naira tried her level best to prove Karthik innocent...when truth of Manish and Akilesh betraying Karthik was revealed post marriage they were forgiven after a day as if nothing ever happened...

Before what happened with Naira...let's understand a scenario...If I see my childhood best friend taking drugs...I threaten him to inform his parents being family friends...but he begs infront of me not to inform his parents...as he himself will inform them...he needs time to face his parents...I agree but on condition that if he didn't inform within few days I myself will inform them...unfortunately he overdosed after a day and died...will his parents accuse me of his death because I knew about his addiction? or will they accuse themselves for not keeping track of his unusual activities?...for not understanding him?...Who accuse somebody of murder because he/she hide about their children activities?

Naira was accused for 2 long years and even after that she is accused whenever he is angry (post leap)...so she lived in that guilt for 2 long years and is living with it even now...Naira and Karthik's case is entirely different from scenario presented...Karthik can't fathom Naira hiding anything from him...more than focusing on situation that may have led to Naira hiding about Shubham's addiction...he keeps focusing on "Things would have been alright If Naira informed him"..."Shubham would be alive if Naira informed him" that's the reason Naira should be punished and kept away from him and from his family...according to Karthik's perspective...for me he is unnecessarily punishing her...to be precise he claimed to hate her in those 2 years based on his single belief...she hides...only she hide truths?...Suwarna mata...Akhilesh...Manish...KD...Mansi...Krthik himself...never ever hide anything?...they were responsible for Shubham...Suwarna mata for giving him what he wanted without even assuring that its better for him or not and further destroying his life after making him dead infront of entire family for 19 years...Manish even after understanding what Shubham was going going through...being concerned about Shubham his endless pain...why he didn't keep track of his son's activities knowing he was suicidal and highly impulsive?...where was Manish the most logical person who believes in actions that time?

Being accused of murder by causing accident (according to proofs) of ur gf's mother and being accused of murder by hiding about BIL's drug addition (he took Naira's name Naira knew truth from before that's it)...are different sort of accusations...I've seen close relative forgiving a drunkard who was a stranger...closing the case...for causing accident of her 6 year old son who lost his life...while forgiving she repeated...my son won't return...most of relatives were against her forgiving her son's murderer...but she was adamant...her husband was with her...she use to teach me too...recently I told her about yrkkh...and she replied don't take serials too seriously at the end they need to exaggerate things to increase drama quotient...I haven't seen any lady as mature as forgiving as her...point is...hiding truth doesn't make someone responsible for someone's death and there are people in real life too who forgive someone even after losing the closest one...

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

Karthik was accused for less than a week...yess he was also being accused of causing Akshara's accident and Naira was unwilling to listen to him that day as she knew he was drinking and driving...she saw proofs against him and believed those proofs...she pushed him...threw him out of house...he kept saying he didn't killed Akshara and she was unwilling to listen...but after a day or two she closed the case despite of believing that Karthik killed Akshara but Karthik didn't accept her apology...than Karthik's father and chachu send Kashyap to make Naira believe Karthik didn't caused that accident and Naira tried her level best to prove Karthik innocent...when truth of Manish and Akilesh betraying Karthik was revealed post marriage they were forgiven after a day as if nothing ever happened...

Before what happened with Naira...let's understand a scenario...If I see my childhood best friend taking drugs...I threaten him to inform his parents being family friends...but he begs infront of me not to inform his parents...as he himself will inform them...he needs time to face his parents...I agree but on condition that if he didn't inform within few days I myself will inform them...unfortunately he overdosed after a day and died...will his parents accuse me of his death because I knew about his addiction? or will they accuse themselves for not keeping track of his unusual activities?...for not understanding him?...Who accuse somebody of murder because he/she hide about their children activities?

Naira was accused for 2 long years and even after that she is accused whenever he is angry (post leap)...so she lived in that guilt for 2 long years and is living with it even now...Naira and Karthik's case is entirely different from scenario presented...Karthik can't fathom Naira hiding anything from him...more than focusing on situation that may have led to Naira hiding about Shubham's addiction...he keeps focusing on "Things would have been alright If Naira informed him"..."Shubham would be alive if Naira informed him" that's the reason Naira should be punished and kept away from him and from his family...according to Karthik's perspective...for me he is unnecessarily punishing her...to be precise he claimed to hate her in those 2 years based on his single belief...she hides...only she hide truths?...Suwarna mata...Akhilesh...Manish...KD...Mansi...Krthik himself...never ever hide anything?...they were responsible for Shubham...Suwarna mata for giving him what he wanted without even assuring that its better for him or not and further destroying his life after making him dead infront of entire family for 19 years...Manish even after understanding what Shubham was going going through...being concerned about Shubham his endless pain...why he didn't keep track of his son's activities knowing he was suicidal and highly impulsive?...where was Manish the most logical person who believes in actions that time?

Being accused of murder by causing accident (according to proofs) of ur gf's mother and being accused of murder by hiding about BIL's drug addition (he took Naira's name Naira knew truth from before that's it)...are different sort of accusations...I've seen close relative forgiving a drunkard who was a stranger...closing the case...for causing accident of her 6 year old son who lost his life...while forgiving she repeated...my son won't return...most of relatives were against her forgiving her son's murderer...but she was adamant...her husband was with her...she use to teach me too...recently I told her about yrkkh...and she replied don't take serials too seriously at the end they need to exaggerate things to increase drama quotient...I haven't seen any lady as mature as forgiving as her...point is...hiding truth doesn't make someone responsible for someone's death and there are people in real life too who forgive someone even after losing the closest one...

@Red

for me kartik is the biggest idiot... i remember when nairas cousin nanu was using drugs kartik was the first one to figure it out by observing nanus behaviour... and when shubham was doing the same thing kartik couldnt figure it out? and this time he had more proof of how shubham was withdrawing large sums of cash and how when they cut him off shubham went to the extent of stealing cash from his parents... it makes it easier to blame someone else than to think where oneself went wrong... so thats why i feel kartik and his mother find it better to blame naira than to consider themselves wrong...

I feel like the entire Goenka family literally placed all responsibilities related to Shubham on Naira.. for what reason, i dont know?

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

Karthik was accused for less than a week...yess he was also being accused of causing Akshara's accident and Naira was unwilling to listen to him that day as she knew he was drinking and driving...she saw proofs against him and believed those proofs...she pushed him...threw him out of house...he kept saying he didn't killed Akshara and she was unwilling to listen...but after a day or two she closed the case despite of believing that Karthik killed Akshara but Karthik didn't accept her apology...than Karthik's father and chachu send Kashyap to make Naira believe Karthik didn't caused that accident and Naira tried her level best to prove Karthik innocent...when truth of Manish and Akilesh betraying Karthik was revealed post marriage they were forgiven after a day as if nothing ever happened...

Before what happened with Naira...let's understand a scenario...If I see my childhood best friend taking drugs...I threaten him to inform his parents being family friends...but he begs infront of me not to inform his parents...as he himself will inform them...he needs time to face his parents...I agree but on condition that if he didn't inform within few days I myself will inform them...unfortunately he overdosed after a day and died...will his parents accuse me of his death because I knew about his addiction? or will they accuse themselves for not keeping track of his unusual activities?...for not understanding him?...Who accuse somebody of murder because he/she hide about their children activities?

Naira was accused for 2 long years and even after that she is accused whenever he is angry (post leap)...so she lived in that guilt for 2 long years and is living with it even now...Naira and Karthik's case is entirely different from scenario presented...Karthik can't fathom Naira hiding anything from him...more than focusing on situation that may have led to Naira hiding about Shubham's addiction...he keeps focusing on "Things would have been alright If Naira informed him"..."Shubham would be alive if Naira informed him" that's the reason Naira should be punished and kept away from him and from his family...according to Karthik's perspective...for me he is unnecessarily punishing her...to be precise he claimed to hate her in those 2 years based on his single belief...she hides...only she hide truths?...Suwarna mata...Akhilesh...Manish...KD...Mansi...Krthik himself...never ever hide anything?...they were responsible for Shubham...Suwarna mata for giving him what he wanted without even assuring that its better for him or not and further destroying his life after making him dead infront of entire family for 19 years...Manish even after understanding what Shubham was going going through...being concerned about Shubham his endless pain...why he didn't keep track of his son's activities knowing he was suicidal and highly impulsive?...where was Manish the most logical person who believes in actions that time?

Being accused of murder by causing accident (according to proofs) of ur gf's mother and being accused of murder by hiding about BIL's drug addition (he took Naira's name Naira knew truth from before that's it)...are different sort of accusations...I've seen close relative forgiving a drunkard who was a stranger...closing the case...for causing accident of her 6 year old son who lost his life...while forgiving she repeated...my son won't return...most of relatives were against her forgiving her son's murderer...but she was adamant...her husband was with her...she use to teach me too...recently I told her about yrkkh...and she replied don't take serials too seriously at the end they need to exaggerate things to increase drama quotient...I haven't seen any lady as mature as forgiving as her...point is...hiding truth doesn't make someone responsible for someone's death and there are people in real life too who forgive someone even after losing the closest one...