A fun game + discussion for Sunday

Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Here's a little story.
In a small Medieval French village, there lives a young married woman. She is extremely bored and unhappy because her husband is a businessman and is almost never there as he is busy traveling most of the time.

She lives in House A on the left bank.

The village is divided into two parts by a river that flows across the entire village. The villagers have 2 options to go from the left bank to the right bank. They can either use the bridge (just one bridge in the village) or they can take a boat ride and reach the opposite bank. There is just one boatman as it's really a very small village with very few inhabitants.

One fine evening, the young woman decides to go to attend a party thrown by a neighbour who lives in House B also on the left bank. She had invited her and the young woman had said she just might come along.

In the party, the bored young woman starts interacting with the local Romeo (playboy of the village) and allows herself to be charmed and seduced by him.

She leaves with him and spends the night with him in his house, which is House C on the right bank, on the other side of the river.

As soon as dawn breaks, the young woman wakes up and remembers with a start that her husband would be returning from his trip during the early part of the day.

She rushes to the bridge as she wants to be back home before he gets back. As she approaches the bridge, she notices with horror that there is a trigger-happy madman on the bridge shooting anything and everything that comes within his sight.

She takes a U-turn upon seeing this and heads towards the boat. She asks the boatman to ferry her back home. The ride usually costs 5 Euros but given the crisis situation, the boatman wants to make the best of the circumstances and demands 50 Euros upfront. She had not carried her purse in her bag and therefore has no money. She promises the boatman that she would pay him as soon as he drops her on the other side. He would have to wait for just 5 minutes. The boatman refuses. He has many takers and doesn't want to waste a single second.

She goes back to her one-night lover's house and explains the situation to him and asks him to help out. He refuses point blank. In fact he looks at her as if asking who the hell are you??

She remembers that there is this guy who was terribly in love with her and who claimed to still love her but whose feelings she never reciprocated as she considered him as just a good friend and had made it clear to him throughout lived in House D on the same side of the village.

She rushes to his house and explains the whole situation to him, the party the night before, the night spent with the playboy, the madman on the bridge, her husband's imminent return, the boatman's demand, the playboy's refusal to help her and asks him to help her out with the money. She promises him she would return the money very soon. he refuses to help her as he is extremely disappointed with her behaviour and is very upset.

She makes a last-ditch attempt with the boatman once again who also refuses citing the same conditions as before.

She has no choice but to go by the bridge. She approaches the bridge and the madman shoots and kills her.

The young woman is dead.

Now comes the question.

Who, in your opinion, is the one who is most responsible for the untimely death of this young woman, her husband?,, the lover?, the platonic friend?, the boatman?, the madman? or the young woman herself?

šŸ˜‰

Waiting for your answers my dear friends. Hope this will slightly make Sunday easier.


.
Edited by Padmajaan - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

884

Users

10

Likes

80

Frequent Posters

1082575 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Umm the woman may have committed adultery because she was feeling lonely, I'm not justifying what she's done is right, but I think the madman is responsible I mean seriously man, he's the one on the killing spree.
1082575 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
But again, she's kinda responsible too, it just struck me šŸ˜†
She didn't have to go to the bridge, reaching home on time wasn't worth her life
I mean she could've somehow stayed on the other side of the village until that man was taken care of
Edited by __Harshi__ - 7 years ago
Anonanon0306 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Tough one, but I'll go with the woman herself. Not coz of the choices she made last night, but for the simple fact that she chose to risk it and take the bridge knowing that the madman was firing away.

In my mind, if she did not know of the madman and say met her death by accident, I would have said the madman. But this was a conscious choice, no different from saying there was a landslide and you still chose to trek across the mountain.

The other two men, the friend and the lover in my mind are also similar agencies having nothing to do with the death. The friend's refusal to help was his right. and he didn't push her on the bridge. She could have chosen to stay back and tell the hubby the truth. The lover, however obnoxious, too has a similar role. Sure they made the situation tough for her but the decision was hers and hers alone.

Hubby, i don't think has a role to play at all here. If she were so unhappy, could have separated or simply owned up to whatever happened the night before.

I am a strong believer of your destiny is in your on hands and your life is what you make out of it.. so pardon my action bias.
Mannmohanaa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
The Young woman herself is responsible. As she chose to spend the night with someone who was likely to forget her the next day. She should've enquired with his behaviour first. :)
The boatman has no reason to favour her, her own karma with that platonic lover came around. She chose a wrong person to spend night with and then in haste ended up self offering herself to death.
As for the husband, he too is partially responsible but I personally feel you've to fend for your happiness in this world unless someone really selflessly loves you.
You are responsible for your choices :)
Mannmohanaa thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Anonanon0306

Tough one, but I'll go with the woman herself. Not coz of the choices she made last night, but for the simple fact that she chose to risk it and take the bridge knowing that the madman was firing away.

In my mind, if she did not know of the madman and say met her death by accident, I would have said the madman. But this was a conscious choice, no different from saying there was a landslide and you still chose to trek across the mountain.

The other two men, the friend and the lover in my mind are also similar agencies having nothing to do with the death. The friend's refusal to help was his right. and he didn't push her on the bridge. She could have chosen to stay back and tell the hubby the truth. The lover, however obnoxious, too has a similar role. Sure they made the situation tough for her but the decision was hers and hers alone.

Hubby, i don't think has a role to play at all here. If she were so unhappy, could have separated or simply owned up to whatever happened the night before.

I am a strong believer of your destiny is in your on hands and your life is what you make out of it.. so pardon my action bias.


Wuuhooo!
Ditto same explanation!😃
Except a tiny starting bit šŸ˜†

Cheers!šŸ¤—
A.Green thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
Husband is responsible!! Why was he returning the same day? Pehle toh chod kar gaya wife ko šŸ˜†

It is clearly mentioned though, he was always traveling and didn't give time to her. Still she thought of him first, and knew he won't like her not being at home :P

So she came running back for the good-for-nothing husband who may have had many flings on his business trips šŸ˜‰

Don't kill me for this answer 🤣

war_is_peace thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
the woman!
itni rich hai toh akkal ghaas charne gayi thi?
all she had to do was fill her purse the previous night šŸ˜†

ok apart from that too sher ke mooh mein haath daloge to haath return thodi milega. kisne bola thaa madman ke direction mein jaane ko.

but i think its no one's fault. it was meant to happen. she was unhappy n she got mukti. end of story šŸ˜†
Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Hehehehehe
I will give my answers at the end.

This was a game we were made to play and we had to give our answer and justify it at a training in France.

There were more than 20 nationalities among my fellow trainees, a few Americans, a couple of Japanese, other Europeans, Swiss, Italian, Spanish, German, etc. many Asians from different countries including China, people from Latin America, from Africa, from Eastern Europe, well you get the hang of it from all over the world.

Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
Will also tell you who the maximum people voted for and why.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".