Do not kill Mukhi's character...Please!

whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Don't kill Mukhi's character...Please!

Yesterday was the first time I got an opportunity to see the most awaited and the most desired episode alone. With bells on and butterflies in my stomach, I was waiting the first scene to start, Aru turned all pleasantly surprised, she couldn't believe her ears...She reached out to behold her the man she loved. I was at the edge of my seat and the scene focused on Mukhiji. With bated breath, I focused on Mukhi's face...and BAMMM...WHAT...????? What reaction was that???? Mukhi with his head hung down with a feeling of GUILT painted all over his face.. But for what?... Or was He ashamed ...again for what? Oh no it cannot be! I could not believe what's was in front of me. I tried to console myself, my poor Mukhi must be feeling shy' and I must have terribly misunderstood it but then to my horror and disappointment, I was so sure it wasn't his shyness because Aru had to hold his face up to sooth him like a child. Aru was soothing him with her sooth talk to take him out of his guilt feelings - "Dekhiye mere taraf,... har pal yaad aati hai meri,... pyaar karten hai na mujh se,... aur luch kehna chahte hai?...to me Aru looked like a teacher and Mukhi nodding to every question like a kindergarten student who could not recite Baba Black sheep have you any wool...' to her teacher.

Sorry for such an opposite reaction, but being an ardent fan of Mukhi's character, I just couldn't take it in the way some of the post from my beloved fellow forum members have described. After I read those beautifully explained post I thought maybe I missed something yesterday so I watched the episode again but to my frustration I just could not agree with them.

The Creatives took two full episodes to build up "the confession and after two such intense and beautifully picturized scenes, it fell so flat at the climax. Why was all that building up of momentum?.. For Mukhi to realize his feelings for Aru, right? And he did realize. He realized not only his love for Aru but also a need to have her. That is why he held her hand so firmly and confidently, saying he could not let her go. I just loved that poise and confidence in Mukhi gesture. It was enough to show that he is now ready to take the rein in his hand. But that is not what I got to see. I agree, In initial stages Aru had to take the lead but she couldn't have making him say I love you'. Such a pathetic portrayal of Mukhi's character. Sorry to say but in that scene with those expressions smeared all over his face it reminded me of Anil Kapoor of Movie Ishwar. ...Bhala Bhala, childlike young man who does not understand a thing about love and his wife has to teach him that. As much as I loved Anil as Ishwar, I hated Mukhi childlike projection in the most awaited love confession. I beg to defer but there was nothing cute in that scene. Rather it was very childish to show if he does not understand what love is. This show is not about teenagers love, to expect cuteness here. Mukhi is a matured 42 years old man who not only knows the depth of being in love but also had helped two lovers to unite. Remember! He understands emotions and can very well express them too. Agreed, he had a lot of hesitation regarding his love for Aru initially but now after such a beautiful build-up by showing a foot kissing and cosy hugs Mukhi was shown still contemplating with his feelings. Why do they now want to show him dysfunctional in emotional expression. Please do not make Mukhi's character a caricature. Please do not mess with his character. Mukhi is simple...but not gullible, He is hesitant but not stupid. He is sober because of what he has been through, I would love see glimpses of youthfulness peeking out of his personality here and there but please don't let him portray as a teenager puppy in love shying before his lady love where Aru has to pat him to make him feel confident. Like everything else Mukhi's character is also mature enough to handle his love feelings. So far he has been shown as a bit raw and unpolished villager, but supremely proud for his culture. Traditional yet progressive. He back women's right to work as much as he back their right to choose their life partner. (Guess that is why he was angree with Aru to give her consent for marrying him). He appreciates and respects Aru and her city lifestyle, yet he had never belittled his village lifestyle. So why then now he should feel ashamed of his torn shoes or his own worthiness or feel guilty about his love or feel shy in front of Aru and more so, why then he felt the need to express his love in Angregi! And then Aru had to trick him to say it in Gujarati?...This is not how he is. Mukhi does not deserved to be shown like a caricature of Rajkappor ke zamane ke village man. Do not destroy the uniqueness of his peronality.

The only consolation yesterday was when Mukhi says confidently, "Main toh ise sambhal loonga par kya Aru apne armaan sambhal payegi? That's who Mukhi is, self-assured and straight forwards. My humble request to the Creatives, Please do not kill it. Rest of the time when again he was shown searching for wards to say something to Aru...well I think I have spoken my mind and disappointment loud and clear.

By the way, I loved the relation shown between Aru and her Mom, so open. And restoration of friendship between Aru and Sangvi and Aru's growing trust on Mikhi's and Sangvi's friendship.

Edited by whitepearl - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.5k

Users

5

Likes

43

Frequent Posters

-RadhaRani- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
@pearl
i can totally understand what u felt even that 'Hu Tane Prem Karu Chu' also put me off and felt OTT.but i am very much ok with his nodding nodding and nodding ..that the our mukhi ji.that time he don't have any words so Aru gave him words and he agree that's very much ArMu style.
ShadeOfWhite thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
ok let me explain this to u..yes I was one of them who simply loved the confession and found the nods beautiful..

u know think about Mukhi's character...he is shy guy right? he is reserved and restrained right? he understands others emotions well...he teaches the little things of life very maturely..but when it comes to himself, he is shy..he is plain shy to confront the happenings of his heart..the idea of marriage itself scared him let alone falling in love..the very first time Mishri wanted him to get married..what not he did to stop it?! and now the idea of falling in love and when he actually fell in love made him go crazy..he had been in this inner dilemma..first of all Aru is half of his age..then the reason he always stated to reject her love was her own dreams and his being so senior to her..

think in this way..that woman is his wife..in whichever situation the married took place..she is his wife and she is in love with him...she confessed it..she was clear abt her feelings and her stance of wanting to spend her life with him...he is also in love..he fell in love with her..without his knowledge and after trying very hard not to indulge himself in this emotion particularly..he fell..and when he had to say it..he was not only shy yes he was guilty..ke he was not supposed to fall in love..he did..guilt iss liye tha ke ussko pyaar hua..it was not about Aru only but it was the emotion itself..as I said love is an alien emotion to him..he was not suppose to fall in love..lekin hua usse..this is what made him guilty..and when he expressed it, he was little uncomfortable but Aru made him accept the fact..once initial inhibition got over see how he felt..how he engulfed the feeling and the woman of his life...he was very happy after confessing..like some burden got off his shoulder.

may be he is 43yrs old mature man..but in heart he has always been this baccha...so from that point of view it was fully justified..and dont forget the type of life he led in village.

hope that explains.
Edited by Mihrimah - 8 years ago
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: -RadhaMohan-

@pearl
i can totally understand what u felt even that 'Hu Tane Prem Karu Chu' also put me off and felt OTT.but i am very much ok with his nodding nodding and nodding ..that the our mukhi ji.that time he don't have any words so Aru gave him words and he agree that's very much ArMu style.

Exaxtly my point RM, it is always Aru who does all the talking and I have no problem with Aru's characterization. She is young but is very balanced person. So far she has been doing just that leading him to acknowledge his love, preparing him to face his own deep hidded feelings and I am extreemly satisfied with her chracter sketch. But not this that she is putting her words in his mouth. Come on ...Ghode ko paani tak toh le ga sakte ho magar paani use khud hi peena hota hai. ( You canbring a horse to the water but he has to drink by himself) Confession should have been from his side. He should have opened his heart and his mouth too. The whole thing seems as if he has been emotionally forced by Aru.
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Mihrimah

ok let me explain this to u..yes I was one of them who simply loved the confession and found the nods beautiful..

u know think about Mukhi's character...he is shy guy right? he is reserved and restrained right? he understands others emotions well...he teaches the little things of life very maturely..but when it comes to himself, he is shy..he is plain shy to confront the happenings of his heart..the idea of marriage itself scared him let alone falling in love..the very first time Mishri wanted him to get married..what not he did to stop it?! and now the idea of falling in love and when he actually fell in love made him go crazy..he had been in this inner dilemma..first of all Aru is half of his age..then the reason he always stated to reject her love was her own dreams and his being so senior to her..

think in this way..that woman is his wife..in whichever situation the married took place..she is his wife and she is in love with him...she confessed it..she was clear abt her feelings and her stance of wanting to spend her life with him...he is also in love..he fell in love with her..without his knowledge and after trying very hard not to indulge himself in this emotion particularly..he fell..and when he had to say it..he was not only shy yes he was guilty..ke he was not supposed to fall in love..he did..guilt iss liye tha ke ussko pyaar hua..it was not about Aru only but it was the emotion itself..as I said love is an alien emotion to him..he was not suppose to fall in love..lekin hua usse..this is what made him guilty..and when he expressed it, he was little uncomfortable but Aru made him accept the fact..once initial inhibition got over see how he felt..how he engulfed the feeling and the woman of his life...he was very happy after confessing..like some burden got off his shoulder.

may be he is 43yrs old mature man..but in heart he has always been this baccha...so from that point of view it was fully justified..and dont forget the type of life he led in village.

hope that explains.


Thanks M, I have read your post and thank you again to take some time out to make me also see through your perseption. I really appriciate it.🤗 The way you have explained in your post is beautiful, very dreamy and how I wish I would have seen the same! I agree to every thing you said about Mukhi. He is shy, retrained, researve, understanding, mature, scared to the very idea of marriage...and also he could not initially understand and handle his feelings for Aru. But that was then before the Anshul drama happened. The whole drama was supposed to culminate in a love confession, and so whatever happend after Aru's kidnap was supossed to deepen their love and make them understand the need to confront their feelings and confess their love to each other. Aru had said it - "ho to bahut kuch gaya mukhi ji." She being a 22 year old is so aware of what is happening and He being double his age could not understand. Fine... if he would have been so emptiheaded. But but he is not that. If on one hand, he understands the need to sooth Aru and had courage to kiss and caress her foot, though water on her with absolute authority which shows so much of grouwth in their relationship, then he should have guts to stand for his love. The same authority and confidence with with he held he hand, he should have confessed his love also. My problem is that only...why was coyly standing there and nodding. Kya bamboo ke neeche ka sara pyarr choo mantar ho gaya? And what was he thinking after being so closed to Aru, he would go away without confessing his love...and if he is so guilty then he should have then also have said sorry for touching, kissing and hugging her. The guilt would have been justified before the kidnap but not after that.
Edited by whitepearl - 8 years ago
-RadhaRani- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: whitepearl

Exaxtly my point RM, it is always Aru who does all the talking and I have no problem with Aru's characterization. She is young but is very balanced person. So far she has been doing just that leading him to acknowledge his love, preparing him to face his own deep hidded feelings and I am extreemly satisfied with her chracter sketch. But not this that she is putting her words in his mouth. Come on ...Ghode ko paani tak toh le ga sakte ho magar paani use khud hi peena hota hai. ( You canbring a horse to the water but he has to drink by himself) Confession should have been from his side. He should have opened his heart and his mouth too. The whole thing seems as if he has been emotionally forced by Aru.

honestly speaking i really not wanted him to say anything on confession
what he said *Nahi Jane De Sakta* that is enough confession from his side.and Aru get that point. and he is so emotional that time he can't say anything to Aru but he don't want let her go also so u can say Dil Ke Haatho Mazboor he did this only. and we have to give him time more.like in precap he saying to Aru ..hum dono ko Aaise koi juda nahi kar sakta now everyday
he will do confession but on his style.


whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: -RadhaMohan-

honestly speaking i really not wanted him to say anything on confession
what he said *Nahi Jane De Sakta* that is enough confession from his side
.

Completely second it dear🤗...there was absolutly no need for him to say anything else. A man of few words, Mukhi has said it all...and on top of that he is a master in expression and emotions showing on his face, he does not need paragraphs. Not at least at this point. May be later but not now.

and Aru get that point.
She is one also of of her kind. I just love the way she picks up hints and gestures. And she is so adorable that even the smallest of Mukhi's hint of inclination made he so happy.

and he is so emotional that time he can't say anything to Aru but he don't want let her go also so u can say Dil Ke Haatho Mazboor he did this only. and we have to give him time more
Bechaara, chalo maaf kiya...par agali baar aisi personality depiction flaw nahin jhela paongi.😆
.like in precap he saying to Aru ..hum dono ko Aaise koi juda nahi kar sakta now everyday
he will do confession but on his style.


Yes ...I really want a confession in Mukhi style, more confident, matured and stable. Mukhi ke character main gaihrai bhi hai aur thairao bhi toh confession bhi toh waisa hi hona chahiye.😳

-RadhaRani- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
@pearl

mukhi ji ka character to bohut baar dheela huva hai and Aru ka bhi😆but u felt worng becoz this is very Big most IMPmoment for ArMu
but u know everytime any one can't be play there roles always.even in big big situation also peoples can't be every time perfect.
whitepearl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
@RM... Ya guess kuch zayada hi dil pe liya...Khir dil hai na...
I must be prepare myself to see such unexpected bombardments on my perception. Aur waise bhi Mukhi ab Mukhi reh hi kahan gaya hai...Dil jo na karai so thoda hai...Mukhiji ab majnu ji jo bangaye hain. 😆 out of character to ho hi gaya hai..😆
Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
Mukhi is very different from Aru. Aru is a brash modern city-bred clear headed youngster who is never afraid of voicing her thoughts and feelings. She has stayed true to her character and is very believable which is why we all are so hooked to this show. We do not like OTT characters, situations, scenes, we do not like warped sadistic unwanted and unrealistic twists and turns, things dragging on and on and most unrealistic and warped which is what is usually served and which we refuse to watch. I personally have no time for all that nonsense.
As for Mukhi, he is from a different generation, come on let's face it and on top of it all, he is from a rural background. He has NEVER been portrayed as a talkative person who is good at giving voice to his innermost feelings, not even with Saanvi. And as far as women and girls go, it has been clearly shown that he is clueless. In fact most of his gyaan in such matters actually stems from the diary such as what to do to please a woman and he actually tries it on Aru! and does this after seeking her opinion on whether all girls are alike.

Besides this, as far as Aru's role in his life is concerned, Mukhi has always been clear despite the way the whole marriage happened. For him she is his wife. Remember the scene where he asked her why she wanted to work for money given that what was his was hers because she was his wife? Or when he told Saanvi that he knows that Aru is right for him or when he always stood up for his Mukhiyayin?? For him it is just a matter-of-fact truth, he doesn't want to delve any deeper.

As it is men and women are very different in general of course. Men are more pragmatic in these matters and women more OTT hihihihi.

And right from day 1, from the very first episode it is very clear that a) he is least interested in getting married and b) that he would never want anyone to feel forced or be in any duress to get married to him or to get their daughter married to him, which is why he didn't want anyone from his village or from any village near his village!!

On top of this all he knows that Aru is very very young, that she has a whole life to look forward to, that she is a city girl, that unlike most people Aru has very very tall dreams and that she is very accomplished in the classic accepted sense of the term such as education, etiquette, speaking English, educated, etc.

He surely feels inferior to her in some respects, feels daunted and overawed in her presence and all the more so now that he has fallen head over heels for her.

All this and his sense of justice about not causing her any harm or to her ambitions plus her youth plus everything else cited above holds him back, restrains him, he who in any case is a man of a few words!!!

Ooops that was LOOONNGGG!!! Sorry!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".