Is Naina suffering from amnesia?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Trupti

@truptishree

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 6 years ago

#11

@Ria

Hi Ria

I saw your PM.

I was also busy with my kid that's why late reply.

Yes dear you can call me Trupti.

Oh! Don't remind the bashing on that thread.

I am a very senior member of this IF but first time ever I ignored all the etiquettes of IF and resorted to personal remarks on one member because that member also crossed his line with me.

But after knowing his sad story I really felt bad and I said sorry to him.

That's the reason I stay away from making personal remarks because you don't know that person in real.

In my post I already made it clear no personal remarks but you can't

help it sometimes.

About Naina even I also feel bad the way her character is shaping.

Though Sameer is my most favourite but honestly I do admire Naina because she is truly a very strong character.

Hopefully in future we will see that.

About your last point yes on very rare occasions Naina's VO said this Mera Sameer.

One more thing Harishchandra's descendant .

You know what she only preaches about truth but she is the most hypocritical character if you ask me.

Edited by truptishree - 6 years ago

Quote

RangnRia

@RangnRia

Navigator

Posted: 6 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: truptishree
@Ria
Hi Ria
I saw your PM.
I was also busy with my kid that's why late reply.
Yes dear you can call me Trupti.
Oh! Don't remind the bashing on that thread.
I am a very senior member of this IF but first time ever I ignored all the etiquettes of IF and resorted to personal remarks on one member because that member also crossed his line with me.
But after knowing his sad story I really felt bad and I said sorry to him.
That's the reason I stay away from making personal remarks because you don't know that person in real.
In my post I already made it clear no personal remarks but you can't
help it sometimes.
About Naina even I also feel bad the way her character is shaping.
Though Sameer is my most favourite but honestly I do admire Naina because she is truly a very strong character.
Hopefully in future we will see that.
About your last point yes on very rare occasions Naina's VO said this Mera Sameer.
One more thing Harishchandra's descendant .
You know what she only preaches about truth but she is the most hypocritical character if you ask me.

Hi Trupti,

Thanks for the reply.I understand handling a home and kids is a 24*7 job and a difficult one at that.

Even I admire strong women.And while reading the story I also admired Naina for her strength of character which I have already mentioned in my first post.

But two things that I believe in

- Practise what you preach.You can not call yourself Harishchandra's descendent and then have different set of rules for different people.

- Standing by one's decisions.Naina knew about Sameer's anger and knowingly signed up for this when she decided that this was shaadi-wala pyar.Then now how can she just pack her suitcase to leave her Marital home?When she had ventured into the jungle,she had not listened to the pleas of Mundit that they may get lost and rather moved more inside the jungle without a damn care for anything.That may be termed a teenager syndrome,but leaving marital home in a fit of rage without a second thought about the night his mother left him in Naina's care...Unfathomable for me...Certainly not signs of a strong woman,rather an arrogant and self-loving lady who after having received her trophy does not care two hoots about the man who gave up everything to just have her in his life.

The writing team needs to watch or read the earlier episodes to treat this amnesia.Else two hugely talented actors may have to pay for a slackened story losing in the TRP battle.

And as for bashing,I am seeing a lot of it on a thread created by Ross.Lesson learnt: No personal remarks on social media since you may not know the real person.

Love,Ria.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

shanzeshh

@shanzeshh

Explorer

Posted: 6 years ago

#13

Wonderful post i would just say u said it all which was troubling me since so long since that mahan act of jump i m so in and out of accepting relating with naina but then i accepted thinking i m sure post marriage we will see a beautiful devoted caring wife but for my shocker bad was ready to get worst what a 2,2 version of naina came out immannerd rude attitude etc etc and i was like what sameer marry into biwi or bachi or hunter wali masterni she lost all her sensitivity softness everything and last nail in coffin was her insensitive attitude towards sameer pleadings infact i dont get how even she thought of leaving matlab is she really belongs to middle class family bcz what i know that time no matter what happens middle class girls never leave their home like this and from then i totally lost the connection bcz yet again in tomorrow epi she is gone leave sameer kuch hua bag uthaya and i m going. Vishaka was wrong nanu was wrong k naina sameer k sath kabhi nahi chodeygi

Quote

Trupti

@truptishree

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 6 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: RangnRia

Hi Trupti,
Thanks for the reply.I understand handling a home and kids is a 24*7 job and a difficult one at that.
Even I admire strong women.And while reading the story I also admired Naina for her strength of character which I have already mentioned in my first post.
But two things that I believe in
- Practise what you preach.You can not call yourself Harishchandra's descendent and then have different set of rules for different people.
- Standing by one's decisions.Naina knew about Sameer's anger and knowingly signed up for this when she decided that this was shaadi-wala pyar.Then now how can she just pack her suitcase to leave her Marital home?When she had ventured into the jungle,she had not listened to the pleas of Mundit that they may get lost and rather moved more inside the jungle without a damn care for anything.That may be termed a teenager syndrome,but leaving marital home in a fit of rage without a second thought about the night his mother left him in Naina's care...Unfathomable for me...Certainly not signs of a strong woman,rather an arrogant and self-loving lady who after having received her trophy does not care two hoots about the man who gave up everything to just have her in his life.
The writing team needs to watch or read the earlier episodes to treat this amnesia.Else two hugely talented actors may have to pay for a slackened story losing in the TRP battle.
And as for bashing,I am seeing a lot of it on a thread created by Ross.Lesson learnt: No personal remarks on social media since you may not know the real person.
Love,Ria.

Hi Ria

Yes handling a home and Kid is very difficult but I enjoy that because my kid is very naughty.

Even I always admire strong women and as for Naina if you see she is really a strong girl with strong moral values and a character.

She is the girl who dared to fall in love despite knowing her conservative family. Brought Sameer out of his Manhoos phase just because she had faith on herself and their love and I have always admired her for the way she loved Sameer from the beginning and I will still say that she is a strong character because the way she stood her ground to break up with Sameer and then again was going to marry Sharad against her wishes and again stood in front of him when he slapped her but she didn't say sorry to him knowing Anand again said yes for alliance.

It's not easy in a way and we all were sympathetic towards her knowing she was wrong to break up with Sameer.(I was Team Sameer but still I felt bad for her just like I supported her during bet phase though I love Sameer)

But yes I do have a problem with her for not disclosing truth about paper stealing. Most of us thought that they will bring this twist during their marriage talk so that way Rakesh will approve their relationship knowing Sam is not a bad kid the way he used to think but no nothing.

This is the main problem I have with her character because from the beginning they have shown her a girl who always stood by truth no matter what but when it comes to her family and friends she chose them over truth but she haven't done this in case of Sameer though she loves him.

I am still waiting for that paper stealing truth to come out in front of Vishakha and Rakesh so they will understand that they were wrong to judge Sameer.

You know I am from Cops Family and it really hurts to see truth is being sidelined and an innocent kid got all the punishment without any of his fault and no regret from Naina or Arjun to put him through this humiliation.

Leaving home don't remind me that it still boils my blood. I already ranted in LU that day.

Seriously I am not able to understand this Naina because she is the same girl who burned her hand to feel his pain and now she is ready to leave him for arguments they had.

TBH I miss that PVKM Naina who was strong but now I don't see her. Hopefully in near future we will see her.

Bashing don't remind me yaar. when I made that post and all commented on it. Admin had to intervene and deleted some of the pages which had personal remarks.

I hate to judge someone because I will not tolerate if someone do that to me that's the reason I stay away from SM because everyone has their own life,own Choices.

Love

Trupti.

Quote

ruchi3179

@ruchi3179

Dazzler

Posted: 6 years ago

#15

I agree what you wrote.But i will not write much as it is not welcomed much.But yes leaving home is a big No & she is surely coming across a self loving woman only.Sameer also has become cleanliness obsessed person or i cn say naina scolding obsessed person.& i dont know why on earth they donts share there opinion or discuss.

Quote

1 2

Is Naina suffering from amnesia? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics