What if Nanu had rejected Naina and attempted suicide? Sam Kya Karta? - Page 2

Agree with you 100%. Neither Sameer or Naina is realizing that the pressure of circumstance has clouded their relationship.

Thank god some sensible question for biased fans n targeting solo fana

I feel Sameer would do what Naina did if the situation had come with Nanu.

And I also feel something like that will play out with Mamaji too. Not suicide attempt but some form of pressure on Sameer when it comes to marriage. That is when Sameer will remember and understand what Naina went through. And how he will handle it then ?

Right now Naina is right in her view, Sameer is right in being mad at her but is he in a position to give her an assurance that his family will be okay and he can convince her family too ?
At least Naina admits she is a coward.

Now that they broke up they both need to introspect on the other's words, understanding the other's POV and they face some situations which will make them realize what they mean to each other and how the other is the best partner for them.

Originally posted by: shahz

Of course Sameer would do what Naina is doing.And if Sameers Nanu was anything like Rakesh or any of the Agarwals and Sameer is well aware of this then I would also say he was wrong to string a girl along with him like this to only dump her.

I for one have no issue with Naina choosing family over love... What I'm not happy is with the way Naina going about this break up... I've explained it in other posts so wont get into that again.

Hmmm... correct.. but more than anyone.. Naina is doing this for her foster parents.. who loved her like Nanu did to Sameer.. so its difficult for her to chose betn the two.. and she chose what she felt is correct option in that situation...

but yes.. the way Naina forced her decision on Sameer was not right.. thy are a couple and should talk before taking any crucial decision... 😳

Originally posted by: koyelbasu

I made a post on this 2 days back. They are actually not on the same platform. Where Nanu was Sam's support, Naina's family is the huge hurdle.

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=5011606

That's why I took this imaginary scenario.. for Naina chachaji is equivalent to Nanu.. and for any girl a father attempting suicide is always a shocking thing.. For Sam Nanu was like his father figure..

thts y I raised this moral question..

Originally posted by: mystique123

Agree with you 100%. Neither Sameer or Naina is realizing that the pressure of circumstance has clouded their relationship.

CVs have decided that no matter what happens these two should never have a proper convo and understand the issues. One convo without any presumptions definitely should have done the magic.

arre.. warna college ke 3 saal kaise khinchte.. CVs jst needed a reason for them to break up.. to isliye.. ye No-talk clause jabardasti ghusa diya..

aisa kaun sa couple karta hai.. 😆

Voh Kya krta kya nai Yeh toh I don't know.. But usko zyada ghalat samjha jata coz Phir entire boy species ko blame krtey k ki ladka tha na usey Kya expect krtey.. Spineless hai.. Use krke ditch kiya n all that. .. If u remember similar post was made by a male member of the forum here in which he mentioned the pov of a male in such situation ... I m not saying ki Naina is wrong. . Not at all. .. She is right in her place .. But at least us 3 years k liye jo sath spend kiye ek koshish toh bnti hai na. Without fighting how can she just give up like that... Maanege Ya nai Uske ghrwaley ek secondary chiz hai but ek try bnti hai. At least for her own self... Ki Kl ko usey yeh regret na rahe ki maine try bhi nai kiya

Originally posted by: violette

arre.. warna college ke 3 saal kaise khinchte.. CVs jst needed a reason for them to break up.. to isliye.. ye No-talk clause jabardasti ghusa diya..

aisa kaun sa couple karta hai.. 😆

Originally posted by: haritha45

Thank god some sensible question for biased fans n targeting solo fana

Ppl r like Sam loves naina so much but naina iis selfish like ssly.Sam loved naina because naina because of her selfless love n ppl forgot that👏n busy in bashing naina

Sorry I m not into bashing any fans here on my thread dear... this is jst to think about a possible scenario.. and how a character would've acted..

Originally posted by: appukrish

I feel Sameer would do what Naina did if the situation had come with Nanu.

And I also feel something like that will play out with Mamaji too. Not suicide attempt but some form of pressure on Sameer when it comes to marriage. That is when Sameer will remember and understand what Naina went through. And how he will handle it then ?

Right now Naina is right in her view, Sameer is right in being mad at her but is he in a position to give her an assurance that his family will be okay and he can convince her family too ?
At least Naina admits she is a coward.

Now that they broke up they both need to introspect on the other's words, understanding the other's POV and they face some situations which will make them realize what they mean to each other and how the other is the best partner for them.

I had always questioned Sam's reassurance.. actually usne bola bahot kuch hai.. lekin phir bhi in reality vo Naina ko solid soln nahi de paya tha.. in fact dono ne ye post scandal situations ko bahot galat tarike se handle kiya.. aur lightly bhi liya..

U r right in questioning Sam at this point.. but future mein kya hoga. pata nahi.. leking I don't think CVs same track Sam ke saath repeat karenge.. may b it will take another form..

but yes it would b essential for them to understand each other's POV..

and hopefully is baar thy talk! 😆