Episode 23.07.2018...Pyar Tune Kya Kiya - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.8k

Users

17

Likes

76

Frequent Posters

violette thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11
My Pointers:

1. Preeti's voice of reasoning and the sister's conversation:

I loved Preeti's voice of reasoning; she was going in the right direction. Giving a different perspective and option to Naina but what she didn't mention was giving Sameer a chance to come up with a solution of his own. This the two sisters didn't even consider it, may b bcoz thy were just too scared with what Rakesh tried to do and Taiji and Tauji's extreme reactions with Arjun tht thy didn't even think that thy had any chance whatsoever.. and also bcoz Naina wanted to keep Sam away from this problem.

But clearly Naina is undervaluing Sam's love. I do the same when I m trying to (overly) protect my husband.. 😆.. and he comes up with one of those most unromantic romantic dialogues.. 😆.. Why do you think that my love is any lesser.. that I m any less stronger than u to handle pain related to you.. or that you deserve any lesser love and respect and care than you shower on me!.. In angry tone of course! 😆 .. and on such days we learn tht thy too secretly love to pamper and care for us as equally as we do .. or perhaps even more! is me bhi unko zyada credit chahiye! 😆 Male ego I tell you! 😆 Oops sorry Ross u r male ! 😆😆

So giving due respect to the love of other partner is also equally important, aur kabhi kabhi vo pyaar jatane ka mauka dena chahiye.. hamesha devi ban ke sab pain hurt aur dukh apne upar nahi lena chahiye.. but u know we women cant help it.. we r biologically and evolutionarily inclined to protect, shelter, nurture, and love unconditionally to our loved ones...

2. Chacha Chachi's love:

Chacha Chachi's love is so endearing... parents love can never be suffocating.. its how we perceive it.. clearly Chacha Chachi has given Naina all the liberty to discuss anything with thm openly.. and she has done so many times in past.. shared her fears and took guidance from Chacha.. remember it was after Chacha's advice that Naina decided to give Sameer a chance when her love was just infatuation .. and learning from her chachaji's mistake, she forgave Sameer after bet phase.. so yes, chacha's guidance is imp in Naina making crucial decisions of her life.. but here she misinterpret .. clearly what he always wanted to convey is b open to him without any fear and he is there to guide them correctly always.. he will listen to them like a friend, see through their fears, inhibitions and flaws and steer them to correct path... If only Naina could!

3. Taijis Taunts:

Clearly what is self-limiting Naina from approaching Chacha is Taiji's taunts to her beloved foster parents. She doesn't care about taunts on herself or her father or brother, she has bear them a lot in past. But them pointing fingers at their parvarish and sanskar because of her is what she cannot bear. But I m sure once these things get cleared with Chacha Chachi.. she would b back to her bold confident self fighting the whole world for Sameer's love!❤️

4. Naina's VO:

And that's what Naina's VO suggests.. and what we have talked about umpteen times.. Her love for Sameer is too strong for her to see him in pain and she will take u turn the moment she realizes her folly ..in thinking that Sam can survive without her.. and of course after getting reassurance from her chacha that love is not a crime.. but in what order these two scenes unfold that we need to wait and watch..

5. Devang's concern, Pooja Bhabhi's love:

I found more love in Devang's concern than Mama-mami's overly effusive laad.. Pooja-Devang's Jodi is going to b a blessing in disguise for Sam! And his questions brings me to the next topic..

6. Sameer's maturity and journey from a boy to man:

Clearly, Sam has long way to go to make that journey from a boy to man. Hopefully this breakup will make him wise.. and mature.. I still find more maturity in Naina's love. Sam had definitely made plans for their future, but has done no concrete work or shown emotional maturity or solid responsible behavior to reassure Naina that he has capability of handling things and her family on his own and she need not be so worried for him that she decides to break up! Had he shown some responsible behaviour handling the aftermath of those scandals, Naina might have taken a different decision. Not that he was wrong from his POV about rubbishing off her fears lightly, but that they weren't on the same page regarding gravity of Naina's situation..

7. Jale par Namak:

Uff I hate this line as it clearly states where this track is headed and with Sunaina spoiler I m just going to skip this unwanted fruitless track that's gonna eat up whole week and make Naina more determined to let go Sam for his own betterment! 🤔

And thanks so much for your humorous post.. Always such a relief!... Waise I noticed a few things as well.. . may b I will point them out later..

p.s. This morning, randomly this 90s song popped up in my mind..

song: Ek baat Bataoun.. batao..
Film: Milan (1995)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHs9_xx1lz0
Edited by violette - 7 years ago
vidrev thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12
Dharthi paad update Ross. The way naina summarized everything to preethi within minutes was amazing and even preethi understood her situation and gave idea as well. Naina collecting all sameer yaade but I remember N vo telling that she has all the things related to sameer even today but how cone she will have it when she decided to leave all the things related to sameer beside. Here Sam baba doing the same thing but he didn't throw them I guess both were really good in acting and the highlight was the narration from your end. Ab dekna yehi hoga ki dharthi paad idea kaam karege Ya nahi. 👏
Booklover94 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#13
Awesome analysis,Ross!
Commenting here after a while,but I usually make it a point to read through when I get some time😆
As usual,youve even managed to make a fairly serious/ sad episode hilarious😆
Agle hafte mein bohot rudaalis Ko hire karna padega, atleast jab tak samaina patch up nahi karte hain😆
But I'm still kinda hoping mama Mami are good people...bus thoda overacting karte hain.
bmk28 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14
Ross, Thank you for your creative update and cheering up my mood too. There are too many issues which are coming up now and then. One more got added to my passport renewal. I am so upset and stressed about it right now that anything which can give some respite is always welcome..
I have cried watching the episode twice - Mt Abu break up & Nanu's death. Ashi was so good in break up scene that my heart went out for her and it looked so real that pain had overtaken for couple of days. Randeep was good in Nanu's death scene and it reminded me of my personal situation too. Rest I would feel bad or eyes become watery. But yesterday I kinda cried for couple of mins during Naina and Preeti conversation (and for releasing my stress too :-P).. So one more Rudali added.. Albeit for few seconds only.. Btw, this rudali thing is too good man.. And its going to stay for few days I guess.. Male one and female one..
Naina's reasoning was very logical and Preeti's acceptance was also logical. Both sisters are thinking from what they have seen in their family. Ashi and Ayesha were excellent. Sameer's family scene looked like to clear out doubts of IF posters only.. Why all of a sudden that talk?! I hope they are real and not like families whose movie names Sameer took. His hug with Mamaji was very warm. Naina and Sameer being strong in front of their families was too heart wrenching. Chachaji ka record trust pe atak gaya hai for some reason.. I hope aage chale or story ko help kare by talking to Naina. Naina does everything keeping in mind what Chachaji feels for her. Its very natural as well..
Loved Dil's background score. Was apt for Samaina's situation.. Rafi song was also apt and its my fav too.. But it did lack the charm.. Original one is too good..

truptishree thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#15
Hi Ross,
As usual i am late to comment.
It was an amazing episode and loved your take on it.
I cried but your update made me laugh.
Naina was remembering all their moments. What a beautiful journey these kids had,not them but we also. TBH it made me cry.
So finally Naina told Preeti everything. I really admire Preeti she was so worried about Sameer also.
Naina shared her fears about their family, scared to break Bela and Anand's trust so nobody can point fingers at their upbringing. Poor girl was talking about her mom and she acknowledges Bela and Anand's love the way they love her even more than Preeti.
She scared for SS also thinking he will again try to hang himself. Kiddo don't worry if you think he will do that for you you are in for biggest shock of your life. He will hang you along with his favourite baalo ki dukan. She thinks she is very weak and will not be able to stand up for love in front of her family and she will hurt Sameer same as Arjun. Can you believe she said she shouldn't have fallen in love with Sameer?
Preeti said wish their family will understand these things and they could have shared with Bela and Anand.
I feel Chachaji is the only one who will clear her confusion like last time and once again she will come back to Sameer like someone mentioned here.
Must say both Ashi and Ayesha were brilliant here.
Mama Mami they genuinely love Sameer and they know that he is the heir of Nanu and they are here as caretakers until he is ready for the responsibilities.
Good they proved me right,poor kid do deserve that love which he was deprived till now. Hope that they will not change in future will not be able to see that.
Sameer witnessed their conversation, he was so overwhelmed by it the way he hugged Mamaji.
Before him it reminded me also of Nanu as VO said. The only important people of his life his Nanu and Naina,but this family also gave him the love which he always wanted. Poor kid was missing Nanu.
Really Randeep was amazing here showing those emotions in that minute scene.
On Preeti's advice Naina is trying to get rid of the things associated with Sameer. Sameer was also trying to throw away her memories TBH it was so painful to watch and on top of that BG ,my favourite song,I was literally in tears.
Don't bash me for this but more than Naina I felt so bad for Sameer. Poor kiddo don't deserve this.
Can't see him in pain yaar. Every time he gets some happiness it gets snatched away from him first his mom then Nanu and now Naina also going away from him. She thinks she is saving him from bigger pain but she is failing to see that now also he is in so much pain for his pain time not gonna matter.
Without her every moment he will be in pain and it will just increase.
Randeep once again he proved that he is living character of Sameer by showing that pain,those tears.
He was amazing where he try to throw those things but can't.
Both Sameer and Naina are crying inside but smiling for their families.They are just 18 yr old kids but the maturity they have they will put all the elders to shame.
Honestly I am not liking this Chachaji's continuous jaap about Maan and Abhimaan. It is really suffocating Naina. Hope she will be able to share with Anand.
And what's with the timeline again? First year is ending,how come they only had one semester till now right?
I don't want to comment about precap,hope he will not take the route of jealousy as Mundit said.
Whatever it is but I don't want Sunaina to suffer a heartbreak because of it.
Episode belonged to Randeep/Ashi/Ayesha but extra star for Randeep.











Anjali33 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#16
Rudaalis!! Really Ross🤣
(Alliteration ho gya ye to)

Ye Devang Bhaiya acche khase sab k good books mein the, suddenly unko aisa dikha diya CVS ne😕 even I doubt Mami but not Mama
mehraan thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#17
Kya episode tha...Loved it!!..Im a sucker for such romances n gve me tissue rolls i wud finish it all but still whistle out...kya mast episode tha!!!Dil ko chu jaye aisi wo baat thi!! Lovely n humourous writeup Ross!!
Ross11 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#18
Thank you all for your wonderful posts, loved reading all.
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#19
Ross... Sorry, it was too late to write yesterday *Inserts Rudalis* 😉 Idea is as good as your review! 👏
So, finally after torturing Preeti for a few days, Naina finally spilled the beans... though Preeti asked her why she was thinking so much about future, that led her to this drastic step... but Naina's explanation about their family's reactions was so spot on that she had to agree and support her... If Preeti had persisted a little more with her alternate view and asked why Naina was not giving a chance to Samaina to fight... maybe Sameer will succeed in convincing their family... how come she was giving up before even trying... Maybe if Preeti had asked all this Naina may have started thinking differently... But no!

Her rightfully Sameer was upset... he also heard Devang bhaiya... when will he start acting on that and take up his business... I keep hoping that something will trigger him but nothing so far! Though I did like that he hugged Mama and found some solace when Mama hugged him back so fondly and Mami fed him... reminded me of Delhi where the older members, except Vishaka took pleasure in singling him out and keeping him away 😡 Atleast for the present Sameer has some peace at home when he is feeling so tortured and restless...

Another thing was both Sameer and Naina remembered Nanu and her mother respectively... but what a stark difference in their words and worlds! While Sameer's VO said no one could replace Nanu and Naina, Mama's family's love was like a band-aid and he was grateful for that... Whereas Naina said chacha-chachi had never made her feel her mother's absence... and maybe she loved them more than Sameer... Why did she fall inn love... What a stark difference in their worlds... for Sameer there is literally no one, while Naina is able to fill those voids...

The whole song was done so well... both trying to throw away those precious little things that connected them, but I'm sure neither did... they must've hidden it somewhere out of sight ... And both trying to smile through their tears, and even succeeding to fool their families... Both Ashi and Randeep excelled in this sequence...

Also, Sameer's VO mentioned how he was cursing Naina was abandoning him like that... such a real reaction that is, even though he still loves her, he is rightfully mad at her and feeling betrayed... He is justified from his POV to feel so cheated... since Naina refused to give him a chance to even try to convince their families in the future... At the same time it endearing to see he understood her POV...

So... just a thought. 😳 When they broke up it was right after the first term tests... and now chacha mentioned final... so my guess is that is atleast 6 months... which means Sameer has been trying and not giving up for 6 months... It also means he had another birthday in between, so he is 19...

So how does Naina not see his persistent efforts all these months? How does she not realize that Sameer will not give up on her? How does she not seeing him hurting for so long? And she is still hurting too... Yet she thinks they can forget each other?

This also means that Pooja should be close to having her baby now... hmmm, wonder if that will have any impact on their story? 🤔

braveheartdoc thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#20
What an amazing update Ross😃👏
Claps for you👏👏 for making hilarious posts daily when the episodes are full of rona dhona😛
Loved the rudaali inserts😆
Sach mein Dimple ki movie yaad aa gayi😉

Ek din mein Naina ko samajh mein aa gaya ki wo Sameer se utna pyar nahi karti jitna wo Chacha Chachi se karti hai...ab tak kya use short term memory loss hua tha😛

Sameer with his Mama Mami...pata nahi kyun ...I feel they are not what they are showing...maybe im over thinking...but surely Poonam's character is the best out of all😃👏
the gifts portion...have the CVs forgotten that Naina still has that shampoo bottle😉

But seriously...Shefali's words have shaken her in and out and she is unable to think staraight at present...Sameer needs a wise advice from someone so that he doesn't end up doing something wrong...but who? He just has Mundit with him with whom he shares everything...I feel Munna kas lost his sensibility after his confession with frock wala Pandit😉
Hope he too gets back to his senses soon😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".