Mar 14th: Hit and miss ! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

2.2k

Users

21

Likes

239

Frequent Posters

appukrish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: umam

Nivi[:)][BR][DIV]I liked the epi.. after the epi, I started thinking why would they portray hits and misses in such a elaborate manner when they had shown us the most magical bike ride scene[L]that scene was so in synch.. if I understand writers , the hits and misses were deliberate - am thinking aloud - logically Naina would never have imagined that there is a chance that she will meet Sameer in a bus stand of all the places[8(][:s] so many miles away from A'bad..To her Sameer is still there, both waiting eagerly for each other[:^(].. Sameer is so lost - cannot expect anything from him as he no longer feels Naina..[/DIV][BR][DIV]Maybe a kind of monologue from Naina on why she is sensing Sameer's presence would have communicated the hits and misses better.. just my thought..[/DIV][BR][BR]


Liked how you put it. That she cannot imagine that Sameer would be at the bus station. Yesterday was here was discussion about Sameer's heart not responding but what about hers.

Today we saw both could not see each other but they surely felt each other.

But I repeat the sequences of missing each other were ott.
dixie123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: umam

Nivi 😊

I liked the epi.. after the epi, I started thinking why would they portray hits and misses in such a elaborate manner when they had shown us the most magical bike ride scene ❤️ that scene was so in synch.. if I understand writers , the hits and misses were deliberate - am thinking aloud - logically Naina would never have imagined that there is a chance that she will meet Sameer in a bus stand of all the places 😕 so many miles away from A'bad..To her Sameer is still there, both waiting eagerly for each other 😭.. Sameer is so lost - cannot expect anything from him as he no longer feels Naina..

Maybe a kind of monologue from Naina on why she is sensing Sameer's presence would have communicated the hits and misses better.. just my thought..



@bold: Thanks for this explanation Gowri. You have put her perspective well.
The execution was not proper then if this is what they wanted to show, the audience doesn't need so much explanation to understand a scene.

Yes, the scenes were not well presented for me, it seemed random with no connection.
dixie123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: appukrish


It was an okay episode. The hit and miss was a big miss considering the couldn't see each other walking almost side by side, Preethi was calling out Naina quite loudly and Naina talking to the guy in the bus, but Sameer couldn't hear it and He puts on the cap just for those few minutes :(
Worst was him drinking water from the bottle without knowing whose it is. Did he think it's his Mom's water bottle?

The takeaway was that they separated physically while their hearts are one and could feel each other's presence. Glad Sameer ko dheere dheere hosh aa raha hai.

Looking forward to Sameer in Dilwalon ki nagari Delhi though poor Sameer looked lost entering the house.


I don't think he thought it was his mother's water bottle. He picked up from the floor of the bus.

@bold: As if we didn't know this already 😆 They should have done a better job executing it. The actors got it right. pata nahi why some of us didn't understand what they were trying to convey. The blame is on the director then ?
dixie123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: aardhan

Nivi... you didn't like it? Honestly i didn't mind it... IMO the episode was dedicated to what we say 'ehsaas' or feeling...😳 Hence the slow pace... as if for those few minute time stood still once more... fate or destiny conspired and brought these two back to the same spot, like it did many months back when they were strangers... in fact Sameer's VO on itefaq sad it all...



Some of the content I'm copying from Laizu's thread as I'm very sleepy to type again... maaf karo. 😛 Episode was both filmy and realistic at the same time! 😆 Filmy because of the hit n miss concept but realistic because neither would even expect the other to be at that remote corner of the world at the same time... yet they did and yet they met! There is no such thing as Happy Coincidences...

An unusual episode it was... very few dialogs... it was a touchy-feely episode.😛


With the cool drink scene and the water tap scene they recreated their first two meetings...Sameer buying bottled water and almost running into her and cool drink (non)meeting in the market ...


When Naina spotted the cool drink bottle she recollected her fond memories of the same starting with the 'I love you Rasna' to their mutual acceptance of love when they drank from the same bottle...


Now I can understand why all that hype was made for that touch episode... because now they can recognize each other's special touch anywhere...


Then Sameer unknowingly drank from her bottle. Though that was weird I can understand the thought here... remember that first time in school he unknowingly ate her aloo paratha... so this was another recreation...


The last time they were in a bus it was from Mt. Abu where they were both torn apart but travelling to the same destination... Now both went their separate ways but both carried fond memories the other in their hearts, they are so connected... and left remembering each other.


Sameer and Naina have hit the reboot button by recreating their first few meetings... they are physically apart and the hit n miss incidents was similar to how it happens with strangers, but they are more connected in their hearts. The first time when the hit n miss happened to them only Naina sensed him but this time there is a sense of awareness for both of them. Yesterday I though Sameer would not sense, but it appears that her touch woke him up for a few minutes but by the time he reached Delhi he drifted back into his black hole.


Another day of quiet Sameer, but atleast he was responsive... that last shot was acutely painful. Just like the VO said... He was among strangers in a new place... and only now he was slowly regaining his senses... Randeep once again excelled in his silent sufferer mode, especially when he entered the cold, dark, empty house where there was not a single soul to welcome him... not even his own mother! 😒


I'm sad Mundit didn't see the card... but koi nahi... I guess the card will also stay hidden until it time for it to be rediscovered. 😳 I'm holding on to it that one day Mundit will see it and give it to Naina... In the meantime, precap was scary, i cannot imagine what turmoil Naina will go through now... And Sameer's own hell is just beginning.


Aarti, as usual wonderful post. I need to see the episode again I think. Hoping I am going to see what some of you guys have liked. I think I am able to understand the realistic part that you and Gowri have mentioned. Makes sense.

The last part of the episode was very painful
Veda1125 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#25
I liked the episode, and, actually it made me emotional, especially , towards the end , seeing both their reactions ..Naina's after reading the obituary and Sameer's after entering Somani's house!! Randeep was fantastic in the last few Episodes .
Did Sameer recognize Naina's water bottle or he just randomly picked up the bottle from the floor???🤪
Me conphujed...gonna miss Kachru and his Chand si mehboob/ tauba yeh matwali chaal..wonder what tracks will they play in future if Rohan is paired with Preeti..since we can expect a contrast to Kachru..lol.
Love ur posts Dixie ❤️
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#26
Hey Nivi...just a thought here. ... let's get more filmy now! 😉 😆


Do you think when Naina reads the paper she will rush to Sameer's house with Preeti? Going by her character she should... but she will find the house locked and then go to school. Mundit will tell her everything then... maybe that card will fly to her...


Since this is a happy thought, I'm going sleep on it. 😆 Good night
rock&roll thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#27
I didn't like the episode too. The hit and miss was getting on my nerves.

But maybe the CVs wanted to convey the ehsaas between the two and also convey that in the near future, thinga will be " so near and yet so far for Samaina.( hope not, fingers crossed).Maybe "ehsaas is all will get in the next few eppys 😕
Sakshi607 thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail 10th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: aardhan

Hey Nivi...just a thought here. ... let's get more filmy now! 😉 😆



Do you think when Naina reads the paper she will rush to Sameer's house with Preeti? Going by her character she should... but she will find the house locked and then go to school. Mundit will tell her everything then... maybe that card will fly to her...


Since this is a happy thought, I'm going sleep on it. 😆 Good night

Had the same thoughts. Maybe she goes to his house and Ramdhari tells her that sameer has gone to delhi but lets her to his room (thoda logic chodna padega, but koi nahi itni baar logic to ignore kiya hai toh ek aut baar sahi) and Naina finds the card and she will remember sams words (ek din tum isse apne seene se lagaogi) and she will hold that card and cry her heart out.
ruchi3179 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#29
For the first time not felt connected with the episode at all
And they jumped to May just like that even though school is still going and exams yet to happen.They could hv easily shown the fairwell then exams and then vacations. During vacation naina visiting native village and nanu death at that time then may would hv made sense .and theremember would hv been continuity. They missed everything just rushing through.
TereLiyeMINU thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#30
Hi Nivi!
Thanks for posting today.You inspired me today to remain motivated enough even in 'interest-less' episodes(of life).😃

Coming to episode---
CVs forgot that there is a thing called ''Less is more''.They could have shown them going distant from each other with buses travelling in opposite directions.
There was enough shouting of the name ''Naina'' by both Preeti and Rakesh to some extent for Sameer to hear.
This ''ehsaas'' thing completely take away logic.Though Sameer is lost and broken still there is a thing called ''id.'' The primal curiousity is always there.And CVs very beautifully messed up with this thing. He hearing her name and searching could have been a beautiful thing than all these water bottle scene and all.

Walt Whitman says--The fruition of beauty is no chance of hit or miss...
And no doubt with this dragged hit and miss we lost some beautiful scenes and essence of our beautiful show.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".