Mar 7th: Zindagi Kaisi Hai Paheli :(

Page

Next Last

dixie123

@dixie123

Sparkler

Posted: 7 years ago

Don't know what to write. The ending of the serial has made me numb. Pretty emotional it was.

I had a lump in my throat seeing Sameer shocked seeing Nanu lying on the floor. But, why was his voice muted ? 😲 his scream shouldn't have been there ? 😕 That whole scene was very painful to see.. How will Sameer survive if anything happened to Nanu 😭Another thing, I feel Nanu won't make it is, the way the music stopped like the line on the ECG machine becomes a straight line. The music was so intense all the while Nanu was struggling and then music died down peacefully..

Major chunk of the episode was given to Nanu actually today😲, his fall, Sameer's fate of having to come back to be by his Nanu's side when he was needed the most and Naina waiting for him on the other end. Wasn't it too slow though or was it only me who felt more than half the episode dedicated to this ?

So, Nanu knew his time was coming. That's how it was shown today. He was emotional again. I wish he won't die but I think he will die. Just bracing for myself for the worst.

Nanu and Sameer, both their actions are so relatable. Sameer, the 17 yr old in a hurry to go and meet his lover who is already late to the party refuses the last minute mooh meeta karna. Haven't we all done a million times to our parents ? But, he is such a good kid, having known what he has done he goes back takes ashirwad and says sorry and gives Nanu the 2 minutes of time. 🤗

Nanu, wants to pamper his child one last time before Sameer left for the party, maybe because he was feeling something, Even without any premonition, these kind of last minute touches, haven't our parents done to us so many times ? It was just beautiful. I actually had a cute smile seeing the two of them.

Nanu emotional blackmailing, Mein samjh saktha hoon, ab teri zindagi mein Naina aagayi hai toh phir... iss Nanu ki kya zaroorat hai. Sameer is guilty, Nanu aisi baat mat kariye. Meri zindagi mein aapke jagah aur koi nahi le saktha KABHI NAHI, ab chali ye apne haaton se jalebi khilayeye. I can have these kind of jalebis for life aapke haathon se. Nanu again with his senti dialogue, Zindagi bhar ka toh pata nahi, Sameer face falls again lekin jab tak zinda rahunga na tab tak I will feed you jalebis apni haaton se .. Pata nahi kab kya Haven't our elders said these kind of senti dialogues to us ?

Sameer is angry now, You said it today dobara mat kehna, aap zindagi bar mere sath rahenge, aapke bina yeh Sameer bhi nahi reh saktha. Nanu tries to lighten the situation and says he won't go anywhere till he becomes Parnana ! Sameer hearing Parnana is happy😳😆, wohi toh.. abhi toh aap hatte katte jawan hai !

Loved that Sameer called Nanu as Nanu and not Nanaji. that is so endearing and feels heartfelt ! Nanaji was like, as if he was talking to a total different person. the bond and connection was missing in that word.

Rest of the episode was good also.

Taiji saying - Paagal hogayi hoon mine, satiagi hoon, dhimak kharab hogaya mera 🤣was pretty hilarious. Bela and Preeti are jugaad queens😎, Preeti says Dharm Barst and Bela comes out with Machli ki kaate outwitting Taioji putting her in a fix and making her forget about the saree😆. And they were ably supported by chachaji also !

It was a beautiful but emotional moment seeing Sameer and Naina get ready. Beautiful seeing them so happily get ready for each other, wanting to look good for each other.😳 Emotional because all this sajna is not of no use because they won't see each other.

At the party, Naina is sad, Kis ke liye saji daji hoon, woh toh kahi deek hi nahi raha. Aww.. Naina thought he will waiting for her outside itself !😳 So cute. She wanted him to be the first one to see her r in his Nani's saree.

Munna saying to Pandit, Tera toh tyre hi nahi, puncture kaha se hogi ! 🤣Pandit can't recognize the girl whom he had a crush on😆, he gets angry on Munna, tu kare toh pyar mein karo toh sapna !!! 😆

Munna calls Naina bhabhi..😳 M and P are shocked to see Naina, they can't recognize her at all, she is looking so pretty, Sameer ke hosh udd jayenge aaj tujhe dekh ke

Aww.. Munna was so cute , got Preeti out of the way so he can propose to Swati.. 😳Swati was ready for the proposal to it seems. It does seem like SwaMun will also be a couple in the leap along with ShefJun.

Hopefully Nanu survives but like Nanu said zindagi ka koi bharosa nahi Kab Kya

Quote

Frequent Posters

KashafZaroon30

@KashafZaroon30

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

Nivi darling...Lovely post...Nanu Sameer convo made me emotional again...how nicely written👏...

Taiji is seriously irritating day by day...I mean her thinking is very shallow seriously...Maas-machhi ..but yes such people are there who discriminate a lot...But Chacha-Chachi are just love...the way they handled Taiji's tantrums and saved the girls was 😳

Sameer and Naina getting ready parallely was so nicely...both were looking so good..wished to see them in one frame but alas we didn't get that...

The whole time I had an ill-feeling in my heart while watching the episode😭...Sameer will be in so much pain if something happens to Nanu..too much for a teenager...

Sameer-Nanu scene was heart-warming and heart-wrenching at the same time...they made us smile and cry in the same scene...infact I found that scene very impactful...it showed 2 things- We should give atleast some time to our elders no matter what, and secondly it showed what kind of a person Sameer is...he might not care about the world, but he definitely knows how to care about the important people in his life. Why don't Somani and Rakesh see that side of him...Somani specially should see it rather than pointing out his flaws...You just have to give him little attention and care and he will give you his heart and soul...I'm highly impressed with his character sketch since the bet track, his strong conscience is something which I have time and again mentioned about and now this...

Nanu's attack scene was properly done, but things after that were messy...😕

Naina's call at the time when Sameer comes and picks up Nanu was actually racing my heart at that time...

But now let's come to some technicalities:

1. Kamya and Hema's voice muted...they praised Naina and no dialogue...why? 😕

2. Farewell scenes were so badly done. Only 10-12 guys in the room instead of students of 2 complete grades, no other teachers.😕

3. The guy who asks Arjun to sing was not shown, only his voice lingering in the room..what was that?😕

4. Arjun lip-syncing on music of Papa kehte hai...I mean no words, and it was so clumsy😕

5. Sameer's entry in the room and his scream muted...big why?...Sorry to say but his helpless call for munshiji sounded funny to me rather than painful...it was clear that the dialogue was added later...his voice was so low that it can't be heard even in the next room...😕

Oh and this reminds me of the deceptive promo of Pooja's wedding aired on TV...In that Bela chachi was shown to be doubtful about Samaina, but now they are completely contradicting themselves and showing Taiji as Byomkesh bakshi...I mean why? To gain TRPs as Taiji can add more spice to this than Bela? 😕

For me today Naina-Sam dress up scene and Nanu-Sameer scene took the cake...even Nanu's attack was well enacted but there were problems...bad editing can kill a wonderful story...Please CVs should be more careful with this...

PS: Nanu will survive I'm hopeful. Till now no article on IF Tellybuzz has been published that Kiran Kumar to exit the show. Such things come on IF soon. So I'm positive he will be there to see his great grandchildren... So fingers crossed😳

Edited by KashafZaroon30 - 7 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Infofan

@Infofan

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 7 years ago

You know how hard I was taking news about Nanu until two days ago right? I just watched the episode twice because I couldn't believe what I saw the first time.This was not one of their best episodes and not because of Nanu.

Fandom is crying and depressed about Nanu for how long now? These people give us a slo mo long scene of his attack! Terribly insensitive. Kiranji was fab in that scene but did we need such a long drawn out scene? For TRP?

I am still in my happy bubble. I think he will survive. Nanu again said he will be there for Sam's shaadi and be a par nana. I am hanging on to that for my sanity! He will survive. If he doesn't we will line up the CVs after tomorrow's episode and fandom can collectively kick the CVs pichwadas!

As usual Nanu-Sameer scenes are so heartwarming. I just want to hug them both. I am trying to forget Chacha's character butchering because I love Chacha -chachi scenes and they were adorable again today. Mundit scenes are a laugh riot as always. Preeti is the best sister one can have!

But several other things were bizarre in the episode.

Sameer couldn't call the driver in to help if Munshi wasn't around? Person of Nanu's age who has just had a massive attack could walk out of the room with someone's help?

Dunno about car model but the licence plate number certainly wasn't unn dinon ka and I wish they had blurred it. The other day Shef was holding a mobile box.

Where did Sam's sister come from suddenly BTW? Even Nanu never mentioned her which is odd if she is Vishaka's daughter, Sam's half sister... oops sorry this was in some BTS.. insta story I think.

Naina's blouse miraculously matches Nani's saree😕. Both looked so good, I wish they had seen each other. CVs mein G*l mata ka bhoot aa gaya hai kya? Sadistic ho gaye hai to not let Samaina be together in farewell party! I was so looking forward to all of them enjoy themselves at the party, Maybe CVs thought they all enjoyed enough in the shaadi and so we didnt get anything here.

I thought Naina might blush on hearing Munna call her Bhabhi.😕

SO much hype over the farewell and it was a dud. Missed Princi and his shayari. The dubing, muting of songs and dialogues... it was weird.

Arjun was looking so champu... his character should have been written better... didnt look like a leader, head boy material but rant for another post.

Naina again chose Sameer over her bhaiya, walked away while he was singing or did she walk out because of his singing😆

But O Bai. SwaMun finally got new dialogues. Hallelujah! It has been so long since we saw them together. Kaan taras gaye thay to hear 'Aye pandit aaj bada sundar lag raha hai' and today we got much more. Swati toh patti hui lag rahi hai.

Munna - Preeti scene 😆 kya ga raha, kaunsa gaana, kya kehte hai papa? 🤣

Whole cast has been getting time off. I wish the CVs take some time off too. They work longer hours than actors, get paid less and dont get as much recognition. SO dear CVs, take a break, come back fresh ho kar and give us smashing episodes again.

Edited by Infofan - 7 years ago

Quote

anjalii123

@anjalii123

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Nivi,sach main was cryin yaa..I know its fiction but cant jus get over wats gona happen to Nanu,,I wud like to beleive Nanu wil pass away..Dono if it wud b in Ahmedabad or in Delhi..But this phase has been taken from Sumit Sirs life..His Nanu passed away whn he was 17..So it wil b the same for Sameer too..Sameer has to fight Somani alone..Sameer has to get responsible n join business like Sumit Sir did @17..Wit Nanu around,Sameer wil not grow up,i mean he wil b the same child like he is wit Nanu..Sameer is jus 17,jus cant imagine how this boy is gona handle Nanus death..Naina is clueless too,tat hurts me the most..But im glad he didnt make it to the farewell Nivi,otherwise not being beside Nanu whn he was needed wud have made him guilty thru out his life..N nivi ,he did call NANU aft a long time,and whn he did tat al i cud think was u..How long we have been waitin for him to address tat way.I luved the scene b/w Nanu n Sameer..It was very emotional but then there was so much luv in everythin Nanu spoke..

Sameer n Naina wont even exchange cassettes 😭.,nor wil he b able to talk to her..I jus hope Munna n Pandit wil go home and find out wat happened to Nanu n b wit him @the hospital..This boy wont b able to handle this loss,and he needs his friends wit him..Cant even imagine how Somani is gona treat this boy in Delhi😭..Hes lost everythin @ such a young age,and al of a sudden he has to become a man takin up responsibilities😕,not easy..

As long as Naina wil b his emotional anchor like how Shashi Mam supported Sumit sir during his difficult times,Sameer wil come out of this pain,and i cant wait to c this phase of their lives how they stand up for each other during thick n thin..

Never knew fictional characters wud take a toll on me too..jus cudnt control my tears cin Nanu

Edited by anjalii123 - 7 years ago

Quote

Dhruvi

@Hearttalks_90s

Voyager

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

i m just too sad... i hv lived with my grandparents. we lived in joint family or to say family - best family - and i was 16 my lost both my dada and dadi in a span of 40 days... its so disheartening to imagine how it wud b for Sameer. though its a fictional character but i just cant get over it... i m not thihnking what happens next. i can just see a kid whose only life support is his nanu, he has to see him in this condition. what happens next wud b unbearable for Sameer...😭😭😭

Quote

Phoenix

@Phoenix100

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

Nivi

I still can't cope up with the pain.😭.. Is nanu actually going,?... Won't he be there for samaina marriage... It seems like there's no hope left... This seemed like a final farewell of nanu...

The sweet scene caught me... The way nanu said i will feed u until i am alive... It was like a final goodbye 😕... Bt in my heart i still hope nanu survives... Let him be critical or bedridden... Bt keep him alive... Atleast until sam is emotionally stable... He's still so dependent on nanu...

It was actually a good thing that sam didn't reach the farewell... Because his guilt wouldn't have let him live all his life otherwise... Watched the nanu collapsing scene again after reading your post... U were right about the bgm was like ecg machine... So we have to be mentally prepared for the worst. 😭

I'm glad that sam had the sweet from nanu's hands... May be for the last time... The scene was too good and emotional... Such things do happen in real life too...

I didn't like a bit that sam's sound was muted while screaming... It was such an important scene and they ruined it by muting... How did sam manage to lift nanu? I thought someone will help him with that... Where are the servants and munshiji gone?

Precap... I guess naina won't know anything about nanu and she'll leave for the village... By the time she comes back, he'll be gone to delhi. 😭

Ps. I think vishakha and somani will make an entry tomorrow... The pace with which things are going, i feel the will wrap up all the remaining tracks by next week... Village track, exams, Naina depressed, taiji doubting everything will be done with... Leap may happen the week after that.

Edited by angelic567 - 7 years ago

Quote

canapoem

@canapoem

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 7 years ago

Nivi, thank you for your post today also considering that it was such a sad turn in the story.

Chacha and Chachi do make a nice pair. No wonder Preeti is so bindaas.

Today I liked that they played the title track when Naina and Sameer were getting dressed.

Considering what was coming up next, glad that they did not put some movie song in BG.

Farewell party scenes were a dud. What was the point of all the students dressing up so well when they hardly had any dialogues or screen time.

Kamya was looking very beautiful today. I still did not understand why her voice was muted out.

Who told Arjun to talk or sing and I am guessing he did song "Papa kehte hain".

LOL Pandit does not even recognise the Samosa girl.

Funny scene was when Arjun started to sing, Pandit closed his ears. 😆

Munna and Swathi progressed a little further today. Good for them

Naina told Preeti that Sameer left from Shefali's house very late, so he must have overslept.

Like seriously, who writes such illogical dialogues. Sameer was not attending a late night party in Shefali's house that he stayed till the wee hours of the morning and I noticed the time in Shefali's room wall clock yesterday, it showed 4 40 in the evening. That is not late.😕

Coming to Sameer and Nanu scene, very emotional.

CVs have been telling us about Judai from yesterday and today Nanu's dialogues felt like a Good bye to Sameer. 😭

I am kind of relieved that Sameer came back to take his camera and found his Nanu lying on the floor. Imagine if he had gone to the party and came home to find his dead Nanu, that would have been more worse.

But the muted voice of Sameer was the biggest disappointment in the episode. Randeep is so good in voice modulation and he lost a good opportunity to show how well he could have conveyed what Sameer must have gone through by modulating his voice.

Director did a very bad job here.

Precap: Let us wait and watch. What is the use of all these speculations when we know story will be going through some very rough patch soon.

PS: From where did this sister of Sameer and Rohan come from? 😕

Ok Adding a little more, did you all notice the bindi packet from which Naina selected the bindi to wear. In those days that's how Bindi packets were. 😊

Edited by canapoem - 7 years ago

Quote

rose1000

@rose1000

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Thanks for the post Nivi.

It was a sad episode. But all of us knew it was going to be like ths. So it was not surprising.

There were good things and there were bad things

Things I did not like

Writing and storytelling has become very shoddy. The direction lacks perfection. Editing not good. I wonder if the PH has hired people from Balaji. So many loopholes, discontinuity...humara serial aisa to na tha...don't know what is happening behind the scenes. Shashi and Sumeet Mittal should pay attention to this before everything goes downhill.

How come Sam was able to lift Nanu alone? Why not call the driver ? Where are the servants?

Let me share this with you all.. My father had heart attack many years back. He had the same symptoms..pain in chest and back, dizziness, vomiting and he was not able to stand. Luckily there were many people to help him and take him to the hospital immediately. My father is short in height and medium built. Still i remember my brother, the caretaker, driver and a gardener...all had to hold him to take him down to the elevator and car...and here they showed Sam , who is just a kid, lifting Nanu...Nanu was unconscious. It is logically not possible to lift him all alone...

Farewell scene...where were the teachers? I just saw only one. Where was Princi and Shanti madam and Romeo Juliet Sir? Very very shoddy execution.

Things I liked

Randeep and Kiran sir scene...Kiran Sir enacted the heart attack victim so well. Very realistic. It was heartbreaking but acted well.👏

Samain scene..very cliched...but still good. Randeep looked dashing. 😳

Swati and Munna...yeyyy finally Swati wanted Munna to propose to her...😆

Pandit...well he did not get to see his Samosa girl. But I loved how he helped Naina make that phone call. I am guessing during judaai period Mundit will help their bhai and bhabhi. 😉

Preeti...that's my gal...always loved her...the way she was trying to prevent Taiji from attacking Shefali's mom...😆

And last Friday I was very angry with the pre cap when I saw Arjun singing Papa kehte hai. It is one of my fav songs and I did not want to see it beiing picturised on a thief. Period. I am sooo happy. Kum se kum CVs ne meri yeh iccha puri kardi. The song was muted...😆

Glad to see Naina chose Sam over Arjun today. I am really curious to see how Naina is transformed as the support system for Sam for lifetime. 😊

Quote

rose1000

@rose1000

Dazzler

Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: KashafZaroon30
Nivi darling...Lovely post...Nanu Sameer convo made me emotional again...how nicely written👏...

Taiji is seriously irritating day by day...I mean her thinking is very shallow seriously...Maas-machhi ..but yes such people are there who discriminate a lot...But Chacha-Chachi are just love...the way they handled Taiji's tantrums and saved the girls was 😳

Sameer and Naina getting ready parallely was so nicely...both were looking so good..wished to see them in one frame but alas we didn't get that...

The whole time I had an ill-feeling in my heart while watching the episode😭...Sameer will be in so much pain if something happens to Nanu..too much for a teenager...

Sameer-Nanu scene was heart-warming and heart-wrenching at the same time...they made us smile and cry in the same scene...infact I found that scene very impactful...it showed 2 things- We should give atleast some time to our elders no matter what, and secondly it showed what kind of a person Sameer is...he might not care about the world, but he definitely knows how to care about the important people in his life. Why don't Somani and Rakesh see that side of him...Somani specially should see it rather than pointing out his flaws...You just have to give him little attention and care and he will give you his heart and soul...I'm highly impressed with his character sketch since the bet track, his strong conscience is something which I have time and again mentioned about and now this...
Nanu's attack scene was properly done, but things after that were messy...😕

Naina's call at the time when Sameer comes and picks up Nanu was actually racing my heart at that time...

But now let's come to some technicalities:
1. Kamya and Hema's voice muted...they praised Naina and no dialogue...why? 😕
2. Farewell scenes were so badly done. Only 10-12 guys in the room instead of students of 2 complete grades, no other teachers.😕
3. The guy who asks Arjun to sing was not shown, only his voice lingering in the room..what was that?😕
4. Arjun lip-syncing on music of Papa kehte hai...I mean no words, and it was so clumsy😕
5. Sameer's entry in the room and his scream muted...big why?...Sorry to say but his helpless call for munshiji sounded funny to me rather than painful...it was clear that the dialogue was added later...his voice was so low that it can't be heard even in the next room...😕

Oh and this reminds me of the deceptive promo of Pooja's wedding aired on TV...In that Bela chachi was shown to be doubtful about Samaina, but now they are completely contradicting themselves and showing Taiji as Byomkesh bakshi...I mean why? To gain TRPs as Taiji can add more spice to this than Bela? 😕

For me today Naina-Sam dress up scene and Nanu-Sameer scene took the cake...even Nanu's attack was well enacted but there were problems...bad editing can kill a wonderful story...Please CVs should be more careful with this...

PS: Nanu will survive I'm hopeful. Till now no article on IF Tellybuzz has been published that Kiran Kumar to exit the show. Such things come on IF soon. So I'm positive he will be there to see his great grandchildren... So fingers crossed😳

Zulu Rakesh has seen it first hand. How much Sam did for the Agarwals...Geez..Arjun cheated in cricket match right in front of Rakesh's eyes...but did that change Rakesh? No. Kutte ki doom kabhi seedhi nahin ho sakti. I am guessing same is true for Somani too. 😡

Quote

KashafZaroon30

@KashafZaroon30

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

#10

Hey Rose our yesterday's incomplete discussion...Sorry I couldn't reply immediately but did it later ...you can check it out here
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4963831&TPN=10

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 ... 8

Mar 7th: Zindagi Kaisi Hai Paheli :(

Related Topics

Explore Topics