A lot of us have been finding the 'Naina wanting to feel Sameer's pain and the way she goes about it' scene unsettling and I agree that on some level it is a little OTT. But, she is very young and naive and quite enamoured with the likes of Romeo and Juliet - if Juliet could die for her Romeo... main itna toh Kar hi sakti hu na..
Also, pain and sacrifice was a recurring theme that was equated with true love in those times. Movies often showed the lady in love fasting till she got sick or climbing mountains barefoot while her feet blistered and bleed to pray at the temple on the top for the love of her life. All these actions will be considered extremely impractical and stupid today, but Ye Un Dino Ki Baat Hai! Considering all the factors that have influenced her concept of experiencing and expressing love, I think we should look at it as a silly fancy of that kachi umar.
Let's share a couple of stupid things that we have done at that age that we would not repeat now.
- Getting in a car where the driver is a little/more drunk with a very strong belief that we are invincible.