Is ishita right in supporting Roshni?

Poll

Is ishita right in supporting Roshni?

Login To Vote
sarsyed thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Just saw the episode and I was a little confused .
Is ishita really correct in supporting roshni?
Is Roshni a victim?She was willfully involved in the relationship inspite of knowing that Adi was married.

Want to know your views and convey the same to the creatives via this poll.


Edited by sarsyed - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

2.1k

Users

5

Likes

37

Frequent Posters

zohakhan7 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
Absolutely NO
Whatever happened in btw Adi n Roshini was consensual and it wasn't like that Adi had raped Roshini
Roshini was mature enough to know the consequences of her deeds
She willingly stepped onto some one's marriage n broke it n crossed the line of limits
She in her own conscious decided to sleep with Adi
She had no shame to do that ..she kept encouraging adi by meeting him ,keeping their marriage photo with her n saying Adi is her husband n what not
She is not a victim like they r portraying as instead she is the culprit of all
Ishita chose her GKC over Aliya whom she called as her daughter
The very same GKC that would remind Aliya of Adi's infidelity
No woman can tolerate a infidelity let alone accept that child born out off cheating
Ishita talks off morality but where was her morality when she chose Roshini over Aliya and now busy pampering that girl forgetting about her young widow namesake daughter ?
She thinks she is right always n her actions are right too but she is no super woman to be always right..She is a human too n can do mistakes too

Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: zohakhan7

Absolutely NO

Whatever happened in btw Adi n Roshini was consensual and it wasn't like that Adi had raped Roshini
Roshini was mature enough to know the consequences of her deeds
She willingly stepped onto some one's marriage n broke it n crossed the line of limits
She in her own conscious decided to sleep with Adi
She had no shame to do that ..she kept encouraging adi by meeting him ,keeping their marriage photo with her n saying Adi is her husband n what not
She is not a victim like they r portraying as instead she is the culprit of all
Ishita chose her GKC over Aliya whom she called as her daughter
The very same GKC that would remind Aliya of Adi's infidelity
No woman can tolerate a infidelity let alone accept that child born out off cheating
Ishita talks off morality but where was her morality when she chose Roshini over Aliya and now busy pampering that girl forgetting about her young widow namesake daughter ?
She thinks she is right always n her actions are right too but she is no super woman to be always right..She is a human too n can do mistakes too


I also think ishita should not have chosen roshni over aliya. It made no sense to me. At the same time, I also believe giving the entire responsibility of adi-aliya marriage breakdown to roshni is wrong, because I have been noticing a regular trend amongst fans to say she broke their marriage, when in fact it was adi who broke his own marriage by cheating on his wife, but roshni genuinely encouraged him too. Although adi showed interest in roshni at the same time even before she started encouraging his advancements as was shown with the way he constantly kept looking at her the moment she returned back on lori.

Ideally ishita should have not supported roshni in the way she is doing now, but if she was concerned due to her being pregnant with adi's child, she should have hired somebody to look after pregnant roshni, and kept in contact with roshni just to know whether she was keeping okay in that state. Because ishita would in no way be wrong to do that, because after all, the child is at no fault.

I know many are saying that adi should not have been killed. Yes, adi as we knew and loved should never have been kiled, but if you list the things he did, and looked at everything including his behavior, they were irredeemable and worse than the things ashok had done and even param had done to a certain extent, and the adi he had become was punished, but it wasn't the punishment I desired for him. The ideal punishment would be seeing him rotting in jail and getting plenty of time to think over what he had done.

Now, after adi, it is roshni who is getting punishment, as she's apparently going to die at birth. This girl ruined her own life, a life that at first she had greatly improved after her divorce from that forced marriage with adi and building a life for herself outside that backwards village of hers with the help of ishita-raman, but she returned their favours and good treatment towards her by equally engaging in an affair with adi and betraying the family. Dying single, alone, unloved is karma for betraying aliya and the bhalla's, and that is one thing I am happy about.
sarsyed thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: zohakhan7

Absolutely NO

Whatever happened in btw Adi n Roshini was consensual and it wasn't like that Adi had raped Roshini
Roshini was mature enough to know the consequences of her deeds
She willingly stepped onto some one's marriage n broke it n crossed the line of limits
She in her own conscious decided to sleep with Adi
She had no shame to do that ..she kept encouraging adi by meeting him ,keeping their marriage photo with her n saying Adi is her husband n what not
She is not a victim like they r portraying as instead she is the culprit of all
Ishita chose her GKC over Aliya whom she called as her daughter
The very same GKC that would remind Aliya of Adi's infidelity
No woman can tolerate a infidelity let alone accept that child born out off cheating
Ishita talks off morality but where was her morality when she chose Roshini over Aliya and now busy pampering that girl forgetting about her young widow namesake daughter ?
She thinks she is right always n her actions are right too but she is no super woman to be always right..She is a human too n can do mistakes too


I agree it was very convenient for roshni just because she is pregnant? And by what means? Adi got punished for his deeds and here roshni is being hailed for having the "ansh" in her womb ?

Would ishita react the same way if ruhi was pregnant with suhail or nikhil's child ? Would she still rejoice like is doing right now? Here she is shown supporting a home wrecker what for just because she regrets killing her son ?

Isnt this hypocrisy ? In fact today ishita reminded me of what toshi once did ,I see no difference between the two now .
Edited by sarsyed - 7 years ago
zohakhan7 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: sarsyed


I agree it was very convenient for roshni just because she is pregnant? And by what means? Adi got punished for his deeds and here roshni is being hailed for having the "ansh" in her womb ?

Would ishita react the same way if ruhi was pregnant with suhail or nikhil's child ? Here she is shown supporting a home wrecker what for just because she regrets killing her son ?
Isnt this hypocrisy ? In fact today ishita reminded me of what toshi once did ,I see no difference between the two now .


And i hate how she forgets her other kids too in her guilt ..first time she tried to commit suicide n forgot about Pihu n Adi n today she was about to shoot herself forgetting about Ruhi n Pihu especially Phu who was still in danger due to Param n Simmi
What if Aliya n Roshini would have gotten pregnant same time ? Who would have Ishita supported then ?
Its sad that Ishita supported this infidelity in the name of GKC n forgotten how this very same Roshini was a part of infidelity and this baby will remind Aliya of her husband's infidelity
Toshi GKC jaap n Ishita shown these days are no different now
Ishita thinks she is a super woman who will always be right n her actions are right always but forgot that she is a human n can makes mistakes too
Her pampering to that culprit Roshini who is behaving like a victim is puke worthy 🤢
Ishita instead of being there with Aliya is supporting n pampering this very same Roshini who willingly slept with a married man and that too twice with her own will n that Adi didn't forced her 🥱
Where is her morals now when she herself is supporting infidelity ?
sarsyed thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: zohakhan7


And i hate how she forgets her other kids too in her guilt ..first time she tried to commit suicide n forgot about Pihu n Adi n today she was about to shoot herself forgetting about Ruhi n Pihu especially Phu who was still in danger due to Param n Simmi
What if Aliya n Roshini would have gotten pregnant same time ? Who would have Ishita supported then ?
Its sad that Ishita supported this infidelity in the name of GKC n forgotten how this very same Roshini was a part of infidelity and this baby will remind Aliya of her husband's infidelity
Toshi GKC jaap n Ishita shown these days are no different now
Ishita thinks she is a super woman who will always be right n her actions are right always but forgot that she is a human n can makes mistakes too
Her pampering to that culprit Roshini who is behaving like a victim is puke worthy 🤢
Ishita instead of being there with Aliya is supporting n pampering this very same Roshini who willingly slept with a married man and that too twice with her own will n that Adi didn't forced her 🥱
Where is her morals now when she herself is supporting infidelity ?


Hope the creatives get the message and stop trying to convince us with lame justifications to roshnis deeds .

Alia definitely didn't deserve a husband like adi she also didn't deserve to be betrayed by the woman whom she called "amma" and who at one point of time has taken care of the orphan Alia.


Divanru thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
A big no .
She is totally wrong in this all ,in killing adi and then supporting roshni .
And then also if she will fight for custody of adi child with bhalla's ,as the arrivals are coming out .
Ishita is responsible for all this mess and CVS can't justify this act of her ever whatever they say until adi is alive .
raavanluvsjansi thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Ishita is not at all right in supporting Roshni.

Adi and Roshni messed up everything
And she is all ready to marry other guy also.
So if not shantanu ,she would marry any other guy .
And she is independent woman to decide on what needs to do with her baby .Its not that she needs Ishita to support her.And Ishita thanking for her life is utter stupidity.She should have felt like killing herself after hearing the news that she is pregnant for raising ADI like this .😡



on a lighter note,Ishita is not doctor as Raman says .How could she believe that Roshni is Pregnant with Adi's kid in such a short span😆of time .Per yhm time frame her marriage was fixed two -three days after they did IT😆




sarsyed thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Divanru

A big no .

She is totally wrong in this all ,in killing adi and then supporting roshni .
And then also if she will fight for custody of adi child with bhalla's ,as the arrivals are coming out .
Ishita is responsible for all this mess and CVS can't justify this act of her ever whatever they say until adi is alive .


WORD👏
Had Shagun supported Roshni after hearing that she was pregnant with Adi's kid would have still made sense .

Firstly she had lost her own son at the hands of ishita now her hope to get him back was through his kid.
Secondly she wasn't attached emotionally to alia as much as ishita was shown to be .

Ishita supporting Roshni is totally out of her character
sarsyed thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: raavanluvsjansi

Ishita is not at all right in supporting Roshni.

Adi and Roshni messed up everything
And she is all ready to marry other guy also.
So if not shantanu ,she would marry any other guy .
And she is independent woman to decide on what needs to do with her baby .Its not that she needs Ishita to support her.And Ishita thanking for her life is utter stupidity.She should have felt like killing herself after hearing the news that she is pregnant for raising ADI like this .😡



on a lighter note,Ishita is not doctor as Raman says .How could she believe that Roshni is Pregnant with Adi's kid in such a short span😆of time .Per yhm time frame her marriage was fixed two -three days after they did IT😆





😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".