Sumiko- have some sense of responsibility

sumiko thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
In today's world which has become more transparent you hear of many cases of domestic abuse among the educated middle class which hitherto never surfaced.
One of the reasons amongst many being the conviction and the Ghasa pita guidance given to a young married girl not to discus matters happening in her matrimonial home with her parents
I ask why
The mother in law of modern times is cool and supposedly tolerant
A marriage is supposed to be of two families also specially where a joint family is involved
The daughter in law is given as much freedom as the daughter of the house
And to top it all what is it so different that one family does from another family within the privacy of their respective houses that has to be guarded like a piece of intelligence
These are some of the reasons young educated girls subjected to domestic violence and abuse take so long to come out with the truth
Sometimes its too late
Parents which till yesterday were your all in all have to be treated as outsiders - for what
This is taking away the girl's one and only armour in an Indian society
Ishita should have been given a better script than the unsavoury lecture she gave to a newly married girl who almost married a once married man and has just started her life
Lecture admonishing her from sharing anything with her Mom
How is it possible for a newly Wed in a new surrounding to confide in anybody else
Please don't encourage such scripts
A girl's only protection is her parents
Just by not keeping things under wraps the heavens won't fall
But may be a girl will be saved from domestic abuse In Time

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

537

Users

6

Likes

5

Frequent Posters

kras thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Nice poat
One side according to me none should interfere in married couple life neither girl's parents nor boy's parents but on the other hand i agree with u also hum apne baccho ko sikhate h ki sasural ki baat kabhi maayke mein mat batana hamesha sabko khush rakhna iske karan hi physical abuse badhta h aur jab ladki par had se jyada julm ho jata h ya ladki mar jati h tab gharwalo ko pata chalta h
But ek sach ye bhi h ki bhalla house mein koi bhi aliya ko torture nahi karega in fact bhalla family to apni bahu ke aage apne bete ko bhul jati h aur ye hum ishra aur romika ke case mein dekh chuke h
cindian thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Actually our elders like sasural matters shld not be shared to maykka its not to differentiate its just like privacy an d to mingle with the family and it will build relationship married wommen shld try to solve their her prpb with hubby,a lady m.law,s.law like tat it just shows a maturity from girl to women only n school we use complain to our parents its totally diff case... It doesn't a
Women shld tolerate if any abuse cause to her... In yhm also the telecasted a scene when Raman told the vacation with shagun,adi,ruhi.. There they shared mother daughter bonding
DikshaN thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
nice post but what happened in the serial is completely different from what ur saying
alia is not subjected to domestic violence
nor is anyone shouting at her in her new household
ishu told her not to discuss petty issues with her mom like that clothes thing
and to top it shagun comes and accuses ishita of interfering than obviously ishu wouldn't like it
it's just my opinion
kras thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: DikshaN

nice post but what happened in the serial is completely different from what ur saying
alia is not subjected to domestic violence
nor is anyone shouting at her in her new household
ishu told her not to discuss petty issues with her mom like that clothes thing
and to top it shagun comes and accuses ishita of interfering than obviously ishu wouldn't like it
it's just my opinion

i m sorry to interfere but i think aliya ia not wrong here she didn't tell her about that clothes thing personally aliya doesn't call shagun in fact aliya baar baar shagun ko hungama karne se rokti h aur kal bhi aliya khush nahi thi shagun ke drame se aur ye baat usne shagun se kahi bhi
And ishita ko bhi ye baat samajhni chahiye ki real culprit kaun h shagun ya adi aur aliya real culprit is shagun
Adi aliya r not culprit
GBSC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Yes.it is correct.
One of my neighbour commuted suicide in just 4 months after marriage.
She would not have had time even to adjust herself in the new house.
wendy25 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Well the case is entirely different here. Ofcourse girl shouldnt severe communication with her parents and share everything that even hints abuse.
Communication with parents is important but that doesnt mean you share everything bit of your sasural's information with your mother. How can anyone trust that daughter in law that shares every bit of sasural happening with her mother who doesnt waste time to tapkofying in her beti's sasural at any given opportunity.
Being mature enough to know when to share and when to keep is what seperates a girl from a married woman.
Here its not normal sasural-mayka case. Alia is practically raised by Ishita. Ishita is her amma first then saas. So if she can be so trusting towards her new mother shagun then its not wrong for Ishita to expect a bit of trust from her daughter in law by marriage and daughter by upbringing. The house alia is married to adores her like a daughter and can never harm even a hair on her head .Here clearly the interefering one is shagun and not Ishita. She was never even a decent human being let alone a daughter in law/mother/wife, so obviously she is meddling in adiliya and bhalla house affairs in pretext of protecting her nayi naveli daughter and brainwashing aliya with her own misguided experiences making it seems like bhalla's n Ishita are some kind of bahu torturing monsters.
A mother's advice is always helpful in her daughter's married life but a woman who herself has been mockery of motherhood and wife how can advice her daughter on about any of this. Such kind of mothers just play intrumental role in breaking up her daughter's home.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".