Re sent by star India:A mail sent by me to Starplus

sindhu.kashyup thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Dear Sindhura,
Thanks for being a loyal viewer of our show Ye Hai Mohabbatein. We understand your concerns and would like to try and address them as below-


Shagun has always been an integral part and one of the pillars of Ye Hai Mohabbatein. The triangle of Raman-Ishita-Shagun because of the very fact that Ishita became the real mother to Shagun's biological kids is the very premise of Ye Hai Mohabbatein. There is no Shagun track or Ishita track or a Raman track. It is a story, a journey or relationships evolving over time where-in the characters play their part according to the story and as we have seen Shagun has always been a threat to Ishita & Raman as Ishita has proven to be a better wife and mother than Shagun ever was.

There is no Shagun track, Ishita track or a Raman track, it is a story and a journey. Raman Ishita are of-course at the peripheral with their interpersonal relationship going through a change due to certain situations and people around them, one of which is Shagun. Raman-Ishita will eventually come together but for that they need to go through a journey which will definitely have certain hurdles in the form of opposing forces like Shagun.

With regards to the Mihir-Aliya Angle, YHM has always been a show that has challenged social evils and norms and our stories have reflected what actually happens in the society. We feel love is a very strong and pure emotion and is certainly not bound by age. Alia develops feeling for Mihir seeing what kind of a sensible, honest and mature personality he is and not because he is older to her.

Also, Ruhi never meant to say that she fell in love with Ishita after Raman-Ishita's marriage. Maybe the way the dialogue was framed made you feel so, we will surely take better care in future.

About Raman's character, he has always been an impulsive character- taking decisions in the spur of the moment and reacting aggressively to situations. His life got balanced when Ishita came in. That is the beauty of Raman Ishita's relationship. They complement each other, make up for each other's mistakes and shortcomings. Raman had gone back to his old self while IShita was gone but now again when Ishita came back, she got the balance in his life back.

We hope to have answered all your concerns. All your other suggestions are duly noted. It is our constant endeavor to give our esteemed viewers a good mix of emotions and drama, and will continue to do so. We hope you will enjoy the way this story progresses.

Regards,

Consumer Response

Star India




From: sindhura ch [mailto:sindhura.kashyup@gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, July 27, 2016 11:03 PM
To: Shankar, Uday (STAR India); Jha, Anil (STAR India)
Subject: Yeh hai Mohabbatein

Dear Sir,

I am regular viewer of YHM from past 2yrs. During early days of YHM story was really beautiful and as year passed it turned into Yeh hai Nafratein .May i know y this change has come? .CVs say that story revolves around ishita and Raman but the fact and truth is, story is adjusted accordingly to fit SHAGUN character.

1.Shagun ka revenge

2. Shagun ka insecurity after leap

3.Shagun ki badla ke naam pe mahanata

4. shagun bani surrogate mother iske peeche bhi badla hai

In the sense, Shagun is main lead and ishra have to be adjusted accordingly.

There is no one ishra centric track without haddis .Always Shagun shagun shagun...unconditional love for this character is irritating viewers immensely.

Now coming to the point, After leap of 7 yrs, here we r expecting re-union of ishra but again CVs concentrating on shagun badla/revenge/marriage. As if she is the lead of the show. We knew that she is antagonist but still there is limit, no ishra centric track at all.

Now you are showing others love stories leaving ishra

1.Disgusting Mihir-Aliya angle (see the age difference), she is just like adi's age and your pairing them

2. By pairing mihir aliya you want bring problems in ishras life. Ishra are there to just solving problems leaving thier personal life and love

3.one more point in this yhm ,you people have focussed more on shaguns marriage rather than ishra love and marriage life their relationship.

May i ask who are wonderful and brilliant heads behind writing such a crap and throwing on our face .

One biggest blunder that happened in recent episodes happened (CVs Amnesia Problem)

Its shagun -Ruhi scenes

Ruhi told shagun that raman married ishita bcos you were not there and slowly i also started loving ishimaa.

If we fans remember its first ruhi who loved ishita and want her as her mother then slowly raman started liking and loving and married her .

HOW CAN U SHOW SUCH A BLUNDER...CVS?

YOU can show so many beautiful tracks

1.Ishita pregnancy and giving birth to a child by undergoing fertility treatments so that infertile women in the society can learn and hope for good(Now you are showing ishra childs love Adi's) No hope for this track now .Divan(Divyanka,Karan) would have potrayed excellently if you have shown this track

2.After leap, you could have shown ishra reconciling their relationship a heart to heart talk clearing all misunderstandings

3. Most imp Raman revealing ishitas truth to PIHU ;Here also as usual you left this to RUHI ; she is also traumatized child for 7yrs. and you alloted this responsibility to her.

4.Both Ishita and Raman bringing out Old Ruhi who was lost 7yrs ago due to extreme trauma and child who lost confidance and trust.

About character RAMAN BHALLA,

What have you made this man, Is he there to make blunders in life and create mess and expect ishita to clear it always

Have CVS ever shown Raman regretting for his mistakes and realising no never

Raman - to do blunders

Ishita - To clear the Mess.

Have you ever shown ishra working together on any issue no not at all

We fans/Viewers are really disappointed by CVS.

At present they are showing Mani- shagun marriage and shagun trapping ishita

Its a request to change the track and make it as an open war between IshraVS Shagun.

Don't even think of getting shagun married to Raman or Ishita to Mani .

We viewers want ishras reunion after 7yrs of separation so don't try to create mess in name of drama and get ishra married to each other revealing real face of shagun before PIHU

I request you both(Mr.Uday and Mr.Anil) to talk to production house and change the track its better if they concentrate on ishras life rather than creating problems in their life and they just solving them.

TRPs already dropped due to shaguns mess and marriage drama always .

Don't spoil this show more(Its already been spoiled)

Thanks,

Sindhura





ref:_00D90bo5a._5006F1ApSSE:ref

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

2.6k

Users

10

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

DiVan_ thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
How is it that they didn't say a word for the tracks we wanna watch? Email them again with all those dream tracks and make it loud and clear that we want a big fat indian wedding for IshRa ke Duje ke liye and then a honeymoon NOT a family trip, for god sake!
shivangi838 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Thanks for sharing this. Glad u took d efforts to voice out our concerns😊. I am actually happy dat sp at least read D mail and had the courtesy to reply back though I m not satisfied wid their answer completely.😆
Points to be noted in their reply -

1. Ishra will always be together and so I think sp wud never allow sha-ram marriage to happen...even if bt wants to😉
That's good and they have clearly said ishita will and always be better Dan shaguniya so shaguniya will be completely negative in upcoming track.😕

2. Mihir alia angle let's c how they tackle it... whether mihir will like alia or not ?? I don't think he will.😆

3. Hopefully our concerns regarding dialogues and especially Raman's dialogues hve reached their ears and hope dey pay more heed to it in future and give us more ishra also in upcoming days.😳

Rest we all know that shagun is going nowhere till show ends becoz of both personal and masala trp reasons so it's better we ignore her presence as much as we can.🥱
ItsNoorfatima thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Their answers are not matching your questions 😕
ishra_JD_club thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Okk priya ray ne ye mail sent ki hei kya
" shagun is integral part of yhm"
She emerge stronger
Shagu. Ke liye baki jayen baadh mein 👏
--QUEEN-- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

IshRa's Icons

Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Tfs this dear😛
Your mail shows how frustrated you are👏. We all are sailing in the same boat😳
And the star plus reply left me rofling😆
I thought this was a show of two broken individuals who were brought together for their common love ruhi. But no, they said that it's a competition between ishita and sshagun to prove who is better wife for raman and better mother for children😆
I would have appreciated sp, if they have said that show needs twists to get ttrp instead of justifying sshagun's
presence forever around ishra
And they said yhm always depicts what actually happens in society. Show me one goddamn wife who is so obsessed with her husband's ex
vanisree thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
tfs. atleast you got replay fm sp. i have been sendding mail to sp regarding surrogacy, infertility of a woman . they dint replied.
Sunstar1 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Sindhu,

1st of all...thank you for sending a big mail to SP with so much in detail

I can see how much you love watching this show like all of us. I totally agree with your concern. but I don't think they will change the concept of story revolving around Shagun char.
I / many of them lost the connection with ISHRA, they are still magical but lost the bonding with the show.
Shagun is not only the show seller for BT, SP, EK but she is also seller for EK's designer sarees, blouse collections(EK business) too. so she became integral part right . now a days, I don't even love her dressing style. ex. the blue saree (jail scene or pihu calling ishima scene), I didn't like her hair style nor her blouse. WHY... 😡 😡 😡

we don't have any option left
Sunstar1 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Shivangi,

I love your review style.

SNS show had Dharam and Meera marriage with the same aged person love and marriage...disgusting. I think same thing they are tying to show in YHM.

we never got full love story of ISHRA, now kids love story started. we get to see Aliya, Rihu, Pihu pregnancy tracks 😡 👏, why not Neelu wedding and pregnancy track. 🤢

2014 & 2015 Ishita was solving all the issues in Bhalla house and now RUHI is the problem solver. 😲
elders in the family has no say, they will start preparations who ever is marrying ...

and SP is supporting their act
😲
Nirvana15 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
The premise of YHM is based on the book Custody. And if anyone has read the book it is very clear that there are three pivotial characters Raman-Ishita-Shagun.

So it is obvious that the story will revolve around them which means Shagun is going no where and will continue to be a hurdle till the end.

As for Mihir and Aaliya love story. I don't see any harm in that. The team just needs to handle it aesthetically. The fact that Shagun (Mihir's sister) is marrying Mani (Aaliya's father) needs to be tackled with sensibly if they are planning to go ahead with Mihir-Aaliya.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".