Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

8k

Users

31

Likes

517

Frequent Posters

shravsss thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#41
Hey Gan,
Shagun's character needs to be described in a better way, if CVs really want us to feel the so called pain she put her self through. First of all, we don't know what happened all these seven years? how she managed the small child, where was her grandparents? okay I get it, she needed to be fed breast milk, the child started to get attached. But, what about rest of the Bhalla's? I still don't get a justification from any of them as to why it was so important for them to hide it from the small child about her real mother? Surrogacy was in itself the worst way of degrading a barren woman. Ishita's dialogue is still afresh in me, "Till now just the world use to call me that, but You made me feel it"...

Raman's character didn't give a good reply as to why was it so important for him to make someone mom when she herself n number of times told him she feels complete, she is mother... etc etc...

Sorry I lost my plot... (I think Cvs are seriously growing on me)


Coming back to the whitest character, As I said in one of the reply post to your post, Shagun's character has always been shown Selfish and now time and again she is just proving it. But, what I don't get is that, how is someone responsible for her own decision of leaving Manoj for someone's child. Did any of the Bhalla's force her?? Did Iyer's requested her to fill in for their Daughter's mistake??

One more thing, Was Shagun not in love with Ishita's Achayiii??? Their Atoot bandhan??? what happened to that?? She didn't try to meet Ishita even out of curiosity???? That's so unrealistic...


What was her whole drama of searching Ishita in Australia then????


If people are to really feel bad for her situation just because they feel Raman is using her because of his anger on Ishita, then, All I have to say to them is Smell the Coffee...


Didn't expect I will write this much😲...
dreamzsrk thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: -Gan-

"shagun ko family mila hai .. Jo usko hamesha se chahiye tha"...



Didn't Shagun already have one during her marriage with Raman.. And chose to leave them. ? So it's not true... It's truly about her priorities.. Then family became a hindrance to her aspirations to monetary and social status... Now that Raman has all that .. She wants to be now in his life as his wife and pihu's mother.

It's not insecurity.. It's called narcissistic aspirations.. Which changes according to self-serving needs.

So let's not blanket tag everyone 's motive as 'insecurity " 😆


👏👏👏

Mreddy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

Every human being is selfish by nature. Shagun held together Raman, Pihu and rest of the Bhallas with her limited authority after Ishita's treachery. Now when she sees her own world is on the verge of collapse because of an outsider who ran away from everyone, she bounds to behave selfish. But CVs will take it to the next level and portray her complete black only to forcefully fit Ishita in Raman and Pihu's life again.

Wow, it is your opinion, but in what way did Shagun hold Raman and the Bhallas together. Other than taking care of Pihu, I do not see any contribution of her towards the Bhallas or Raman.
Edited by Mreddy - 9 years ago
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: shravsss

Hey Gan,

Shagun's character needs to be described in a better way, if CVs really want us to feel the so called pain she put her self through. First of all, we don't know what happened all these seven years? how she managed the small child, where was her grandparents? okay I get it, she needed to be fed breast milk, the child started to get attached. But, what about rest of the Bhalla's? I still don't get a justification from any of them as to why it was so important for them to hide it from the small child about her real mother? Surrogacy was in itself the worst way of degrading a barren woman. Ishita's dialogue is still afresh in me, "Till now just the world use to call me that, but You made me feel it"...

Raman's character didn't give a good reply as to why was it so important for him to make someone mom when she herself n number of times told him she feels complete, she is mother... etc etc...

Sorry I lost my plot... (I think Cvs are seriously growing on me)


Coming back to the whitest character, As I said in one of the reply post to your post, Shagun's character has always been shown Selfish and now time and again she is just proving it. But, what I don't get is that, how is someone responsible for her own decision of leaving Manoj for someone's child. Did any of the Bhalla's force her?? Did Iyer's requested her to fill in for their Daughter's mistake??

One more thing, Was Shagun not in love with Ishita's Achayiii??? Their Atoot bandhan??? what happened to that?? She didn't try to meet Ishita even out of curiosity???? That's so unrealistic...


What was her whole drama of searching Ishita in Australia then????


If people are to really feel bad for her situation just because they feel Raman is using her because of his anger on Ishita, then, All I have to say to them is Smell the Coffee...


Didn't expect I will write this much😲...


The only track they dealt with Shagun's inner workings was the accident track... Ever since her rentry into Bhalla house it has always been more about giving her more screen space rather than actually making her character believable...hence even with all the effort on the part of cvs to establish her as a changed individual including complete wardrobe overhaul... She's becomr more unrelatable...it's like trying to fit an odd piece of puzzle forcefully into a place where it doesn't belong.. It may stick but the differences will show ..so we feel no sympathy for Shagun inspite of her wardrobe, long monologues . Their half-hearted attempt of establishing Shagun -Pihu bond...Shagun remains unrelatable
radrose thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#45
everyone remember ruhi but shagun never remember her ones
her mamta for pihu is acting very soon pihu will show shagun her real place ones she know about ishita been her real mother

than real game will start
brihati thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: radrose

everyone remember ruhi but shagun never remember her ones

her mamta for pihu is acting very soon pihu will show shagun her real place ones she know about ishita been her real mother

than real game will start

but at present the way ishita is being portrayed in pihus eye( that ishita will make pihu and sharam alag)
do u think pihu will accept acknowledge ishita??
i dnt think so according to pihu ishita always fights with raman as ruhi told her
pihu will choose shagun only😭
shravsss thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: -Gan-


The only track they dealt with Shagun's inner workings was the accident track... Ever since her rentry into Bhalla house it has always been more about giving her more screen space rather than actually making her character believable...hence even with all the effort on the part of cvs to establish her as a changed individual including complete wardrobe overhaul... She's becomr more unrelatable...it's like trying to fit an odd piece of puzzle forcefully into a place where it doesn't belong.. It may stick but the differences will show ..so we feel no sympathy for Shagun inspite of her wardrobe, long monologues . Their half-hearted attempt of establishing Shagun -Pihu bond...Shagun remains unrelatable



She is unrelated to YHM ever since Adi also accepted Ishita as his family especially as his Mother. Surrogacy was fit in to the story, just to make her relate in the story. But, CVs should remember that for drama they have shown her as a very black protagonist and not grey... So, now they shouldn't really expect us to see her as White Protagonist whom we can emote with, when it is even difficult to relate to her as ' A Grey Protagonist '.

She will remain unrelatable to YHM.😉😉
vidya.anand thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#48
Hugs 🤗to you and all my friends here...

Yes Gan. Raman is obsessively in love with Ishita and this anger stems up from that deep love. His love is deep like the ocean. Ishita staying away from him and hiding the truth that she didnt die has hurt him too much. probably, he hadnt ever thought that she will go away like that. His expectation was that she will forget all his angry words and come back to him. So he is not able to digest it.
Barren and helpless women shouldn't have self respect. they should just be happy that someone is there to love them. This show gives us such a message.
This is not to bash Raman but I am blaming the CVs to have made him like that and making yeh hai mohabatein into nafratein!


Originally posted by: -Gan-



Vids 🤗 should I thank Shagun for bringing all the old friends back to the thread again 😉


Raman when it comes to Ishita sees no one .. They have established well that he's totally indifferent to Shagun ever since he fell in love with Ishita.. So in his life he's currently obsessed with Ishita, albeit negativily .. So in his eyes no one has committed a bigger crime than Ishita by staying away from him .. Hence selective memory..

Edited by vidya.anand - 9 years ago
.riah. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#49
Shagun ke liye Sab kuch chalta hai 😳
Don't we know that by now already. This is their way to justify Shagun going grey again.
And that is what we heard already 😆 "this is how normal human beings behave when something they have wanted for so many years is being taken away from them" 🥱
Love some of the comments here and agree with a lot of them. Almost all of it covered so nothing more to say.
Only lets be prepared for a lot of reasoning done by some ppl to justify the character and everything she does now. Things might be 🤢 on and off
--QUEEN-- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3

IshRa's Icons

Posted: 9 years ago
#50
Oh come on people, Shaggy is selfless right from the beginning. You didn't get it.
She left Raman fifteen years back so that he concentrates on his business and rise from ashes
She left ruhi so that baanjh like ishu gets a daughter.
She left adi in fire,so that ishu comes and saves him ,so that ishrarudi live happily.
Next she went
to Mumbai to get fit and fine, so that she becomes surrogate for ishra. And in Delhi, when she came to know that they didn't even consummate, she herself made IT possible in ishra's life and became the surrogate herself.
And the most important thing,she took care of pihu SSIRF PIHU KE LIYE, she lied first time in her life that she's the actual mother of pihu. And can anyone be this selfless?
And for the first time when she's trying to get selfish that too ishita ke liye, can't you people understand that?
How cruel😭

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".