No One Can portray Shagun's Role better than Anita!|Warning p.3

Ajay_Sanjana thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
I'm liking this track Divz trying her best to copy shagun... but i guess Divz ko enough time nhi diya gya shagun pe work kr k copy krne ka.. Divz ke Face pe Wo shagun wala ego,arrogance, attitude nhi ...Divz cute,innocent jyada lag rhi hai shagun copy track mein...Aur Anita ka face bahot jyada innocent n cute hai fir bhi Anita ne shagun ka role bahot jyada acche se portray kiya...hats off to Anita... Lakho mein ek episodic mein Anita ne ruhanika ke mom ka character bhi bahot acche se play kiya tha exact opposite role tha shagun se... After watching yesterdays episode i'm sure now evn Divz can not portray shagun's role better than Anita so baki Actress ki baat hi chhodh do...


-Sorry maine Divz Anita ko compare kiya...i like both Actress... but its really unfair ki Divz jab acche se shagun ko portray bhi nhi kar pa rhi hai toh bhi kuch log Divz ko Anita/shagun se better bta rhe hai... plz blind fan naa bne aur jiska jo credit ho naa chhine... please...sorry once again just wanted to say this...
SORRY ONCE AGAIN if i'm hurting anyones sentiments . Love Divz Ani both.
Edited by Ajay_Sanjana - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

3.7k

Users

17

Likes

103

Frequent Posters

iffanvidz thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
what I feel is divz is doing mixed character of shagun and ishitha...
so that is the correct acting...
If she changes the face also same as shagun then there is no uniqueness...
sskazii thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
you know what? i agree No one can play Shagun better than anita it has been proved since the show started. But the problem started wen these dumb cvs started making Shagun more of a devi than Ishita. Mujhe saint Shagun pachi hi nahi in the first place. The screeching and screaming and the nasal voice only looks good on negative characters not on saints.. if you understand what i say.
hdivan thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I won't go into comparison bt divs is current best actress in telly world.no one can denies that.about shagun character divs is doing commendable job as shagun bt yes shagun character suits Anita most.bt as u kniw cw in gum is good till it has its teste then we throw it off
Edited by hdivan - 9 years ago
Pravalli thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Dear it is not only potraiting a character pehle say he shagun ka character anita kar rahi hai so divyanka has potrait like shagun with Anita's expressions it is not easy to patray another actor kyunke har actor ko apna alag style Hota hai divyanka was trying her best to look like shagun and she is doing very well aur divyanka does not portray as shagun inher own style she has to act like anitha only if she has her own choice then she can do better than that coming to episodes she was doing a fantastic job with walking style to talking and expressions I can say that she was one of the best actress in indian telly industry
smilinggirl2590 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
I think u r confusing .. Playing a character s diff , copying a act s diff ... Anita played shagun for 2 YRS , she played the character and it was made shagun style ... She doesn't need to imitate . it's just being her... But divyanka playing shagun s diff . she has to copy ... She can't improvise . she can't put her style... She just have to copy some one else character mannerism ... I think tats difficult... She convinces and without flashbacks u can point out which is ishita which s shagun...so tats brilliance in acting ... Comparing ishita as shagun and ani as shagun s stupidity... Anita played shagun as her way . divyanka copying ani style. Both are diff.
The_Imane thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Well I dont think It's allowed to compare both, but as everyone is doing so indirectely n srcasticly even mocking one, I will neglect the fact that you compared DT n Anita.
DT is a very good actress...she has been awesome in many Ishita scenes..
But she just cant be Shagun..DT as Shagun is like it was offscreen or another character...
She cant have that attitude with wich Anita stand and walk as Shagun.
She cant have that way of dialgue delivry Anita give as Shagun..
Yes audience is maybe too exagering.
But frankly, I'll prefer to say it's because the character Ishita has been so mahaan and attitudeless for two years, that it just give a breath of fresh air...and it's amusing to see her like that...
Actors are artists, and in artists there is no one better work than another, it's not A business project.
Artist can do two extremely differrant work on the same subject that are both top..
Anita is just awesome as Shagun, and no one can replace her..
She has been working on her character since long..
Where DT is just given to copy that..
Had DT have got a similar character, she would have her own mannerism and attitude which would be fabulous..and as Anita would have marked the wiewers...
The_Imane thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Ajay_Sanjana

I'm liking this track Divz trying her best to copy shagun... but i guess Divz ko enough time nhi diya gya shagun pe work kr k copy krne ka.. Divz ke Face pe Wo shagun wala ego,arrogance, attitude nhi ...Divz cute,innocence jyada lag rhi hai shagun copy track mein...Aur Anita ka face bahot jyada innocent n cute hai fir bhi Anita ne shagun ka role bahot jyada acche se portray kiya...hats off to Anita... Lakho mein ek episodic mein Anita ne ruhanika ke mom ka character bhi bahot acche se play kiya tha exact opposite role tha shagun se... After watching yesterdays episode i'm sure now evn Divz can not portray shagun's role better than Anita so baki Actress ki baat hi chhodh do...


-Sorry maine Divz Anita ko compare kiya...i like both Actress... but its really unfair ki Divz jab acche se shagun ko portray bhi nhi kar pa rhi hai toh bhi kuch log Divz ko Anita/shagun se better bta rhe hai... plz blind fan naa bne aur jiska jo credit ho naa chhine... please...sorry once again just wanted to say this...
SORRY ONCE AGAIN if i'm hurting anyones sentiments . Love Divz Ani both.

Of which show you talking about? Is that Teri meri love stories?
But I don't remember that girl to be Ruh, she was elder..
Tought I remember Anita and Ruhanika had came togheter before YHM too..
Please can you tell me the show's name or give a link if you have,?
Anisha_anitan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Divyanka switching roles is commendable but still the style and the way anita did shagun cant be matched
-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: smilinggirl2590

I think u r confusing .. Playing a character s diff , copying a act s diff ... Anita played shagun for 2 YRS , she played the character and it was made shagun style ... She doesn't need to imitate . it's just being her... But divyanka playing shagun s diff . she has to copy ... She can't improvise . she can't put her style... She just have to copy some one else character mannerism ... I think tats difficult... She convinces and without flashbacks u can point out which is ishita which s shagun...so tats brilliance in acting ... Comparing ishita as shagun and ani as shagun s stupidity... Anita played shagun as her way . divyanka copying ani style. Both are diff.


Well, it's far from being right. It's difficult to create something on your own and that too for the first time. Copying exactly like that is easy specially if you are an imitator or an actor. That's the case in general ,not about this case only and it's true for other form of arts too...like singing. When a music composer and a singer create a song it's tough, in reality shows singers imitate them and even surpass them but it doesn't mean they are better than the original.

And, I'm not interested in DT vs Anita acting comparison or silly subtle fan wars. If you feel otherwise, you are most welcome. 😳
Edited by -MS- - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

9 months ago

Offered typecast Negative Roles Due to Massive YHM Popularity- Anita H

Anita Hassanandani Says She Was Always Offered Negative Roles During Her 5 Year Hiatus Due to Yeh Hai Mohabbatein's Massive Success! In a new...

Expand â–¼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Phoenix-

5 months ago

Happy Birth Day ANITA...PARTY PICS

Happy Birth Day ANITA...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".