It's just insulting to couples struggling with infertility - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

67

Views

8.3k

Users

35

Likes

337

Frequent Posters

vidya.anand thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
I agree to all the posts here...
CVs lost the plot long back and they just prove time and again that they neither have the ability nor the maturity to handle such sensitive, serious plots.

This track is plain mockery and proves again that CVs dont even do basic research into what they show. They seriously dont have any idea about such treatments.
Meeting or knowing about the woman who becomes the surrogate is not even possible neither does the woman knows about whose baby she is carrying...its all kept confidential for obvious reasons.

Here, CVs have trespassed all sane logical reasons making everything a mere mockery and display of foolishness!

Anyways I have to add that I have stopped watching the show as I am not able to connect to anything at all. I just read the WU for 2-3 episodes together. But this thread made me vent it out...

pls CVs...dont put ur heads into plots about which you have absolutely no idea nor have the time and patience to know about it before u show it on the show!

Mohabatein ke naam par couples ke beech ke rishte ka mazaag banaa ke rakh diya!😡

DivianTanz_Divz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
Wrote in Aru's post :
Aww... I am so elated with the love of CVs for Shagun.
That's all I can say.
God bless us. I haven't watched the epi. Read updates... I Was so happy reading the update that my electricity had gone in YHM time😆.
So, this week back to back worst episodes. Are CVs competing on how worse episodes they can make in Indian TV history🤣!!!
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: -K.13-

I posted this else where but am including it here.

I don't care about characters right now...just the regressive insensitive cruel CVs/SP/BT

This show, from day 1, had a focus on infertility. Ishita was ostracized for her inability to conceive & women watched this show because they could relate.

So how is it appropriate or empathetic to show a woman who was taunted as a "baanj" for years become pregnant almost immediately after her marriage consummated. What was showed is that her infertility (which was explained to us as tubal scarring) was CURED by sex.

Fine - viewers digested it as a miracle...but then women who have infertility issues often suffer miscarriages. She was not shown as her having a miscarriage due to her ailment...but it was showen that her miscarriage occured after an accident, that could affect any woman.

In a span of 2 weeks this show undid the infertility tag of Ishita's & now she is denying surrogacy not because it doesn't alleviate her of the "baanj" tag but because she doesn't want to give false hope. Should she not be given more time to introspect on what this means to her as a women or do they not want to offer her that depth?

And if that wasn't the worst...they have shown the husband who wanted his wife to experience a 9 month pregnancy go BEHIND HER BACK to try for surrogacy. She didn't go for any treatments, but he made the decision for HER to use the eggs. This is a COUPLE's decision that has been descricated.

Now think of the women who spend $100000 of dollars on TREATMENTS (not tests) to get pregnant. Think of the women who suffer multiple miscarriages due to reproductive tract issues. Think of the women who commit suicide or suffer severe depression because of the title "baanj." The people involved with this show may not have seen this in real life but I have worked with many women in this situation. This situation is soul piercing for couples.

The recent handling of surrogacy & the medical profession yet again sheds a horrible light on the entire process.

YHM is not handing out hope to the women who watched this show because they were in Ishita's place. it's also not handing out handing out realism about the struggles an infertile woman faces when trying getting pregnant.

----

Everything appears to be just for TRPs and in the process it looks like people involved have forgotten empathy towards fellow humans. I understand drama is needed for shows because I've watched tons of desi shows. But for a topic that was a tenant of the show (along with infidelity, second chances, and nature vs nurture)...it's sad to see it turned into a sick joke.



WORD!! 👏

Krishy I have been so livid ever since I read the LU...I have not been able to sit down and write cohesively why today's episode and the current track has wrong in so many different levels...but if I had written I wouldn't have put it so well! You covered everything...twhat the CVs are doing is outrageous for even the OTT TRP melodrama that is so common in Isdian telly shows...this is pure unethical...whether surrogacy happens or not, it doesn't matter ...that they can think in this kind of regressive ways..makes you wonder are these the same craetives who wrote the beginning months of the show...like you said this kind of thinking defies the very premise the show was based on...

Aru.Divan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: -K.13-


sp bc BT was always this way & arent afraid to admit it. Anyone who learns a show is BT (some later than sooner) generally knows it will be amoral. SP just kept them in more check bc they were ruling the charts with safer less dramatic stuff

Now that they are losing badly, they are letting BT spread their normal filth to garner TRs

It's SP who claims to have nayi soch but in reality doesn't come close

Money >>>> morality/ethics/empathy



but so regressive ..!!! Like insulting too many things at once and this is nowhere going to garner money or empathy
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
I am just so pissed at how they decided to force surrogacy/scam down our throats

Even if it would suck to see both agree - at least I wouldn't feel disgusted as a human being. What they are showing right now is blatantly for shock & awe...and if TRPs trend down, they'll cut things short & give a sh*tty ending.

I'm not even mad at how the characters are acting bc this is beyond that. It's even beyond getting certain things/people in focus - it's cheap shock & awe BS thought up & approved by pathetic greedy humans

I literally feel heartbroken thinking of the couples who can't ever have a baby...of the women who can't go through labor pains...of the men who don't get to pamper their wives during her mood swings

I mean for most couples, pregnancy is a gift...and some people actually don't get to have that gift.

And surrogacy is a valid option if ALL other options are exhausted & both couples agree. Bc surrogacy can fill the void in a couples' life. It can give them a symbol of their love - a little him & her to watch flourish.

No doubt Ishita will get pregnant one day but at what cost with this track?
Edited by -K.13- - 9 years ago
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
sorry guys have to go...will be back in the evening ...hopefully much calmer 😆
avni_19 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
WORD Gan Di...They have literally ruined everything. Raman and Ishita take vows of not hiding anything and look what Raman does..He hid two things, one storage incident, second but the most important one signing the surrogacy papers, and Ishita hid the news of Rinky's so called affair...! She/He has no clue about what's happening with them in their home. I swear if Ishita gets to know about the surrogacy cum storage incident through some other source, she will be heart-broken and she might not even trust him. Arghh!! Yuck...This is totallyyy GROSSS!!! And as per articles, if Rinky is dead, The blame game will start and all will point Ishita...even Raman..because he loses his senses when he is angry!😡
You know what, I seriously wish they shut the show abruptly, it makes me sad to say or write this because they are literally INSULTING the medical science, and those who struggle to conceive. Such audiences sit and watch such shows so they kinda get a social message..Yeh pora TRP keliye kar rahe..Its horrible!😡

How I wished CVs read ur message...!

But again I heard that this surrogacy is simply to expose the scam that's happening in that clinic! Lets see how far its true..Well I am actually least bothered about the whole thing..They killed Medicine, butchered Raman's character to an extent that there is no point of return and don't know what all is happening.

Shagun being in that room was..I don't know how to explain..I felt that whole thing was OTT! Being over-concerned over IshRa..Sounds fishy right. And Ando Chor Doc ko sirf IshRa hai kya pure din raat treat krne keliye! Haad hai!


ishra00 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18
Truely agree with each and every word. I am so much disappointed that I dnt feel like typing anything. have not been watching it since last 4 days. Just to creat misunderstanding between the lead pair cv have choosen such a cheap logic. YHM will not be same anymore. Even DIVAN magic wont work in these illogical stupid tract. RIP YHM
akdhalover thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
I have given up totally on the show even stopped reading wu
This can't get any worse
Edited by akdhalover - 9 years ago
ishra00 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
🥱
Edited by ishra00 - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".