YHM -Daily Episode Discussions and Live Updates Thread #61 - Page 100

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

63.7k

Users

50

Likes

2.6k

Frequent Posters

fariza91 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
where did u guys see that ishita is with rooh at the airport? it's not in the episode ryt cause i haven't seen that scene then :( btw MY Raman 😭 he stole the show 2day and ishita was great too but a male expressiing his feelings like that.. i must say HATS OF KARAN⭐️ and DT too
ShvetaSankar thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: fariza91

where did u guys see that ishita is with rooh at the airport? it's not in the episode ryt cause i haven't seen that scene then :( btw MY Raman 😭 he stole the show 2day and ishita was great too but a male expressiing his feelings like that.. i must say HATS OF KARAN⭐️ and DT too


Some pics was posted from OLV in forum where Ishita is seen with Ruhi in Airport and Sarika seems to have spotted them.. Yeah Absolutely KP and DT were par excellence today.. Stellar performances I would say..
Edited by ShvetaSankar - 10 years ago
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago

It has been a while since I have discussed the show and its characters, their actions or the repercussions of the same but tonight I cannot hold myself back somehow.

I have been reading stuff that Ishita has gone out of line in undermining her marriage with Raman that the way she has been behaving she is inflicting pain upon those who mean her well, who love her enough. There have been people who have said not everything can be swept under the rug by saying that a mother is doing this, not a wife, and all that jazz.

I agree with a few things, I do not with a few but I would like to present a POV here perhaps ignored entirely.

For those who think that Ishita needs redemption after the words she hurled tonight at Raman - I would strongly disagree with.

I strongly believe that a person is a product of their past as much as their present. Our present defines what we wish for in the future, but our past shapes us into the people we are. A person and their circumstances can as well as do change but neither of these can happen in the blink of an eye, well except for the circumstances part. You may become a pauper by a financial crisis so huge you can't avert it try as you may if its destined and likewise you might just win a lottery out of the blue if you are destined to do so, but can it change you as a person in a matter of moments just as easily? No.

Why am I saying all of this?

Simple Ishita is reacting the way she is based on her past & her present.

She mentioned today without Ruhi there is no them to Raman. Is it really a wrong thing to say? She did become his wife because Ruhi wanted Ishita as a mother. Raman did not want a wife but he did want a mother for Ruhi when he married her. Likewise, Ishita was not interested in marrying Raman for the man he is but because he was the man who coincidentally fathered the child she fell madly in love with.

To understand Ishita' words today Ishita' history has to be taken into account.

Was this really a mother saying things today, was it a wife, or was it Ishita a woman, a woman scared out of her wits that came to the fore here today?

Remember it wasn't just Raman but everyone else who faced her wrath too, her sisters included. One with whom things aren't even rocky at the moment. She is mad at everyone but mostly the situation.

Did she say she would leave Raman? Divorce him, no. She said there is no them without Ruhi.

In her past she loved a man for 12 long years of her life, let us assume Ishita is a 30-year-old woman now. 12 of those 30 years she was in a committed, loving relationship with someone she thought she would spend the rest of her life with.

Did it happen? No.

Why? Because she cannot procreate, cannot have a child of her own due to a biological impairment beyond her control.

Did she expect that 12 years would account for nothing instantly when faced with a hurdle that she never intended to be faced with? No. The answer would always remain the same.

Today that woman is a wife, a daughter-in-law, a sister-in-law but most importantly she is a mother, and it is by the virtue of being this child' mother did she attain the aforementioned relationships in her life in the first place that she had lost all hopes off.

From where I see, Ishita is scared out of her mind at the prospect of losing Ruhi because with her gone she fears she is no one. She is the same Ishita that no one wanted before this child.

Ruhi is her miracle, the one who made it possible for her to have a family where a man grudgingly wed her.

Yes today that man is in love with her madly, but the very man not a few hours back said he needed his son to move forward in their marriage. He had to have Adi to take their relationship to the next level. Perhaps that man wanted to feel complete before he could surrender himself to her mind, body, heart and soul and claim her similarly.

She was fine with that, happy, euphoric even before her world came crashing down in a matter of hours.

What changed that? The prospect of losing Ruhi or by extension everything associated with Ruhi.

A woman who was discarded aside after 12 years before she could even process what hit her when she learned of her condition, by a man who had vowed to spend the rest of his life with her, can it not be possible that she fears that history may repeat itself with her?

When Ruhi' custody was originally up for the battle in the court, as a newly wedded wife of her husband of not even a day, she was coolly told by the man he would have the divorce papers ready for their marriage to be dissolved since Ruhi doesn't want her too now.

Is it so hard to imagine she thinks one day those words could turn real?

Yes, she knows Raman loves her, feels it in her bones, but she has also known love is not enough to keep two people together, hold them forever since she has underwent the bitter experience once.

Can it not be that she fears that if 12 years weren't enough for Subu to stay by her, how long before Raman breaks and for the sake of his children perhaps decide to get back together with the woman he detests, solely because she has his children. A daughter whose legal custody is in her possession apart from the fact she biologically gave birth to her and a son who loves that woman to bits.

She knows Raman the man, the husband can be relied upon, but can the father put up with her if he is deprived of his children? Would he not shun her, rebuke her or hate her if, if he has to spend his life with a woman who cannot bear his children.

A family that has a matriarch who wants an heir badly enough, and has one already would they want her even if she is unable to provide them with another heir if at all?

Would they submit, yield to the evil woman one day because she has the children who the man loves and adores to bits, the family cannot do without.

To simply put it, what started the dominoes falling for this situation to arise -

Toshiji' incessant ranting about the family needing an heir and wishing Adi would be back with them because Romi has now become ineffectual on that account. Yes, he has fathered a child with Sarika but she is in no mood to let bygones be bygones, and even if she does relent in the future, which I think she would, there is no guarantee that the newest addition to the Bhalla clan will be a Ghar Ka Chirag only and not a Ghar Ki Lakshmi.

In the face of all these things, their one reliable hope is Aditya, a child that Raman already has had with Shagun from his disastrous marriage. A child who loves his mother above all and who wants his mother by his side forever, a son Ishita has no hopes of winning over because she has faced such resistance from his end. She knows he may have found it in his heart to have made peace with her as his father' new wife but he is not willing to give her the mantle of his mother, even a stepmother.

A child whose influence can crumble the foundations of her marriage, something she has already seen. Should things become ugly in Ruhi' absence, she basically may find herself watching her life go up in flames as she nearly did on Lohri, when the family meekly gave into the demands of the child and instead of making him understand the rights from the wrongs stood mere spectators.

With his mother as the center of his universe, should that child one day again a demand as to have his mother back with him, so that his family consisting of his parents, himself and his younger sister can be together under one roof.

Would the family want to hold onto her in the face of such a demand forever -she, a woman who they did not even want in the first place? A woman they know has been good to them but cannot help them promote the family tree?

Would they think twice and even if they do, would they listen to their hearts, their conscience when it matters, or would she be chucked out before she can even understand what hit her?

Was what we witnessed today really the outburst of a woman, the mistake, as some call it, of a wife or the full-blown fear of a woman abandoned before, discarded earlier that took place?

Was it just Ishimaa, the mother in the driving seat today when she chose to rage and react the way she did or was it Ishita, the woman there as well?

The woman who fears that the life she nearly had given up the hopes of, the life she finally attained a chance to live out courtesy of her miracle, her little Ruhi, may be falling apart once again while all she can do is be a mere spectator as it happens, like she did last time.

jaya321 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

It has been a while since I have discussed the show and its characters, their actions or the repercussions of the same but tonight I cannot hold myself back somehow.

I have been reading stuff that Ishita has gone out of line in undermining her marriage with Raman that the way she has been behaving she is inflicting pain upon those who mean her well, who love her enough. There have been people who have said not everything can be swept under the rug by saying that a mother is doing this, not a wife, and all that jazz.

I agree with a few things, I do not with a few but I would like to present a POV here perhaps ignored entirely.

For those who think that Ishita needs redemption after the words she hurled tonight at Raman - I would strongly disagree with.

I strongly believe that a person is a product of their past as much as their present. Our present defines what we wish for in the future, but our past shapes us into the people we are. A person and their circumstances can as well as do change but neither of these can happen in the blink of an eye, well except for the circumstances part. You may become a pauper by a financial crisis so huge you can't avert it try as you may if its destined and likewise you might just win a lottery out of the blue if you are destined to do so, but can it change you as a person in a matter of moments just as easily? No.

Why am I saying all of this?

Simple Ishita is reacting the way she is based on her past & her present.

She mentioned today without Ruhi there is no them to Raman. Is it really a wrong thing to say? She did become his wife because Ruhi wanted Ishita as a mother. Raman did not want a wife but he did want a mother for Ruhi when he married her. Likewise, Ishita was not interested in marrying Raman for the man he is but because he was the man who coincidentally fathered the child she fell madly in love with.

To understand Ishita' words today Ishita' history has to be taken into account.

Was this really a mother saying things today, was it a wife, or was it Ishita a woman, a woman scared out of her wits that came to the fore here today?

Remember it wasn't just Raman but everyone else who faced her wrath too, her sisters included. One with whom things aren't even rocky at the moment. She is mad at everyone but mostly the situation.

Did she say she would leave Raman? Divorce him, no. She said there is no them without Ruhi.

In her past she loved a man for 12 long years of her life, let us assume Ishita is a 30-year-old woman now. 12 of those 30 years she was in a committed, loving relationship with someone she thought she would spend the rest of her life with.

Did it happen? No.

Why? Because she cannot procreate, cannot have a child of her own due to a biological impairment beyond her control.

Did she expect that 12 years would account for nothing instantly when faced with a hurdle that she never intended to be faced with? No. The answer would always remain the same.

Today that woman is a wife, a daughter-in-law, a sister-in-law but most importantly she is a mother, and it is by the virtue of being this child' mother did she attain the aforementioned relationships in her life in the first place that she had lost all hopes off.

From where I see, Ishita is scared out of her mind at the prospect of losing Ruhi because with her gone she fears she is no one. She is the same Ishita that no one wanted before this child.

Ruhi is her miracle, the one who made it possible for her to have a family where a man grudgingly wed her.

Yes today that man is in love with her madly, but the very man not a few hours back said he needed his son to move forward in their marriage. He had to have Adi to take their relationship to the next level. Perhaps that man wanted to feel complete before he could surrender himself to her mind, body, heart and soul and claim her similarly.

She was fine with that, happy, euphoric even before her world came crashing down in a matter of hours.

What changed that? The prospect of losing Ruhi or by extension everything associated with Ruhi.

A woman who was discarded aside after 12 years before she could even process what hit her when she learned of her condition, by a man who had vowed to spend the rest of his life with her, can it not be possible that she fears that history may repeat itself with her?

When Ruhi' custody was originally up for the battle in the court, as a newly wedded wife of her husband of not even a day, she was coolly told by the man he would have the divorce papers ready for their marriage to be dissolved since Ruhi doesn't want her too now.

Is it so hard to imagine she thinks one day those words could turn real?

Yes, she knows Raman loves her, feels it in her bones, but she has also known love is not enough to keep two people together, hold them forever since she has underwent the bitter experience once.

Can it not be that she fears that if 12 years weren't enough for Subu to stay by her, how long before Raman breaks and for the sake of his children perhaps decide to get back together with the woman he detests, solely because she has his children. A daughter whose legal custody is in her possession apart from the fact she biologically gave birth to her and a son who loves that woman to bits.

She knows Raman the man, the husband can be relied upon, but can the father put up with her if he is deprived of his children? Would he not shun her, rebuke her or hate her if, if he has to spend his life with a woman who cannot bear his children.

A family that has a matriarch who wants an heir badly enough, and has one already would they want her even if she is unable to provide them with another heir if at all?

Would they submit, yield to the evil woman one day because she has the children who the man loves and adores to bits, the family cannot do without.

To simply put it, what started the dominoes falling for this situation to arise -

Toshiji' incessant ranting about the family needing an heir and wishing Adi would be back with them because Romi has now become ineffectual on that account. Yes, he has fathered a child with Sarika but she is in no mood to let bygones be bygones, and even if she does relent in the future, which I think she would, there is no guarantee that the newest addition to the Bhalla clan will be a Ghar Ka Chirag only and not a Ghar Ki Lakshmi.

In the face of all these things, their one reliable hope is Aditya, a child that Raman already has had with Shagun from his disastrous marriage. A child who loves his mother above all and who wants his mother by his side forever, a son Ishita has no hopes of winning over because she has faced such resistance from his end. She knows he may have found it in his heart to have made peace with her as his father' new wife but he is not willing to give her the mantle of his mother, even a stepmother.

A child whose influence can crumble the foundations of her marriage, something she has already seen. Should things become ugly in Ruhi' absence, she basically may find herself watching her life go up in flames as she nearly did on Lohri, when the family meekly gave into the demands of the child and instead of making him understand the rights from the wrongs stood mere spectators.

With his mother as the center of his universe, should that child one day again a demand as to have his mother back with him, so that his family consisting of his parents, himself and his younger sister can be together under one roof.

Would the family want to hold onto her in the face of such a demand forever -she, a woman who they did not even want in the first place? A woman they know has been good to them but cannot help them promote the family tree?

Would they think twice and even if they do, would they listen to their hearts, their conscience when it matters, or would she be chucked out before she can even understand what hit her?

Was what we witnessed today really the outburst of a woman, the mistake, as some call it, of a wife or the full-blown fear of a woman abandoned before, discarded earlier that took place?

Was it just Ishimaa, the mother in the driving seat today when she chose to rage and react the way she did or was it Ishita, the woman there as well?

The woman who fears that the life she nearly had given up the hopes of, the life she finally attained a chance to live out courtesy of her miracle, her little Ruhi, may be falling apart once again while all she can do is be a mere spectator as it happens, like she did last time.


Well, it is one of the most beautifully written assumption based one sided writings that I have ever read on this forum.

fariza91 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
beautifully written EkPaheli.. i applause you ⭐️ loved everything and i totally understand where ishita is coming from and your post is one the reasons i comprehended the depth of the situation and her reactions, outburst
Shanig123 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
@EkPaheli Aani I knew for some reason or the other I will see something from you . It is so sad that some takes sides and on who s right and wrong . Hope you will give insights more often
poppinss thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

It has been a while since I have discussed the show and its characters, their actions or the repercussions of the same but tonight I cannot hold myself back somehow.

I have been reading stuff that Ishita has gone out of line in undermining her marriage with Raman that the way she has been behaving she is inflicting pain upon those who mean her well, who love her enough. There have been people who have said not everything can be swept under the rug by saying that a mother is doing this, not a wife, and all that jazz.

I agree with a few things, I do not with a few but I would like to present a POV here perhaps ignored entirely.

For those who think that Ishita needs redemption after the words she hurled tonight at Raman - I would strongly disagree with.

I strongly believe that a person is a product of their past as much as their present. Our present defines what we wish for in the future, but our past shapes us into the people we are. A person and their circumstances can as well as do change but neither of these can happen in the blink of an eye, well except for the circumstances part. You may become a pauper by a financial crisis so huge you can't avert it try as you may if its destined and likewise you might just win a lottery out of the blue if you are destined to do so, but can it change you as a person in a matter of moments just as easily? No.

Why am I saying all of this?

Simple Ishita is reacting the way she is based on her past & her present.

She mentioned today without Ruhi there is no them to Raman. Is it really a wrong thing to say? She did become his wife because Ruhi wanted Ishita as a mother. Raman did not want a wife but he did want a mother for Ruhi when he married her. Likewise, Ishita was not interested in marrying Raman for the man he is but because he was the man who coincidentally fathered the child she fell madly in love with.

To understand Ishita' words today Ishita' history has to be taken into account.

Was this really a mother saying things today, was it a wife, or was it Ishita a woman, a woman scared out of her wits that came to the fore here today?

Remember it wasn't just Raman but everyone else who faced her wrath too, her sisters included. One with whom things aren't even rocky at the moment. She is mad at everyone but mostly the situation.

Did she say she would leave Raman? Divorce him, no. She said there is no them without Ruhi.

In her past she loved a man for 12 long years of her life, let us assume Ishita is a 30-year-old woman now. 12 of those 30 years she was in a committed, loving relationship with someone she thought she would spend the rest of her life with.

Did it happen? No.

Why? Because she cannot procreate, cannot have a child of her own due to a biological impairment beyond her control.

Did she expect that 12 years would account for nothing instantly when faced with a hurdle that she never intended to be faced with? No. The answer would always remain the same.

Today that woman is a wife, a daughter-in-law, a sister-in-law but most importantly she is a mother, and it is by the virtue of being this child' mother did she attain the aforementioned relationships in her life in the first place that she had lost all hopes off.

From where I see, Ishita is scared out of her mind at the prospect of losing Ruhi because with her gone she fears she is no one. She is the same Ishita that no one wanted before this child.

Ruhi is her miracle, the one who made it possible for her to have a family where a man grudgingly wed her.

Yes today that man is in love with her madly, but the very man not a few hours back said he needed his son to move forward in their marriage. He had to have Adi to take their relationship to the next level. Perhaps that man wanted to feel complete before he could surrender himself to her mind, body, heart and soul and claim her similarly.

She was fine with that, happy, euphoric even before her world came crashing down in a matter of hours.

What changed that? The prospect of losing Ruhi or by extension everything associated with Ruhi.

A woman who was discarded aside after 12 years before she could even process what hit her when she learned of her condition, by a man who had vowed to spend the rest of his life with her, can it not be possible that she fears that history may repeat itself with her?

When Ruhi' custody was originally up for the battle in the court, as a newly wedded wife of her husband of not even a day, she was coolly told by the man he would have the divorce papers ready for their marriage to be dissolved since Ruhi doesn't want her too now.

Is it so hard to imagine she thinks one day those words could turn real?

Yes, she knows Raman loves her, feels it in her bones, but she has also known love is not enough to keep two people together, hold them forever since she has underwent the bitter experience once.

Can it not be that she fears that if 12 years weren't enough for Subu to stay by her, how long before Raman breaks and for the sake of his children perhaps decide to get back together with the woman he detests, solely because she has his children. A daughter whose legal custody is in her possession apart from the fact she biologically gave birth to her and a son who loves that woman to bits.

She knows Raman the man, the husband can be relied upon, but can the father put up with her if he is deprived of his children? Would he not shun her, rebuke her or hate her if, if he has to spend his life with a woman who cannot bear his children.

A family that has a matriarch who wants an heir badly enough, and has one already would they want her even if she is unable to provide them with another heir if at all?

Would they submit, yield to the evil woman one day because she has the children who the man loves and adores to bits, the family cannot do without.

To simply put it, what started the dominoes falling for this situation to arise -

Toshiji' incessant ranting about the family needing an heir and wishing Adi would be back with them because Romi has now become ineffectual on that account. Yes, he has fathered a child with Sarika but she is in no mood to let bygones be bygones, and even if she does relent in the future, which I think she would, there is no guarantee that the newest addition to the Bhalla clan will be a Ghar Ka Chirag only and not a Ghar Ki Lakshmi.

In the face of all these things, their one reliable hope is Aditya, a child that Raman already has had with Shagun from his disastrous marriage. A child who loves his mother above all and who wants his mother by his side forever, a son Ishita has no hopes of winning over because she has faced such resistance from his end. She knows he may have found it in his heart to have made peace with her as his father' new wife but he is not willing to give her the mantle of his mother, even a stepmother.

A child whose influence can crumble the foundations of her marriage, something she has already seen. Should things become ugly in Ruhi' absence, she basically may find herself watching her life go up in flames as she nearly did on Lohri, when the family meekly gave into the demands of the child and instead of making him understand the rights from the wrongs stood mere spectators.

With his mother as the center of his universe, should that child one day again a demand as to have his mother back with him, so that his family consisting of his parents, himself and his younger sister can be together under one roof.

Would the family want to hold onto her in the face of such a demand forever -she, a woman who they did not even want in the first place? A woman they know has been good to them but cannot help them promote the family tree?

Would they think twice and even if they do, would they listen to their hearts, their conscience when it matters, or would she be chucked out before she can even understand what hit her?

Was what we witnessed today really the outburst of a woman, the mistake, as some call it, of a wife or the full-blown fear of a woman abandoned before, discarded earlier that took place?

Was it just Ishimaa, the mother in the driving seat today when she chose to rage and react the way she did or was it Ishita, the woman there as well?

The woman who fears that the life she nearly had given up the hopes of, the life she finally attained a chance to live out courtesy of her miracle, her little Ruhi, may be falling apart once again while all she can do is be a mere spectator as it happens, like she did last time.


@Ekpaheli Been reading your work the past few days and loved up writing. . Thanks for your contribution.

Beautiful insight. It really is a very different take on the situation. And you have delved very deep into Ishu mind Her perspective. . er may be is high time to get into ishra relationship without.Ru How do you think this track may proceed?
Nichuss thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
aani perfect one...strday more than ishu i felt for raman... His whole world swept away... Waiting 4 episode
shadeslayer thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

It has been a while since I have discussed the show and its characters, their actions or the repercussions of the same but tonight I cannot hold myself back somehow.

I have been reading stuff that Ishita has gone out of line in undermining her marriage with Raman that the way she has been behaving she is inflicting pain upon those who mean her well, who love her enough. There have been people who have said not everything can be swept under the rug by saying that a mother is doing this, not a wife, and all that jazz.

I agree with a few things, I do not with a few but I would like to present a POV here perhaps ignored entirely.

For those who think that Ishita needs redemption after the words she hurled tonight at Raman - I would strongly disagree with.

I strongly believe that a person is a product of their past as much as their present. Our present defines what we wish for in the future, but our past shapes us into the people we are. A person and their circumstances can as well as do change but neither of these can happen in the blink of an eye, well except for the circumstances part. You may become a pauper by a financial crisis so huge you can't avert it try as you may if its destined and likewise you might just win a lottery out of the blue if you are destined to do so, but can it change you as a person in a matter of moments just as easily? No.

Why am I saying all of this?

Simple Ishita is reacting the way she is based on her past & her present.

She mentioned today without Ruhi there is no them to Raman. Is it really a wrong thing to say? She did become his wife because Ruhi wanted Ishita as a mother. Raman did not want a wife but he did want a mother for Ruhi when he married her. Likewise, Ishita was not interested in marrying Raman for the man he is but because he was the man who coincidentally fathered the child she fell madly in love with.

To understand Ishita' words today Ishita' history has to be taken into account.

Was this really a mother saying things today, was it a wife, or was it Ishita a woman, a woman scared out of her wits that came to the fore here today?

Remember it wasn't just Raman but everyone else who faced her wrath too, her sisters included. One with whom things aren't even rocky at the moment. She is mad at everyone but mostly the situation.

Did she say she would leave Raman? Divorce him, no. She said there is no them without Ruhi.

In her past she loved a man for 12 long years of her life, let us assume Ishita is a 30-year-old woman now. 12 of those 30 years she was in a committed, loving relationship with someone she thought she would spend the rest of her life with.

Did it happen? No.

Why? Because she cannot procreate, cannot have a child of her own due to a biological impairment beyond her control.

Did she expect that 12 years would account for nothing instantly when faced with a hurdle that she never intended to be faced with? No. The answer would always remain the same.

Today that woman is a wife, a daughter-in-law, a sister-in-law but most importantly she is a mother, and it is by the virtue of being this child' mother did she attain the aforementioned relationships in her life in the first place that she had lost all hopes off.

From where I see, Ishita is scared out of her mind at the prospect of losing Ruhi because with her gone she fears she is no one. She is the same Ishita that no one wanted before this child.

Ruhi is her miracle, the one who made it possible for her to have a family where a man grudgingly wed her.

Yes today that man is in love with her madly, but the very man not a few hours back said he needed his son to move forward in their marriage. He had to have Adi to take their relationship to the next level. Perhaps that man wanted to feel complete before he could surrender himself to her mind, body, heart and soul and claim her similarly.

She was fine with that, happy, euphoric even before her world came crashing down in a matter of hours.

What changed that? The prospect of losing Ruhi or by extension everything associated with Ruhi.

A woman who was discarded aside after 12 years before she could even process what hit her when she learned of her condition, by a man who had vowed to spend the rest of his life with her, can it not be possible that she fears that history may repeat itself with her?

When Ruhi' custody was originally up for the battle in the court, as a newly wedded wife of her husband of not even a day, she was coolly told by the man he would have the divorce papers ready for their marriage to be dissolved since Ruhi doesn't want her too now.

Is it so hard to imagine she thinks one day those words could turn real?

Yes, she knows Raman loves her, feels it in her bones, but she has also known love is not enough to keep two people together, hold them forever since she has underwent the bitter experience once.

Can it not be that she fears that if 12 years weren't enough for Subu to stay by her, how long before Raman breaks and for the sake of his children perhaps decide to get back together with the woman he detests, solely because she has his children. A daughter whose legal custody is in her possession apart from the fact she biologically gave birth to her and a son who loves that woman to bits.

She knows Raman the man, the husband can be relied upon, but can the father put up with her if he is deprived of his children? Would he not shun her, rebuke her or hate her if, if he has to spend his life with a woman who cannot bear his children.

A family that has a matriarch who wants an heir badly enough, and has one already would they want her even if she is unable to provide them with another heir if at all?

Would they submit, yield to the evil woman one day because she has the children who the man loves and adores to bits, the family cannot do without.

To simply put it, what started the dominoes falling for this situation to arise -

Toshiji' incessant ranting about the family needing an heir and wishing Adi would be back with them because Romi has now become ineffectual on that account. Yes, he has fathered a child with Sarika but she is in no mood to let bygones be bygones, and even if she does relent in the future, which I think she would, there is no guarantee that the newest addition to the Bhalla clan will be a Ghar Ka Chirag only and not a Ghar Ki Lakshmi.

In the face of all these things, their one reliable hope is Aditya, a child that Raman already has had with Shagun from his disastrous marriage. A child who loves his mother above all and who wants his mother by his side forever, a son Ishita has no hopes of winning over because she has faced such resistance from his end. She knows he may have found it in his heart to have made peace with her as his father' new wife but he is not willing to give her the mantle of his mother, even a stepmother.

A child whose influence can crumble the foundations of her marriage, something she has already seen. Should things become ugly in Ruhi' absence, she basically may find herself watching her life go up in flames as she nearly did on Lohri, when the family meekly gave into the demands of the child and instead of making him understand the rights from the wrongs stood mere spectators.

With his mother as the center of his universe, should that child one day again a demand as to have his mother back with him, so that his family consisting of his parents, himself and his younger sister can be together under one roof.

Would the family want to hold onto her in the face of such a demand forever -she, a woman who they did not even want in the first place? A woman they know has been good to them but cannot help them promote the family tree?

Would they think twice and even if they do, would they listen to their hearts, their conscience when it matters, or would she be chucked out before she can even understand what hit her?

Was what we witnessed today really the outburst of a woman, the mistake, as some call it, of a wife or the full-blown fear of a woman abandoned before, discarded earlier that took place?

Was it just Ishimaa, the mother in the driving seat today when she chose to rage and react the way she did or was it Ishita, the woman there as well?

The woman who fears that the life she nearly had given up the hopes of, the life she finally attained a chance to live out courtesy of her miracle, her little Ruhi, may be falling apart once again while all she can do is be a mere spectator as it happens, like she did last time.


Good Lord!! Aani that was an absolutely brilliant write-up. I am happy that I happened to come to the live update thread when i did. An excellent insight into all things that make Ishita Bhalla/Iyer.👏
smilydear thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

.

To simply put it, what started the dominoes falling for this situation to arise -

Toshiji' incessant ranting about the family needing an heir and wishing Adi would be back with them because Romi has now become ineffectual on that account. Yes, he has fathered a child with Sarika but she is in no mood to let bygones be bygones, and even if she does relent in the future, which I think she would, there is no guarantee that the newest addition to the Bhalla clan will be a Ghar Ka Chirag only and not a Ghar Ki Lakshmi.

In the face of all these things, their one reliable hope is Aditya, a child that Raman already has had with Shagun from his disastrous marriage. A child who loves his mother above all and who wants his mother by his side forever, a son Ishita has no hopes of winning over because she has faced such resistance from his end. She knows he may have found it in his heart to have made peace with her as his father' new wife but he is not willing to give her the mantle of his mother, even a stepmother.

A child whose influence can crumble the foundations of her marriage, something she has already seen. Should things become ugly in Ruhi' absence, she basically may find herself watching her life go up in flames as she nearly did on Lohri, when the family meekly gave into the demands of the child and instead of making him understand the rights from the wrongs stood mere spectators.

With his mother as the center of his universe, should that child one day again a demand as to have his mother back with him, so that his family consisting of his parents, himself and his younger sister can be together under one roof.

Would the family want to hold onto her in the face of such a demand forever -she, a woman who they did not even want in the first place? A woman they know has been good to them but cannot help them promote the family tree?

Would they think twice and even if they do, would they listen to their hearts, their conscience when it matters, or would she be chucked out before she can even understand what hit her?

Was what we witnessed today really the outburst of a woman, the mistake, as some call it, of a wife or the full-blown fear of a woman abandoned before, discarded earlier that took place?

Was it just Ishimaa, the mother in the driving seat today when she chose to rage and react the way she did or was it Ishita, the woman there as well?

The woman who fears that the life she nearly had given up the hopes of, the life she finally attained a chance to live out courtesy of her miracle, her little Ruhi, may be falling apart once again while all she can do is be a mere spectator as it happens, like she did last time.


Completely agree with you here, this is all which clouded her , after watching the episode now I can say your insight for the words she said is correct as the way she said was clear that without Ruhi we can't stay together for long as there will not be any 'We' . Why? because she can't ... As Raman can't move forward without Adi in good hands , Ishita can't move forwards when Ruhi is not safe and I am sure Raman can't move forward with this reality along with the guilt that he is responsible to put her daughter in this mess.

What strikes me here is Ishita loosing hope ? Why ? because of the past and present going around her. What she saw when the whole thing comes in focus, how did everyone react? They were numb. She was the only one holding her hope there in front of Shagun and they said nothing. When she said 'koi tumhain yahan Ruhi nahi dega' that was less for Shagun but more for herself to listen that 'Yes' we are with you. Ruhi is not going anywhere but what she found ' No Reaction'. She still hope for things to get hold on herself she tried herself in everyday including a secret meeting with Shagun and she waited everyone else to try for their part But game plan was big and she couldn't do anything.

Before that the main thing which playes here was Toshiji's non stop rant of GKC,her statements Ishita can't be mother, Romi can't be father and the one who is in Sarika's womb , now she is not ready to share. she is not confident this time that how they all will react when Adi n Ruhi are facing each other. She knows she can't stop this swap, and everyone will be ready with this swap evenif with the heavy heart. And she can't leave Ruhi, with Shagun, at this time even for a single hour as she is determined to take revenge and will never let her meet Ruhi. What are the probabilities that Shagun'll leave India forever ? How could she find her daughter ? How would Ruhi survive without her? As she never connects with Shagun and never accept her even as a family member . For Ruhi she is only Adi's mom.

In those conditions what are her options? only one, to elope with Ruhi. This is exactly what she did ...

She is right now thinking of Ruhi only, she is not thinking which mess she is leading herself , Ruhi and Raman into. She is not trusting anyone as she has found herself many time standing alone and fighting for herself and her past gave her this lesson when bad time comes, things move from your hand Like sand. This is exactly she is trying to do, trying to hold hers good time, her life, her Ruhi.

After all this I can found Raman the ultimate looser here ... He can't save both of his kids,he can save only one and for other again he has to go for a long process and didn't know how much damage Shagun can do with the other kid.

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: -SG-

11 months ago

YHM fame Pankaj Bhatia Not Paid Dues Over A Year, YHM Costars Support

Yeh Hai Mohabbatein fame Pankaj Bhatia accuses makers of a TV show of not clearing dues; Aly Goni, Divyanka Tripathi extend support In an...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

8 months ago

Offered typecast Negative Roles Due to Massive YHM Popularity- Anita H

Anita Hassanandani Says She Was Always Offered Negative Roles During Her 5 Year Hiatus Due to Yeh Hai Mohabbatein's Massive Success! In a new...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: ChanChanMan

4 years ago

YHM DT #8 (Strictly Reserved for IshRa/DivAn)

I dare you to post a thing about anyone other than DivAn.

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: TheStranger

1 years ago

YHM cast net Worth - DT, AH, KP

Divyanka Tripathi Estimated net worth is around 37 crore Property: apartment in Mumbai, house in Bhopal Cars: Mercedes Benz E- class sedan 75...

Expand ▼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Aditi_X

4 years ago

Connected: A YHM Story (COMPLETED)

My retelling of the iconic show Yeh Hai Mohabbatein. Four separate souls -- Raman, Ishita, Ruhi, and Adi -- in four separate cities But somehow...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".