Mani Nahi....Shani - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

3.9k

Users

9

Likes

48

Frequent Posters

iDea-yeS-viruS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
same thing I posted in this and previous thread.I can't bear when she compare Raman with mani
_Dipsi_ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#12
Ishita is not confessing because she is not sure about raman feelings. She found his gestures caring rather than loving.
Jealousy track I am ok if it will be for 3-4 episode not more than that. Raman realised it's ok but confession because of this not ok. Ishra relation and realisation were never look force and hope ishra confession won't be force because of third person.

Ishita compared raman and mani even i didnt like that raman is raman and mani is mani. Mani is too formal eee I can't imagine raman like that. Raman is not sweet like mani but his gesture is sweeter.

Btw I like mani but don't want him in ishra confession where he will give lecture to raman on relationship


totally agree

Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: suseesuez

Not only Raman,I also feel same. I didn't want any jealousy track ever. But CVS brought Mani track as jealousy. OK but I feel CVS failing to handle it sensibly.

First I want to know why Ishita didn't ready to confess even after she realised her love. Is it because of shy or ego. I won't consider this as points. In case is it because of afraid about rejection. I think this is stupid point. They married for ruhi sake. They didn't do contract marriage for valid period like SaVan or Arshi did. What will Raman do if she confess. Week he leave her and do another marriage. Rubbish. He can't her way from this marriage. so it's better to start new life with her. Sooner or later Raman have accept and agree this point (see here I didn't talk about Raman love over Ishita. We all know Raman loves Ishita. I talking like in case Raman didn't have any feelings on her) lemme remind you chits drama. That time Ishita mistook mihirs love as Raman's. That time she didn't get angry but a confusion whether to accept his love or not even she hated him. Because she clearly knows it's better improve marital than living loveless marriage. Why this logic didn't use in Raman track.

Why would any self respecting girl who is told on a daily basis that she is pagal, without brains, trouble blah blah blah etc...WHY would she confess she loved a man speaking to her like this?🤔 Even if she has realised she loves him coz underneath he is a decent caring guy, which I don't think ishita has. She hasn't realised she has begun to have those kinds of feelings for him. Just as Raman hasn't realised. Raman talks as much bokwas to himself as he does to ishita😆 "Denial"... as they say isn't just a river in Egypt.😆

Now about jealousy track. Raman never tried to make her jealousy.he just praised him as manmadh but never praised another girl.(if you let night dinner track, that time he told lie because of she called him as kadoos) I think he made her jealous only at accident track. But he didn't do it by intention. It's all her misconception. In sanjana case also her misconception only led her to jealous not Raman's work. But this time why Ishita only trying to make him as jealous.

Ishita isn't making raman jealous. Raman is managing that alll by himself,😆 helped by his past😆 She is not doing it delibrately. Mani is her best friend, she is seeing him after a long time and she is being OPEN and HONEST about him, and how he is. In this if ravan kumar gets jealous than he is a very intelligent man, maybe he can start showing a bit of care for ishita's feelings instead of throwing them and spewing all that nasty verbal hmmm?

OK . she making him as jealous but why yesterday she compared Raman and Mani.I really upset with it. If CVS want a person to make Raman jealous, a simple person is enough. Why they bring a person can giving compete to Raman. Last time her bonding with bala praised by many. Seriously I'm asking who is the hero of yhm? Raman or whom Ishita dates with? It's story about Raman who turns to soar from ideal. In initial episodes she compared Raman with bala. That time I accepted that bassist because she didn't know Raman goodness. But this is time coming with Mani bond is disappoints me. If CVS want to bring jealousy track, why didn't bring Ishita Mani bonding as normal one rather than showing ishita has reason to fall on him. This is a story about a man who lost his lovable son and betrayed by wife and questioned about his potential. If CVS show Ishita comparing and praising another one with Raman, it's injustice to Raman character.

Not injustice at all. Raman's behaviour towards ishita on a daily basis is appalling. Now please don't give me examples of how he cares coz I know them all.. But if he is dumb enough to undo all that by all the verbal diahrea he spews on her on a daily basis then even a stupid person would see the difference between him and another person who speaks not only decently but nicely! And ishita hasn't been shown to be stupid. Not yet anyway.

I think it's all because everyone here desparatly want Raman to confess first. See my opinion love needs is own time. If it's come because of some out force like jealousy or something, we can't feel it. I don't care whom confes first but I'm saying that bringing situations to force a character to confess first will kill the magic. it won't look like natural. It always better to go with flow. Give space to them and let their feelings on their own not by force.
People like raman need a zor ka jakta to stop fooling themselves and others and also to realise AND APPRECIATE ppl in their lives. Its better he realises and personally I don't think he will confess. We are, I think, now going to see quite a few weeks of him bad mouthing ishita even more and adding mani to it. YEs yes I know he wasn't like that before etc etc. But now its high time he changed, if this story is going move ahead faster than a snail.

Ravna kumar is too akdu to confess...lol...don't worry. 😆



An intro of someone, ANYONE who isn't a dirbag a la suraj, pervmeet, etc etc is a good thing.
ANY NORMAL person/girl would compare 2 people who treat her so differently. As for why a character who is on par or better than raman...well...why not? a story has gotta evolve. Shagun is always there in background as insecurity for ishita. Mani will do the same for raman.
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: suseesuez

superior here means showing him as loving, caring, brilliant, moral while showing Raman as kadoos



But they have shown raman as kadhoos from the beginning and introducing another khadoos wouldn't have done the storyline any good. Its obvious that ishita would never be volentarily friends with a khadoos. Mani is a catalyst for raman to be shown to change...for the better. One hopes!
iDea-yeS-viruS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15
@pathera

you kidding me. didn't you.
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: aa8684

Ishita's praising for Mani is over the top, forget how mani behaves check how Ishita is behaving .. Well coming from culture we follow woman when she gets married some instant changes do happen same happened with Ishita s well she has fell for Raman which is acceptable ... She fights for Raman whi is again natural she take cares of Raman which is quite real ..but than this Mani thing ... no matter what no mater how they both were close to each other as friends in school or college whatever there are ethics which a sensible woman like Ishita is ignoring OK mani knows she is married and he respects that (really i doubt) but what abt Raman in order to make him jealous she is crossing the thin line ... it was fine spending a full day with Mani after ages that was pure friendship but than in every single mani mani mani chant comparing her husband with mani stop it ... this very unreal which wife do like this ... knowing Raman had been through bitter past where his wife was involved with another man she should be sensible ... Raman is not like this but what if he start thinking that he came between Ishta and Mani and than decide to step will Ishita be alright with it and will be happy living and bringing up Mani's kids happily ... an ideal life with Ruhi and Ramn



I disagree. The Maani jaap is believable, he is her best friend and they have not seen each other for a long time. Considering how raman treats and speaks to her, the difference between raman and mani is going to be even more stark and blatant for ishita to notice and she voices it. And why not.?! Any normal person would notice and voice the diffrence.

Again it is sooo clear that ishita is not doing it to make raman jealous. Why are so many ppl not seeing it?🤔 In ishita's mind, raman has ZERO feelings for her, it doesn't even occur to her that there would be even a shadow of jealousy. Therefore there isn't even a question arsising of ishita having to be "sensitve" about raman's past.

As for raman moving away so mani and ishita get togather...lolll I don't think so. If anything I'd hazard a guess at ashok dumping shagun and for adi's sake, raman takes back shagun with ishita reluctantly agreeing. So many incidences from the recent past point to a future raman shagun track. Im not saying them in love track but "circumstances" of some sort putting them togather
@ red
you are forgetting ishita is only legally and in matters regarding family, raman's wife. The don't have a PERSONAL relationship of husband and wife and no..im not talking about sleeping togather. Personallyt between them its a "sahmjota" for ruhi. So her talking so openly and effervescently about Mani is believable even in an indian household.
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: suseesuez

@pathera

you kidding me. didn't you.



Why would I do that?
I don't think ishita is praising mani to delibrately make raman jealous.
raman is jealous alll by himself coz he is an insecure man due to his past. THAT is not anyone's fault but shagun's.
AnY person would notice 2 ppl who treat her/him as differently as raman and mani treat ishita. And most would voice it too.
Sandysprings thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Panthera



Why would I do that?
I don't think ishita is praising mani to delibrately make raman jealous.
raman is jealous alll by himself coz he is an insecure man due to his past. THAT is not anyone's fault but shagun's.
AnY person would notice 2 ppl who treat her/him as differently as raman and mani treat ishita. And most would voice it too.


Exactly.. Ishita is not doing anything deliberately.. Its Raman who is assuming and getting jealous by himself ..I'm enjoying this jealous and hurt Raman ..ishita suffered lot because of shagun /Raman's past ..we saw jealous ishita ..why not Raman experience that pain ..
Ishita-mani r friends who met after long time so they talk and spend good time ..what is wrong in that ..and its better than shagun torture ...

Raman always taunt ishita which give her wrong signals ..thatswhy she thinks that Raman has no feelings for her ..and she will not confess till she feels Raman has feelings for her ..she still think Raman and she r friends only ..they respect each other nothing more ..
She is comparing Raman and Mani because of Raman's behavior towards her ..she understand that he is not actually means whatever he said but still expecting some nice words from him ..there is nothing wrong to expect this from husband but what Raman do ..always opposite to it ..
Raman is insecure is not ishita's fault ..and Raman has to realize that ishita is not shagun ..and ishita deserve respect and not tooo harsh words every time..

Raman already two times did fake confession.. And played with ishita's feelings ..people still want that ishita has to confess !!! How does ishita do that ?? And why ?? If she does that then Raman will sure make fun of her ..so its Raman's responsibility to correct situation then only ishita will sure support him ...


mayu1982 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#19
Seriously this track is actually very stupid and no maturity in it all. The only reason I am liking it little bit because of very talented actor KAran PAtel. He is simply superb otherwise for me this is very childish track - Don't think mature ppl need third person in life to confess. ON lighter note- THIS MANI THE shani is over dose of sweetness. Ek IShita is more than enough for the serial. Now male version of IShita is more difficult to digest .
iDea-yeS-viruS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
@Panthera
Yeah. She deliberately doing it all. Because she didn't know wwhich can hurt her husband and which can't. Yes why should she know to his helpings which can hurt and which can't. He is contract husband what's need to understand his feelings. But Mani is her childhood friend. So it's necessary to understand his sensitive side. She should praise his goodness. She must to compare Raman with Mani to improve his standards like Mani.

Because Mani is gentle man who didn't do aanything since she rejected by subbu. But Raman is insensitive because he landed in this contract marriage for daughter sake while he has plenty chances to remarry in past six years due to his success in his carrier.

Sorry for this post. II didn't mean no jealousy for Raman. But this execution of CVS is insensitive.

I think these two incidents will explain what I meaning. Because when these two happened I liked it.First, killer track. WWhen Ishita get did photo, she asked him do he jealous. He stunned with it.Second, mihir engagement. WWhen she praised bala for gift, he spent 3 hours to design a necklace. I liked his jealousy that time.




But this track pure irritating. Can't CVS show sensible incident to show his jealous rather than bringing Mani as shani.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".