How reliable are medical reports - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

82

Views

8.2k

Users

28

Likes

170

Frequent Posters

BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: JLZDK


Medical reports are mostly reliable.
Each patient is different from the other. there are many types of infertility and many causes too. So if Ishita is infertile it is a diagnosis made by a doctor based on tests done on ishita which has proved that she is not a treatable case of infertility. You cannot compare another infertile lady with ishita because that lady may be having a different or perhaps treatable cause of infertility. Sometimes the male partner also have to do some tests in order to rule out other causes of infertility.




Interesting point

And valid too

But how can you be sure without even trying
992227 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: --mancityfan--




Interesting point

And valid too

But how can you be sure without even trying

a woman can be diagnosed as infertile even before marriage. it is based on a series of tests both hormonal and imaging. The reason for her to approach a doctor may be due to usual symptoms like weight problems or associated with abnormal menstural cycles or lack of secondary sexual development. there is an entity called primary infertility where there are genetic abnormalities leading to hormone imbalance which can affect the development of ovaries or uterus. There are wide range of other causes too. So not being able to conceive after marriage is only a minor part of the whole infertilty thing.
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: JLZDK

a woman can be diagnosed as infertile even before marriage. it is based on a series of tests both hormonal and imaging. The reason for her to approach a doctor may be due to usual symptoms like weight problems or associated with abnormal menstural cycles or lack of secondary sexual development. there is an entity called primary infertility where there are genetic abnormalities leading to hormone imbalance which can affect the development of ovaries or uterus. There are wide range of other causes too. So not being able to conceive after marriage is only a minor part of the whole infertilty thing.[/QU

OTE]


You have explained well

Lets see

felciya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#54
Very Good Topic to discuss. One of my cousin had the same problem like Ishita. She took treatment for 6 months. Dr told her to wait for 1year. She was blessed with a healthy girl baby after 1 year. Ishu can go for second opinion. Health issues varies person to person. Now days medical science is doing wonders. She can try naturally first If she is not conceived She can go for treatments like IUI, IVF. Miracles do happen. But i dont want Ishu to concieve coz they are showing a barren woman can be a good mother than the real mother. they are giving a social message to the society.I heard my Papa's Boss didnt have child so they kept wifes sisters son with them after 3 or 4yrs with out any treatment naturally they got their own baby boy. They are having two Boys. So Miracles can happen.But this is Ektas show anything can happen in her shows. Later They might show her with her own baby for high voltage drama with lots of twists n turns.
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#55
Thanks everyone for your opinion

It was a good discussion
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: felciya

Very Good Topic to discuss. One of my cousin had the same problem like Ishita. She took treatment for 6 months. Dr told her to wait for 1year. She was blessed with a healthy girl baby after 1 year. Ishu can go for second opinion. Health issues varies person to person. Now days medical science is doing wonders. She can try naturally first If she is not conceived She can go for treatments like IUI, IVF. Miracles do happen. But i dont want Ishu to concieve coz they are showing a barren woman can be a good mother than the real mother. they are giving a social message to the society.I heard my Papa's Boss didnt have child so they kept wifes sisters son with them after 3 or 4yrs with out any treatment naturally they got their own baby boy. They are having two Boys. So Miracles can happen.But this is Ektas show anything can happen in her shows. Later They might show her with her own baby for high voltage drama with lots of twists n turns.




Very good post

Yea in such sensitive issues you need to have multiple opinions

And yes since they are showing Ruhi and ishita as base of story it looks improbable
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#57
You know what Vyas I somehow have always thought that the declaration of one doctor and Subu' consequent rejection of Ishita is the lamest thing I have seen on the show. Even the Iyers themselves believing it is so crazy since they are all educated and Ishita herself is a medical professional who knows how important is a second opinion. I wanna see why she never went for one or if she did were the results the same.
If they had stuck to the book Ishita would have been a divorcee who would have known she can't conceive AFTER attempts leading to a divorce,but I guess EK thought the show would do better if she made Ishita a single woman with a broken engagement so she can live up to the pristine standards and be a true blue virgin for her hubby so I wont be taken aback if and when this twist happens.

Also this being a Balaji show I am kinda counting on it already 😆 not to mention the fact that I think it would be shown this was all some grand evil scheme Subu' mom came up with to separate the duo perhaps fearing that the Iyers who have no sons with their daughters help are snatching away hers and she would lose all power in her household, not to mention the fact that Iyers are a very typical middle class family and the woman is greedy as hell, she might have wanted a lot of dowry from them and with the marriage of Bala- Vandu learned they have next to nothing on them and hence chose to make profit on her second son while she still could since her first one clearly made her suffer a loss. Such women have that mentality that we have raised our sons to be this successful doc or engineer now we must earn from his in-laws the returns of our investment since their daughter would reap the benefits of our son' education 😡 🤬
alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

You know what Vyas I somehow have always thought that the declaration of one doctor and Subu' consequent rejection of Ishita is the lamest thing I have seen on the show. Even the Iyers themselves believing it is so crazy since they are all educated and Ishita herself is a medical professional who knows how important is a second opinion. I wanna see why she never went for one or if she did were the results the same.

If they had stuck to the book Ishita would have been a divorcee who would have known she can't conceive AFTER attempts leading to a divorce,but I guess EK thought the show would do better if she made Ishita a single woman with a broken engagement so she can live up to the pristine standards and be a true blue virgin for her hubby so I wont be taken aback if and when this twist happens.

Also this being a Balaji show I am kinda counting on it already 😆 not to mention the fact that I think it would be shown this was all some grand evil scheme Subu' mom came up with to separate the duo perhaps fearing that the Iyers who have no sons with their daughters help are snatching away hers and she would lose all power in her household, not to mention the fact that Iyers are a very typical middle class family and the woman is greedy as hell, she might have wanted a lot of dowry from them and with the marriage of Bala- Vandu learned they have next to nothing on them and hence chose to make profit on her second son while she still could since her first one clearly made her suffer a loss. Such women have that mentality that we have raised our sons to be this successful doc or engineer now we must earn from his in-laws the returns of our investment since their daughter would reap the benefits of our son' education 😡 🤬



@bold... this is actually in one of Vidya's fan fics... where they lie to Ishita (its not her fault, there is some problem with Subbu)... Now that would be something Aani !!!
Edited by always_a_TV_fan - 11 years ago
BombayTroll thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">You know what Vyas I somehow have always thought that the declaration of one doctor and Subu' consequent rejection of Ishita is the lamest thing I have seen on the show. Even the Iyers themselves believing it is so crazy since they are all educated and Ishita herself is a medical professional who knows how important is a second opinion. I wanna see why she never went for one or if she did were the results the same.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">If they had stuck to the book Ishita would have been a divorcee who would have known she can't conceive AFTER attempts leading to a divorce,but I guess EK thought the show would do better if she made Ishita a single woman with a broken engagement so she can live up to the pristine standards and be a true blue virgin for her hubby so I wont be taken aback if and when this twist happens.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Also this being a Balaji show I am kinda counting on it already😆not to mention the fact that I think it would be shown this was all some grand evil scheme Subu' mom came up with toseparatethe duo perhaps fearing that the Iyers who have no sons with their daughters help are snatching away hers and she would lose all power in her household, not to mention the fact that Iyers are a very typical middle class family and the woman is greedy as hell, she might have wanted a lot of dowry from them and with the marriage of Bala- Vandu learned they have next to nothing on them and hence chose to make profit on her second son while she still could since her first one clearly made her suffer a loss. Such women have that mentality that we have raised our sons to be this successful doc or engineer now we must earn from his in-laws the returns of our investment since their daughter would reap the benefits of our son' education😡🤬</font>



Aani

I think it is bit vague whether ishita has taken 2nd opinion or not so we can't be sure

I also think that how without ever naturally trying they can come to conclusion that she is infertile but someone above described possible reasons for diagnosis too so can't say

I also agree think this infertile thing being whole Bala mom conspiracy can't be ruled out and you have also put out perfect reasons for it

And your Virgin logic is absolutely hilarious but true and poor ishita getting second hand jawaani
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: always_a_TV_fan


@bold... this is actually in one of Vidya's fan fics... where they lie to Ishita (its not her fault, there is some problem with Subbu)... Now that would be something Aani !!!


I dont know of this fic but wow sadly this cannot be shown in the show since he already has a son 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".