Sid? Karan? Karan or Sid?? so confusing!!!

Hey guys,

Even though today's episode rocked, I was so confused whether to believe it was Karan or Sid pretending to be Karan:

Things pointing him to be Karan:
- Honestly Sid could not have pulled off karan's personality with so much grace.
-Karan respectfully greeted everyone
-Sid would know his limit and not hug and mislead Abha as he knows how much she loves Karan
- He did not have the tattoo on his back when Karishma confronted him.
-He knew that Abha wanted a boy and that he wanted a girl.

Things pointing him to be Sid:
- His arm is injured as Dushyant pointed out
-He has Sid's phone with him
- He wouldn't let Abha in the bathroom with him.
- The phone call from the hospital about Karan's ashes.

The confusing points:
- Karan was so calm about knowing that Abha brought someone called Sid who looks like him home to save the mother.
- Karan didn't mention to Abha that he met Sid and Sid gave him his phone (like he told Karishma)
-What the hell is massi still doing here??? If it is Karan he should tell them all the truth and have her kicked out
- Why would the nurse call about Karan's ashes when yesterday they showed that he was saved and it was a miracle???

I am so confused! The CVs better have a good explanation for this! Otherwise they are making their lives more complicated for us and the betterment of the storyline.

I think the following happened before 'Karan's' entry to SB:

- Karan is alive; the doctors inform Sid who is going crazy outside about how to tell Abha that Karan is dead.
- Karan is able to talk to Sid and Sid tells him all that has happened since his accident. Karan tells Sid that if Abha tells everyone at home that she cant find Karan then Massi will use that and make her life miserable. He will tell Sid that he wont be able to go to Ujjain soon as he still needs to be in hospital for another week. But he asks Sid to do him one favour and that is to go and help Abha kick massi out.
- Sid will initially refuse but Karan will convince him and spend the whole day prepping Sid. Karan will tell him that the time he is ready to come back to Ujjain he will call Sid.
- Karan will tell Sid not to tell Abha anything as she has already been through so much and I don't want her running her to tend to me and then everyone will get frantic about the situation.
-Sid will tell him how can I pretend with Abha when she loves you so much; Karan will tell Sid that he trusts him and knows he won't take advantage of Abha's love for Karan. He will then tell Sid its only a matter of days.

have not seen the episode yet but I like your POV about what might have happened.

hmmmm......... I think massi has put the nurse up to the ashes bit!!!! Coz Doc said K was fine...

its so confusing...i guess i will stop watching for few months than watch again...because after the few months...it will be stuck on the same place.....

The show is so confusing......I mean if Karan is really alive than y did Sid tell Karishma tat Karan is dead???I mean it doesn't make sense.....

Originally posted by: saranya2791

The show is so confusing......I mean if Karan is really alive than y did Sid tell Karishma tat Karan is dead???I mean it doesn't make sense.....

Yea...i jus watched the 1st March episod....n i was thinking da same thing......lols....Sid actually is nt aware tat Karan is alive.....but da funny thing is tat Sid thinks tat Karan is dead.n he's nt bothered about Karan's body and all.....I mean he juz left da hospital juz like tat.........???Lols and yes i totally agree with u......da doctor will unite them!!!