Why i like/ don't like X- factor ! - Page 2

Originally posted by: Padma55

The emphesis on basic concept for show that of finding Extra factor in common population seems lost some where.

Still they have atleast 4 who can still keep X-Factor alive for next season. They are:

Seema

Sajda Sisters

Nirmithi

Deevana group

If not this show we would have never hear these guys and also the improvements the great mentors did on their lives.

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Seema
Sajda Sisters

My choice for TOP 3

OMG MM the song link you posted my fav too 😃 Thanks. Ab mazaa aayega jab Mukesh ji ka topic jab bhi niklega.

Mukeshji was my first love as far as any singer is concerned. After marriage Rafi saab was introduced to me in a different light by my hubster. I love Rafi saab. Such a versatile singer. No one can beat him in what he did. But Mukeshji has a this place in my heart for his soulful voice.😳

Originally posted by: TheUltimate

Good topic. I agree that the old songs have their own charm. I believe they can be sung over and over and over again and still do not get stale. Of course, one needs a basic understanding of music to appreciate the bygone era songs.

Thankfully, the judges and the producers are not listening to the requests of brain dead, musically challenged folks and not throwing away old songs.

I also agree that it provides a good platform to the talented bunch.

I do not agree much to the point that this show has become a typical musical reality show. The judges and the format of the show give contestants liberty to insert an X-factor of their own in an already good song. Can you imagine Anu Malik's reaction in Indian Idol if a contestant tried one of these tricks?

Originally posted by: Raha26

I started to watch this program, bcus Shreya Ghosal was there.. But now I watch this show for Sonu Nigam too :)

Well, I live in Denmark and we have X factor too.. But this one is different from other countries, as India telecasts the program both friday and Saturday. 😊
But this is nice too :-). We just have the elimination on every episode!
I'm just sad that the jugdes haven't pick the best singers to the live show! Kartar Uncle, Amit, Geet they are the weakest link, but still they're on the show! (That's mine opinion!)
And Shahiti was really good, but she is eliminated! 😭

Originally posted by: musicmuse

👏👏

The judges are excellent and masters in their field👏

I am sure their judgement is equally fine😊

What we see and hear on the show is just a miniscule part of the whole comment they make.

The editor very cleverly only retains small portions which can generate controversy.

There is enough controversy on the forum😆

well done editor bhai👏