Dialogue delivery of Icchaa:Mod's note PG3 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

3.3k

Users

16

Likes

98

Frequent Posters

ruchira23 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: shon703

@ rim10 - your lines

Also Tina being a Bengali and born and brought up in Kolkata, her pronunciation are sometimes incorrect. Inspite of this whatever she has acheived at such a young age is remarkable
actually this bit is corrcet she is benagli, bengalis have dififculty talking hindi in verey pressing manner and yes she i s19. but then even pooja agaur is also 19, but her hdialogue are faaaantastic and so again she is nroth indian gujarati- so no qualms abt it
yes ichca needs time sure

see bengali is not the reason for speaking defect, we are bengali bt we are born and brought up in delhi only so we don't have that defect,infact u can see anandi(pratyusha banerjee) she is not having such problem as she is from jamshedpur bt tina is from west bengal where u will see even sikhs are talking in bengali.....how could u expect her to speak in proper hindi, she cannot change that defect so easily
Edited by ruchira23 - 14 years ago
547039 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#12
arey yaar ok pratuyusha, joy mukherjee, sushmita ... al fin eok
we are just giving some reaons... why ihcha cant spk well okk...
and in nutshell dekhnewalon ko background leeke kay karna hain, fhokat ka TV on krkey sympthaisze on their background thodi hota hai
yes we must give her time etc etce fine... lkien at th eminute her dialogue delivery is horribl
souroj thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: shyams

I don't know why newbies r opening actor bashing topic 🤔 and if I may remind you Actor comparison strictly is against IF rules.
What in your perception is a good dialog delivery by Tapasya may not be good enough for others


I have also noticed this. Why this actor comparison all the time. To show someone the best u don't have to pull the other one down.
sonali_dg thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
In my Point of view... All characters in telly world are having shades of grey, few flaws.. since that is in a way connected to the real world..where we all are individualistic in our own ways.. what we need to assume is this is the way Iccha the character talks...Compare that to your own siblings, does everyone speak alike?
As far as Tina's pronunciation is concerned I think she needs to emphasize on that, simply being a Bengali born is not an excuse for mis-pronuncing your National Language. If a non-bengali mis-pronounces certain words of Bengali like Shahrukh in Devdas, undoubtedly they will be laughed at. And I personally believe every language needs to be spoken in its own accent and its own pronunciation else, the it looses its essence.
varun.tap thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: mikku87


Hi all


After seeing yesterday's episode I thought of comparing the
dialogue delivery of tapasya and icchhaa.


Icchaa's voice is really irritating and inspite getting a
strong punch dialogue she delivered it in a bad manner.i think tapasya's
dialogue delivery is far better than Ichaas…all my friends who are not regular
viewers of this serial also said the same after seeing yesterday's episode…actually
the director should take care of all these things..after all icchhaa is the
main protagonist and if her real voice does not suit the character they should
ask someone to dub for her..


Don't you feel it guys?



Director uses her only for ichch's face nothing else
she is protogonists of the serial its does't matter because tapasya is one and only who run the show by her performance and break through acting....hichcha's voice always very scratchy and unpleasent for ears.........
her voice always very irritating....
mai to yahan tak keh sakta hoon ki ye serial sab ke boycott hone ke baad bhi tapasya issko no.1 trp ke saath chala sakti hai.....
there is no comparision in between tapasya and ichcha in depatment of acting...........and on screen performance........
cjs369 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Ichcha was fantastic yesterday... all the screaming and shouting does not mean good dialogue delivery ... keeping in mind her docile mild character ...the supressed anger came out very well in her dialogue delivery ... many of my friends who dont watch this serial regularly also felt ichcha was too good yesterday...😳
sonia77 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#17
Her dialogue delivery is below average..unfortunately..😉..and i have been saying this for ages..even when i was watching the show regualrly...i fail to understand why they as in the creatives or the team has not helped her improve upon this!..when its really their job to do so..or find a solution in the least!...i just saw the repeat of last nights episode...if you compare her delivery in direct contrast to rashmis. in their face off in this particular episode.....its pretty obvious...😉...to anyone really...i have no intention to offend the actress..she's really quite sweet tina.....but i just happened to see this thread while browsing and couldnt help myself. as i have infact just seen the repeat episode on tv... in all fairness she being one of the leads in one of the top shows...its just not happening...😉
ankit111 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#18
I don't want to compare Ichchha with anyone as comparison is against IF rule, but Ichchha dialogue delivery was perfect for the situation and for her character 😆 😆 well done Tina. 👏
tiny15 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: ruchira23

oh c'mon it is not necessary that if she is portraying ichcha that means she should not have any pronunciation defect or should have a voice like sushmita sen to make it pleasing😲 many grownup ladies have a voice like a kid,but that does n't mean she should stop talking😡and for your kind information ichcha is an innocent girl as a ckt so if her voice is like a kid that's highly justified😊

i agree id u ruchi that she has voice like the ckt needs!! 👏👏👏and also that many grown up ladies've kiddish voice. even one of my classmate in univ.'d kiddish voice & she was even tall & healthy. wen 1st time she talked 2 us we were surprised that such gal cud've such voice but that was sweet voice & also she was a nice gal 2!!
and though i agree wid sonali that being bengali shudn't b an excuse not 2 able 2 speak hindi properly while working in hindi daily but i think its really difficult 4 any prsn whos mother tongue isn't hindi. nad moreover tina"ll defntly overcums this. but i wud like 2 say that in india hindi is not the only lang bcoz our constitution has acknowledged 22 languages & our constitution allows states 2 hav their regional language as official language of the state wid 2nd official lang is either english or any oder of their parliament's consent!!
@sonali i wud like 2 make a correction here hindi is not india's national lang. indian constitution'd accepted it as 1st official language of india & 2nd is english & all indian lanuages r sumtimes referred 2 as national languages!!😊😊
and sum ppl may find rash's dialogue delivery not gud as 4 me screaming & shouting r not the signs of gud acting rather overacting!!🤢🤢🤢
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 14 years ago
#20

**Mod's note**

Since the scene yesterday featured the confrontation of both Ichha-Tapasya in one frame where both actors were involved in the scene...so comparing their performances and discussing about it ,is absoultely fine as long as there is no actor bashing or name calling happening against the actors...Constructive criticism of an actor's acting is fine(which involves the voice modulation discussion) but no actor bashing will b tolerated...
Uttaran Dev team


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".