Do you think Edward Should of Forgave Bella?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Mrs.Pattinson/Robert/Cullen/Edward

@ROBlicious.

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: Ambrosia

My answer is no. I think Edward deserves someone much better; Edward needs someone who he can love completely and I don't think Bella proved she could...

Totaallly Agree. I mean Edward has been waiting for his soulmate for like 100 years and Bella doesn't fit in. I mean even on the wedding she let Jacob flirt with her. 😕

Quote

Mrs.Pattinson/Robert/Cullen/Edward

@ROBlicious.

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: disha_sen

i agree that jacob had flaws n he forced bella to kiss him bt in new moon it was bella's behaviour that made jake feel that she hated ed coz she didnt like anyone to mention his name. wen jake started avoiding her in new moon she cries and breaks down n pleads with him nt to "break up" wid him. what was that suppossed to mean?
Anyways its my POV and i guess each person has his or her own POV. I completely respect ur POV and i expect the same too😊

By "Breaking up" she was talking about their friendship. Jacob was clearly taking advantage of her inncocence while Edward wasn't there. Jacob thinks he KNOWS bella is better with him. Edward doesn't even think that, he wants her to be with someone she can be happy with.

Jacob just sorta emotinoly blackmailed her by saying i will kill my seelf. Edward still wasn't upset.

I think Edward is being hurt from every side, and Bella doesn't desvere someone as good as him.

I am sorry to everyone but Edward needs someone who can give up anything for him. He is in love with her and has to feel fire burning in his throat the entire time and she can't tell Jacob she wants Edward. Like what is that.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Dark Charm

@WildestDreams

Moderator

+ 69

Posted: 15 years ago

#13

Bella is in love with Jacob but for Edward she feel something more important...he is her destiny and can not live without Edward... but jacob is very important for her. The abandonment of Edward in New Moon has pushed Bella to create a link deep with Jacob, something that started as a strong friendship that has grown stronger with time and then turns into love.

Talking about the 1st kiss...when I read the part, I was angry(not so much as i was expecting that this will happen😆)...Jacob dissappointed me...I don't hate him but kissing someone other girlfriend😭.

Talking baout 2nd kiss:

One wasn't enough😡...Especially when Bella ask Jacob to kiss her, I was there to tear the pages bitten by rabies...I stop reading the book and start reading after 2 days.

Edward love her soo much and what she do...kiss Jacob.I feel so bad for Edward.

and I hope he say something to her but nothing.

Anyways thse are my opinions....no one feel bad😊

Quote

Mrs.Pattinson/Robert/Cullen/Edward

@ROBlicious.

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: -Parm-
Bella is in love with Jacob but for Edward she feel something more important...he is her destiny and can not live without Edward... but jacob is very important for her. The abandonment of Edward in New Moon has pushed Bella to create a link deep with Jacob, something that started as a strong friendship that has grown stronger with time and then turns into love.

Talking about the 1st kiss...when I read the part, I was angry(not so much as i was expecting that this will happen😆)...Jacob dissappointed me...I don't hate him but kissing someone other girlfriend😭.

Talking baout 2nd kiss:

One wasn't enough😡...Especially when Bella ask Jacob to kiss her, I was there to tear the pages bitten by rabies...I stop reading the book and start reading after 2 days.

Edward love her soo much and what she do...kiss Jacob.I feel so bad for Edward.

and I hope he say something to her but nothing.

Anyways thse are my opinions....no one feel bad😊

Beautiful! Seriously Awesome opinions, i couldn't of said it better my self.

Even Kristen in an interview said "She Loves Jacob but Edward is her soulmate and she cannot live a life without, if she is willing to become a vampire then its pretty clear how much she loves him."

Jacob kinda pressures her to fall for him, while Edward is slow and steady. 😳

Quote

shraddha

@guju_girl1

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#15

I totally agree with you!! In normal circumstances a boy would have never forgiven the girl! But this is Edward we are talking about here! He was probably taking the balme on himself somehow!! Thats just the way edward is! He never foragve himself for leavig her and was probably thinking "this is part of my punishment"

I felt SOOO bad for Edward on that part! I was pissed beyond word at Bella!!

Quote

Stark_Wolf

@Stark_Wolf

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

#16

Hi im new to this forum....love twilight and more than that Robert........

i hated bella for that...urghh how can she kiss jake like😡.......poor edward

its wierd know afterwards jake will be her son in law....

Quote

Zaria

@fly_chick

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: disha_sen
in no way can u blame jacob coz bella was wholly responsible for it. in edwards absence she seeked jacob and behaved n spoke in such a way that she made it seem that jake is more than her best friend. she used words liks "break up" n made jake feel that she completely hated edward n wanted to forget him. it was totally bellas fault. she took advantage of jake while edward was away.
i feel bad for ed but it was only bella at fault .

Totally agree with you Disha- I think bellas the one at fault here- i don't think she deserves either Jacob or Edward- she broke both guys hearts even though edward won't admit it. She gave Jake the impression she was slowly moving on which got his hopes up and then used to run off to see him- what's he supposed to think and edward was always guilty that it's his fault because he left her. She hurt them both so i really began disliking her charecter in eclipse.

Quote

Dark Charm

@WildestDreams

Moderator

+ 69

Posted: 15 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: xoHarshaxo

Beautiful! Seriously Awesome opinions, i couldn't of said it better my self.

Even Kristen in an interview said "She Loves Jacob but Edward is her soulmate and she cannot live a life without, if she is willing to become a vampire then its pretty clear how much she loves him."

Jacob kinda pressures her to fall for him, while Edward is slow and steady. 😳

Edward Cullen is the most romantic and his look is attractive, while Jacob Black has a nice physique and a big smile.

Jacob want everything happen quickly and Edward😍..no words😊

Quote

jiya sharma

@jiasharma

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

#19

I lyk bella in twilight n in new moon bt frm eclipse her cnfusion regardng edward n jacob force me to hate her...n edward is so unselfish.....luv him more 4 dis...wnt to hav smone lyk him in my lyf..lol...n for sure i dnt want to be cnfused as bella... 😊

Quote

iqbalkrocks

@iqbalkrocks

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

#20

Bella's confusion regarding Edward and Jacob is questionable, but then again Edward did leave her completely broken when he left in New moon. And Jake is the one who helped pull things through. But even then Bella always said that her heart was never fully healed until Edward came back.

So her confusion is kind of justified, in the sense that she feels guilty for choosing Edward when Jake is the one who was there for her in her deepest sorrows. But Edward is the one she cant live without, and Edward understands her dilemma.

All in all I dont think Bella is selfish at all, infact on the contrary she is very selfless and looks out for everyones needs. If Edward forgave her for kissing Jacob, then she has also forgiven him for leaving her so broken. They both have flaws, and just because Edward left her for her own good does not mean that the separation became any less painful for her.

I guess it just depends on the mind frame you are in while reading certain portions of the book. When reading new moon, you would be against edward for making the decision to leave, but while reading eclipse and breaking dawn, you would feel bad for Edward as Bella turns up making one mistake after the other.

PS: I am not criticizing Edward, infact I am huge supporter of Team Edward!

Edited by iqbalkrocks - 15 years ago