Discussion Of The Week..

mallika_14 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#1


Hey There,

As you all know Twilight Saga: New Moon's going to release in November...Loads of time left...Though we all can't wait for it to come out..We all are too excited..and its first trailer was irrestible..
So Why not to have an amazing discussion till then?😊

Through Discussions we will get to know eachother's opinions..I'm so ready for the discussion..Can't wait to read the answers...So pull on your socks..GET READY!..

Remember These discussions are just for fun and to know eachother's opinions..No Bashing Whatsoever.😳

So Lets See What you think about the twilight saga?🤔

Here i Start:

What was your first impression of Twilight? Did you think that it was a good introduction to the series? Why or why not?

Why is it that Bella's blood calls to Edward more than anyone else?

Why does Bella accept that fact that Edward is a vampire so quickly?

What are your opinions about Bella & Edwards's relationship, and why?

Although bella cares much more for edward, do you think she is really lying to herself cuz she loves jacob?

What do you think the apple symbolizes on the cover?

What was your first impression of Edward and the Cullens?

Did you find yourself able to relate to Bella in Twilight? If so, how?

Edward and Bella are, of course, terrific characters. But the secondary characters are also great. Who is your favorite?

Did this book change your view of vampires? If so, how? Is it a positive or negative change?

Do you think that Bella is a strong or a weak woman? Is she a good role model for young women? How does she fit with your view of feminism?

What about Edward as a role model for young men?

Did the end of Twilight make you want to read New Moon?

Is Rosalie's dislike of Bella justified? Why or why not?

Would it appeal to you to live forever? Why or why not?

The author makes clear that vampires have to be very attractive to their prey, but do you think Edward is too perfect? Why or why not?


Do Not Forget To Have Fun.







Edited by mallika_14 - 16 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1k

Users

5

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

nimmy1010 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
YIPEEEE....1ST TO COMMENT....!!!!!!🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳



What was your first impression of Twilight? Did you think that it was a good introduction to the series? Why or why not?
actually i saw da muvi 1st....and was quite hooked to it....n afta da 1st buk....need i say more???😃

Why is it that Bella's blood calls to Edward more than anyone else?
ummm....mayb coz shes a totally difrent person....edward has never known another person like her....n mallika...dis is a srsly tuf qs...😊

Why does Bella accept that fact that Edward is a vampire so quickly?
she obviusly noes der is sumthing difrent wid edward...n she cant agree on da fact dat he mayb human n hes defintly SUMTHING....so beautiful...ethreal...😳😳😳

What are your opinions about Bella & Edwards's relationship, and why?
i wud say each is unique in its own way....i mean edward thinks he does not deserve bella (midnight sun) n bella thinks she doesnt deserve him...da way dey cum to noe dat they luv each other eqaully & their level of love can only compete wid deir own is unique too...

Although bella cares much more for edward, do you think she is really lying to herself cuz she loves jacob?
i dont think so yaar....coz she cant LIVE WITHOUT EDWARD...n besides as a saying goes''u can luv many ppl....but u can only luv n cant live wothout 1 person''....n jacob was her only support wen edward left her...v cant blame her for feeling dat way...

What do you think the apple symbolizes on the cover?
an apple is da forbidden fruit & da sign of da original sin...n bella falls in luv with a vampire wen she wasnt supposed to...despite his warnings...n edward to fell for a human...so in a way dey both did sumthing forbidden....but thankfully ended up happily ever after unlike adam & eve....

What was your first impression of Edward and the Cullens?
'''GOSH!!! THEY R SOO BEAUTIFUL....WISH DEY WUD EXIST IN REAL LIFE....ATLEAST EDWARD😉😳'''''

Did you find yourself able to relate to Bella in Twilight? If so, how?
yup...i related to her...in more ways dan 1...coz da main point...she doesnt think shes gud enuf or even pretty even to deserve sum1 like edward...she has always considered herself average....i feel da same way bout myself...😊

Edward and Bella are, of course, terrific characters. But the secondary characters are also great. Who is your favorite?
i adore emmet....hes such a cutie character...always lafing off things n ready for a fite😃

Did this book change your view of vampires? If so, how? Is it a positive or negative change?
b4...as wid most of us...vampires were villans wid 2 fangs...hu changes into a bat n drinks blood....but after twilight i pray every nite dat da world has many vampires...n atleast 1 like edward hu is made for me....😆😆😆

Do you think that Bella is a strong or a weak woman? Is she a good role model for young women? How does she fit with your view of feminism?
ummm...shes a storng human...1st to hv da guts to keep da baby of da man she luvs...she doesnt like an audience to her pain...she doesnt like hurting da love of her life...n she puts other's happiness b4 hers...in most of da cases at least...n it is gud to b selfish sumtimes...😛

What about Edward as a role model for young men?
i cant think of a more perfect role model for young men dan edward...da way he treats his girl...takes care of her...puts her happiness forth b4 anything else...protects her frm evry danger...da courtesy...oh...i can fill a whole buk....😆😆😆

Did the end of Twilight make you want to read New Moon?
OF COURSE..!!!!! infact i was sooo eager dat insted of waiting for da hard copy, i downloaded da a copy of new moon & eclipse frm da net n read dem frm da laptop...wich i usually hate to do....😃😆😆

Is Rosalie's dislike of Bella justified? Why or why not?
i guess yes...coz she wantd da human life bella was throwing away...but bella was justified in her actions...n so was rosalie...dey had deir own reasons to think wat dey wantd frm life...bella proced edward above evrything else....whereas, rosalie wantd a family of her own....i guess dats reason enuf...😊

Would it appeal to you to live forever? Why or why not?
yes....and no...if i get a i loving n caring companoion as edward n also if v dont age...i can live forever....but den if v r alone...n aging...der is no point in being a burden for sum1 else...is der?? so its a chioce dat a higher power up der has alredy made for us...being mortals...😊

The author makes clear that vampires have to be very attractive to their prey, but do you think Edward is too perfect? Why or why not?
edward isnt too perfect...like he mentioned in new moon, he wasnt gud at tracking....he appealed to bella da way she appealed to him....n if u read da novels carefully, carlisle is even more perfect...edward has killd humans n drunk deir blood...dat doesnt make him perfect rite?....he himself says hes too selfish coz he wants bella...but its not a problem fo her...hence its fine...she needs him just as much as he needs her .....😳

dis is my longest ever post i guess....gr8 DOTW mallika👏
Edited by nimy.10 - 16 years ago
mallika_14 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
^Haha..too many questions?..
Thanks!

What was your first impression of Twilight? Did you think that it was a good introduction to the series? Why or why not?

Yes Definately,..Twilight is the first book ive ever read,otherwise im not a book reader whatever you call it.
I got to knoe about twilight from one of my friends...she used to praise twilight alot..so i decided to read the summary on the net first...and when i read summary..it was irrestible..so i told my mom to get that book for me...and i coudn't stop reading..its very very addictive.Stephanie has done a great job.👍🏼

Why is it that Bella's blood calls to Edward more than anyone else?

What i think..because she was a different person...He had not seen any girl like bella in his years...her scent was intoxicating...Yeah Nimy...This ques. is kinda tough.🤔

Why does Bella accept that fact that Edward is a vampire so quickly?

Because she had never seen a guy so beautiful..with flawless features..in her whole life...and his scent used to spin her head😆
😆😆..and his eyes used to change color..so she got suspicious...

What are your opinions about Bella & Edwards's relationship, and why?

Very very different..Extraordinary Love story they have..
so pure...who woudn't want a man like edward who knew his responsibilities?...
He's the most unselfish creature..Who woudn't?🤔..
I wish i had a man who resembled edward in every way!☺️
And Bella..a down to earth woman...always used to think that edward is not ment for her...They both dint know how special they were for eachother.😆😆

Although bella cares much more for edward, do you think she is really lying to herself cuz she loves jacob?

Noways!..she always loved edward more....who would reject a man with such gorgeous features?😕
Jacob..a werewolf..Hmph!
Vampires are sexy..they sparkle in the sun...and do werewolfs sparkle?..No..they Stink.😳

What do you think the apple symbolizes on the cover?

the forbidden fruit..Err!😕

What was your first impression of Edward and the Cullens?

Haha..What a wonderful Question!
I had never seen such god like figures ..with such flawless and terrific features.First Impression was amazing.I Loved each and every cullen in my first go!....I wish i was one of them....
I would love to marry a Vampire..but he has to be a vegetarian!😆😆
My Fav. Cullens are Edward and Alice..2 Fantastic Vampy's!...

Did you find yourself able to relate to Bella in Twilight? If so, how?

Well,Yeah...I'm kind of like her...i'm too clumsy..always dropping things..tripping over something..
And yeah the main thing I'm shy too...I don't get along too easily.

Edward and Bella are, of course, terrific characters. But the secondary characters are also great. Who is your favorite?

Aliceee!
OMG!...i adore her..she's a fun-loving girl with a great sense of humour.I would love to go for shopping with her.😆😆..Then she'll buy me expensive clothes..(Kidding!)..she is too cool to hang out with.
Did this book change your view of vampires? If so, how? Is it a positive or negative change?

Yes,Definately...I used to think that vampires are bad..they just hurt peoplee..they are no good .
But after reading/watching twilight...it has definately changed my view...Good vampires DO EXIST...with flawless features(Sorry,I missed the main thing)😆😆😆

Do you think that Bella is a strong or a weak woman? Is she a good role model for young women? How does she fit with your view of feminism?

She is neither Weak nor Strong..She fell in love with a vampire?..Who would do that...she had guts to do that..if i would have been in her place...I might not have accepted...Who woudn't get scared?
I mean yeah it was edward with flawless features..But still there's a fear inside...So she seemed strong in that case..
But she coudn't defend herself..that was one weak point...One should know how to defend...So she' was a mid woman.😆😆
What about Edward as a role model for young men?

PERFECT is the right word.
He was perfect in everything...What Else a woman wants in a man?😕

Did the end of Twilight make you want to read New Moon?

Yes!
The ending was Fantastic...The whole saga is too addictive!
You wont Belive?I read the whole saga in 2 months.!
Though i know many of you had completed in 1 Month.

Is Rosalie's dislike of Bella justified? Why or why not?

Yes.
Rosalie was one vampire who craved for her human life.
And Bella wanted to Give Up her human life.So this disgusted her..

Would it appeal to you to live forever? Why or why not?

With Edwardd Only..Otherwise No!😆😆..
I need Gorgeous Vampy's to survive.

The author makes clear that vampires have to be very attractive to their prey, but do you think Edward is too perfect? Why or why not?

😲😲😲
He was Perfect...
Tell me his flaws Somebody!(Mona would you like to help me with this?)😆😆
😲😲


Edited by mallika_14 - 16 years ago
nimmy1010 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
hey maliika....i hv pointed out a few flaws in edward myself....though my heart breaks while admitting it....

but hu da hell cares....im prepared to overluk any kinda flaw if i get a man like edward in my life
nimmy1010 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
flaws like he did hunt humans b4....for a while....den he wasnt gud at tracking victoria....he considers himself as selfish for wanting bella wich im not counting coz its a GUD flaw.... :D
MasterKatara18 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

What was your first impression of Twilight? Did you think that it was a good introduction to the series? Why or why not?
Well when I first found out about Twilight, I wanted to know what was the hype all about, it was late July I guess 🥱 I googled about the book on the net and like everyone else I was went nuts for it all of a sudden. When I read the summary, I was already dying to get the book in my hands. I have always loved Vampires 😆 In movies or books, I always liked Vampires. Reading abt Twilight in which a human falls in love with a Vampire was nothing new to me as I had watched a few movies which had the same plot. But when I read about Edward Cullen being a ''vegetarian", I was shocked 😲 I wanted to know why and in what way a VAMPIRE is a Vegetarian 😕😆 So I grabbed the book the very next day and started reading it from afternoon till late night. I think I didn't even sleep the whole night despite having school the very next morning 😆 But OMG! I didn't even stop reading coz it was so addictive.

Why is it that Bella's blood calls to Edward more than anyone else?

I have read Midnight Sun and everytime Edward thinks is Bella even human? I think the same. Girls like her are very rare who are so self-less. And Edward has already explained it, It's his personal brand of heroin 😛 He has his own taste 😳😆

Why does Bella accept that fact that Edward is a vampire so quickly?

Bella did realize it, somewhat I should say, after he saved her from the van. If Im not wrong, Bella also mentioned Edward is more than just a human. And the little little things that disturbed her like he always stayed out of the sunlight, he skipped bio class, never eating. This stuff turned her doubts in reality.

What are your opinions about Bella & Edwards's relationship, and why?

One of the purest relationship I've read 😳 Edward has never come across a girl like Bella. Bella never could have imagined to get such a beautiful creature from the face of the entire world to be hers, ever, yet she does get him 😆

Although bella cares much more for edward, do you think she is really lying to herself cuz she loves jacob?

I don't think so! She can't live without Edward. In New Moon she went to a complete Zombie mode. Imagine if Edward leaves her again, she will NEVER be that happy even if she stays with Jacob. And to me, Bella + Jacob = 👎🏼


What do you think the apple symbolizes on the cover?

The forbidden fruit. It wasn't mentioned anywhere in the book but after watching the movie, I understood it. Those pale white hands are Edward's and the apple he's holding are just like what we see in the movie. Apple's the sweetest fruit and Edward's offering Bella the apple. If she forbidds it, she can be saved from numerous things as the fact is that he is a Vampire. A danger to her while she's a human. If she accepts it, her life is then in a way doomed. Hence, being the forbidden fruit.

What was your first impression of Edward and the Cullens?

BEAUITFUL! A family like his who are vegetarians are so rare 😆 And they are all so gorgeous looking. They have amazing talents and can you imagine a VAMPIRE being a doctor? 😕 I find Carlisle to be a very sweet father figure and the same goes for Esme, a perfect mother figure 😳

Did you find yourself able to relate to Bella in Twilight? If so, how?

Oh yes 😆 Bella from Twilight has given many girls a hope to find a beautiful Vampire 😳 🤣 Just kidding, tho I wish it was real 😳
Bella is extremely clumsy and trust me, im no less 😆 She falls 3 times in a day, I fall 6 times then 😳 She has a very quiet and shy nature, thinks low of herself and doesnt get along well with others. She finds herself average and non-attractive. I have to say in short, she is a girl with low-self esteem. And that's exactly how I feel about myself =|

Did this book change your view of vampires? If so, how? Is it a positive or negative change?

From young, I have always imagined Vampires with fangs, burning to cinder in the sunlight, and being extremely mean and ruthless. But Twilight isn't like the sterotypical stories you read about Vampires every now and then. It's good to read something out of the box and Twilight has given us that change 😛

Edward and Bella are, of course, terrific characters. But the secondary characters are also great. Who is your favorite?

Alice! Do I need to mention why? She's so adorable. Everyone wishes to have a sister or a best friend like her! And she is an expert when it comes to shopping 😛 The best thing is, with her around, nothing can go wrong as she can see the future 😉😆

Do you think that Bella is a strong or a weak woman? Is she a good role model for young women? How does she fit with your view of feminism?

She is neither weak nor strong. She did something most woman won't. She fell for a Vampire. She faced so many obstacles. The biggest thing she did was to give birth to a baby who was cross breed. Imagine the pain while reading it 😳 She is a strong woman to me.

What about Edward as a role model for young men?

Edward's a perfect role model for men. Men are nothing compared to him 🤣

Did the end of Twilight make you want to read New Moon?

OH YES! You have no idea how hard was it for me to find the book first of all 😳 And I had to wait for 2 months after reading Twilight to read New Moon coz of my damn O Levels last year.

Is Rosalie's dislike of Bella justified? Why or why not?

She has a right to dislike Bella. Rosalie said it right in NM when she said she didn't ask to be like this. She would even trade her beauty for a normal human's life. While Bella wanted to throw away her human life and this disgusted Rosalie. So both are justified.

Would it appeal to you to live forever? Why or why not?

If I was given the chance to live forever, I would. But I would need a companion like Edward 😳 And of course, I would wanna stop aging! Im already close to 18 in a few months and Edward's yet 17! 😔 I don't wanna grow old!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 😭😆

The author makes clear that vampires have to be very attractive to their prey, but do you think Edward is too perfect? Why or why not?

ROFL! What should I answer here? Vampires have been always seductive to the human eye and I think there's nothing new about it 🤔 As for Edward, his flaws are hard for me to name but there are a few flaws in him. I have to be honest here so im saying that 😆 But yet, he is almost perfect for me 😳


Great DOTW Mallika 👏 I enjoyed every question 😳
missindia26 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
What was your first impression of Twilight? Did you think that it was a good introduction to the series? Why or why not?
Well I really wanted to read it cos all my friends were raving about how addictive it was and it didn't disappoint! It was totally un-put-down-able and was a brilliant first book, I definitely wanted to read on. It was definitely something different.

Why is it that Bella's blood calls to Edward more than anyone else?

I think its a combination of her sweet scent and her unique personality, she's so selfless etc and so intoxicating and intriguing to him

Why does Bella accept that fact that Edward is a vampire so quickly?

Well there are many hints, like how he saved her etc, he already looks too perfect to be human, coupled with his sometimes erratic behaviour so it wasnt a big step to take to believe him

What are your opinions about Bella & Edwards's relationship, and why?

Very beautiful, they complement each other. I like to hope there's such undying love stories in reality. 😍


Although bella cares much more for edward, do you think she is really lying to herself cuz she loves jacob?

I think the only reason she got so close to Jacob is beacause of the abscence of Edward, she loves Jacob as a friend and feels guilty for breaking his heart but would always choose Edward over Jacob 😃


What do you think the apple symbolizes on the cover?

Forbidden fruit, as Edward "shouldn't" be with Bella. It also made me think of bite as I connect apple with bite, and bite with vampire.

What was your first impression of the Cullens?

Loving! They have such a wonderful relationship between them. And of course beautiful too! 🤗

Did you find yourself able to relate to Bella in Twilight? If so, how?

Yes, in some ways. She's clumsy, with low self-esteem, reads a lot, shy sometimes, and like Bella, I wouldn't believe someone like Edward would fall in love with me. That said, the fact that Edward and Bella do fall in love kind of gives the rest of us some hope. 😛

Did this book change your view of vampires? If so, how? Is it a positive or negative change?

Definitely a change in a positive way. I used to think of vampires as the typical rather gruesome-looking male who lives in Transylvania. Now, whenever I think vampire, I think oooooh 😛

Edward and Bella are, of course, terrific characters. But the secondary characters are also great. Who is your favorite?

This is too hard a question. Esmes bcos she's so lovely, Alice cos she's so cute, Emmett cos he's so funny. The one character I liked better in the film was Chralie dunno why but really loved him in the film.

Do you think that Bella is a strong or a weak woman? Is she a good role model for young women? How does she fit with your view of feminism?

I reckon she was strong. She stuck by her choices and went through so much pain, especially in Breaking Dawn, giving birth and transformation must have been horrific. Her choices weren't always maybe right, so maybe she isn't the best role model but definitely a good woman. There was a discussion about her being anti-feminist, I definitely don't agree with that.

What about Edward as a role model for young men?

Perfect!! He's noble, brave, caring as a son, husband and father, corteous, always worries baout Bella etc so he has great qualities. I know so many girls who are trying to mould their boyfriends into Edward. 😆

Did the end of Twilight make you want to read New Moon?

Yes! I had to wait a week for my friend to lend it to me, that was torturous.

Is Rosalie's dislike of Bella justified? Why or why not?

She has a right to dislike Bella, because she believes she's making the wrong decision. It's frustrating to see Bella make the mistake (in her opinion) of dooming herself. Then again, Bella was right in her reasons.

Would it appeal to you to live forever? Why or why not?

If I had someone like Edward who I was totally in love with and him with me. Maybe when I was 18...so 2 years time...but yeah if I had love otherwise what would be the point

The author makes clear that vampires have to be very attractive to their prey, but do you think Edward is too perfect? Why or why not?

I don't think Edward's perfect and I like that about him. Of course, he's pretty close, with his truly-to-die-for looks, his love for Bella, his noble qualities etc. But I think he has falws too, like he can be a bit possessive, though I love that, and his willpower is not as strong as Carlisle's. Also, he is not truly selfless. But for me, he's absolutely fine! 😍
Fun discussion =D
mallika_14 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
What do you think the apple symbolizes on the cover?

The forbidden fruit. It wasn't mentioned anywhere in the book but after watching the movie, I understood it. Those pale white hands are Edward's and the apple he's holding are just like what we see in the movie. Apple's the sweetest fruit and Edward's offering Bella the apple. If she forbidds it, she can be saved from numerous things as the fact is that he is a Vampire. A danger to her while she's a human. If she accepts it, her life is then in a way doomed. Hence, being the forbidden fruit.

Thankss monaa..
i was confused..
you cleared out my confusion:P
mallika_14 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: nimy.10

flaws like he did hunt humans b4....for a while....den he wasnt gud at tracking victoria....he considers himself as selfish for wanting bella wich im not counting coz its a GUD flaw.... :D



Yeah he used to hunt just coz Human Blood made him stronger..but then he realised and stopped..so thats fine.
yea he coudnt track victoria...i agree...
But whatever i just dream to be with edward cullen..i wish he existed😆
i can ignore his flaws..i dont mind..!😊
nimmy1010 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
hey mallika...da apple thingy is sorta obvius...and i dont agree with mona18 on certain aspects...like da fact dat she cud hv been saved...coz der was no qs of being ''saved'' wen bella herself chose she wantd edward n wantd to bcum immortal...but yes agree wid da muvi bit...at da cafeteria wen edward holds da apple....😳😳😳 he luks soooo cute...😆..but apart frm dat dey do sort of convey da msg of da buk cover too....😊

and if u go thru stepehnie's official website, she has ansered dat very qs in da FAQs...below is her anser...

q.What's with the apple?

(STEPHENIE'S anser) The apple on the cover of Twilight represents "forbidden fruit." I used the scripture from Genesis (located just after the table of contents) because I loved the phrase "the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil." Isn't this exactly what Bella ends up with? A working knowledge of what good is, and what evil is. The nice thing about the apple is it has so many symbolic roots. You've got the apple in Snow White, one bite and you're frozen forever in a state of not-quite-death... Then you have Paris and the golden apple in Greek mythology'look how much trouble that started. Apples are quite the versatile fruit. In the end, I love the beautiful simplicity of the picture. To me it says: choice.
Edited by nimy.10 - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".