Analyses of AMIT by a Sangeet Visharat

amit has

• grt sense of sur n taaal
• voice clarity
• understands the meaning of the song ...puts the rite feel into the song – by stressing on the rite word in the rite place n rite way, rite amount of feel n stress
  
• He can create the mood of the song,
• even the half notes (komal sur - keys between saa – re, re – gaa, gaa- ma, called komal re, komal ga etc… they r impt 4 variations, alaap, flow of the song) r perfect n very clear (wot adnaan sami commented on…jo choti 2 harkatein hote hain wo clr hain)
• perfect pitch… high n low notes theek jageh par chorta hai (does not leave the ending notes incomplete)
• rounds off the last lyn or word (gives flow to song)

Song analyses:

Bulla ki

• arijit of fame gurukul who was trained cud not sing this song n changed it
• there is a different tune n different scale in every line (diff to manage 4 even the best of singers)
  
• the voice change in between was amazing
• spiritual feel…u get goose pimples when a singer hits perfect note
  
• esp the lower part.. " naa main moosa na main paaroha" very diff to sing

Humma2

• "kho hi gaye hum to " – changed scale in middle of song beautifully…very difficult to do in the middle of a song..
  prashant was criticized 4 this by sonu nigam (went off key while changing scale midway thru a song)

Tanhayee

• missed the initial beat n took tym to pick up the song again coz – (this is impt.. he missed a beat but had 2 wait the whole lyn to get over before he cud start)
• ek gud singer agar beat miss kar de to uski majboori ho jaati hai ki wo sahi jagah ke liye wait kare… wo gaane ko kahin se bhi nahi uthaega kyun ki if u r a gud singer n a perfectionist u cannot do makeshift kaam..ek beat nahi sun paaya to puri line khatam hone ke baad hi catch karega… else the whole song will go wrong…taal galat pick ho jayega
• but wot ever he sang puri imandaari se sur aur taal ke saath gaaya… feelings bhi puri thi… u cud feel the pain in his voice

Wow.. great analyse.. I am not a Visharath..Not too gyani guni in music..

.But I do have Visharaths in my family so can understand where s/he is comming from.

This is a great analyses.. It makes a lot of things clearer now.

komal sur - keys between saa – re, re – gaa, gaa- ma, called komal re, komal ga etc…

this reminds me of my music lessons LOL!! those were the days.. Just did for six months,,,how i hated them 😆 😆

Please say thanks for this analyses..

addyydda, I contacted my relative (A sangeet Visharath too) and she concurs with the above analyses.

About Bulla Ke Jaan..I made her listen to Aneek, Rabbi and AMIT's version...
She further added that Aneek's version was more Classical based (he made it different). Said Rabbi Shergill's version is not pure Sufiana...is bit fusion.. Amit was a bit different but more closer to Rabbi and she said that because of his Voice Quality..AMIT's verson sounded like sung in "Khuli Awaaz".

She says AMIT is a GOOD singer with good potential. Has good sense of sur and taal.. She said that in music pupils are also trained to pick up, if taal is cut... How to start in between taals quickly.. (dunno i I can explain well though...what she said..it was too technical for me!! 😆 )

When I told her he is not trained, she was surprised.. She said not just Komal, AMIT is good at Tivr sur too. And understands Sam.. (whatever that means..its greek to me now Ha Ha)

However, She adviced AMIT to go for more Classical training coz she said that Training and Riyaz makes Voices more flexible and Pukka. there is rules and grammar.

thats gud to hear... hes naturally gifted... gaane ke liye janam liya hai 😃 ...
imagine wot he will b lyk with a little training...

thanx... doesnt it feel gud 2 know that ppl who have studied misic also agree with us that amit is a gud singer with potential 2 b better... he wiil do well in life...
so amit fanz r support of amit is justified ...
vote him 2 the II title

WoW!!!!!1

Great going

👏
vote 4 talent vote 4 Amit

vote 4 talent vote 4 Amit

vote 4 talent vote 4 Amit

@addyydda,

yes I agree.. I always admired his voice, but at the back of mind I thought am I making a mistake by choosing him.. But when 2 people who studied music concurs that he does has potential..and at this point the better one. I felt good. 👏

hey why dont u guys get a sangeet vishaarat to analyze prashants songs... n then put it up in the forum... 😃

even ppl wit know how in the muzik industry have faith in amits potential n talent....adnan sami, AM, JA, sonu nigam, sajid wajid to name a few... so v can b sure that v r backin the rite guy...

amit4indianidol