Did Hrithik Roshan deserve the Filmfare awards for "Best actor"?

He won it for Kaho Naa Pyar Hai over Paresh Rawal in Hera Pheri.

He won it for Koi... Mil Gaya over Sanjay Dutt in Munna Bhai MBBS.

He won it for Dhoom 2 over Aamir in Rang De Basanti.

And he won it for Jodhaa Akbar over Naseeruddin Shah in A Wednesday.

Was he deserving for any of the Filmfare awards he got?

Originally posted by: Looney86

He won it for Kaho Naa Pyar Hai over Paresh Rawal in Hera Pheri.

He won it for Koi... Mil Gaya over Sanjay Dutt in Munna Bhai MBBS.

He won it for Dhoom 2 over Aamir in Rang De Basanti.

And he won it for Jodhaa Akbar over Naseruddin Shah in A Wednesday.

Was he deserving for any of the Filmfare awards he got?

In 2003 Salman for Tere Naam was deserving.

Originally posted by: Looney86

He won it for Kaho Naa Pyar Hai over Paresh Rawal in Hera Pheri. NO, but also Paresh imo, should have been in different category.

He won it for Koi... Mil Gaya over Sanjay Dutt in Munna Bhai MBBS. YES

He won it for Dhoom 2 over Aamir in Rang De Basanti. YES!!

And he won it for Jodhaa Akbar over Naseeruddin Shah in A Wednesday. MAYBE

Was he deserving for any of the Filmfare awards he got?

Was deserving for Jodhaa Akbar. Rest no.

He wasn't extraordinary in Kaho Naa Pyaar Hai tbh but for a debutant to draw a distinct line between Rohit and Raj, I think he deserved credit, plus amongst all the other nominees, I feel he was the best. Paresh Rawal wasn't nominated and Hrithik was nominated for Fiza also that year if my memory serves me right.

Koi Mil Gaya he fully deserves it imo. He was fabulous as Rohit ❤

Dhoom 2 also he did I feel. We tend to underrate action movie stars just because we assume all they do is stunts but he put in a lot of effort for Aryan who isn't a character similar to how he was in real life. Personally I think the charisma and charm that he brought to that character overpowered the rest. But again, I might be a little biased for this one. Wouldn't have really minded if Aamir won for RBD I guess.

For Jodhaa Akbar also I feel he fully deserved it, that was literally one of the best performances of his career, he looked and had the command of a king, although Aamir in Ghajini would be a close second, if not equal to Hrithik.

He deserved the award for Guzaarish as well imo.

Well for real lets look at the other nominees for the years and measure the merit

2000

Hrithik for KNPH won over Hrithik for Fiza, Sanjay Dutt for Mission Kashir, Anil Kapoor for Pukar & SRK for Mohabbatein

2003

Hrithik for KMG won over SRK for KHNH, Big B for Baghban, Ajay Devgn for Gangajal, & Salman for Tere Naam

2006

Hrithik for D2 won over Hrithik for Krrish, SRK for Don, SRK for Kank, Sanjay Dutt for Munnabhai 2 & Aamir for RDB

2008

Hrithik for JA won over Aamir in Ghajini, SRK in RNBDJ, Akshay Kumar in Singh is kingg, Naseerudin Shah in A Wednesday & Abhishek Bachchan in Dostana

He won it for Kaho Naa Pyar Hai over Paresh Rawal in Hera Pheri - if you think in present time then maybe not but back in 2000s he showed what a complete actor means (act, emote, dance, action etc.) and to be honest he did deserve

He won it for Koi... Mil Gaya over Sanjay Dutt in Munna Bhai MBBS. - definitely yes

He won it for Dhoom 2 over Aamir in Rang De Basanti - definitely yes

And he won it for Jodhaa Akbar over Naseeruddin Shah in A Wednesday - it's a tough call but yes HR was more dynamic than Naseerudin Shah

He missed out in Guzaarish and Lakshya and I think he deserved there too. Hopefully, he gets one for super 30

It’s a filmfare award...that is whoever pays the most fare for it...everyone knows this...you can buy them

Originally posted by: d2rocks

He missed out in Guzaarish and Lakshya and I think he deserved there too. Hopefully, he gets one for super 30

What if its ignored cause of who directed it ??

Originally posted by: DragonBoy49

Well for real lets look at the other nominees for the years and measure the merit

2000

Hrithik for KNPH won over Hrithik for Fiza, Sanjay Dutt for Mission Kashir, Anil Kapoor for Pukar & SRK for Mohabbatein

2003

Hrithik for KMG won over SRK for KHNH, Big B for Baghban, Ajay Devgn for Gangajal, & Salman for Tere Naam

2006

Hrithik for D2 won over Hrithik for Krrish, SRK for Don, SRK for Kank, Sanjay Dutt for Munnabhai 2 & Aamir for RDB

2008

Hrithik for JA won over Aamir in Ghajini, SRK in RNBDJ, Akshay Kumar in Singh is kingg, Naseerudin Shah in A Wednesday & Abhishek Bachchan in Dostana

so many bad performances nominated, mostly of so called king LOL