Malini Kapoor's role to end in Balika Vadhu - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

107

Views

8815

Users

22

Likes

286

Frequent Posters

aparnauma thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
Anandi is not asking for support. 
It is coming her way πŸ˜›

They are coming to help her because they want to show how much they care for her.πŸ˜›

While Jagya and Dadisa know how to keep a distance Anant doesn't seem to know where he needs that.

No person with any sense will outright reject help that is coming because of the goodwill that people have for her/him unless it becomes too intrusive.

There is a lot of difference between going around looking for help and taking the help that is coming in their way.

Being dependent on someone and accepting the help that came their way are two different things.


If the writer wants to tell a story of two people who were brought to gether in a child marriage ended up having a bad marriage which didn't survive but remained friends for life and will go to any extent to help each other who is any one to stop him?
It is his story and the constitution of our country gives him the freedom to tell the story that he wants.If he wants to show how a man who made a lousy husband to his protagonist but the best ever friend whom she can trust her life with why does it become a problem? Anandi was willing to put her life at risk to get Jagya's wife out of the clutches of Akheraj and people still are stuck on exes πŸ₯±

Why is Akheraj after Jagya?It is definitely not because of Anandi but because he crushed Akheraj's political career and sent him to jail. If Anandi didn'tcare about his wife or his feelings for his wife why would she put herself up in exchange for Ganga?She could have sat back and watched Tamasha while Jagya tried out all kinds of ideas including Mangala's idea.

She held herself and her daughter responsible for Ganga's kidnap when she knew that Akheraj had an axe to grind with Jagya also.Inspite of that people say she doesn't care about Ganga?



surabhi01 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
When jagya get married to gauri anandi live at least 2 year without support of any outsider man .it is anandi who dont want to have second marriage and till 11 year there is no outsider man in anandi life so how reach conclusion anandi need support of man .anant by chance and himself come into anandi life anandi did not search man for support by herself
surabhi01 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
Who does not have support who is totally self made
surabhi01 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 0 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 8 years ago
And there is no need for pushpa die for anandi anant marriage if cvs wanted to show an an marriage then cvs can show an an marriage without pushpa death too because pushpa anant is already divorce if cvs wanted to an an marriage why they did not show after divorce when even after divorce an an did not get married so how reach conclusion when pushpa will die afterward an an marriage will happenEdited by surabhi01 - 8 years ago
aparnauma thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Missesha

@ bold - Yes. There is no fun in watching Anandi's  half baked attempts of stopping child marriages, running an NGO type school without head or tail, searching for a long lost child by making lose attempts, pretending to leave her ex-husband's house by giving long lectures but come back at a drop of hat and become a lynch  there and so much more


There is nothing that Anandi does right with a clear - cut thought process, execution and strategy. She only makes half-baked attempts about everything and then leaves it all hanging. Work wise she is all over the place and very poor manager of her work, habits and life.

The reason sometimes I don't comment over lamely executed tracks is because there is no point in digging the same loose issues over and over again. If peoples' silence is assumed as non-appreciation of Anandi's work, than that is true. There is nothing good in the GOOD that Anandi pretends to do.  So yes, unfortunately there is nothing left to appreciate Anandi anymore. 

---------------------

Her character post leap is indeed non-value adding, otherwise makers won't be working on Nimboli (the next lead) to run the show. Even makers know that they have milked enough out of their character Anandi. 

Anandi is now like the "Dogs" of BCG Matrix. (i.e. Low Market Growth Rate and Low Market Share) 

Below is the quote from Boston Consulting Group Matrix, whose theory on 'Dogs' exactly explains the viabiity of Anandi's character (product of BV) in the show 

All products eventually become either cash cows or pets [dogs]. Dogs are generally considered cash traps because businesses have money tied up in them, even though they are bringing back basically nothing in return. These business units are prime candidates for divestiture. 

Is Nimboli being promoted as an independent lead?If they are so confident about Nimboli as an independent lead they wouldn't be hanging on to Anandi.πŸ˜›
They know very well that people connect with that character only as estranged child of Anandi and not as an independent lead 
They made sure even if Anandi and Nandini didn't know the connection between them CVs ensured that viewers are not left in any doubt. 
People watched Jhalra story because it is Anandi's daughter's story and not some random kid's story.
Jhalra wasis hold people interest only as long as the story revolves around the child.

It is obvious that they wanted to tell the story of Jhalra wasis but knew very well that it may not grab eye balls so they sold the story under brand Anandi.
Even if cash cows end up as pets like it is being said  they still can't let go of them that easily in this particular case this pet dog is what the viewers connext with and this particular pet dog is the bridge they are using to sell Jhalra story Mangala and Harki story.πŸ˜›



aparnauma thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: Missesha

Wonder what are the basis of your statistics? Do you have any proven records from reliable sources, which can prove that Anandi is still admired and looked upon?. Or is that all just your assumption?


I have read various internet based posts outside of this forum for last 3 months on regular intervals only to see what people think of Anandi outside of IF. And all the posts have one essence only: Let the crap end. Let Anandi do something worthwhile. 

People do not seems to sympathise with Anandi anymore, because not a single post that I read has justified Anandi's actions or shown sympathy for her. (Even Managala's evilness doesn't seem to  make people's heart melt for Anandi)

Agressive justifications are only happening on this forum. And if those handful of justifications makes you think Anandi admirers are in majority, then I am afraid you are mistaken. 

On the contrary, the channel now feels the need for clubbing BV with other shows much frequently than ever before. Is it because they want to attract  regular viewers of other shows to re-start watching BV?

What is the percentage of people who have access to Internet in our country? 
Among the people who have Internet access what percentage of people come and post their views on the show? 
What is the percentage of people who have TVs in their home? 
If online viewers and their opinions make so much difference why is that this shows and characters which are so popular with the online viewers and forums such as IF close down because of low TRPs?

There is an article posted in the forum right now about how advertisers put money on shows like BV πŸ˜›

As for clubbing shows fusion episodes it is happening across the channels and in Colors they have fusion episodes for almost every show of theirs barring Ashoka which is a historical show.



Missesha thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma




If the writer wants to tell a story of two people who were brought to gether in a child marriage ended up having a bad marriage which didn't survive but remained friends for life and will go to any extent to help each other who is any one to stop him?
It is his story and the constitution of our country gives him the freedom to tell the story that he wants.If he wants to show how a man who made a lousy husband to his protagonist but the best ever friend whom she can trust her life with why does it become a problem? Anandi was willing to put her life at risk to get Jagya's wife out of the clutches of Akheraj and people still are stuck on exes πŸ₯±




It's funny when people don't get a justification on how two exes can live together, then they will straight away question " who is the audience to question the writer / show maker" . As if the show makers are eternity who can never can go wrong. 

Apart from that, good to know that people can endorse two exes staying together in one roof.πŸ˜›Sorry,  I can't endorse that, so I will question. πŸ˜Š 
Edited by Missesha - 8 years ago
Missesha thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

 

What is the percentage of people who have access to Internet in our country? 
Among the people who have Internet access what percentage of people come and post their views on the show? 
What is the percentage of people who have TVs in their home? 
If online viewers and their opinions make so much difference why is that this shows and characters which are so popular with the online viewers and forums such as IF close down because of low TRPs?

There is an article posted in the forum right now about how advertisers put money on shows like BV πŸ˜›

As for clubbing shows fusion episodes it is happening across the channels and in Colors they have fusion episodes for almost every show of theirs barring Ashoka which is a historical show.




 Ok, so basically you have no statistics / evidence to support your statement. You are simply making an analysis based on your own understanding / perception and just on those basis you are even releasing a statement " that those who express their dislike towards Anandi are only a minority" 

Since it's only your assumption, it's debatable. If you have proven records then let's discuss, otherwise concluding that those who dislike Anandi are minority is INVALID 
Edited by Missesha - 8 years ago
hisusmita thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
I dont know where it is shown , I mean how it is clear that Anandi always needs male support.

I think since childhood she never needed any male support. She did what her heart told her to do. She fought for the people who are in problems, in pain but never disrespected her elders, never disobeyed them. She did what is right but always given importance to her loved ones.

 I thought I am not clear where it is shown that she always needed male support , I wanted to recollect it from the beginning.

From childhood she used to do everything for the people , Bhairon Singh supported her because he knew that she is doing the right thing. She never waited for Bhairon to come or pleaded him. But its Bhairon , who realised what he should be doing earlier , the girl is doing that so he ran after her, helped her complete the things which she initiated seeing people in problem.

That does not show that she needs male support.

She loved Jagya as she knew that he is her beendh

After Jagya humiliated her, insulted her badly she decided to rebuild her life. She never needed any man in her life. She started education for the girls and elderly persons.

After Shiv came he was impressed seeing her capability , her willpower. Its Shiv who has fallen for her, not the other way round. She didnt want to marry , But when married she fulfilled her all responsibilities.

After Shiv when her in laws was ready to go to Singapore, she never asked anyone to stay back for her saying she needs male support. But she was firm that she cant go as she cant leave her Nandini here. Atleast if she stays in India , she may get her one day.

She wanted to stay in KB.

But her DS, Daddu decided that she will be with her DS as before leaving Daddu wanted to leave her with her Maika, for forumwasis it may be A's ex sasural but Anandi, BHwasis, Jaitsarwasis , writers all came a long way. For them she was the beti of the house when the son left them, they did their Kanyadaan and she will always be beti there. Its her Maika.

She refused but Daddu said its his order.

Anandi came there not seeking any male support, not for Jagya,  But for DS who wanted her to be there.

Nowhere it was shown she came there because she needed Jagya's support.

They have shown few scenes here and there that she wanted to leave but DS forced her to stay with her. So we have to go by that .

She came there for Daddu and DS, not for Jagya (male support)

As per the tagline, theme rishta of Anandi and DS who were completely opposite earlier bonded in pain so well that for DS there is no difference between Jagya and her Anandi.

For her both Jagya's kid and Anandi's kids are same.

They have come a long way, they dont bother about what society thinks. They are very clear in their mind what relation they share.

That relation is not based on seeking any male support.But a family where if any problem arises everyone stands for each other.

Infact Anandi supported Jagya when he was in problem always.

Both of them have past baggage , which is very open . So their spouses accepted them that way.

Now Its the relation between Anandi and DS , not Anandi and Jagya.

After she came to BH it has been shown, she is searching for her daughter,  Ofcourse once complaint is filed, it is the job of the police to help the civilians. You cant run without any head and tail. Police were doing their duty and she was following up

She has managed to built a school for the girls (no where they have shown she has taken male support to build the school)

Neither financially nor emotionally.(no male support , atleast that is what has been shown)

DS was there with her.

It is she who helped doctor Anant (actually he needed female supportπŸ˜†)

She helped him to get a job thru Jagya.

Now also she is doing everything of her own. Every good job what she initiated since her childhood , Jagya , DS everyone is doing that , not because she needed male support but because they realised and understood what she started was a right thing to do. So they willingly came forward.

Whoever is helping her is coming of their own and if it is acceptable she is not denying that.

But not in a single scene it is shown she is crying for any male support. The only male support she actually longs for is Shiv's support, even that she keep within herself, deeply buried in her heart, never cries in front of any one.. She talks to his photo , she gets the strength and her life goes on.



Edited by hisusmita - 8 years ago
Shinya thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

 Ok, so basically you have no statistics / evidence to support your statement. You are simply making an analysis based on your own understanding / perception and just on those basis you are even releasing a statement " that those who express their dislike towards Anandi are only a minority" 

Since it's only your assumption, it's debatable. If you have proven records then let's discuss, otherwise concluding that those who dislike Anandi are minority is INVALID 


Great points, Missesha!
You dismissed the case with valid arguments.