Can we say Public Voting is better - Page 2

Can you imagine children begging for votes. THey would fall apart knowing the general public does not like them.

No, not in Lil Champs. There would be added pressure on the children to impress viewers, which would possibly affect their singing. Someone has to leave each week and many of us admit that almost all of the kids sing really well. Lets just hope the judges make the right decision each week. At the same time, we know the channel wants high TRPs and will try to create controversies- stupid comments by the judges, wild cards etc. The controversies are what really ruin a good music show, public voting or not.

Originally posted by: SHUBHA99

These Judges choosen by Zee with their track record and experiance in music field in mind. The comments reflects those personalities in terms of their perceptions on individual participants. This is their privilage and they can tell whatever they want in that position.

Just like fellow members calling one of the judges bla bla bla. This perticular Judge is of catogary A with + 5 and his musings reflect his cherecteristics.

All are not same and we need to be tollerant to every one...

my only concern is that, the judges shld give grades without any partiality and by not giving any rude comments and wrong decisions..

OK, i jus wanted to know wat each one's perspective of bringing public voting because its decided that there will be public voting in the contest but not sure when.. Lets hope for the best

Originally posted by: ans24us1

I agree with you on the point of the selection of songs etc.. But i also mentioned that for having same judges which leads into partiality, public voting could be of a better choice.. We keep on bashing judges and there for public voting, we kept bashing public and which constitutes of you, me and every one... What is the use of having judges choice then... There should be different judges for each episode... Then it makes sense.. warna again there will be only partiality

Having different judges each week is not realistic though. It also depends on how we want the judges to evaluate each contestant. Should the decision of who stays and who leaves be based on one performance (the most recent one) or all the performances, right from the start? The bias may still be there. Celeb guests in II2 and SRGMP were biased and they were only judging one episode.

Anu Public voting for this series is worse..... But definitely the judges needs be changed.... first of all they discourage the contestants a lot.... and then the partiality as proven by Jadooji.....