Sonarika Bhadhoria as Parvati-Discuss Here ONLY - Page 13

Created

Last reply

Replies

452

Views

52.3k

Users

82

Likes

841

Frequent Posters

whatthewhat thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
I get the fact that people have strong sentiments about Mouni Roy. To me this is a tv show. Some people tend to take all this personally. fine.

But to those who have "religious" objections to different actresses playing Sati/Parvati...I find this confusing.

Surely outward appearances are immaterial? It is the essence/spirit/atman...(whatever you want to call it) that remains constant...So why become attached to something as superficial as an outward form?


I am asking this question in all seriousness.😊

*added*
I ask this with all due respect to those who have a different perspective. This is not meant to offend anyone. I only posted this in the spirit of trying to understand a perspective that is different than mine.
Edited by narangi_77 - 13 years ago
satiisparvati thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
well we know for a fact the mouni and sonarika don't have the same soul
whatthewhat thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
^

I was not being literal...😆 😆
But I'm glad you brought up Mouni and Sonarika...these are actresses...this is a tv show...so help me understand the religious objection...


fairfaxwarrior thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
Narangi,
when you talk of religion and religious stuff (esp. mythology, which are primarily events driven) each person will visualize the occurances/stories in their own "Imagination" . However, through "Adwaita" siddhanta, the stories can also be narrated with abstraction. With this perceptive, we will see each and every person as "The Supreme(Ishwar)". And there won't be any differentiation of bhakta and swami. Which I am dead doubtful about your posting. You claim that your'e a religious person, do you know the vibhuti of "godess parvati"? Agreed that it's not possible to ask godess to act Parvati's role (!!), but it's a human effort to atleast find the suitable PRESENTATION which could give little brief about godess (since you say that your'e a religious guy go & crosscheck about parvati ). Here I am not saying that MOUNI is THE ONLY girl on this face of earth, but compared to Sonarika Bhaduria & mouni the "Parvati ness" presenting characteristics in mouni is more linear than "Sonarika".

For a quick reference, if you can't reach out any books, hit to wiki and glance through. If you look carefully about reviews, people are not switched on "f-tv" here to watch the best glamorous hen, they are expressing their views & expectation by finding some of the appearance/presenting similarities of parvati. The difference between mythology and adi grantha/upanishad is mythologies took the form of stories and stories are remembered based on the suitable chars and hence it got advanced as plays in theaters and even movies, unlike upanishad. So respect others vote accordingly (if interested) else keep your religious toto in vein.

Regards,
Sachin
whatthewhat thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: fairfaxwarrior

Narangi,

when you talk of religion and religious stuff (esp. mythology, which are primarily events driven) each person will visualize the occurances/stories in their own "Imagination" . However, through "Adwaita" siddhanta, the stories can also be narrated with abstraction. With this perceptive, we will see each and every person as "The Supreme(Ishwar)". And there won't be any differentiation of bhakta and swami. Which I am dead doubtful about your posting. You claim that your'e a religious person, do you know the vibhuti of "godess parvati"? Agreed that it's not possible to ask godess to act Parvati's role (!!), but it's a human effort to atleast find the suitable PRESENTATION which could give little brief about godess (since you say that your'e a religious guy go & crosscheck about parvati ). Here I am not saying that MOUNI is THE ONLY girl on this face of earth, but compared to Sonarika Bhaduria & mouni the "Parvati ness" presenting characteristics in mouni is more linear than "Sonarika".

For a quick reference, if you can't reach out any books, hit to wiki and glance through. If you look carefully about reviews, people are not switched on "f-tv" here to watch the best glamorous hen, they are expressing their views & expectation by finding some of the appearance/presenting similarities of parvati. The difference between mythology and adi grantha/upanishad is mythologies took the form of stories and stories are remembered based on the suitable chars and hence it got advanced as plays in theaters and even movies, unlike upanishad. So respect others vote accordingly (if interested) else keep your religious toto in vein.

Regards,
Sachin


I am finding it difficult to understand you.

You seem to have totally misunderstood me. I never claimed to have the answer, and nowhere did I claim to be religious. I was only trying understand the (religious) perspective of others. What I stated about outward appearance was my understanding - I never claimed it was the only perspective. I posted my understanding only so that others could tell me how their perspective differed.

I also feel that my posts were entirely respectful. It was not my intention to offend. If you took offense, well, there's very little I can do about that.


Edited by narangi_77 - 13 years ago
Life_Is_Dutiful thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
I can say only one thing.
If u r interested in Lord Shiva,if u want 2 know abt his life,den plz continue watching it.
If u r watching da show 2 see mohit-mouni jodi only den plz stop watching da show.
Dat's all i can say.
ritika06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
I was reading all the comments here in this thread.I too want to say one thing.Devon ke dev mahadev is totally different from other serials on tv because it is about Gods and Goddesses and not human beings.People watch other serials mostly because they like a certain pair,their chemistry,etc.I am sure most of you have started watching the show to know about Lord Shiva's life.Till now we only had lot of serials on Lord Ram,Lord Krishna,Lord Vishnu but after a long time,we have a serial based on Lord Shiva.Of course,there was a serial,Om Namah Shivay but that was long back.People started watching this show to know about Lord Shiva.Then they started liking mohit as Shiv and Mouni as Sati.Due to the liking for this jodi,they forgot the true reason for watching this show and started demanding to see mouni as parvati.Well,guys,mohit is not shiv and mouni is not adishakti.they are mere human beings who are playing the roles of Gods.Please don't give so much importance to these human beings.Please watch this show to know about Gods.In this materialistic world,please give atleast 20 minutes to watch this show about Gods.
Members favouring Sonarika are more interested in knowing Lord Shiva and Parvati;s story.Neither they nor me are interested in knowing whether sonarika will look good with mohit or not,how will their chemistry will be.they just want to gain knowledge about Shiva.Other things don't matter to them.
That's all i can say. Sorry for this long post.
NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: JanakiRaghunath


You mean MS's Krishna? Anand Sagar (AS) directed Ramayan of NDTV Imagine, whereas Meenakshi Sagar (MS) was the director of Jai Shri Krishna. They were also from different production houses. AS belongs to Sagar Arts whereas MS belongs to Sagar Pictures. But yes, I do hope this show doesn't drag baby Parvathi's story like JSK did with Bal Krishna. At least Krishna was known in his childhood, but the significance of Devi Parvathi was in her adult years, so there's no point in dragging her infanthood.


yeah janaki i meant that one only. I am very bad at remembring such stuff...D
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
All those people writing of Sonarika have you even seen her as Parvati yet??
shes not even entered the show and youll are making opinions of her
everyone says Mouni has the "divinity" needed for Parvati..just a question how come no one saw it before DKDM?..when Mouni was cast as Sati people though Nikhil Sinha was mad to cast a very modern contemporary girl like her as a Devi-but he managed to get the best out of her...
Similarly for Sonarika-she may be very sweet,young and bubbly in real life...she may have even played the crying and simpering Abhilasha-but yaar that was needed for the role-Nikhil Sinha will manage to get the best out of her im sure of it...to make as\n opinion of her we should first atleast see her as Parvati?
and ya for Gods sake no comparing Sonarika and Mouni, but of them are really diffrent and cannot be compared!
vanadhi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
me too,i never felt mouni will suit the role ,but she rocked ,lets wait for the new one too

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".