Quality Singers - Page 2

Poll

please be honest, which show do you think has better quality singers

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

2.5k

Users

19

Frequent Posters

sana.abraham thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: ReXLoVeR

kooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooL!!!!!!! Im gonna go see his concert wit Salman Khan in it called Rockstars theyre comin herre soon liike in April or May. Icant waiiit!! Hope ii get to meet him!

😳😳😳awww...well goodluck..i hope you get to meet him too...hes no doubt the sweetest guy ever..as is sallu😳😳...the concert should be rocking..its only them 2?😕..and i thought theres a concert.."heat" or something..with akshay..saif and them?....

sana.abraham thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: pateh23

thank god there isnt FG

😆

madhavi_r108 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#13
SRGMP anyday!

Just wanted to add, when people say X Factor or something, what do you mean ?

I always thought X Factor meant three things

1) Looks
2) Performance Skills
3) Overall presentation

If these are what make X factor, the SRGMP finalists had it.. Vinit, Himani,Debo and Hema used to dance for songs that required to dance like in the club songs special or Punjabi pop or Qawalli.. Nihira moved when she sang..she performed the least, but her voice was so good that it didnt matter!! Barring Debo (he is married so not commentin about the 'HOT' factor), i thought the top 4 were pretty good lukin too.. Vinit was cute, Himani and Hemu were hot, Nihira had a sweet face.. and their overall presentation was always top notch..

Coming to other contestants, Twinkle and Paresh were reputed performerrs and they surely looked good..

My point is when peopl say tat SRGMP looks for Singing an d II for x factor.. i dont see the difference.. Amit sana danced as much as Hemu did.. but he is said to have X factor.. and Farah Khan making such an issue of people keeping eyes closed.. Amit Sana closed his eyes when he sang Woh Kisna Hain ! Soem songs you HAVE to close ur eyes to get the feel.. if the audience can't connect..its their loss !!

Saying this, II 1 had a lot of good singers whom I think would have done good on SRGMP too.. Prajakta and Amit Sana would be on whom I'd have my money on, they were almost perfect..

II 2, Meenal Amey and Karu are good SRGMP material..

Just my POV..no intention to hurt any1..
sapnokirani24 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#14
compared to II2---i think srgm.... but in general all THREE shows..FG, II and SRGM all have great singers 👏 👏 👏
sana.abraham thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: madhavir108

SRGMP anyday!

Just wanted to add, when people say X Factor or something, what do you mean ?

I always thought X Factor meant three things

1) Looks
2) Performance Skills
3) Overall presentation

If these are what make X factor, the SRGMP finalists had it.. Vinit, Himani,Debo and Hema used to dance for songs that required to dance like in the club songs special or Punjabi pop or Qawalli.. Nihira moved when she sang..she performed the least, but her voice was so good that it didnt matter!! Barring Debo (he is married so not commentin about the 'HOT' factor), i thought the top 4 were pretty good lukin too.. Vinit was cute, Himani and Hemu were hot, Nihira had a sweet face.. and their overall presentation was always top notch..

Coming to other contestants, Twinkle and Paresh were reputed performerrs and they surely looked good..

My point is when peopl say tat SRGMP looks for Singing an d II for x factor.. i dont see the difference.. Amit sana danced as much as Hemu did.. but he is said to have X factor.. and Farah Khan making such an issue of people keeping eyes closed.. Amit Sana closed his eyes when he sang Woh Kisna Hain ! Soem songs you HAVE to close ur eyes to get the feel.. if the audience can't connect..its their loss !!

Saying this, II 1 had a lot of good singers whom I think would have done good on SRGMP too.. Prajakta and Amit Sana would be on whom I'd have my money on, they were almost perfect..

II 2, Meenal Amey and Karu are good SRGMP material..

Just my POV..no intention to hurt any1..

👏you hit the right notes ...totally true

anonmember thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: madhavir108

SRGMP anyday!

Just wanted to add, when people say X Factor or something, what do you mean ?

I always thought X Factor meant three things

1) Looks
2) Performance Skills
3) Overall presentation

If these are what make X factor, the SRGMP finalists had it.. Vinit, Himani,Debo and Hema used to dance for songs that required to dance like in the club songs special or Punjabi pop or Qawalli.. Nihira moved when she sang..she performed the least, but her voice was so good that it didnt matter!! Barring Debo (he is married so not commentin about the 'HOT' factor), i thought the top 4 were pretty good lukin too.. Vinit was cute, Himani and Hemu were hot, Nihira had a sweet face.. and their overall presentation was always top notch..

Coming to other contestants, Twinkle and Paresh were reputed performerrs and they surely looked good..

My point is when peopl say tat SRGMP looks for Singing an d II for x factor.. i dont see the difference.. Amit sana danced as much as Hemu did.. but he is said to have X factor.. and Farah Khan making such an issue of people keeping eyes closed.. Amit Sana closed his eyes when he sang Woh Kisna Hain ! Soem songs you HAVE to close ur eyes to get the feel.. if the audience can't connect..its their loss !!

Saying this, II 1 had a lot of good singers whom I think would have done good on SRGMP too.. Prajakta and Amit Sana would be on whom I'd have my money on, they were almost perfect..

II 2, Meenal Amey and Karu are good SRGMP material..

Just my POV..no intention to hurt any1..



Well said esp the part about x factor! 👏 👏

Farah makes such an huge issue about closing eyes, its really irritating. With songs like tadap tadap, saathi re bhool na jaane, hddcs, getting the right feel while singing is important and if one has to close their eyes, don't see why it should be a problem. I think it helps them connect more. When Amey was singing tadap tadap, you could see the pain on his face esp when he closed his eyes. Isn't that what performance/x factor is all about- connecting w/your audience and making them react to the performance?

Shamit's-Saiyan thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#17
ill go with SRGMP having the better singing quality 😊
RMCanada thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: sana.abraham

just wondering...because i personally think..without any offence to anyone here...that sa re ga ma pa this year...had some of the best new singers..and many of them are singing for mainstream hindi films already...specially compared to the ones i've been watching on Indian Idol...i thought amey,karu and panna...were the ONLY good singers..on the show..whereas i found..they still didnt match up to the sa re ga ma pa contestants...when it came to some songs...again no offence...just wondering if everyone watches INDIAN IDOL..just because of the tag, label and hype behind it...or if you all really disagree and think that they have better quality singers😊...hehe take care!

i agree

karunya_forever thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#19
singing of TALENTED ones cannot be compared by us.we can only judge when we exactly know who is better,but sgmp have so many talented singers and ii2 as well,so we cant POSSIBLY compare TALENT of other show WITH THE TALENT of the another one....
Sunitha.V thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#20

SAREGAMAPA indeed. It had more number talented singers this year than other shows. That could be because of its legacy. I mean that show is existing for many years now and it has produced a few good playback singers already. So it has already delivered, whereas II is yet to prove.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".