Originally posted by: orms
Most consistent does not mean the best. For every 5 people who supported Sushant there may be an equal number who must have thought that Chang and Yana were better.
Many people on the net and even in this forum have agreed that very often the judges have been partial to Sushant. I'm not a fan at all of Shiamak Daver's dance (he's not in the least bit versatile... but that would be another topic!), so his opinion matters nought to me... especially, more so, when the NATION agreed that Sushant did not deserve the title.
I found Sushant's dancing style boring (not him but his dancing... blame his choreo if you will!) and I cannot change my opinion because "falana.. falana" said he's good. I'm sure you're intelligent enough to permit me my opinion as I am gallant enough to respect yours.
I never said I'm challenging your opinion. I wrote my views eariler once and have since not returned to debate. I did not say that Shiamak Terrence etc. thought he was best to change your opinion. I just wanted to point out that just like you didn't like it, many others liked it too. You find his performances boring, your opinion, I don't, my opinion, similarily judges liked it too-- why not leave them to their opinions too?? Why to assume that the judges were partial???😊
Besides, the nation voting doesn't necessarily mean MORE PEOPLE voting. There was multiple voting here.
Add to this that people support favourites while voting.
Add to this, that many people watch, appreciate, but don't vote. I live in a hostel full of girls who were rooting for Sushant but didn't vote cos they felt its all fixed anyway. Same for Yana and also for Chang--- my Mum hasn't given a single vote to Chang even though she liked him.
Add to this that many voted on the consideration of who progresses from non-dancer to dancer and not on the basis of whose performances were best
(Now please don't misunderstand me- I'm not saying chang was not good and all and didn't deserve to win and Sushant was the best-- NO-- I am just saying that there are many facets to voting- it is a highly unreliable method of judging "Who was best" in my opinion)
Look, I'm not trying to point out that you are wrong or your opinion is wrong. All I'm trying to say is that we all have different tastes and what appeals to one certainly might not appeal to others.😊 I just wanted to say that Chang winning does not necessarily that "Sushant's dances are boring" becomes a verdict or ultimate truth (As you wrote in the post I quoted-- nation agrees with me, I rest my case) . As I said, there is nothing truly right or wrong here. Some dances appeal to some people, some don't. As simple as that.
Edited by nikitagmc - 13 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount