3 Idiots MOVIE and MEMBER Reviews - Post HERE! - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

356

Views

33.3k

Users

89

Likes

373

Frequent Posters

anna143 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#91
Woohoo great reviews so far
-Edelweiss- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#92
I seriosuly fail to understand why people get so hyper with critics reviews, whether its good or bad. Afterall these reviews are just someone else's opinion about the movie. Yes that someone is suppose to have more cinematic knowledge, but that does not necessarily mean that their opinion will match the general consensus of the public. Every individuals preferences differ, and hence a good or a bad review shouldn't matter. I have no trust in any of this so called critics reviews.

And another why do all fans get so worked up over their actors releases. I mean, just because its an Aamir film, that does not automatically make it an amazing film, and put the crtics under obligation to give them great reviews. And before anyone puts me under the Aamir haters category, I'll clarify I am a massive Aamir fan, but that does not mean that I'll blindly accept all his films to be great. Its best to watch the movie yourself and decide rather than depending on reviews and calling critics name just coz the review they wrote was not in favour of the film.
-Aladin- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: -Edelweiss-

I seriosuly fail to understand why people get so hyper with critics reviews, whether its good or bad. Afterall these reviews are just someone else's opinion about the movie. Yes that someone is suppose to have more cinematic knowledge, but that does not necessarily mean that their opinion will match the general consensus of the public. Every individuals preferences differ, and hence a good or a bad review shouldn't matter. I have no trust in any of this so called critics reviews.

And another why do all fans get so worked up over their actors releases. I mean, just because its an Aamir film, that does not automatically make it an amazing film, and put the crtics under obligation to give them great reviews. And before anyone puts me under the Aamir haters category, I'll clarify I am a massive Aamir fan, but that does not mean that I'll blindly accept all his films to be great. Its best to watch the movie yourself and decide rather than depending on reviews and calling critics name just coz the review they wrote was not in favour of the film.

Words of wisdom. I applaud thee. 👏
xChandnix thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#94

Originally posted by: Human_Torch

i know all these kaminey fan girls and aamir haters will start bringing reviews to pull down the film...because even they know themselves tht 3 idiots will crash almost every possibility for their favourites to win any award😆

Was there really a need to start bashing other members on I-F when all they've done is post reviews; the comment for 'aamir haters' and 'kaminey fan girls' was just random and not needed. Don't think anyone on I-F however big a fan is sad enough to want to actually post 'bad reviews'. Indirectly this was said towards a certain member who i'll state again just posted a review so please do not bash members, however its fine if you've realised what you said was wrong and edited your post.
-Aladin-, Human+Torch and sydealiayaz: please guys do not start just bashing and making rude comments towards each other..it ruins the whole thread for the others and just take things lightly if you feel someone's said something wrong/bashing then tell them through PM and give them a chance to rectify their mistake rather than just having an argument in this review thread. If it continues then definitly tell the dev team through reporting their post or PMing us but there is absolutly no need to start fighting here. Specifically sydealiayaz, please watch your languageee..no need for profanity in english or any other language.


laly thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#95
A Billion Idiots, 3 Wise Men
I would like to start this by saying this is not a traditional review. I'm not a critic and I'm sure if a critic were writing this, they would analyse script, stars performances, directing and other factors and those are done by folks much better than I, who are full- time critics. This therefore is not just another movie reviewed on a Friday because 3 Idiots isn't just another movie. It is much more than that. It is a story whose importance and urgency needs talking about which I'll attempt to do.
My first day of college, after 12 years of an education system where we learnt Shakespeare by heart, a professor asked me what my favorite Shakespeare play was and I replied Hamlet. The professor asked, "Why?" and I gave him a long answer repeating something a dead academic had said which my ICSE text books told me to say. The professor stopped me and asked, "That's rubbish. I didn't ask what so-and-so thought of Hamlet, I asked what you thought." I was stumped. I had known education to mean repeating what old people with beards had said. This professor was asking me something no one had ever asked me before, to think on my own. "I have no idea why Hamlet is my favorite play sir but I'll think about it" I replied. And that's the day I learnt that the difference between learning and getting a degree is vast. And I realized that a mind was not just to remember, it was to create, to ask, to be curious, to unlearn all the rubbish that was forced into our heads without context or understanding, That day taught me that to really understand anything, you had to have an open mind and be an idiot.


Very simply, 3 Idiots is a story of 3 people who come to an engineering college. Two with certainties of the career they wanted (Sharman Joshi and Madhavan) and one (Aamir Khan) with curiosity that anything is possible. And the film captures the journey of how he transforms not so much their lives but their ideas and many years later, they go in search of him. What Mr. Khan's character does in college is to introduce the idea that a simple question lies at the heart of every greatx problem (Einstein, Newton, would agree) and if you ask it, and keep an open mind, you have begun an education. And if one really learns by asking, then marks and jobs and careers and stability, sort itself out.

In a nation of double digit suicide rates and cut-off percentages of 97 per cent and engineering entrance exams considered brutally difficult globally, this is not just a message that needs to be heard, this is a fundamental shift in how we need to think as a society. And this big budget Bollywood movie has beaten policy-makers, think tanks and pundits in asking that question. We talk of beating China's growth, we talk of being the new world power over the US and Europe and we consider the fuel in our fire to be educated young people and yet the education we give them is to memorise and compete endlessly, first as students, then as the middle class for salaries to buy material consumer things. Yet, in everything, we don't create new ideas, we just follow western processes. As Mr. Aamir Khan's character says in the movie (and I paraphrase), "If you really want to do something to become someone in the world, don't run after money, create ideas that change the world, money comes". Bill Gates dropped out of college, Shakespeare never finished school and the Wright brothers who invented the airplane couldn't afford school.

As Warren Buffet once said, "Anything of any value in this world came from someone considered a mad man in his time". If we want to create the next Google or revolutionise clean technology, if we want the next generation of MF Husseins and Nandan Nilekanis, if we really strive to make a better India (not one of catch phrases but taken seriously in the world for new ways of thinking), I'd listen carefully to what the creators of 3 Idiots are saying.

Rajkumar Hirani, working off a script he wrote with Abhijat Joshi in a Vidhu Vinod Chopra production (loosely based on a Chetan Bhagat novel), creates a motion picture that does much more than entertain and educate – it makes you think about the way you think – while making you laugh and cry and be taken on a cinematic journey as any film would.

Mr. Chopra, Mr. Hirani and Aamir Khan are a great combination, not just for showbiz power (arguably the biggest combination in Bollywood today) but for their intelligence and their thoughts on India. In 3 Idiots and the Munnabhai franchise and in Mr. Khan's own productions, one can see that the effort is more than just to make a movie - it is to effect change for a better India while being hugely entertaining. Whether it's tackling corruption, religious, class, caste barriers, the way we treat our elderly, handicapped, the way we teach, fall into backward thinking, illiterate beliefs, their movies always pass on a progressive message subtly that ours is a cosmopolitan, free, secular, possible society and great freedoms used responsibly build a great nation. Rather than use our diversity to divide that factions do in our country, their stories use that diversity as a strength for all that has come before making us able to build what we will. Like Infosys, liberalisation, the new India of the movies of these 3 wise men is the one I want to live in.

I hope this movie is made compulsory viewing for anyone under 30 with a dream (that's about 70 per cent of a billion) because when our Prime Minister referred to the potential of our young population, he said (quoting Victor Hugo), "You cannot stop an idea whose time has come". The time for young India to think for themselves has come. And this movie is not challenging the system of education, it is saying if you've ever had a dream and a passion, follow it because your instincts teach you more than any text book can- don't be a machine, be an idiot.

Being an idiot, I'm giving this 4 stars because I think this is much bigger than just a film, it's a cultural phenomenon. Just like the Velvet Revolution affected change in Czech Republic with rock music, maybe this movie will affect societal change about how we learn. Yet one of the film's arguments is that rankings don't matter; only what you think does. So you must go see it. Whether you like or dislike it, whether it bores you or elates you, as long as you've thought for yourselves, and allowed the idiot in you to awake for a bit, I think the creators are happy. All is indeed, well.
Ultimate_Shadow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: xChandnix

Was there really a need to start bashing other members on I-F when all they've done is post reviews; the comment for 'aamir haters' and 'kaminey fan girls' was just random and not needed. Don't think anyone on I-F however big a fan is sad enough to want to actually post 'bad reviews'. Indirectly this was said towards a certain member who i'll state again just posted a review so please do not bash members, however its fine if you've realised what you said was wrong and edited your post.
-Aladin-, Human+Torch and sydealiayaz: please guys do not start just bashing and making rude comments towards each other..it ruins the whole thread for the others and just take things lightly if you feel someone's said something wrong/bashing then tell them through PM and give them a chance to rectify their mistake rather than just having an argument in this review thread. If it continues then definitly tell the dev team through reporting their post or PMing us but there is absolutly no need to start fighting here. Specifically sydealiayaz, please watch your languageee..no need for profanity in english or any other language.


thanks ....i will take care next time
455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#97

Originally posted by: desigal90

Omg unanimous positive reviews!

And bebo is being appreciated! Kareena I finally forgive you for the trash you did post JWM thanks to Kurbaan and 3 Idiots!

you really had to mention Kurbaan? Didn't you? lol

3 Idiots: Movie Review

23 Dec, 2009 01:20 pm ISTlGaurav Malani/INDIATIMES MOVIES
Print EMail Discuss Share Save Comment Text:
R. Madhavan, Aamir Khan, Sharman Joshi in a still from the movie '3 Idiots'. Check more pics
Director: Rajkumar Hirani
Cast: Aamir Khan, Sharman Joshi, R Madhavan, Kareena Kapoor
Rating: *****

In a late scene from the film, 2 of the 3 idiots zip down their pants and pat their bottoms facing the third idiot. Rather than feeling gross at that instant, you have a lump in throat. For the zillionth time in a Hindi film, a bride runs away from the pheras on her wedding day. But the scene still doesn't come across as clichd. For a group of all-male engineering students, to 'deliver' means to literally carry out a delivery operation on a woman in labour pain. And when the motionless newborn responds to a goodwill chant of ' aal izz well ' in true-blue Manmohan Desai mode, you fail to find a fault in the filmi formula. That's the golden touch of Rajkumar Hirani.

So after successfully dispensing philosophies of ' Jaadu ki jhappi ' in Munnabhai MBBS and ' Gandhigiri ' in Lage Raho Munnabhai , Hirani incites a new philosophy of ' Aal izz well ' in 3 Idiots . And like his doctrine, all is well in his helluva film.

Loosely based on Chetan Bhagat's bestseller Five Point Someone , 3 Idiots takes the plot much beyond the campus confines and the target audience much above the youth, for universal appeal. The story starts a decade after the graduation of college companions Farhan (R Madhavan) and Raju Rastogi (Sharman Joshi) who get a clue on the whereabouts of their missing third friend Rancho (Aamir Khan). As they set out on a road trip from Delhi to Shimla to Manali to Ladakh to find their friend, the narrative cuts to and fro into flashbacks as we are introduced to the three idiots in an engineering college.

Rancho clearly is different from anyone else in the college with his individualistic thought-process and rebellious attitude, which invites the ire of the college principal (Boman Irani) and affection of his daughter Pia (Kareena Kapoor).

Coming from Rajkumar Hirani, there was clearly a risk involved in the film's setting and characterizations for having a dj vu effect with his first film. Boman Irani, as the principal, almost revives his disciplinarian dean characterization from Munnabhai MBBS which is more palpable with his disgust towards the rebellious protagonist, Rancho (akin to Sanjay Dutt) who is furthermore in love with his daughter (ala Gracy Singh). Nevertheless, Hirani's direction is so impeccable that without a conscious effort, the analogy never strikes your mind and the scenario never looks repetitive.

In his trademark style, Hirani grabs your attention from scene one with an unconventional opening to the film. Thereafter every single scene written in the screenplay (by Hirani and Abhijat Joshi) is not just relevant but also has a clear set objective ' to be funny or be deeply poignant. Which means it either makes you laugh or cry and at some superlative instances do both simultaneously (which is an achievement). The writers have kept absolutely no room for any intermediate option.

The introduction sequence of the principal is hilarious and so is an annual day Hindi speech of honour by an NRI student. Raju Rastogi's poverty-stricken family is introduced with such nonchalance in spoofy black-and-white frames that what could have ideally been a melodramatic tear-jerker scene is transformed into a laugh-riot. The short-n-smart suspense induced at the interval point teases your anticipation. Sharman's revival scene in hospital reminds of the inspiring carom board scene from Munnabhai MBBS while the delivery sequence in the pre-climax is tackled tactfully and tastefully. The excellence in screenplay can't be summed up in merely a paragraph. In fact even the romantic song Zoobie Doobie is one of the most creatively conceptualized numbers since 'Dhoom Tana' (Om Shanti Om) or 'Woh Ladki Hai Kahan' (Dil Chahta Hai).

The writers also represent a lot of their ideologies through the thoughtful dialogues touching several academic issues from grading systems, parental pressure, student suicides, conformist coaching to theoretical knowledge, without getting preachy at any instance. Sample a straightforward gem that says, "Even a lion learns to obey his ringmaster. But you call him well-trained and not well-educated". Several engineering jokes make way into the script and never fail to make you laugh.

Shantanu Moitra's music is in perfect sync with the mood of the film. C K Muraleetharan's cinematography and Hirani's editing are flawless. Manish Malhotra and Raghuveer Shetty's informal styling succeeds in giving the film it's trendy campus feel and the 30 plus trio convincingly pass off as college students.

Performances are a highlight with Aamir Khan clearly stealing the show in the role of the sharp, optimistic, livewire Rancho. He is so effortlessly natural in his act that you take a moment to analyze and appreciate this as one of his career-best performances. Sharman Joshi is as much competent showing brilliance in both funny and emotional moments. Madhavan has an easy screen presence and perfectly complements his costars for amazing companion chemistry. Kareena Kapoor may have less screen-time but this is amongst one of her most appealing acts. And that is beyond her gorgeous looks. Boman Irani is exceptionally good as the principal. Despite adding a lisp to his character, he doesn't make a caricature out of it, which is the usual tendency. His mannerisms so distinctively remind you of the professors from your college days. Omi as the nerdy NRI symbolizes the teacher's pet you encounter in every classroom.

Rajkumar Hirani serves you idealism but with utmost conviction. He is able to establish a compelling connect with his audience, qualifying himself as one of the finest filmmakers of his time. Who else can turn something as trivial as pudina chatni into a price indicator? The film redefines idiot as 'I do it on my own terms'. After watching the film, you won't mind being certified as an idiot. If you still don't approve of the film, you are a certified cynic.

' 3 Idiots ' is one of the most entertaining films of the decade.

http://movies.indiatimes.com/Reviews/3-Idiots-Movie-Review/articleshow/5369288.cms
That review praises sooooooo much the movie - it lacks a certain balance ---
Anyway when I see the movies I'll know if I like it or not --- I don't trust anyone else than me as far as cinema is concerned....
Edited by lalixlili - 15 years ago
desigal90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#98
Course Lily, considering 3 Idiots and kurbaan are the ONLY two films of kareena's htat I've liked post JWM, I had to mention the ONE other film besides 3 Idiots 😆
Come on, give me some member reviews. I'm going on Friday, surely someone on this forum watched it!
455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: aneeshadgr8

geet is bluemoon.

matter over.dont open it again now.lets keep it peaceful today,'cause its my bday..!!..(haan haan pata hai m so besharam to declare it like this🤣)

Happy belated b-day mine was on the 12th on December...😆😳
455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: desigal90

Course Lily, considering 3 Idiots and kurbaan are the ONLY two films of kareena's htat I've liked post JWM, I had to mention the ONE other film besides 3 Idiots 😆

Come on, give me some member reviews. I'm going on Friday, surely someone on this forum watched it!

The reviews are overall very positive --- I hope the audience will create the buzz - let's keep fingers crossed for Aamir& my Sharman 😳😳 and your Bebo 🤢 LOL
btw I had the courage to watch one of her itw she's pretty honest and doesn't think that she does pathbreaking kind of cinema - Good to know *roll eyes* -- but why does she always have to mention that she has talent🤢🤢🤢?
Does she really believe that thanks to her "talent" she's a BW actress? --- and all her speech about 'having confidence in yourself and people will have confidence in you' rubbish ---- she doesn't make anything to make me like her a bit....🥱🥱🥱Sorry I tried LOOOOOOOL
Don't like the non sense talking of BW's people
.............................................................................
She's likeable only in her avatars in movies LOL

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: woodland · 4 months ago

Oooh why are the claws out all of a sudden? 👀...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 7 days ago

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972624019976515864

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972624019976515864
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 6 days ago

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972622901443752106

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972622901443752106
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 19 days ago

https://x.com/filmibeat/status/1968397140549345682

https://x.com/filmibeat/status/1968397140549345682
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 24 days ago

Movie has released worldwide 12th September and will release in India too...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".