indogirl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

I have seen that lately everyone is bashing Prerna a lot. So I thought I would look at her character from a real life perspective and see where she stands. Also let me make it clear that I am not writing this as Anu or Bajaj fan. I am writing about a woman's kasuatis in life from a woman's perspective.

I think that Prerna's character is not as low as we all think. From very beginning she has stood by what is right. Before she had to choose between her lovers and now between her children. In any situation, what she tries to do is not essentially wrong, but it is her ways that are faulty.

One fault of Prerna is that she expects everyone else to be perfectly trustworthy. She builds relationships but fails to realize that they can be broken easier than built. She doesn't realize that relationships are very delicate. One must nurture them. If we talk about the current situation, she expects bajaj to understand her no matter what. She wants him to trust her. But she fails to build that trust. But sometimes you have to prove to even your closest companion how much you love them. Prerna believes that 20 years of marriage is proof enough of her loyalty. But she forgets that people are by nature insecure. They need to be reminded again and again of your loyalty. However, why is it Prerna who needs to prove her loyalty and support to her husband (whether it is bajaj or Anu)? Why don't we expect the same from her husbands or even her kids?

Another fault of Prerna is that she fails to communicate her feelings properly. She acts too fast, too quickly and without knowing the complete truth. Yes, she corrects herself in the end, but the damage is already done. But again communication requires two people. Prerna fails to explain her feelings and her viewpoint. But others fail to listen to her arguments as well. Why do we always expect Prerna to give clarifications? Why does Prerna have to clarify her relations with Anu to Bajaj? Why didn't we expect Bajaj to clarify when Prerna refused to believe Madhavi on their wedding day? Why did we expect Prerna to prove to Anu that Sneha is their child? Why should the women always give "agni-pariksha"? Why not men? Why do we expect Prerna to love Kuki, Tushar and Vishaka unconditionally, when we don't expect Kuki or Vishakha to respect Prerna's love?

Here we cannot only blame Prerna for problems in her relationships. Two people are involved in a relationship and it takes both of them to create a rift. In kzk playwrights have failed to build marital relationships. Bajaj trusted and understood Prerna more when they weren't married than now. Similarly, there is a greater understanding between Anu and Prerna now than when they were married. Furthermore, whenever there is a problem in family, Prerna is blamed for not taking care of the family. And this happens in real life too. Why is that always a woman is blamed for her kids' mistakes. Isn't a man equally responsible for bringing up his kids? Isn't he responsible for his kids' mistakes?

Although I have pointed out Prerna's faults, I must admit that these faults bring her character closer to reality. These faults of her are very human. Prerna's shortcomings actually compliment her character than destroy it. She is not perfect, yet she strives towards a better life for her loved ones and this is what makes her a realistic woman.

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

2.9k

Users

15

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

LifeOLicious thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Brilliant!! finally someone has said what I had been thinking about for days...thanks so much indogirl!!
Fatty Acid thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
Awesome insight indogirl, prerna is the scapegoat often, and i don't think there really is any reason, but something that roots greater in our own mentality and what we've grown up, this show shows a woman caught between two men, and whether we like to believe it or not, we don't see that as right, or as normal, we can see men do this, but we can't see women behaving this way, we can see a woman caught between two men, but she only likes one, and the other one she doesn't want to hurt feelings, but never when she loves two men, that is what indian cinema and india culture has drilled into our heads, and ekta has reversed it so it will take some time to get used to, i wish i could explain what i mean to say more accurately, something must have been lost in traslation
amaypranay thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
hey Suchi...I understood what your point of view....I feel, that Prerna has taken her relationships for granted..and I feel it is very realistic......
and then again, she always speaks faster than she would realize what her loved one has to say....and here she alawys fels letdown..or that why is this happenening...to her...ahe strives towards doing her duties...which could be for any one she cares deeply for....and she feels that the other's will understand her point of view....

can't but put one point across, I remeber one or two examples when she was married to Anu....and Bajaj was not there, she felt it was her duty to be with his kids...I remember, she, Anu and Prem were at the beach, playing with the ball, and having so much fun, she got a call from Vishaka...and she ran there to be with kuki....leaving Prem and Anu, not that it was wrong, but yet, Prem wanted to spend some time with his Parents..and here Prerna..ran thinking it was more imp to be with kuki and vishaka...I don't even think she realized that Anu and Prem will even think anything for that matter..I remember so many instances, when i felt like telling Prerna no...think first and then take the action....anyway, i just wanted to piont of some view points...
but Suchi, very well put...and great analysis...
indus thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
very well said,Indogirl.
most of us here are females i beleive and can atleat empathise with one.
prernafreak thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6

yes, very well explained, thanks for defending her with proper storyline facts & from your perspectives too 😊

it's nice to know that females also like her not just coz she's only paired with anurag or bajaj.
Edited by prernafreak - 19 years ago
Manasi_16 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Enthusiast Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
Very well written indeed...I'll put my views later...just one point.

You asked Why do we blame the mother for the children's mistakes???

That happens coz the mother soends max time with them...all the values are instilled by her, not the father. So, when children grow up to be well mannered, mothers are praised. If u see even SRK always speaks of his mother who taught him everything

Another example: I've been extensively researchin on the Ambani family & I realised that how much ever Anil Sir & Mukeshbhai praise Dhirubhai for developing their business accumen, when it comes to family values & personal achievements, they only mention Kokilaben
ronit13 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
well prerna is not alwayz wrong but as a matter of fact she is alwayz 56 percent wrong as when a mother has 6-7 children she has to treat them equally if one of them was lost and cums back as a villian and he paralysis your other child then it means the mother has to punish her child not simply ignore it caz he was lost if she can't see her child in jail then atleast she shud punish him in any other way but shud not make lame excuses.and her child abuses her hubby,and more he plays filthy tricks wid her sister?he calls her father(of course bajaj is yudi's father by not blood relation but other valid reasons) bhoda oldy then he shud be punished
a mother can't be wrong but she is alwayz selfish
indogirl thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Manasi_16

Very well written indeed...I'll put my views later...just one point.

You asked Why do we blame the mother for the children's mistakes???

That happens coz the mother soends max time with them...all the values are instilled by her, not the father. So, when children grow up to be well mannered, mothers are praised. If u see even SRK always speaks of his mother who taught him everything

Another example: I've been extensively researchin on the Ambani family & I realised that how much ever Anil Sir & Mukeshbhai praise Dhirubhai for developing their business accumen, when it comes to family values & personal achievements, they only mention Kokilaben

I agree Manasi that it is the mother who is credited or blamed for how her children turn out. And it was proper at that time and period. Before fathers were the financial pillar of the family while mothers stayed home and took care of kids. Mother instilled good values in her kids, while father provided the financial support. So it was logical to hold mothers responsible for children.

But time has changed. Today, especially in metropolitan cities, mothers also work outside the home. Husbands and wives share the household responsibilities and participate in care of children together. Women also contribute to financial needs of the family. Men do participate in house work and childcare more than they used to before.

Time has changed, but our mindset has not. We still hold mothers responsible for children's deeds. I am just saying that men should be responsible for kids' mistakes as well. I also believe they should be credited for their kids' achievements, too. We have moved forward with the time and adapted to western traditions, but our mindset is still the same. Even working women are sometimes blamed when kids are spoiled. We still hear things like, " her family fell apart or her children are spoiled because she was out working when she should be taking care of her kids". But you will never hear this for a man. This is our mindset. And it needs change with circumstances.

LifeOLicious thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

indogirl you are my mindreader!!! i have been too busy to reply to this...but i agree with you hands down!

it is nature and it is natural for the mother to be the closest with the kids but that does not mean we blame her for everything that goes wrong in the kids lives. if we have to blame or praise i think both are responsible...yet they are not entirely responsible either (unless they are evil like apo*na! ) so dialogues such as "if you were at home more with the kids then so and so would not happen" is very demeaning!! it is easy to blame someone always...and most of the time the mother is the scapegoat!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".