Episode- Not As Emotional?

Page

Next Last

Payal

@-iPayal-

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

hey guys!! 😃...

i know were all still in a big shock about the promo, some of us like it, some of us dont...but

did you guys feel like the episode wasnt as emotional(sad) as i thought it was gonna be? i dont mean the actors....they were all fab!👏...but theres was something missing.

maybe its becasue i was expecting kekta style rona dhona or something😆

how come they didnt show a varun scene...where he finds out about all this? and when did the mother come? ...and at the funral...dont you think it was just a lil wierd that none of the bros were consoling the mom? poor thing was breaking down, but the boys were hugging themselves?😕😆

what do you guys think?

Quote

Frequent Posters

441213

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

yES i know no1 consoled da mother...not even Prithvi...and mayb there was a Varun scene but they edited it..bechra he is not geting equal screen space as prithvi and sam...anyways...i m happy that they finished da rona-dhona seq in one episode..i thought it would get dragged 4 atleast 2 epi like ektas serials...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

*Reemz*

@*Reemz*

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

I think these type of scenes NEED melodrama in order for the revenge to look somewhat justified. I didn't think much of the acting either but I don't think it was the fault of the actors. They barely had any crying to do...! So what if they are men? Disappointing episode to be honest.

I think the whole thing should have been stretched to about 2-3 episodes! Mourning and revenge in one episode? Not correctly done.

Quote

Who-I-Used-2-Be

@Who-I-Used-2-Be

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

I think it was one of the best episodes of the show, and it had the right amount of emotions and sadness for me..I liked the fact that it was kinda balanced and not overly dramatic ..The only flaw in the death scenes for me was the fact that they didn't show anyone going to console their mom; that was a major directorial blunder. It'll make up for the blunder a little if they show them consoling their mom in today's episode but still it was a mistake not to show it in the first place..

As far as not showing Varun's reaction is concerned, I think it would've been better from a storytelling point of view had they shown Varun's reaction to their father's death, but from an acting point of view, they did the right thing by not showing his reaction. No offence to Varun's fans, and I really mean it, but the actor just doesn't have the acting prowess to portray those severe kinds of emotions and reactions. So, it was alright for me that they didn't show his reaction to the death..😳

And yes, the episode was really fast-paced and one thing followed another quickly but I suppose they didn't want to stretch the death and funeral thing because it's a really dark and gloomy angle..They had to show the death and rush it at the same time , in order to retain the basic concept of the show..

No offence meant to anyone, really..It's just my opinion..😳

Edited by Who-I-Used-2-Be - 16 years ago

Quote

Heavens_Kiss

@Heavens_Kiss

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

Yeah everything was pretty much covered up in this episode itself wasn't it!! Although i liked the fact that they fastforwarded evreything,and made it look as if what we were watching for the past 2 months was merely a flashback,and all these events which we have been witnessing upto know happened during that course,a Varun scene was still a must,coz i wanted to see Dishant the actor,i know he is pretty good,but most of his scenes have been with Rosh,i wanted to see how natural he could be in a different situation.! I think the creatives faultered there !! If he is going to take his revenge out which is evident now we needed to see his anguish and pain as well ,when the news was broken out to him.!! We got to see Sam andG.K but not him??? Maybe they did not want to make it too melodramatic,i dont know,but a little more drama would not have hurt at all!! Big mistake there!!,although fast forwarding to the funeral scene was pretty much Ok. Good post Pops!! I agree with you on most points.!!😆

Edited by anisha12 - 16 years ago

Quote

284462

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Who-I-Used-2-Be
I think it was one of the best episodes of the show, and it had the right amount of emotions and sadness for me..I liked the fact that it was kinda balanced and not overly dramatic ..The only flaw in the death scenes for me was the fact that they didn't show anyone going to console their mom, that was a major directorial blunder. It'll make up for the blunder if they show them consoling their mom in today's episode but still it was a mistake not to show it in the first place..

I am glad it was minus the melodrama we are used to, but still the funeral was a bit sudden, how did the mother arrived so soon, where is the funeral being held in mumbai or manali - it left you with lots of unanswered questions.

The blending of the gujaral mansion scene where it was still morning with the funeral which was evening didnt help either.

I understood that they had to be together when they lit the pyre and they have such a sad look towards their mom when they are about to do it.

But yes, it would have really helped and taken the scene to another level if atleast one of them had gone to their mom's side.

But to give the benefit of doubt, i think the younger ones almost broke down around the same time and prithvi now being the head of the family had to be there for them and hence the hug sort of thing.

Hope they make it up in tonite's epi.

I guess in the end they had to leave the viewers with the haunting image of brothers grieving together and prithvi's oath of revenge and contrast it with the Gujaral ladies sticking together too.

Quote

284462

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

@anisha: Varun's reaction needed to be shown, period. I guess they are saving it up for the time when he finds out about roshni, so you will see Dishant's other intense side too.

And isnt it odd that except varun (atleast so far) doesnt seem to have had any second thoughts on hurting the very girls they were falling in love barely hours ago.

Atleast varun had a logical reaction, let us hope both prithvi and sameer feel a bit guilty about it.

Quote

Heavens_Kiss

@Heavens_Kiss

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Shwetha!
@anisha: Varun's reaction needed to be shown, period. I guess they are saving it up for the time when he finds out about roshni, so you will see Dishant's other intense side too.

And isnt it odd that except varun (atleast so far) doesnt seem to have had any second thoughts on hurting the very girls they were falling in love barely hours ago.

Atleast varun had a logical reaction, let us hope both prithvi and sameer feel a bit guilty about it.

Shwets i coudn't agree with you more!! Firstly on Dishant,unless the actor is put in in that situation how are we going to know if he can perform that scene or not??? It was odd to say the least,they could have probably avoided the Varni date and shown that scene instead,i dont know if they are going to show it from a storytelling point of view and show it in flashback mode as someone pointed above but will it have the same impact seeing it that way???.And about Sam and G.K taking their revenge without having second thoughts??😆 That is seriously surprising,even G.K ,i mean he is the one who is supposed to have his head on his shoulders,but as per the precap u can see him even trying to coerce Varun into doing something that he propbably has reservations in doing in the first place,and well Sammy,i think he cares abut Avni alot,doesnt love her yet,but he has always been impulsive from the very beginning,But G.K ??😕(maybe the pressure of giving back Balraj his dignity and the guilt of not being able to save him is weighing on his mind and is not making him think right at the moment. but he is going to regert it).

Quote

284462

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: anisha12
Shwets i coudn't agree with you more!! Firstly on Dishant,unless the actor is put in in that situation how are we going to know if he can perform that scene or not???
To be honest, I had zero expectations from Dishant initially and he has constantly surprised me with his acting abilities in a pleasant sort of way👏.

As for him not being able to pull it off, well of all the promos his reaction was the one that made the most impact didnt it, so i think the creatives did him the actor, varun the character and us a disfavor by not showing his reactions.

I mean his confrontation with the both the brothers as to why they hid such a huge thing from him in the first place and his reaction on seeing his dad would have been scenes worth watching.

It was odd to say the least,they could have probably avoided the Varni date and shown that scene instead,i dont know if they are going to show it from a storytelling point of view and show it in flashback mode as someone pointed above but will it have the same impact seeing it that way???.
Ah, the flashbacks, i would still settle for the above scenes in the flashback mode if they decide to show it
And about Sam and G.K taking their revenge without having second thoughts??😆 That is seriously surprising,even G.K ,i mean he is the one who is supposed to have his head on his shoulders,but as per the precap u can see him even trying to coerce Varun into doing something that he propbably has reservations in doing in the first place,and well Sammy,i think he cares abut Avni alot,doesnt love her yet,but he has always been impulsive from the very beginning,But G.K ??😕(maybe the pressure of giving back Balraj his dignity and the guilt of not being able to save him is weighing on his mind and is not making him think right at the moment. but he is going to regert it).

Whatever yaar, if he wants to hurt Ila do the right thing by burning her photos and not her daughters'😕

There are many ways you can hurt Ila without them going on the revenge mode.

Prithvi can actually let Damini marry Inder and see what a disaster it would be for her (ofcourse knowing Damini she would get inder to sign the divorce papers at gun point as soon as she finds out,😆) But still, the damage would be done.

Sameer has already severely dented avni's confidence and hurt her, aur kya baaki hai.

As for Varun, why do they need to involve him in the first place. What are they going to tell him , Listen Varun, Ila has 3 daughters, we both have picked ours and you have the responsibility 🤢 of getting the youngest one to fall for you🤢

But majorly, be it prithvi or varun didnt think it was necessary to involve varun with their dad's case cos they wanted to protect him,

But for revenge they deem it necessary to involve him???????????👎🏼

And suppose varun had not met roshni, then what atleast these two had prior contacts with damini and avni.

Poor Varun what how was he supposed to have gone about impressing roshni😕