TV review: Sach Ka Saamna will put Star on the comeback trail
Priya Ramani - Wednesday, July 15, 2009 10:50 AM
Trust an Indian television channel to market a risque, daring show as an agnipariksha.
Star
Plus' Sach Ka Saamna, which begins tonight, is a fascinating look at
the way we really live, behind all our put on hypocrisy and bland
exterior selves. Was chatting with a couple of colleagues over coffee
and we all agreed that the first half hour in Dev D was the best part
of the film. Anurag Kashyap's interpretation of Paro as a regular bold,
brash, horny desi girl from Punjab provided stunning insights into the
way we actually are. Back then, actress Mahi Gill said she could
identify with the character; that it was close to her heart.
Anyway, here's what I wrote about Sach Ka Saamna after seeing the first episode. Don't forget to catch it tonight!
Will Smita Mathai take Star back to No. 1?
She's
the epitome of wedded bliss. Today she's dressed in a striking blue
sari, this former teacher with a lovely smile (that fades rapidly as
you watch her), two children and a husband of 16 years. A Sindhi
married to a Christian. She's classic Incredible India. Incredible at
hiding the garbage life has shovelled her way. Until, of course,
television offered her the chance to win Rs1 crore in exchange for 21
truths about her relationship with her mother, her inner sexual
longings and her childhood secrets and jealousies.
Thus far Indian
television has never managed to successfully replicate the
American-style intimate, confessional chat show format, a genre powered
by Oprah Winfrey, arguably one of the world's most influential women.
Indians just aren't brought up to confess on prime time television that
they were raped by their uncle/neighbour when they were 11, or that
they are having affairs with their wives' sisters. Family secrets, we
believe, should be buried in the darkest recesses of our emotional
selves.
Star India's sensational new show, Sach ka Saamna, the
local version of the globally successful Moment of Truth, manages to
smash through this barrier with its deceptively simple format. All a
contestant has to do is answer yes or no to any question the host asks.
Twenty-one right answers and she's a crorepati. A lie detector test,
taken prior to the show when the contestant is asked 50 questions,
confirms whether the answer is right or wrong. How difficult can that
be, right? And how dramatic can it be when she has already answered all
the questions that she is going to be asked on the show?
It's
tougher than you think. Especially when your family is sitting on the
same stage, watching you spill your guts with a simple yes, no, yes,
no. "The best part about this show is that you know all the questions
and you know all the answers," says Star India's Keertan Adyanthaya.
The channel screened people with interesting lives, those who had been
through a lot. Adyanthaya says nearly 50% of the contestants backed out
when they realized how far they would have to go-some of them quit
after the lie detector test. Smita Mathai decided she would stay on.
In
the first episode (catch it on 15 July at 10.30pm on Star Plus), she
bravely answers many questions, including: Can you forgive your mother
for not being there during the birth of your second child? Do you live
in fear that your husband will become an alcoholic again? Do you think
your mum-in-law was a better mother than your mother? Do you believe
your parents love your brother's children more than yours? All this,
while her husband, mother and two more family members watch from 5ft
away.
And here's one for you, dear reader.
Would you ever
cheat on your spouse if you knew he/she would never find out? There can
be only one true answer to this question, if you don't fool yourself.
After all, a large part of the reason we stay faithful to the loves of
our lives is because we want to protect the long-term security of our
relationship more than anything. We can't risk losing them. But if you
knew for sure that you wouldn't lose them, why then, cheating would be
just another guilty indulgence.
Alas, the Indian version of the
show will have less sex and more emotion. But maybe that's the smart
approach considering the show was recently banned in Greece on grounds
of decency/taste. I'm almost certain that no contestant has won the big
prize since this show went on air in the US last year. Incidentally,
the US show was inspired by a Colombian show which also ran into
trouble after a contestant said yes when she was asked if she had paid
a hitman to kill her husband.
Star's yes/no brand of truth certainly seems more radical than Rakhi Sawant's attempts to play pastel princess on NDTV Imagine.
In
the cut-throat world of general entertainment channels, Star Plus is
bound to gain significant brownie points with this show. Then again,
the executives at Colors are aware of the ratings potential of this
show...maybe they have something planned?
Star's new show also
goes head-to-head with Sony Television's new reality biggie Iss Jungle
se Mujhe Bachao! that begins two days earlier, on 13 July, at 10pm.
When viewers have to pick between Mathai's secrets and a B-grade
celebrity trapped in a Malaysian forest, who will they chose? I'm
placing my bets on Mathai.
http://blogs.livemint.com/blogs/first_cut/archive/2009/07/15/tv-review-sach-ka-saamna-will-put-star-on-the-comeback-trail.aspx
comment:
p_commentcount