- Anu Malik:"I don't see you as the Indian Idol" - - Page 2

Originally posted by: vishlesha

Hes justified in his anger...because no matter what they say about him....he never seems to go in the bottom three....

So its likely that the judges are pissed...

And Anu Mallik is known for his hasrhness.......

so yeah...

Edited by kaushikbasu - 15 years ago

The judges dont understand that the public will support the person who needs it. Not who necessariliy deserves support.

agreed, Remo isn't the strongest person on the show. phirbi, AM has no right to insult Remo like this..

Originally posted by: Shawn89

The judges dont understand that the public will support the person who needs it. Not who necessariliy deserves support.

 

By the judges tearing down Remo, it makes people want to vote for him more, because he is not being treated right! Usually people vote and support the person who isnt being treated properly.

yah but he was right! Remo hasnt been singing any good for all the galas and if thats the type of singing he is going to be providing, he has no right to be in the show, because so many of the other contests sing ten times better then him and they have been eliminated while Remo has been safe all the time. Example: Shinni! She was amazing! Its not right for good contests, consistant contestants to be kicked out while the not so good ones remain safe all the time. What kind of judgements are the audience making? Based on looks? Based on eligibility? Based on Gender? Anu Malik was fully justified in what he said. I do think it was a bit harsh, but if thats the way audience understands that Remo shouldnt be in the show, then so be it!Edited by frenzgrl129 - 15 years ago

Originally posted by: frenzgrl129

yah but he was right! Remo hasnt been singing any good for all the galas and if thats the type of singing he is going to be providing, he has no right to be in the show, because so many of the other contests sing ten times better then him and they have been eliminated while Remo has been safe all the time. Example: Shinni! She was amazing! Its not right for good contests, consistant contestants to be kicked out while the not so good ones remain safe all the time. What kind of judgements are the audience making? Based on looks? Based on eligibility? Based on Gender?

Originally posted by: kaushikbasu

 

No based on sympathy. Our problem is not why he is staying but judges being insultive to a contestant who is their not because of his faults or unfair play. BTW if Remo would have been 10 times better, Shini would have been eliminated anyway.

ditto i had same feelings yday.. i dunno y dese ii production house doesnt remove him  as de judge..

i agree anu malik was way out of line saying that to remo

you know guys- this whole topic is foolish.