DOTW: Selfish, Selfless?

Angel-Jot thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
DOTW: Actions Of The Characters-Selfish, Selfless?

In the past 3 seasons, each character in the show has been shown as either selfish or selfless [or both]. Let's discuss some particular characters and their actions.

*Stefan forcing Damon to change. Damon did not want to become a vampire yet Stefan forced him to because he loved him. Was Stefan's love selfish or selfless?

*Elena finding difficulty choosing a brother. I understand she doesn't want to lose anyone but was it not selfish of her to keep both hanging?

*Damon vs Stefan. When Damon met Elena, he compelled her to forget they ever met. When Stefan saved Elena, even though Elena was half dead so she had no idea who was doing what so compulsion was not needed but would Stefan have compelled her? Would he have made her forget that he saved her? The fact that upon seeing her face, he decided to pursue her, does it make him selfish or selfless?

*Damon telling Elena to choose. Was that selfish or selfless? Stefan only pointed out to her that she feels something for Damon, but Damon asked her to choose one.

..and i can't think of anymore. 😆
You guys tell me, what was selfish, what was not. 😃 Please don't bash the characters.

-TVD DT

Edited by Angel-Jot. - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

963

Users

5

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

GulaabiAakhein. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
*Stefan forcing Damon to change. I think it was Selfish of Stefan to do that. Yes, he loved his brother and everything, but he had no right to make that decision for him. He didn't want to complete the transition and Stefan should have respected that.

*Elena finding difficulty choosing a brother. S.E.L.F.I.S.H

*Damon vs Stefan. Umm.. this is a tough one. I think it was very selfless of Stefan to do what he did in Elena's case. He saved her because she did look like Katherine. (Well, obviously because her dad told her.. but still..) but then he compelled her to forget. So pretty selfless.. and Damon toh compelled her because he did that to everyone! He never wanted ppl to know that he cared. So..

*Damon telling Elena to choose. I don't think it was either selfish or selfless, it was just right. He needed to know! Obviously he didn't want the Katherine kind of love all over again. So I think he was right to ask her to make up her mind and stop dragging both of them along! She had to let one of them go!


Great Post :) 🤗
-SexyAngel- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Stefan forcing Damon to change- thats not selfish or selfless... thats just his love for his brother😳
Elena finding difficulty choosing a brother- Thats plain selfish... i know she needs to find out for herself whom she really loves but she left both brothers hanging 😔
Damon vs Stefan- well i dont think he wud hav compelled her even if she saw him but i wudnt call that selfish... him saving elena itself is a selfless thing😃
Damon telling Elena to choose- thats not selfish... even i want her just to choose one brother from heart😆
moosewithgoose thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Stefan forcing Damon to change: Selfish cause he "forced" it on Damon even though he didn't want it.


Elena finding difficulty choosing a brother: Selfish, I know she was confused and all, but there's a saying, don't lead someone on if you are not sure of your own feelings, unfortunately that cant be said for her after 3x19.

Damon vs Stefan: I would say Damon was selfish in compelling her the first time they met. Stefan was selfless when he went to save her but stalking her all those months w/o her knowledge was selfish .

Damon telling Elena to choose to make a choice: Damon wasn't telling Elena to choose exactly, it was his last moments or so he thought and he used the word "if" u had to make a choice who would get the "goodbye".It wasn't either selfish or selfless imo.



*~sneha~* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Angel-Jot.





*Stefan forcing Damon to change. Damon did not want to become a vampire yet Stefan forced him to because he loved him. Was Stefan's love selfish or selfless?
It was selfish.Definitely.I mean,damon did not want to turn.All he ever wanted was to be with katherine.And he didnot want to live a life that did not have her..and at that point he believed she was trapped in the tomb forever.
Even after turning,all he ever did was find a way to open the damn tomb.
Stefan shouldn't have forced damon.

*Elena finding difficulty choosing a brother. I understand she doesn't want to lose anyone but was it not selfish of her to keep both hanging?
Thats completely unfair.She has no rights keeping both of them hanging by a thread.I mean,she HAS to pick one eventually.she can't really be all i love you both and i can't afford to lose anyone.
I do get where she's coming from.she did say in one episode that i can't chose because i've lost so many people that i love..and i can't lose one more.But,she should've realized that her not choosing can cause problems between stefan and damon.

*Damon vs Stefan. When Damon met Elena, he compelled her to forget they ever met. When Stefan saved Elena, even though Elena was half dead so she had no idea who was doing what so compulsion was not needed but would Stefan have compelled her? Would he have made her forget that he saved her? The fact that upon seeing her face, he decided to pursue her, does it make him selfish or selfless?

I think he would've.He wanted to meet her the right way.and get to know her the right way...isn't that why he joined the school?And also waited for a long time before he could tell her that he was involved in saving her life and the whole incident.And that does kinda make him selfless.

*Damon telling Elena to choose. Was that selfish or selfless? Stefan only pointed out to her that she feels something for Damon, but Damon asked her to choose one.
Damon honestly expected it to be him.I don't blame him for being frustrated...who wouldn't be? Stefan told her to resolve all her issues...he even told her if they ever find their way back...if she wants,she can tell him what happened with damon.It was a bit selfish of damon..but it is something that can be justified.




Great discussion of the week 👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".