Aamir's song Oct 05/08

Page

Next Last

Mike Khan

@m_khan90

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

I liked Aamir's performance of oct 05/08 "Aoa Gay Tum Sajna" I got goosebumps but the judges does not like it that much and gave only 8 marks each.

I know little about sur and taal. I only rely on my ears. If it sounds good to my ears than I consider it good.

Those of you who know music can you tell me please what does Aamir lacks in todays performance.

To me his voice is getting better and better. I found so much soul in his voice that the song touches my heart.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iU2WzlD2BUk

Edited by m_khan90 - 16 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Mike Khan

@m_khan90

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: uk001
who got eliminated???

Aamir and Apurva supposed to be eliminated. They found a technical aspect not to eliminate to lowest scorer (Aamir and Apurva) since there were not all the three judges were there so no elimination.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

uk001

@uk001

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

😊Thank god for that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

its ryt anyway cuz der was no singer judging...gud luk 2 aamir he got saved dis time but really needs to pull his socks up for next week 👍🏼

Quote

Mike Khan

@m_khan90

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

124 ppl have watched it and nobody response. If they cannot say he sang excellent then say that Aamir did not sang well. But tell me the reason why you do not like it.

Edited by m_khan90 - 16 years ago

Quote

Minali The Great

@Guardian Angel

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

I had to collect my thoughts today before responding.

I was watching the videos and writing notes for doing my updates and just had to leave the site after the marks Aamir got. It took me some time to get back.

KK is a director of movies and RS is a performer. We lacked a judge with some musical knowledge, not that KK and RS are ignorant! I could not believe that Aamir got just 8 stars each for his performance Did anyone notice that KK and RS said he was not up to his normal standard but noone was able to pinpoint his fault today? Also when AK announced that Aamir and Apurva will be eliminated today......... one grandpa started to talk in the middle and he had a mike already!!! I therefore feel this was a drama on Zee's part. Sadly it is at the expense of poor kids. Aamir-Apurva got 35 points which will be carried next week, like all jodis. I hope they do a hat-trick and climb up the ladder. All the best to them!!

I donot have in-depth music knowledge but to me this was one of the better performances of Aamir. All the best Aamir......... you rock!!👍🏼 Some day he will make a big name for himself......... that is my sincere wish for him.

Quote

Fatima

@Rhimjhimsawan

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

I have no sort of knowledge in music. I am soo soo glad and still thanking god that Aamir is saved. It would've been horrible to see him go while Vibhore is still here. I love Aamir.

As for the song....I love that song. I listen to it all day long and It really IS my FAVORITE song. (beside o re pia) And even though I am in love with Aamir's voice, it was different than the original. (not different in a good way.) but something felt missing. I love that song. It touches my heart and goes straight to soul. I was waiting for that to happen with this song too. But it didn't happen. I wasn't blown away by anyone's performance this week. Loved Vasu the most!

Quote

kuhu.kuhu

@kuhu.kuhu

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

I have no sort of knowledge in music. I am soo soo glad and still thanking god that Aamir is saved. It would've been horrible to see him go while Vibhore is still here. I love Aamir.
As for the song....I love that song. I listen to it all day long and It really IS my FAVORITE song. (beside o re pia) And even though I am in love with Aamir's voice, it was different than the original. (not different in a good way.) but something felt missing. I love that song. It touches my heart and goes straight to soul. I was waiting for that to happen with this song too. But it didn't happen. I wasn't blown away by anyone's performance this week. Loved Vasu the most!

U said it all ....I also felt Amir was not comfortable with the song ....Moreover the line follows

"Anjaane Hi Tere Naino Ne Waade Kiye Kayi Saare Hai" is

Saanson Ki Lay Madham Chalein, Tose Gaye..which is in high pitch and beautiful but achanak he jumped to last line of the song ..."Sapnon Ka Jahaan"..I was like, this doesn't sound right ..I lovee that song soo much that I also think that Amir didn't do justice to the song and he is lucky that today's marks were not counted ..He was definitely the weakest link today ...but his last 2 performances were mindblowing and he has improved a lot from his li'l champ days .....

As usual Anamika rocked with the lataji number IMO ...according to me she rocked yet again👏 ....

Quote

Fatima

@Rhimjhimsawan

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: bruno4

U said it all ....I also felt Amir was not comfortable with the song ....Moreover the line follows

"Anjaane Hi Tere Naino Ne Waade Kiye Kayi Saare Hai" is

Saanson Ki Lay Madham Chalein, Tose Gaye..which is in high pitch and beautiful but achanak he jumped to last line of the song ..."Sapnon Ka Jahaan"..I was like, this doesn't sound right ..I lovee that song soo much that I also think that Amir didn't do justice to the song and he is lucky that today's marks were not counted ..He was definitely the weakest link today ...but his last 2 performances were mindblowing and he has improved a lot from his li'l champ days .....

As usual Anamika rocked with the lataji number IMO ...according to me she rocked yet again👏 ....

thank you!!!! that's it! I didn't notice everyline but I felt so horribly wrong when he sang "sapnon ki jahaaaaaan..." I love love love that song and when he sang it I felt something was horribly missing!

Anamika always does great!

Quote

Mike Khan

@m_khan90

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

Thank you guys for commenting. You should have realised that they only let sing one mukhda and one antra. Even the adults does not sing the whole song.

Since Aamir is not aggressive at all so he does whatever he is told to do. Look at Apurva when she was critisized she at once told the judges that she is doing the western dance for the first time, her training in the kathak dance. If Aamir is said anything he will quietly listen to it and not argue even if he is right.

ANYRATE I THINK HE AND APURVA WILL BE ELIMINATED NEXT WEEK AS THIS JODI WAS THE LOWEST SCORRER THIS WEEK.

Quote

Zidane-nedved

@Zidane-nedved

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

of course Anamika did a great job cause she got the fake Confidence of Lil Champs as Zee did their best to lower Aamir so Anamika would be higher. Please listen to their performance before the last 5 weeks in Lil Champs. Listen to her when she tried that song in Jab we Met! they cant even be compared. Aamir is raising himself after he was mistreated and wrongly loosing to the 3 most weakness of top 7(Aamir,Smita,Rohit and Vibhore) was better than those in top 3. Maybe Anamika would be in nr 4 but Tanmay and Rohanpreet? this was the weakest season of lil champs!

Quote

1 2 3

Aamir's song Oct 05/08

Related Topics

Explore Topics