Why I think both SwaSan are right on their stand?

BB_CallmeC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
I have posted my stand on couple of threads but I felt this thing required an individual post .
For me, based on yesterday's episode, Both SwaSan's reaction were justifiable to me. I don't think Swara was being mahaan by stepping back. And definitely Sanskaar was not being stupid by staying silent yesterday.

Firstly, coming to Swara. I read on few post that Swara is being Mahaan by completely stepping back and leaving the decision on Sanskaar. I don't think thats wrong. I think thats one of the wisest decision she has ever taken in her life.

I think Swara is doing the same thing that Sanskaar did too!!

When Laksh was going all haywire for Swara and blackmailing Swara to comeback in his life, Sanskaar did suggest her to consider the thought of going back to him. Yes, he didn't force her, just gave her a suggestion even after her denying that thought millions of times not only to him but to everyone who had confronted Swara for that matters. The reason being, first and foremost, Swara didn't have anyone in her life then. She didn't have or lets put it that way, she hadn't realized her feelings for Sanskaar then. And second of all, according to Sanskaar, that was Swara's first love too. So he asked her to consider the possibility too if she wanted too!!

I think Swara is doing the same thing. She is giving him the chance to decide between his first love and her. The reason being firstly, Sanskaar never had a bad memory with Kavita. He was not wronged by her in any way (atleast not then) like she was wronged by Laksh. And secondly, yes, she was his first love. And it was way too intense then Swa---Lak.. To the level that he was ready to destroy his own family for that. And yes, lastly, we as viewers know that Sanskaar has accepted Swara but she is still not aware of that. I understand he has publicly and proudly acknowledged her as his wife, especially in front of Kavita and that does says a lot. But even in the past, there has been a lot of incidences, where Sanskaar has acknowledged her as his wife but then in the closed room, has asked her to stay away from him. For example, his recent confrontation with Ragini after that property transfer celebration party.

Its not the Swara is not trusting his love for her. She is just giving him an option to back out and go back to his first love, only if he wants to. She is not forcing it on her. When Sanskaar had suggested her to go back to Laksh, its not that he didnt trust her stand or her feelings for Laksh, he was just giving her an option. And I agree that this is the right time for her to step back. I am not sure if everyone will agree with that. Kavita is already being all touchy touchy and emotionally blackmailing Sanskaar. And if Swara keeps fighting (obviously not like Kavita), the guy is gonna be so frustrated with the two girls running behind him. He does need some sanity and space to think this through, make a right decision and take a right step at the right time and of course thats what Swara is doing. She told him what she feels many times and even when he heard her conversation with DP, she said it clearly, whatever he decides, she will accept it. And even if that is continuing their relation. It was very clear. Giving him that space he needs to figure out what he should exactly do and how. And they are sure about one thing, stepping back doesn't mean they won't see eachother until Sanskaar comes up with a decision. If Sanskaar will need her for something or for that matters, Swara would need him, they would be there for each other as each other's support no matter what the situation is. And thats given.

Now coming to Sanskaar, I think his reaction was also completely justified yesterday. I don't think Sanskaar was wrong today by being silent either. Don't get me wrong, but I would be the happiest person when he will come out of his mute mode, run to Swara and unite with her. But I think his reaction was justified for me. First and foremost, he loved Kavita to death. And second of all, he never had any bad memory with Kavita like Swara had with Laksh. There were two main important reasons that Swara kept outrightly rejecting Laksh: First and foremost, he didn't trust her. And second and most important, he jumped into a matrimony with her sister. Hence, from then there was no looking back for her. No matter whether Swara would have loved any one else or not, she would not have gone back to him. But incase of Sanskaar, thats not the case. If Swara wasnt in his life, had he not loved her, he would have immediately gone back to Kavita (provided that he didn't love Swara). He was in utter shock!! He didn't know what to do. The girl, his first love that he had assumed to be dead was in front of him and asking him to come back in her life. He definitely doesn't love her today but he does have a very soft corner for her and he cares. And the way she was being all touchy touchy and emotionally blackmailing him how she cannot survive without him, is gonna stop him momentarily to tell her the truth. Obviously, he wouldn't want to hurt her. She hasn't done anything wrong to him. She hasn't wronged him like Laksh had wronged Swara. Yes, I know, in this process, he is hurting himself as well and Swara too. But it has to happen. Yes, he does need to find a perfect time, sit down calmly and make her listen to himself.

If he keeps stretching this, thats when I am not gonna like it. I wasnt happy with the engagement development as well to be honest. Especially the OLVs, which suggested he is not telling her the truth because he fears she might not be able to handle it. His fears for me are still justifiable. I understand them. He wants to protect her and thats why he is taking that step. In order to protect Swara and Shomi, he got into the forceful wedding with Swara despite of not wanting to be in since he didn't believe in forceful marriages. His prime goal then was still to protect Swara and get her justice. But Kavita still needs to know the truth. The earlier she knows that the better it is for her. Else, it is gonna spoil three lives. But I am not gonna say more about this. I am waiting for the episode before I can conclude my stance on that. Yes, Kavita should know the truth as early as possible because you are giving that girl false hopes. Even if you care for the girl, you will have to tell her the truth because you are risking her health condition even badly by not telling her until the nth hour and then leaving her in the mandap.

I think the most important thing is both SwaSan are clear in their heads of what they want and they both know that too and are still ready to support each other in every possible, despite of the chances that they might not end up together (which won't happen, so don't panic, LOL). Yes, I am hoping he backs out in the engagement itself and is not stretched until the wedding else I am gonna be majorly pissed. But my reaction would still depend on what they have shown. If both SwaSan decide to that and stretch it until the wedding, no one can be blamed except of both of them.

And the most important and intense scene for me was when both were trying to avoid looking into each other's eyes. They both were scared that they will breakdown the moment they will read the pain in each others eyes. And thats what they were trying to avoid. Both are trying to handle the situation as calmly as possible.

So everyone calm down, chillax and lets us all together brace ourselves for yet another bumpy ride which will finally get us to reunion of SwaSan.

Edited by SwaSanFanGirl - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

2.5k

Users

16

Likes

217

Frequent Posters

tootiefrootie11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#2

Hey Shona!
Wow your on a roll aren't you?! 😆
I can't do a long reply as in the midst of somehting but will come back later. However very quickly, my 2 cents worth. I myself wanted Swara to entirely leave the decision up to Sanskaar but I still feel the way the cvs are/ will stretch this is not justifiable enough. Swara was always shown as a strong character, she was a passive give into fate type and should be shown having some fighting spirit. I don't mean she should be desperate and engage in cat fights for Sanskaar but totally handing him on a plate to Kavita is stupid imo. I think there is a difference between the way Sanskaar handled the situation with swalak and the way Swara is behaving currently, Sanskaar did leave the decision to her but didn't back off like that and certainly didn't give up. I am not saying for sure Swara will do this but the indications from the spoilers seem that she will. I will wait and watch before making up my mind but the CVs treatment of Swara usually let's me down so my expectations are very low.

With Sanskaar I feel so far his PoV is understandable as much as I don't like the situation, but as you say it needs to be nipped in the bud asap as if it stretches and if he agrees for the engagement I will not be able to stomach it.

Just my 2 cents worth summed up rapidly! X

BB_CallmeC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: tootiefrootie11


Hey Shona!

Wow your on a roll aren't you?! 😆
I can't do a long reply as in the midst of somehting but will come back later. However very quickly, my 2 cents worth. I myself wanted Swara to entirely leave the decision up to Sanskaar but I still feel the way the cvs are/ will stretch this is not justifiable enough. Swara was always shown as a strong character, she was a passive give into fate type and should be shown having some fighting spirit. I don't mean she should be desperate and engage in cat fights for Sanskaar but totally handing him on a plate to Kavita is stupid imo. I think there is a difference between the way Sanskaar handled the situation with swalak and the way Swara is behaving currently, Sanskaar did leave the decision to her but didn't back off like that and certainly didn't give up. I am not saying for sure Swara will do this but the indications from the spoilers seem that she will. I will wait and watch before making up my mind but the CVs treatment of Swara usually let's me down so my expectations are very low.

With Sanskaar I feel so far his PoV is understandable as much as I don't like the situation, but as you say it needs to be nipped in the bud asap as if it stretches and if he agrees for the engagement I will not be able to stomach it.

Just my 2 cents worth summed up rapidly! X


Haha, LOL. I don't know what is upto me right now? I am just continuously making some or the other post. LOL.

I am dying to meet the fighter Swara again. Trust me!! But currently, I don't think she is handing Sanskaar over in plate to Kavita. That would seriously mean that she is forcing Sanskaar to accept Kavita like she did to Laksh, when she kept forcing him to accept Ragini. But clearly she is not doing that since she hasn't given up on her love for him and his love for her. She is just giving him an option and space to decide. Which I think is ok. She might be considering Kavita's health as well because she knows how much Sanskaar cares and wouldn't want to hurt her in any way. If she would have said something like, Sanskaar tum apne pehle pyaar ke paas chale jao and would have left after that, I would have been majorly pissed with her. Yes, she should definitely think of the circumstances of if Sanskaar ends up choosing Kavita over her, three lives are gonna be shattered. But I am hoping that she is keep that hope of Sanskaar will take the right decision. Lets see!!

When Sanskaar misunderstood Swa----Lak relationship, he did completely back out and ignored Swara obviously because he was hurting internally. But he was ready to take that for Swara's happiness. The moment he realized that wasnt the case, he was back in his game again!! Swara is hurting too. The thought of losing her love again is breaking her too. And she is ready to take that for Sanskaar's happiness. The moment Sanskaar will choose her over Kavita, she will be back in her game too. Thats when we will get the fighter Swara back who will protect her husband from the evil and gold digging hands of Kavita!!

Oh, Sanskaar has not denied for the engagement. If you have seen the new OLV, he is not opposing the engagement because he is scared that if he tells the truth to Kavita, she won't be able to handle it. What I want is him to finally confess during the engagement and stop this and not drag it until the wedding!!

And thank you for commenting on my thread always despite being busy. I am really sorry I haven't gotten a chance to unres post on your SS. I will do that soon.. I promise!!
Edited by SwaSanFanGirl - 9 years ago
tootiefrootie11 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Haha, it's good na, keep us and the forum active!
I haven't watched the OLVs or any segments etc either. I am majorly fed up of this crap and I seriously think there's no point in getting so worked up at the moment over the characters we love as the cvs simply don't engage with that. They want trps and want them through mindles melodrama. They need a new villain so got two. Kaveri and Kavita, as I am sure Kavita will be a major nasty piece of work. But the cvs need a forced separation and MU between SwaSan and this is what they come up with, the Sanskaar and Swara we know and love would have sorted this in 10 mins flat but as the makers want to drag for months it matters not that Sanskaar would NEVER give in to such obviously staged pressure and even Swara would never back off in the way they seem to be showing. My current plan is to watch for SwaSan, survive on the FFs and not get over upset.

Don't worry re the FF- totally understand, will wait for your views whenever you get the time, I too need to unres on your OS which was lovely:)
Edited by tootiefrootie11 - 9 years ago
BB_CallmeC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Shruts!!
not two, we have three villains. There is one more new entry!! Ragini ki mausi😆 😆 who apparently hates Shomi. So we are gonna get Shomi-Shekhar and Mausi angle too😆

So this is how it could work. Kavita will become mahaan by reuniting SwaSan. But because Swara has to protect her ma-baba from mausi, she will be busy with that and won't be able to spend enough time with Sanskaar. Boom, Kavita will use that for her favor and create MUs between them😆 😆

And yes, I agree. All this CVs care about is TRPs. They won't even care whether what they are showing actually suits the character or not. I was so not convinced with Sanskaar's character when he let Swara humiliate by Ragini. I was trying to go along with the hopes of him being pretending, but no!! that wasnt the case.
Similarly, with Swara, you are right!!! She is a fighter and she would have fought wisely and smartly instead of begging and crying!!
Edited by SwaSanFanGirl - 9 years ago
suwas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
So far Swara & Sanskar are right in the way they acted today. Swara told bade papa why she isn't showing her fighter spirit. I like the fact that she didn't give up on Swasan relationship, become mahan & force Sanskar to accept Kavita like she was asking Laksh to accept Ragini. I am glad that Sanskar heard what she had to say to bade papa & she is waiting for his decision & is not denying her love for him.

Want to see what Sanskar does next, how much he gets pushed into relationship with Kavita. I will be disappointed if he goes ahead with the enagement. That's against his character. He is always very straight forward, thoughtful, acts only after considering all consequences of actions & goes ahead only if he is ready to face those. He should know he can't go on without telling Kavita about his love for Swara or it will spoil three lives.

Less I talk about MM residents the better.
sarathy321 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Hai dear. ..
I can agree only to some extent to this post...
I am really disappointed with Sanskaar's mute zone from the beginning. ...he was keeping mum seeing swara getting humiliated by rags ...he was keeping quiet when this girl. Swara...so called his love was on her knees , crying , begging to trust her...I was still hoping that that silence was due to some plan but again was disappointed when came to know that he had a selfish motive of protecting his heart...
Now when kavita is back...I can understand he had to make choices. ...but I want him to make the choice as soon as possible. ...
May be he had chosen swara but had not yet conveyed it to her or kavita...
May be he loves swara to the core but swara doesn't know if he wants her back in his life
I agree he fears about kavitas heartbreak and health, then I am unhappy that he doesn't think about swaras heartbreak which once laksh had already done carried away by sanskaars revengeful plans.. ...
When he was leaving the decision of whether to go back to laksh to her, we could see her always worrying about sanskaar even when she didn't realise that she lpves sanskaar...
So, I am expecting that kind of reaction from sanskaar...I don't find him worried for swaras heartbreak. ...instead he is worried for kavita s heartbreak. ...
And about sanskaars view on kavitas character. ...I know he thinks she is sweet ...let it be...if kavitha was really good and positive. . ...then will sanskaar go and marry her just to comfort her? Then what is the difference between sanskaar and laksh?
I know cvs will not stretch this to marriage, but still I don't want sanskaar to choose swara only becoz kavita is negative. ...
These things I am saying becoz sanskaar is the character I loved the most on indian tv...that may be the reason why I cant bear a single comprimise in his character. ...
And above all sanskaar was the one who destroyed swara in the name of revenge for kavita...he was the one who held her closer when her heartbroke and gave her rights to use her...but again he is one who said she was using him and broke her heart again for kavita
Sree8410 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Hi Shona,
IK both are right on their own stand and everything is going as we expected. But the thing is handling sad Swasan is difficult. They end up spoiling our mood for no good reason.

Swara shouldn't do what Sanskar did. Here what broke her was his claim that he is the same person which to anyone will sound like he is willing to give Kavita a chance. He didn't accept their relation and she kept on looking at him throughout but he was quiet the entire time. When she doesn't have a reason to fight how will she. I don't want her to fight till he opens up to her as of what is in his mind.

I'm not blaming him for not speaking up, the situation was such IK. However I would have loved to see him trying to talk to her when he saw DP and Swara talking to let atleast one person know his decision, ie his wife. Rather than searching for her in the house he can go and get her, or call her to some place to inform her his decision. This silence will not help him or anyone else, like you said will end up hurting the one he wants to protect. I agree keeping Kavita in dark will not help but I really doubt whether she will try to understand the situation. She needs help. Let see what happens today. I want to see him take atleast some effort in trying to contact Swara. Baki sab I don't care. Just a little effort to make things right.

Its just one day of kavita and we are all irritated, how are we going to tolerate her for an entire month?
Edited by Sree8410 - 9 years ago
Fatma6 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
Shona positivity ki dukaan.
Nice post.
Would really agree on few points ,yes swara has done the right thing by letting sanskaar decide what he wants.

She has done her part as to tell him in so many ways, what he means to her and how much she is in love with him.

Swara is a fighter I wouldn't deny . she has protected her family just like a sherni would do.

But this is pyaar ka maamla,she has been very clear and now given sanskaar breathing space to decide.

But sanskaar really puts me off.
Sachai aadhi adhuri is always dangerous, he did say he is married once then why not repeat it again.
When once kavitha heard him,second time also she can hear him say that.

I don't know if the scene has not played out well coz when she hears him she doesn't look like she is distraught like how swara was when kavitha hugged sanskaar.

This is the reason why I believe he could have repeated what he said down.
Truth how much ever harsh it might be needs to be told, delaying that is gonna coz problem.
This is were most of us are disappointed with him and clearly agree with you that he has to tell kavitha or else three people are going to suffer.

But after the nightmare of kavitha running as per olv which u posted he is not gonna tell.

More than sanskaar its sujatha am really annoyed at.
Annapurna was so calmly trying to explain things to kavitha but she had to barge in and tell they were forcefully married and are divorced.

I would have loved if sanskaar had even gently chided her.
But nahin aankon mein aasun aye woh bhi swara ke janeke bad.
He saw her talking with DP still he stood there.

Kuch toh he should say na .
OK as u say lets wait for tomorrow ka episode. If he is not calling swara and telling her why he kept quiet then it is seriously not done. He is letting her suffer.


BookWormV thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Hey Shona (guessing that is your name [:-)]
Really liked this post. I agree with you completely regarding both Swara and Sanskaar reactions. Kavita has just come back into Sanskaar's life, she was his first love who has definitely not done anything wrong to anyone as yet actually. Truthfully I don't even know if she is negative or not. It is all just speculations at the moment. Both their reactions were justified.

This post was much needed as a lot of people have started mentioning how both the characters are being butchered by CVs. Really yaar, how exactly is a person supposed to react to a past love coming back to life where the circumstances for separation was not a mutual breakup or hatred induced breakup but was death? You cannot forget that Sanskaar did love Kavita unconditionally 5 years back and his life had literally stopped due to her death. Just because the poor guy is in love with Swara now, which has been clearly shown in yesterday's episode, does not mean he should tell Kavita to get lost. That would be pretty uncharacteristic. Really agree with you that he should clear the air now itself to avoid prolonged MUs.

Again have to say a much needed post for all the spoilers and speculations running around. :)

-V


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".