Don't Call Me Shurley (11x20) [Discussion Thread]

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

~*sindhu*~

@~*sindhu*~

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#61

Originally posted by: .annihilation.

I just read that too. I didn't agree to the theory that Sam had it all this while too. It was clear enough that Chuck put it in Sam's pocket that very moment. Jensen's answer. Its alarming. 😳 Didn't they know their characters much better than the writers ever did?

I think they are blissfully happy in their vacation so the whole show has wiped out of their minds now. They are just speaking whatever please the fandom at the moment.

Another thing that disappointed me. I always believed Sam picked the amulet and kept it with him. I thought it mattered. Maybe it was my headcanon speaking

Quote

Jackles

@Jackles

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#62

Originally posted by: -SAMAN-

3) Can I make it my head-canon that Sam had the amulet (samulet) all this time rather than assuming God putted it there?

Jensen just confirmed in #asylum16 that Sam had the samulet all this time, and it will not surprise Dean but he'll be touched.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

annihilation

@annihilation

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#63

Originally posted by: ~*sindhu*~

There is Jenny Klein whose 'Just my imagination'epi got nominated for an award. There is Charmelo whose epis always bring in the best ratings .. But both of them mainly writes MOTW. So you know fun for me. There Dabb who has been with the show since the begining. There is Bob Berens one of the very few people who can write an epi with all four characters without giving us a migraine. There are plenty still left. I m sure they will bring in more writers for next season.

You enjoy it, don't you? 😳 You scare people first and then later give them hope too. Then, I'm just going to hope that all evens and odds be in the show's favour. Sigh.

Quote

Jackles

@Jackles

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#64

Originally posted by: -De.De-

Dean keeping it in his pocket??😲😲 *Khushi se khudkushi karle* 🤣☺️
I am waiting for moment when he starts wearing it.

P.s. Saman, you in Asylum or getting updates from Tumblr?

Well, Jensen's first thought when he read about "rise of the samulet" was, "Oh, God! Not again," as it pokes his face while running. 😆 So it's confirmed that he won't be wearing it. 😭

I wish that I was there *Dreams away the pipe dream* I'm getting updates from various Twitter accounts!

Quote

annihilation

@annihilation

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#65

Originally posted by: -SAMAN-

Edited: It wasn't a surprise for Jensen, actually. But it did caught Dean on the hop. He'll be keeping it in his pocket in next episodes. My cinnamon rolls 😳

Sadly. Nope.

Jim tweeted that Chuck put the Samulet in Sam's pocket that very moment. Sam did not have it the whole time. Like Sindhu said, J2 are blissfully happy in their vacation and saying things to please the fandom. I'm sure Jensen must have forgotten this detail or was never really given and thus assumed that Sam had it the whole time.

Doesn't make sense that if Sam really had the whole time, it didn't appear even once in past seasons. Not even Dean got the fake amulet, not even when they were searching for potential Hand of God objects.

Dean keeping it in his pocket now is definitely good to know though.

Quote

~*sindhu*~

@~*sindhu*~

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#66

Originally posted by: .annihilation.

You enjoy it, don't you? 😳 You scare people first and then later give them hope too. Then, I'm just going to hope that all evens and odds be in the show's favour. Sigh.

Main kisiko kya daraungi. Main khud dari hui hoon .. I was loving an Indian show after a decade or so and I think they are gonna butcher it in the name of TRPs .. Phooti kismat 😆 Rona aa raha hai ab.

Finally feel the pain of losing Robbie Thompson by the fandom 😆

See the whole point I was tensed when Kripke left, the show survived. The same happened when Ben left but the show survived , then Adam left ( I forever love him for Bad Boys ) it still survived. So I think Robbie leaving won't hurt much . Maybe u will still get nostalgic epis from others as compensation so who knows. The truth is they leave only when they know they can't add much to the story anymore. I know for a fact they are all emotionally attach to the show. Ben and Kripke still keep a track of the storyline. Adam still cheers for the show every now and then. So they will still be around to chip in when the need arise. Just not officially on the papers.

I always believed nobody ever brought back those heart wrenching epis like Sera used to write. So thats one thing show lost in its run.

Edited by ~*sindhu*~ - 9 years ago

Quote

annihilation

@annihilation

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#67

Originally posted by: ~*sindhu*~

Sam's safe box. Clearly my headcanon but no one can take this away from me for the moment. It was in the box, Chuck stole it. God steals too. Sam will be pissed.

That's one hell of a theory. I wish this were true, I hope this becomes true. In that way, Sam would have had it with all this, just out sight out of mind case.

Quote

annihilation

@annihilation

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

#68

Originally posted by: ~*sindhu*~

Main kisiko kya daraungi. Main khud dari hui hoon .. I was loving an Indian show after a decade or so and I think they are gonna butcher it in the name of TRPs .. Phooti kismat 😆 Rona aa raha hai ab.
Finally feel the pain of losing Robbie Thompson by the fandom 😆

Which Indian show is that? Oh, aao behen saath me roye. 🥺

See the whole point I was tensed when Kripke left, the show survived. The same happened when Ben left but the show survived , then Adam left ( I forever love him for Bad Boys ) it still survived. So I think Robbie leaving won't hurt much . Maybe u will still get nostalgic epis from others as compensation so who knows. The truth is they leave only when they know they can't add much to the story anymore. I know for a fact they are all emotionally attach to the show. Ben and Kripke still keep a track of the storyline. Adam still cheers for the show every now and then. So they will still be around to chip in when the need arise. Just not officially on the papers.

I always believed nobody ever brought back those heart wrenching epis like Sera used to write. So thats one thing show lost in its run.

I get you, completely. This is why I'm always worried too, its as if SPN is not a show for us. Its our kid and we are mothers. 😳 Yeah agreed on the Sera part too but somehow I just can't forgive her for killing off Bobby and giving us season 7 (I can forgive her for S7 though)

Quote

~*sindhu*~

@~*sindhu*~

Sparkler

Posted: 9 years ago

#69

Originally posted by: .annihilation.

That's one hell of a theory. I wish this were true, I hope this becomes true. In that way, Sam would have had it with all this, just out sight out of mind case.

I just feel like its something Sam will keep with him and never share because Dean threw it and think Dean doesn't need it but he can still keep it with him. You know like he did when Dean went to hell. He is the sentimental type who collects stuff thats why he has that box, why will will he not pick up the amulet then? He wasn't as hopeless as Dean was back then so maybe he kept it and never really found a time to give it back.

I m just glad Jensen thinks so and maybe he played it like that without confirming with the writers about who had it all this time. I just don't understand why couldn't they write something around it to give it some meaning other than glowing in God's presence. I m here for the brothers and their bond not glowing amulets.